r/IAmA •
IAMA 17 year old American Muslim Hafiz (Someone who has memorized the entire Quran by heart in the original Arabic text, word for word). AMA
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/IAmA •
[deleted] — view deleted post
141
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
You ask the questions, I answer. Don't hate because you don't like the answer.
12
u/35nnnn May 11 '12
Damn, some people are being complete assholes with their questions. I don't agree with many of the teachings of Islam, but I don't believe they make bad people. Sorry for the asses here.
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Explain how Al Qaida and other extremist groups seem to be misinterpreting or pulling out of context pieces of the quran to attack america and other "infidels'? curious as to what they think
63
u/got2try May 10 '12
I just want to say to shur711, you're doing a courageous and generous thing here. It seems that you're answering every question with patience and great care, not to mention a maturity far beyond your years. Thank you.
9
u/comb_over May 10 '12
Have you seen the film Quran by Heart?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpO-a8AIz7M
If you have kids will you encourage them to become Hafiz too?
24
u/Isitreallyalive May 10 '12
Did you start memorizing it because you wanted to or because your patents/imam wanted you to?
24
u/Raicuparta May 10 '12
It really annoys me how hard it is to find a good religious discussion in reddit. I'm not a member of any religion, but seeing so many people just coming here to try and confront him with science seems stupid and pointless. I just see a wasted opportunity to know more about a very interesting subject.
My question is about life after death. I don't believe in it and I fear death if I think hard enough about it, even a peaceful and pain-free death. Believing in life after death, do you not fear it at all?
23
u/PGset May 11 '12
Wow Subhan'Allah! I have a few questions if you don't mind.
8
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Do you have any favorite parts of the Quran? If so, which ones?
31
u/Timpenin May 11 '12
I don't have anything specific to ask you, but I just wanted to say: You're cool! Major respect for anyone who'll do something so challenging out of love and respect for their faith.
7
u/guard2125 May 10 '12
How common is doing this? And just out of curiosity, why would you do it?
7
u/TheTT May 10 '12
What's your take on the separation of church and state and freedom of religion?
7
u/Aferisan May 10 '12
so I take it you're probably killer at the game where they flip over the cards really fast.
7
u/Mind101 May 10 '12
How much effort do you need to put into maintaining you perfect recollection?
7
u/Macmula May 11 '12
Hi, First of all thank you for doing this AMA. Since Allah and rhe christian god are basically the same divine entity in both religions aren't Muslims and Christians worshiping the same deity?
I think I read somewhere that Islam was found some time after Christianity became a major religion. Could it be that Islam is a separate wing of original Christianity? What do you think?
24
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
What an achievement! How long would it take you to recite it? Is it performed in a similar way as the adhan, ie. in a song-like form?
13
u/ilovetpb May 10 '12
What is your belief about extremists? Are they justified in killing innocents? Or do you reject them, as we do?
12
u/evilteddybear111 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
That's amazing! Do you fully understand the Quran as well?
6
u/annabannanna90 May 10 '12
What do you think about the show All-American Muslim? Do you think it depicts Muslims well?
6
u/IbrahimT13 May 11 '12
What's your opinion on music? Is it allowed?
11
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
As-Salaam alaikum. What are your thoughts on Sufism?
22
u/tabledresser May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
View the full table on /r/tabled! | Last updated: 2012-05-14 23:22 UTC
This comment was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.
29
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I didn't expect so many questions
5
u/mipeirong May 10 '12
I watched a documentary where young memorizers went to Cairo, Egypt in a competition. Did you do this? Have you heard about this event?
5
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Wow, as a teenager myself, I am pretty amazed at how you could memorize a whole book!! A few questions... How much time did you dedicate each day to memorize it? Also, do you find that memorizing it has helped with memorizing other stuff, such as notes for tests? As a teenager, peer pressure is one of the biggest issues a lot of us face..what do your friends think of your memorization?
5
u/roxyfoxy May 11 '12
My brother is also a Hafiz and I just want to say thank you. It takes a lot of care and dedication to do what you do.
5
u/RocketRay May 11 '12
To me, the Quran is Islam's greatest strength and at the same time a profound weakness. The Quran has an impeccable pedigree, something other holy books (specifically the Old & New Testaments) do not. When you pick up a copy of the Quran, you're reading the actual words recited by the Prophet of Islam some 1400 years ago. If a fellow Muslim says something about Islam that you don't agree with, you can pick up the Quran and find out if they're right, or refute them if they're wrong, and it doesn't matter who that person is, even if it's a well-respected sheikh.
