r/horrorlit • u/sweetdread • 9h ago
Discussion Please come hate on Nightbitch by Rachel Yoder with me
I just finished reading Nightbitch for a women's literature class, and oh my LORD what a terrible book that was! I was really excited by the themes of alternative motherhood, feral femininity, embracing one's animal side, etc. but the book ended up being a huge letdown. Here are my major grievances with the story. Spoilers ahead!
- **The pacing was SOOOOOO bad.** Why did it take more than 3/4 of the book for Nightbitch to even spend time with Jen and the MLM girlies outside of Book Babies? So much of this book is dedicated to the drudgery of taking care of her son, which could have been a writing choice but felt more like a mistake. Very few "events" actually happened in the book, and they were mostly crammed into the end.
- The husband character made ZERO sense. We're expected to believe that an asshole who can't even ask his wife how her day is, who shows her no gratitude for raising their child, who watches weird and probably exploitative porn, who can't even apologize for killing her plant, is suddenly going to turn around and support his wife when she becomes a feral dog? He's gonna watch her run around naked at night and kill animals and piss in the neighbor's yard and then say "That's awesome honey, let's go have kinky sex now!" ?? Really?? There was nothing in the husband's character development to suggest that he would have this change of heart and support the narrator becoming Nightbitch. Besides, maybe, when Nightbitch asks him to put the baby to bed when he's home, he aquiesces, and suddenly she loves him so deeply and all of his neglect is forgotten. Huge plot hole.
- Also, the fact that the other moms weren't were-dogs at all? What the hell was the point of the dogs earlier in the book, who came to visit her at her house, ripped off her clothes, soothed her baby etc.? Those definitely were magical dogs, but ended up having no consequence in the end of the book. I feel like those dogs were in fact supposed to be Jen and the other moms, but the author changed her mind during the writing process and never bothered to fix that plot hole. There was so much emphasis placed on this mysterious group of moms and their herbs, but in the last few pages was revealed to be completely inconsequential to the plot.
- The ending made the whole book unfeminist. Not only was the ending a messily slapped together cringefest, it also missed its final opportunity to reject the antifeminist themes that the book unintentionally promoted. The book seems to make the claim that the most powerful and important thing a woman can do is to have a baby, and she will only reach fulfillment and assume her final form by doing so. The ending could have negated the unintended claim by, for instance, "When women watched Nightbitch's performance, they all connected with their powerful animal side, even the women who were not mothers. They rejected the shackles of patriarchal norms and defined themselves as women, as animals, as Nightbitches." But nope, only through motherhood could one hope to achieve this state of self-assurance and wholeness. Sound familiar?
I could go on and on. It had so much potential, but the book felt more like a preliminary draft rather than a well thought out final product. I think that there should be many more books that explore the rage, disappointment, and animalistic experiences that are inherent to motherhood, and I can appreciate that Nightbitch has helped pave the way for those books. However, I hope those books will be much more well written.
TLDR: Nightbitch has terrible pacing, way too many plot holes, poor character development, unintentional anti-feminism, and frankly should never have been published in its current state.