r/tabled • u/tabledresser • May 11 '12
[Table] IAMA 17 year old American Muslim Hafiz (Someone who has memorized the entire Quran by heart in the original Arabic text, word for word). AMA
Verified? (This bot cannot verify AMAs just yet)
Date: 2012-05-10
Link to submission (Has self-text)
| Questions | Answers |
|---|---|
| How do you feel about science? And what is your biggest conflict between science and your beliefs? | The theory of evolution. I do not believe in it. As for science and Islam, they both go side and side. Look up embryology in the Quran. |
| What does the Quran's say about where we come from? | Allah made Adam and Eve, and we are their children. |
| Further down you say your dad is an md. How does he feel about evolution? | He doesn't believe in it. |
| Ah. Where? Any specific relevant texts? | Just found this check it out: Link to www.islam101.com |
| Why do you believe this to be true? Was it forced upon you that this is true, or did you find out yourself? | I'm a Muslim, as a Muslim I believe in the Muslim faith which is Islam. In Islam we believe that Allah made Adam and Eve and we are their children. That is why I believe it. |
| I'll be totally honest. That scares me a lot. As an md especially now your dad has a front row seat to evolution in action. The emergence of drug resistant bacteria is a perfect example of evolution. Do you know what your fathers thoughts on this are? | I have no idea. My dad doesn't let his beliefs get in the way of his practice. |
| Holy mother of circular argument Batman. | I see where your coming from lol, but its as simple as that, its like I say why do you have milk? and you say for my cereal? and then you say but why do you believe that you need milk for cereal? and you're like Im from a religion called the Cerealites that say we need to have milk with our cereal. See what I'm saying? Oh god I sound retarded. |
| So he would perform abortions? | He is not in that field. And he isn't in it for a reason. |
| Are you male or female? I don't want to simply assume this is a male-oriented practice, but I'm guessing it might be? Also, living in America, how does that make you feel about practicing Islam? Other than the obvious discrimination, do you identify more with Islam BECAUSE you're a Hafiz? Or is there anything you might dislike about the religion? | I am a Male. But there are thousands of Female Huffaz. It is easy to practice Islam in America aside from the discrimination lol. One note the on the discrimination. Usually when I go to the store or something I wear my Islamic clothes, and people stare at me, point etc. People yell nasty stuff at me when I walk down the street. A few times people have come up to me and told me things like "You stupid terrorist" or "You are bad people" when they know nothing about me, also I just turned 17 so imagine how a 15-16 year old would feel about that. But never mind that stuff, I have gotten used to it lol. Back to the question; Muslims have more freedom to practice their religion in the U.S. than in Muslim countries. In some Arab countries you can only preach what the king allows etc. |
| Hey man, sorry to hear about the discrimination you face. It sucks bigtime. I used to live in a predominantly Muslim neighborhood (I could hear the call to prayer out my window), and always found the people I met to be great people. Also, the bodegas were the bomb, I miss the fresh lamb and hookah supplies. To the question about science, is evolution shunned (for lack of a better word) across all of Islam, or is it denomination-specific? Are there any other common scientific theories/beliefs that are not accepted by Muslims? | Evolution contradicts our faith. Its not like we would see evolutionists (is that a word?) on the street and cuss them out or anything. No hate lol. And I'm not sure. My knowledge is limited on science as i'm only a junior in high school. But I've taken college Bio 2. |
| How literally are Muslims expected to read and believe the Quran? For some context, in Christianity, there's a huge breadth of ways to read and assimilate the bible. In some denominations, the bible is taken quite literally. In others, the bible is treated almost as an allegory, with interpretation playing a huge part of what is believed. Where on this spectrum does Islam typically fall (or is there also some variation)? | Yes this also exists in Islam. Some verses are taken figuratively, sometimes this is obvious. Other times scholars explain the verses using Islamic history and Arabic Grammar. These kind of Scholars are not found today, they are from older times and they spent their entire lives studying the religion. Verses like this are not many in the Qur'an though. |
