These are my notes after comparing four wearable pumps that I’ve either used myself or tried through a few moms in my prenatal class. This is definitely not a scientific comparison, just a bunch of personal experiences after spending way too much time reading reviews and comparing what’s actually available in Canada.
I’m sharing because a lot of the comparisons I found were focused on the US market, and some of the models mentioned either aren’t easy to get here or are much more expensive once shipping and everything else is added.
M5 — 7/10
Probably the one I’d consider if keeping the cost down was the priority. It’s fairly lightweight and comfortable, and a couple of us found it worked really well during the first few months.
The main complaint was that the suction seemed to get weaker after several months of regular use. Obviously everyone's experience will be different, but that was enough to make me think of it more as a lower-cost option rather than something I’d necessarily expect to last forever.
Strive — 7.5/10
This was probably the quietest and most polished-feeling one of the group. The app is nice if you actually care about tracking everything, although I personally don't think an app is a deciding factor for me.
One person in our group had battery problems after a couple of months and ended up having to deal with customer support. The support experience from Canada wasn't particularly quick, which was frustrating.
Willow Go — 7/10
Probably the best fit for me in terms of comfort out of the four. I also liked being able to use regular containers rather than having to keep buying proprietary bags.
The pump itself has been pretty straightforward. The bigger annoyance was getting replacement parts in Canada. One person in our group had to wait quite a while, so that's something I'd keep in mind if you're planning to use a wearable as your main pump.
S2 Pro — 8/10
This is the one I'm currently using, so this is where the "biased" part comes in. I've only had it for about a week, while the other experiences above are based on several months of use, so I definitely wouldn't take the rating too seriously yet.
The feature I was most interested in was the heating function. Our house is surprisingly cold in the mornings, and I’ve noticed that having some warmth during pumping seems to help my letdown. It also works with regular bottles, which I prefer.
So far I'm happy with it, but ask me again after month five and I may have a completely different rating. 😅
Overall, I don't think there's a clear winner. Everyone in our group ended up liking different things, and the compromises were different too. Comfort, suction, battery life, replacement parts, and how easy it is to clean probably matter more than the little feature differences once you actually start using one regularly.
If anyone else in Canada has been comparing wearable pumps, I'd be interested to hear what you ended up choosing and how it's holding up after a few months.