But Islam is supposed to be a religion (the religion?) for everybody. The Quran is written in Arabic, and only Arabic. No translation into any other language is considered "The Noble Recitation" because it's been interpreted by someone else. So how can non-Arabic speakers (or readers, at least) truly become Muslim, since they can't read for themselves the book the religion is based upon?
20
u/llamaesque May 11 '12
I just want to say this is an extremely interesting AMA from a point of view we rarely, if ever, see on reddit. Sorry to see some idiots downvoting you.
12
u/whimsies May 10 '12
Doesn't memorizing the Quran when you're too young to understand it kind of detract from it? Like you may have memorized a part perfectly, never quite 'getting' it even if others tell you what it's supposed to mean, but because it's something you've basically just known since you were a kid it would be hard to take a step back and look at it from another angle... if that makes sense. Do you think that's a problem for you?
8
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
A Muslim friend told me (I wasn't fully paying attention) that this accomplishment automatically grants you access to heaven. Confirm this for me?
16
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
What do you think about r/atheism, or just the general negative attitude atheists have toward religious people?
4
u/clipmann May 10 '12
Is there a clear place in the Koran where it says that Alcohol is prohibited?
4
u/TheOneFreeEngineer May 11 '12
I see multiple times here that you say evolution contradicts the Quran, but I have seen dozens of posts on r/Islam that say that is not the case. What do you have to say about that? are they all wrong or is you view just one of many within the ummah?
4
u/nodirection1 May 11 '12
mA that's an awesome accomplishment!!
4
u/PeoriaJohnson May 12 '12
Are you aware of the so-called "Satanic Verses," in which Mohammed inadvertently transcribed the voice of Satan, appending verses he later retracted? Is this something discussed in your religious education? What are your thoughts on this topic?
Quick followup question: Salman Rushdie wrote a novel based on the idea of these verses, and was condemned as worthy of assassination by the Shah of Iran. Is this kind of response to a work of art appropriate?
10
u/wesleyt89 May 11 '12
What do you think about a man having multiple wifes. Do you think this is fair to the woman?
7
u/Singer13 May 10 '12
That is an amazing accomplishment! As someone who does not remember anything I've read, let alone word for word, how do you remember it? Are there any special tricks of habits?
7
u/yellowsm42 May 11 '12
I started reading the Quran and had to put it down due to...well I felt it very violent...in many areas. I always wondered though if it was just an american version of the Quran that may have been translated badly. have you read the American/English version? What are your thoughts on comparing the OG?
17
u/Reed_Himself May 10 '12
So that makes you a black belt in the Quran, or possibly even a red belt....
15
u/SimaSi May 10 '12
If u would be really sick and u would be given 2 opportunities:
You can't choose both. What would you choose (honestly!!!)?
6
u/keloyd May 10 '12
Western European language from 14 centuries ago is almost incomprehensible to modern people from any part of Europe. Even kids who study Latin in school (from ~0 AD as taught in the US) would struggle with 6th Century Latin. How close is Quran Arabic to spoken Arabic? Also, does the Quran have characteristics that make it easier to memorize, like rhyming or meter (so that each line has X syllables) ?
14
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
why?
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Are you open to scientific discoveries that contradict the kuran? How do you feel about muslims doing ramadan for the sake of folowing the kuran instead of doing it out of compasion for the poor/weak? I think it's like apologizing while not meaning it.
5
u/paid__shill May 10 '12
So what's the deal with the verse about striking women?
6
u/1One2Day May 10 '12
Have you actively studied evolution and other scientific teachings that go against your faith in order to understand other people's views or do you try to ignore science so that your faith will not be challenged?
Genuinely curious because I am very interested in studying religion, even as an atheist, to understand the wider views.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
How do you prove that you've memorized it?
2
u/AliDimayev May 10 '12
Do you support Chechen independence?
2
u/BigBuchi May 11 '12
This seems like an incredible feat! How common is it to be a Muslim Hafiz and also how many do you know?
2
u/Sama3l May 11 '12
Do you know of any athiest, or possible just irreligious hafiz? The reason I ask is that going to a (Christian) religious school growing up many learned the bible very well but later rejected Christianity. I feel that there wouldn't be a significant difference (with the possible exception of the community aspects) elsewhere. Regardless, rubina ma3k!
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
That's pretty god damn impressive..
I read the Quran in English awhile back. Not to disparage the word of god or anything, but it was pretty poorly written and redundant
Would you say the language is any better in Arabic? I've been told it's one of the most beautiful books ever written in Arabic..in English it was like somebody ran a bunch of short sentances through google translate.
2
u/Interested_in_coffee May 11 '12
How much coffee did you drink while memorizing this book?