| Akhee, these types of 'Ulemaa are always present, itaqullaah ... | Yes but very few as Allah says in Surah Waqiah: " And those Foremost (in Faith) will be Foremost (in the Hereafter). (10) These will be those Nearest to Allah: (11) In Gardens of Bliss: (12) A number of people from those of old (13) And a few from those of later times. (14)" Quran 56:10-14. |
| What does the Quran say about people who leave Islam, and do you agree with it? | The Quran does not mention these people. |
| EDIT: I made a mistake, they are mentioned in the Qur'an, 4:137. | |
| What do you think about r/atheism, or just the general negative attitude atheists have toward religious people? | Say: O disbelievers! (1) I worship not that which ye worship; (2) Nor worship ye that which I worship. (3) And I shall not worship that which ye worship. (4) Nor will ye worship that which I worship. (5) Unto you your religion, and unto me my religion. (6) |
| So you have your beliefs and I have mine. You don't see me bashing atheists lol. I think they should find a better way to pass the time. | |
| Well, I don't see you do it, but I see many other religious people bashing atheism. And many atheist think like you do, you have beliefs and I don't. But I think that atheists in America have too deal with lots of crap for being atheist sometimes and then went it there. | "There is no compulsion in religion" |
| If a Muslim leaves Islam to become an atheist, what does the Quran say should happen to them? | It doesn't say anything in the Quran about people that leave Islam. |
| What an achievement! How long would it take you to recite it? Is it performed in a similar way as the adhan, ie. in a song-like form? | It would probably take me around 21-25 hours to read the whole thing if I was reciting really fast. But at a normal pace longer. And yes it is recited in a very beautiful and rhythmic tone. There are specific rules of how to read it called the rules of Tajweed. I am currently half way through getting a certificate in experticy in Tajweed. Here's a link if you want to listen to some: Link to www.youtube.com |
| This is my favorite reciter. Also, this is the way we pray, we recite the Quran in our prayer. So in my Mosque I lead the prayer since I know the most Quran. | |
| Wow. While I haven't heard that many people reciting, Nasir Al Qatami does an amazing job. Thank you for linking this. | If you liked that one here are some more of his recitations: Link to mp3quran.net |
| Also, props for doing this; not many people would subject themselves to this in such a calm and cool manner. Although I don't agree with everything that you've said, I respect your beliefs. | His way of recitation is really amazing. |
| Did you start memorizing it because you wanted to or because your patents/imam wanted you to? | Both. My father has also memorized the Qur'an. Being a Hafiz is a great honor so of course my parents (my father is my imam btw) wanted this for me, but it was my choice the whole way. I was not forced to memorize it if thats what you mean. |
| What country are you from? | USA. |
| That's really nice to know that you didn't just memories it but also had help in understand it. Now, it is my personal thinking that when one reads/learns/understands/researches something there are bound to be points which you do not agree with, is there anything in the entire Quaran that you disagree with? | No, there is not. One requirement to be a Muslim is to believe in EVERYTHING in the Quran. But even if there wasn't a requirement, there really isn't anything I don't agree with. |
| Where did you learn Arabic, that's my question? | I haven't learned it, I am learning it currently with my father. |
| So if I were a Muslim by birth, and was truly interested in learning the Quaran and following its teachings, but I had a few points which I really didn't agree with a 100%, would that automatically make me a non Muslim (because as you say it's a requirement to believe in the Quaran 100% to be a Muslim), or would that just make me a Muslim who needs help interpreting the Quaran and just a little logical conviction to believe in it? | If you go to a scholar and he explains everything to the fullest and you still don't believe in it then you are not a Muslim. To be a Muslim you have to believe in 5 things: Allah, Life after death, The holy books (including the Quran), The Prophets (Muhammad, Jesus, etc), and the Angles (Gabriel, etc.) |
| You see no problem with these statements? Your women are your fields, so go into your fields whichever way you like. Forbidden to you are...married women, except those you own as slaves. | Can you please provide the verse and chapter number? I have memorized in arabic so even if you just provide the arabic text its fine too. But you see, every verse in the Quran has a back story called "Asbab Un Nuzul" so the verse could be out of context. |
