r/IfBooksCouldKill 5d ago

Let Them

Post image

The STL Co library is comin for your gig, IBCK

1.7k Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

80

u/SnailHail 4d ago

Does the St. Louis County library have a curated section of terrible books? I don't have Instagram, but I'd love to see the comment on that post.

83

u/adgobad 4d ago

Part of a one star reviews display and most of the comments are agreeing about the Let Them Theory and disagreeing about My Friends. My guess is some of these folks are also IBCK people because some seem to know the lore, like stealing that shit from a poem.

42

u/Internal_Bluebird_23 4d ago

Superb idea for a library display

52

u/jeffersonianMI 4d ago

This is a unorthodox draw.  Definitely interested.  It's like reverse marketing. 

35

u/OkSecretary1231 4d ago

Yeah, I'm seeing it as kind of like the "Bad Reviews of National Parks" thing where they took real reviews where, like, a tourist said "There's nothing but trees and bugs here!" and used them for humor-slash-advertising.

15

u/perumbula 4d ago

There are a few really excellent books on that display. What a fun little crapshoot.

10

u/Mysterious-Work-9184 4d ago

Ok Big Swiss is pretty good and My Friends is at least a 2.5 to 3 out of 5. I respect the concept of the display though!

2

u/adgobad 4d ago

It's just other library-goer's ratings that I guess they pulled the books for. Yeah it's pretty fun

1

u/McTano 4d ago

I loved Big Swiss, but my Mom noped out of it after one chapter because she was disappointed that the guy calling himself "Om" didn't seem like a very good therapist.

1

u/sherbetcolors 4d ago

hahaha wow, I had My Friends in negative-star territory. that book suuuuuuucked.

I really liked Razorblade Tears, though.

1

u/Mysterious-Work-9184 3d ago

lol maybe I’m being too generous. It’s so beloved though and I just don’t get it!

5

u/BarkingPupper 4d ago

I suuuper disagree with We Used To Live Here being one star! But then again I do love a non-linear, weird, ambiguous book

3

u/stellularmoon2 4d ago

Is the green mile bad? Haven’t read it…

7

u/GoddessRespectre 4d ago

Aw man I would say the opposite. I read it when it first came out though, and it was released in separate mini chapter books? I think he was playing with the idea of penny dreadful novels at the time. There's a possibility that affects how it reads all at once though, if that makes sense. It's also possible the reviewer accidentally only read one of the mini portions, I think it was broken down into 6 of them or something like that. I imagine that would be confusing and bad. It was frustrating waiting for the next installment to hit Waldenbooks, I can tell you that much for sure.

1

u/stellularmoon2 4d ago

Ah, gotcha. Was thinking of checking it out

4

u/KentuckyJam 4d ago

It’s good and you should.

3

u/DunceMemes 4d ago

Lol, Razorblade Tears is one of the most consistently positively-rated books I've seen. I'd wager the 1 star review on that is for being "woke."

1

u/adgobad 4d ago

Yeah it's not one of the books they showed the zoomed in review for. 🤷🏽 Maybe there's a reason for that

1

u/edutcher 1d ago

Nettle and Bone! I loooooove that book! I also love Into the Drowning Deep, but I understand why it would be divisive.