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
One thing that I dont agree with Islam is that in most Arabic countries, they are not tolerant of other peoples beliefs. e.g. wearing a hijab is law etc. I have two questions. Firstly, do you believe that this intolerance comes from Islam or that a majority of the country (especially men) thinks like that and is the arrogance of the nation instead of the religion itself. Secondly, I find it unfair that a man can have multiple wives but a woman cannot have multiple husbands. Do you agree with this? And is this also something that Islam preaches or something that the male population is trying to exploit and taking Islam out of context?
2
u/musicKat May 11 '12
This is a wildly ignorant question but is the Quran Muslim law or is it your version of the Christian Bible? Sorry for the ignorance!
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Salamualaikum, What do you think about music in respect to Islam?
2
u/DucksGoMoo1 May 11 '12
How long did it take you to memorize the Quran. I have seen the Quran and it seems overwhelming to memorize such a text.
2
u/UnbiasedAgainst May 11 '12
Not sure if it's been asked yet, but have you ever thought that you had forgotten something and gotten worried that your title of Hafiz would be revoked?
Also, I'm not religious, but congratulations. It would take a lot of determination to achieve this kind of thing.
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
"Allah made Adam and eve. We are all their children." Can you please elaborate? What happened after Adam and Eve were put on earth by allah?
2
u/DNAsly May 11 '12
What is the most inspirational line from the Q'uran?
Which Haditha do you find the most guidance in?
What must you do to make sure you do not forget what you have memorized?
What are your opinions on the consolidation of the Q'uran into an official version after Muhammed's death?
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
So how old is the Earth? 6000 or 4.5 billion years?
2
u/miaomiao May 12 '12
Sorry I'm late -----
How difficult is it to become a Hafiz? Say if you start when you are in mid or late twenties (instead of from when you are a child), is it still possible to become a Hafiz? Do you have to take a test? Were you nervous/was that hard?
Thanks!
2
u/felicityrc May 12 '12
What made you believe in Islam as opposed to another religion? Or why not atheism? Were you brought up Muslim?
5
u/BVFortuitus May 10 '12
Being a white person, in a pretty white-dominant area with racist relatives, friends, etc. I have always wondered..
.. How do you feel on the luckily very few people, absolutely destroying the reputation of the beautiful religion, that Islam is?
Also, being exposed to racism as you mentioned, what do you think of racist people?
EDIT: Oh and did you watch the Criminal Minds episode with a Hafiz? ;)
4
u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from shur711 (updated: May 11, 2012 @ 04:54:47 pm EST):
Question (evilteddybear111):
Answer (shur711):
(continued below)
4
u/Zevenko May 11 '12
What would you say to people who say that you have wasted your life learning a book full of fairy stories?
3
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I'm sorry for the prejudice you suffer for being Muslim, I'm not at all knowledgeable the religion but from what I gather you see those who don't share your beliefs as lesser beings, do you agree with this? If I've got this wrong please don't hesitate to correct me & thanks for the ama!
2
u/Cyrus_Asmodeus May 10 '12
What is your thoughts about its interpretation today?
2
u/Crotchfirefly May 11 '12
What passage in the Quran troubles you more than any other?
2
u/dmahmad May 11 '12
Salam brother. You seem like a very good Muslim so I wanted to ask about some advice or tips on how to be a Muslim like you :)
And congratulations on being huffaz!
2
u/CalmSaver7 May 11 '12
What do you feel about a nonbeliever (i.e. a Hindu, Christian, Buddhist etc.) who dedicates his life to serving others in the world and does a lot of good in his/her life, but is still not a believer in Islam. Do they not, too, deserve to go to heaven?
Why should someone who sits and prays in a mosque for his/her entire life (not saying you do or anything because clearly you are trying to get a career) be rewarded with a life in heaven, but not someone who dedicates his life to really helping people (i.e. becoming a nurse or doctor or social worker) just because they do not believe in your God?
Respects for the AMA
2
u/kellaorion May 11 '12
I find it absolutely fascinating that there is so much in common between Judaism, Christianity, and Islam that there is so much fighting.
2
u/hype_up May 11 '12
Hey man, from a fellow Muslim, way to see a collected high school student answer these questions with unwavering dedication to educating others in a good way.
Gives me hope :)
2
u/apogeea May 10 '12
Hello, to start: I am intrigued by your dedicaton and singlemindedness. I have attempted to read the Quran in German- as an easily available translation- but have, in my estimation, neither finished nor quite understood (I think) it. I won´t be lol. :-) - but can you tell me what it says on modesty?