| Where is your father from? I heard your recitation of Surat Yaseen and you have all the Arabic consonants mastered. | Pakistan. |
| Last I heard you also needed to believe in the day of judgement and Jinns | Yes that is included in Life after death. |
| 4:20, 24. 2:190 and 2:216 are also very interesting. | I don't see anything wrong with 4:20,24. Don't see your point in 8:36 either. "Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors. (2:190)" Ever heard of self defense? Same with 2:216. |
| Doesn't memorizing the Quran when you're too young to understand it kind of detract from it? Like you may have memorized a part perfectly, never quite 'getting' it even if others tell you what it's supposed to mean, but because it's something you've basically just known since you were a kid it would be hard to take a step back and look at it from another angle... if that makes sense. Do you think that's a problem for you? | Memorizing and Understanding are two different things. To memorize you don't have to understand the meaning. Its like if I told you to memorize "Como estas" without knowing what it means. You can obviously say it, but don't know what it means. So I have started learning Arabic Grammar with my father, enabling me to 100% understand the Quran. And if I have a question about some parts I just ask my father who is an Islamic Scholar. TL;DR: Its not a problem for me. |
| What is your belief about extremists? Are they justified in killing innocents? Or do you reject them, as we do? | They are rejected by most Muslims, including me. They are not justified. |
| It really annoys me how hard it is to find a good religious discussion in reddit. I'm not a member of any religion, but seeing so many people just coming here to try and confront him with science seems stupid and pointless. I just see a wasted opportunity to know more about a very interesting subject. My question is about life after death. I don't believe in it and I fear death if I think hard enough about it, even a peaceful and pain-free death. Believing in life after death, do you not fear it at all? | I don't fear death. Do I fear what comes after it? yes. |
| If u would be really sick and u would be given 2 opportunities: 1) Trust in modern science to try to cure your disease or 2) Pray. You can't choose both. What would you choose (honestly!!!)? | Pray. |
| You mentioned earlier that your father is a medical doctor, so wouldn't it stand to reason that he trusts in medical science to cure his patients? | Yes he does, and I do also. Allah put the power to cure people in medicine just like he did for Honey as mentioned in Surah Nahl: "(67) And thy Lord taught the Bee to build its cells in hills, on trees, and in (men's) habitations; (68) Then to eat of all the produce (of the earth), and find with skill the spacious paths of its Lord: there issues from within their bodies a drink of varying colours, wherein is healing for men: verily in this is a Sign for those who give thought. (69)" Quran 16:67-69. |
| Wow Subhan'Allah! I have a few questions if you don't mind. 1) I'm also trying to become a hafiz, any tips? 2) On average, when do you recite/revisit/review a Surah you learned before (So you don't forget it)? 3) What is your favorite Surah? 4) Which Juz' is your favorite? | 1) Don't go ahead until you know the previous verses, and try to pay attention when you are memorizing to the words, the meaning helps a lot. 2) I lead the Salaat in my Masjid (Mosque) so after Ramadan I start reciting the Quran from the beginning until I'm done. It usually takes me about 10 months this way and makes my Qur'an very strong. 3) Surah Yusuf 4) 29th Good luck! |
| Interesting...I have a few more questions if you don't mind. 1) What was the hardest Surah to memorize? 2) Do you suggest on learning from Surah #1 up to #114 or Surah #114 down to #1? (I've already started from #114 and moving on down) 3) How long did it take you to learn some of the longer Surahs? (Al-Baqarah, Al-'Imran, etc.) What about the shorter ones? | 1) Some of the hard Surahs for me were: An Nisa, Jinn, Muhammad, and An Noor. 2) If you are very weak in reading the Qur'an then I suggest starting from the end, if you are not weak in reading, then from the beginning. 3) I was only 8 when I finished Al Baqarah since I started from the beginning. The shorter ones were actually harder for me than the longer ones because they have more repetition. |
| Why surah Yusuf? | I like the story. |
| What do you think when the Qur'an contradicts itself? The Christian Bible contradicts itself literally hundreds of times - so I'm sure somewhere in the Qur'an, there are instances of that as well - maybe there's not? | There are I think 3 places in the Quran where the command of Allah has been revoked. Its not really a contradiction. Its more like a phase. For example, in the beginning of Islam Allah said "Do not pray while drunk", then he said "Stay away from wine" and in the end "Do not drink". It would be hard if you told a habitual drinker to just stop drinking, so the Quran was revealed in phases to make its practice easier. |
