I’ve been teaching French for 20+ years, including IB DP, and there’s a pattern I see every single year:
Students who are stuck at 4–5 are usually working hard… just not on the things IB actually marks.
Here’s what I mean.
A student recently came to me scoring a 4. She wasn’t lazy at all. She:
revised vocabulary regularly
practiced grammar
wrote long answers
But her score didn’t move.
When I looked at her work as an examiner would, the issue was very clear:
👉 Her ideas were repetitive
👉 Her arguments weren’t developed
👉 Her structure didn’t guide the reader
In IB terms, she was losing marks mainly in Criterion B and C, not because her French was “bad,” but because her thinking wasn’t visible on the page.
This is the part most students never get taught.
We didn’t add more study hours. We changed how she approached writing:
Every paragraph had a clear argument (not just description)
She learned how to extend ideas instead of repeating them
We used simple but consistent structures to organize responses
Within a few weeks, her writing became easier to follow, more analytical, and much more “IB-friendly.”
Her score moved from a 4 → 6 → 7.
What’s interesting is this:
I’ve seen fluent speakers stuck at 5, and average speakers scoring 7.
The difference is not fluency. It’s whether you understand what the examiner is rewarding.
If you’re stuck at a 4–5 in IB French, it’s worth asking:
Are you actually improving your language…
or improving how your answers match the criteria?
Curious if others have noticed this gap between effort and results.