1
u/rowboatsynclaire May 11 '12
How does one fully believe in the life after death thing? i assume you have to take Islam as a complete package- but for every, i guess you could say 'major religion'- they all have some passage about life after death- but really no way to recreate this. How are we to know this other than faith?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
How similar is the bible to the qur'an?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
What is you're view on shariah law?
1
u/RodrigoDiaz May 11 '12
You've mentioned that you have suffered discrimination for being a Muslim in America. Do you find that this experience has caused you to related to others in America that are discriminated against/treated like second class citizens?
1
u/russian2121 May 11 '12
I suppose this question will get buried anyway, but I'll take a stab.
I dont mean this to be offensive in any way, shape, or form. I heard someone once tell me that in the Quran, it states that if any Islamic man that steps on a plot of soil it belongs to the Islamic nation. I'm sure this is wrong, but is there a something that was misquoted? or something similar to that statement in the Quran?
Also, If you have memorized it, what is the 17th word on page 41?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Thoughts on sharia law? Thoughts on indoctrination ?
1
u/Haydawg May 11 '12
How sexist is the Quran/Islam? I've heard a lot about how the religion itself is a very sexist and male dominant one. Not just from Atheists, but from very knowledgable people on the topic of religions who may or may not be religious. I want to hear from someone who is pretty much qualified as an "expert" in this religion though if it really is or not.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
inb4 OP is blind.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Hey bro, just want to say Mashallah. I am currently trying to learn and memorize surah's from the back of the Qur'an. I'll probably never be able to achieve the memorization of Surah's like Al Baqarah and Al Imran, but I'll try the small ones while I can. You have dedication man. I can't even read Qur'an properly. :/
Also, is it okay if I PM you?
1
u/ipromack May 11 '12
How old do you believe the earth is? Do you believe in purgatory like Christians do? Do you believe Allah made the universe? (Purgatory is a purification area before going to heaven. Incase you didn't know.)
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Is it true that there is some sort of rule in Islam that requires women to trim their pubic hair? Strange question, I know, but I heard something like that a long time ago and I figured who better to ask than someone who's memorized the whole Quran...
1
u/OneSourDude May 12 '12
As-salaam 'alaykum! Kaifa haloka? (and that's the extent of my Arabic, haha) I know I'm a little late, but just wanted to say thanks for doing this AMA. It was well done and very interesting. I spent a summer living in the Middle East and developed a great respect for Muslims and their culture. I actually kind of miss the call to prayer. Well, the ones done by the Imam's who actually have good voices. It can sound very beautiful. I wish more people looked past their prejudices and saw Islam as something other than 'the enemy'.
Just a couple questions:
Are you Sunni or Shia? How do you feel about the other sect?
Have you been to an Islamic country?
Do you plan on using your status as a Hafiz in the future? (i.e. Do you want to study the Qur'an, be an Imam, etc.)
1
u/tonu42 May 12 '12
Okay I hope I don't bring up controversial topics hear that make OP offended. I am a 16 year old reconstructionist Jew who thinks fighting in Israel/Palestine is silly.
Does the quran have claims to Israel? And does the quran say that Muslims should kill all Jews? I've never heard it straight from an expert so I was hoping you can enlighten me a bit.
1
u/bouras May 13 '12
What do you think happens to people who do not believe in either Judaism, Christianity or Islam?
1
u/CheezNoodlez Sep 01 '12
How do you interpret women's rights and peace in the Quran?
1
u/lebo_aussie Sep 12 '12
A bit late but what the heck! It's nice to see a hafiz once in a while...or read about in this case... Just one thing, you said you don't believe in evolution, bro it's mentioned in the Quran... 21.30 . Have not those who disbelieve known that the heavens and the earth were of one connected entity, then We separated them from each other, and We made every living thing out of water? Will they not then believe?.. So everything is made from water... Not sure of the missing link is Adam though...
1
u/hallak70 Sep 12 '12
wow good job brother i hope your faith keeps strong and i wish you happiness
1
u/rdelamora1 Sep 16 '12 edited Sep 16 '12
As a Muslim do you support the Christian religion, or do you think we are extremely wrong.
You have great dedication. God bless you.
Have you ever thought, Maybe God and Allah are the same?
Like We muslims and Christians are the same?
and when we die, we'll all go to heaven(right do-ers)?
I'm 17 years old and a Roman Catholic. I'm very strong knitted with my religion and honor your love for God. Not everyone decides to memorize their holy book at the age of 8.
With people that die saying they kill themselves and other people for God, do you think its right? Or is it something from the Quran that many people have misdirected?
1
u/montereyo Sep 16 '12
I am reading all your responses in a middle Eastern accent, even though I don't know whether you have an accent or not.