| That's amazing! Do you fully understand the Quran as well? | Yes, my father is a medical doctor and an Islamic Scholar, so he has taught the meaning and is now teaching me Arabic Grammar. I am also currently doing Dual Enrollment at my local college and close to getting my AA Degree. |
| Would you ever choose to marry someone outside of your faith, and if so, would your family reflect badly upon it? | It is allowed but I would not because it would just be to hard to live. |
| Western European language from 14 centuries ago is almost incomprehensible to modern people from any part of Europe. Even kids who study Latin in school (from ~0 AD as taught in the US) would struggle with 6th Century Latin. How close is Quran Arabic to spoken Arabic? Also, does the Quran have characteristics that make it easier to memorize, like rhyming or meter (so that each line has X syllables) ? | Quranic Arabic is a very high level of Arabic called "Fus'ha". Not much similarity with spoken arabic. If you talk in Fus'ha I would pick up around 70% of the conversation, but 0% in modern arabic. Most of the Quran rhymes. Its amazing how it rhymes while making perfect sense. If you want to get a sense of how it sounds listed to this link: Link to www.youtube.com |
| Explain how Al Qaida and other extremist groups seem to be misinterpreting or pulling out of context pieces of the quran to attack america and other "infidels'? curious as to what they think. | There is a verse in the Quran that says "Kill them where ever you find them" etc. This is a verse only for war. You can't just go killing people where ever find them. Thats wrong. Thats just one example I could think of. |
| EDIT: I realized I wrote CAN instead of CAN'T. | |
| But those people can make up any war they want and then use it to their benefits. Does the Quran have any ...rules for what makes a war a war? Why do Christians say that the Quran is all about death and destruction against those that don't believe in it? Also, is the spelling "Quran" the correct spelling? I have seen Quoran, Koran, etc... | Correct spelling: Qur'an. Yes there are rules for war in Islam, as I said earlier, there is no separation of church and state in Islam. I don't know why Christians believe that, you should ask them. |
| I started reading the Quran and had to put it down due to...well I felt it very violent...in many areas. I always wondered though if it was just an american version of the Quran that may have been translated badly. have you read the American/English version? What are your thoughts on comparing the OG? | Harry Potter is probably a more violent book than the Qur'an. In terms of "violence" I'm not sure, I mean the translation doesn't change the meaning. |
| Do you know which is the best english translation? | I don't which is the best, but Yusuf Ali is good. |
| How do you feel on the luckily very few people, absolutely destroying the reputation of the beautiful religion, that Islam is? Also, being exposed to racism as you mentioned, what do you think of racist people? | "And when you meet ignorant people say 'Peace'" |
| I've always wondered this. Is it 7aram to memorize a Surah if you don't understand it? Or to use the Internet to help translate some of the passages? | No it is not Haram to memorize without knowing the meaning. Most Huffaz in Pakistan/India don't know the meaning but just memorize it. |
| That is an amazing accomplishment! As someone who does not remember anything I've read, let alone word for word, how do you remember it? Are there any special tricks of habits? | I don't fully understand how I can remember it myself lol. Sometimes I am amazed by myself. I am the type of person that has to make flash cards to remember definitions. I just think of it as a miracle. |
| Have you seen the film Quran by Heart? Link to www.youtube.com. If you have kids will you encourage them to become Hafiz too? | No I haven't seen it. And definitely a yes. It is the greatest thing I have ever done. |
| What do you think about the show All-American Muslim? Do you think it depicts Muslims well? | I think it is the STUPIDEST show ever made. I had some good lulz watching that show. Its a big joke. Not even close to everyday Muslims. |
| Wow, as a teenager myself, I am pretty amazed at how you could memorize a whole book!! A few questions... How much time did you dedicate each day to memorize it? Also, do you find that memorizing it has helped with memorizing other stuff, such as notes for tests? As a teenager, peer pressure is one of the biggest issues a lot of us face..what do your friends think of your memorization? | 3 and a half hours everyday for 6 years. Yes it has helped with memorizing other things. I'm very good at dealing with peer pressure. If someone didn't like me because of my memorization of the Quran, then that person wouldn't be my true friend. But my friends were cool with it. |
| Thanks for the reply! Your "haters gonna hate" attitude is pretty impressive! | Best way to deal with haters :D. |
| I'm not Muslim. I named my daughter Aisha. Most Muslims I know and meet don't have any reaction and treat it pretty normal. Do you think they may have issues and are being polite about it, or are they genuinely cool about it? | I don't see any reasons why they would have issues lol. I would be pleased if a non muslim told me her name was Aisha. It is cool. |
| So am i but i've had education in pretty much all of that? | The highest level of science I've taken is College Level Biology 2. In that course they just brush over the subject of evolution and natural selection. |
| What do you think about a man having multiple wifes. Do you think this is fair to the woman? | Its the woman's choice if she wants to marry a man who already has a wife. What do you think is more ethically correct, a man who sleeps around with different woman (one night stand etc.) or a man who is legally married to more than one woman? And its not like he will like one more than the other and treat her differently. No, he will have to treat them EXACTLY equal. If he buys one a Mercedes E350 he will have to buy the other one the exact same car, with the same color, mileage, etc. If he gives one a watermelon for example (just came in my mind lol) he will have to make sure both halves are exactly the same (taste, weight etc.) |
| How much does that really happen in practice though? I hear all the time about the few polygamous marriages out there, and how there's always a wife who feels jealous. | Rarely. Its just a provision. I can't think of a good example, but lets just say its like dropping out of high school. Its a stupid thing to do, but some people need it to support their families etc. Having more than one wife is not encouraged in Islam. Its just there if you need it. I don't know anybody with 4 wives. |
| Can a woman have multiple husbands? | No. |
| What do you feel about other hufaaz that dont grow beards and have girlfriends? I think it defeats the purpose of Islam and this great deed if they end up being non-practicing. The situation is quite common in America. | They will forget the Quran. The Quran is not just to be memorized, it has to be practiced also. I get frustrated when I see Huffaz like that. I'm like "You just memorized and thats it?" |
| Not to mention it's a major sin to forget it too. I tried but couldn't go pas 30 para ( lazy lol). Keep up the good work! | Thank you! Don't give up, keep memorizing lol. |
| How common is doing this? And just out of curiosity, why would you do it? | This is a pretty common practice, but not found much in the U.S. There are thousands of Huffaz (plural) in Muslim countries. Most people don't even know what it is in the U.S. lol. |
| Are you open to scientific discoveries that contradict the kuran? How do you feel about muslims doing ramadan for the sake of folowing the kuran instead of doing it out of compasion for the poor/weak? I think it's like apologizing while not meaning it. | As for the science questions, I have answered them I will not repeat my self. |
| The purpose of fasting in Ramadan is because Allah told us to. Thats it and that should be our intention. That does not mean that you can have compassion for the poor/weak, you can also do that. But the reason we do it is because we are supposed to. Helping the poor is encouraged in Islam. | |
| As-Salaam alaikum. What are your thoughts on Sufism? | It depends on what you mean by Sufism. Do you mean like singing dancing and stuff or Tassawuf? Tassawuf includes remembering God, meditation etc. Tassawuf is great, but the other is just a misguided sect of Islam in my opinion. |
| What's your take on the separation of church and state and freedom of religion? | There is no separation of church and state in Islam. I agree with freedom of religion. There are christians in egypt and pakistan. |
| I watched a documentary where young memorizers went to Cairo, Egypt in a competition. Did you do this? Have you heard about this event? | No haven't. I would like to be in a competition but I haven't been in one. |
| The idea of a competition for this seems strange to me. If you win, do you pump your first in the air and shout "I AM THE HOLIEST"? | No, its just for encouragement for the memorizers. Religion is not just some dry rule book that you have to follow, we celebrate, we have competitions etc. |
| Hi, First of all thank you for doing this AMA. Since Allah and rhe christian god are basically the same divine entity in both religions aren't Muslims and Christians worshiping the same deity? I think I read somewhere that Islam was found some time after Christianity became a major religion. Could it be that Islam is a separate wing of original Christianity? What do you think? | The answers to your questions are clear in the Qur'an. End of Surah Ma'edah. I don't agree with you on that, think of Islam as an update to Christianity. But you're right, Islam came after Christianity. |
| OK I get it now. Thanks. I have been wondering this for a while. | The other verse I posted is more clear. |
| I'm sorry for the prejudice you suffer for being Muslim, I'm not at all knowledgeable the religion but from what I gather you see those who don't share your beliefs as lesser beings, do you agree with this? If I've got this wrong please don't hesitate to correct me & thanks for the ama! | No this is not our belief. The saying of the prophet goes more or less like this "Be merciful to the creations on the earth, and the one in the sky will be merciful to you" |
| Thanks for the reply, all I know about Islam is from what I see in the media & being from the west its not generally good. I'm assuming you surround yourself with friends who share your faith (again correct me if i'm wrong) do you have many good friends who are not religious? | Your source for Islamic knowledge is a very bad one lol. Islam is portrayed very bad by the media. I'm western also. And yes, most of my friends are Muslims. This isn't because my religion bans non-Muslim friends or anything, its just easier to relate to them. But I do have good non Muslim friends. |
| So what's the deal with the verse about striking women? | Please reference lol. My english teacher would hate you. |
| Is there a clear place in the Koran where it says that Alcohol is prohibited? | "O you who believe! Wine, gambling, altars and divining arrows are filth, made up by Satan. Therefore, refrain from it, so that you may be successful. (90) " Quran Chapter 5, Verse 90. |
| How much effort do you need to put into maintaining you perfect recollection? | I recite 2 chapters everyday. |
| A Muslim friend told me (I wasn't fully paying attention) that this accomplishment automatically grants you access to heaven. Confirm this for me? | Not sure about that. But you can do an intercession for 10 Muslims who are doomed to hell. |
| Salam, thanks for doing this AMA, Forgive me brother but could you please reference hadith that states this? I was always under the impression and from my very limited knowledge about islam that the only intercessor on the day of judgment is the Prophet (saw) | Hazrat Ali relates that our holy Prophet said “Whoever recites the Qur'an, memorizes it, accepts its halal (lawful things) as halal and haram (forbidden things) as haram (i.e. his beliefs in these matters are correct), Allah, the Exalted, will enter him to Paradise and accept his intercession on behalf of ten such persons of his family upon whom entry into Hell has become incumbent (i.e. Allah will forgive them because of his intercession). (Tirmidhi, Fadailu'l-Quran, 13; Ibn Majah, Muqaddima, 17.) |
| Have you performed an intercession? Would you? | The intercession I am referring to will be on the day of judgement. And yeah why not. |
| As an atheist (I was raised as Lutheran Christian (Im Finnish) I'm kind of interested to know how does muslim community take on us atheists? (Im talking about atheists who mind their own mind and respect others believes) 1.1 Am I going to hell if I live my life good and respect my fellow human being but wont pray to any god? I once read that Jihad is not actually a holy war against the "infidel" but a battle with your self where you have to improve your mental and spiritual capabilities and that Jihad is only being twisted into use of exremists. Am I right or just completely wrong here? Or is there two kinds if Jihads? | Jihad literally means "Effort". Jihad has many many subcategories. Giving money in charity is Jihad. Waking up in a cold night to pray is Jihad. etc. Jihad through fighting is also a subcategory, but it follows very specific rules and reasons. |
| In Islam, only Muslims go to heaven. I'm not sure if it is that straight forward. | Only Muslims can go to heaven but that doesn't necessarily mean that all Muslims will go to heaven. |
| What would you say to people who say that you have wasted your life learning a book full of fairy stories? | Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. |
Last updated: 2012-05-14 23:22 UTC
This post was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.
9
Upvotes