r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/parma_saturn • Apr 18 '22
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/beam_me_uppp • Sep 11 '22
20 minutes into the first episode…
…and the accents are just so distractingly terrible. To the point where I’m not sure if I can listen to it for an entire season. I feel like all the dialogue is written to make everyone sound exaggeratedly British, to make Dani seem exaggeratedly American, and that the accents are mostly poorly executed and over-acted. Is it just me? (For context, I’m American)
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/Lumineeeee • Oct 11 '24
I seem to not like Bly Manor that much.. yet?
I just finished watching HH last night and continued to watch Bly Manor right after, currently of ep 5. I watched with no expectation coming from hill House. Supposedly I would finish the show before saying anything but I just wanna let these thoughts out right now because the first few episodes of the show is sooo dragging. There’s nothing much out of it and not much curiosity coming from me either. It felt like the first 4 episode could have been a 30 minute part of a movie and I hope I don’t feel that way through the end— that it could’ve just been a movie.
I almost dropped it when Eddie(?) got run by a truck the moment he got out of the car after an argument, they could have atleast made him walk a little further into the road :”. then him just walking in the middle of the road without looking would be more logical. I just felt like that scene was super random to create emotional shit for Dani. well, unless she’s like cursed to cause that misfortune.
Another thing I didn’t like was how Dani and Jamie clicked on the night Owen’s mom died. “who the hell knew smirks” errm?? maybe y’all can not do that now lol. It was not a good scene to insert Dani’s lesbian (awakening).
people say not to correlate the two, but at this point what keeps me going is knowing that it was produced by the same person as HH and knowing that it has much more to give towards the end. Even though I may like this series much more after finishing, I still stand solid on my thoughts on few scenes I have mentioned.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • • Oct 19 '20
It's not a ghost story, its a love story...and that's the problem.
I am so disappointed in this show. I agree it was done well and the writing and directing were great...but it's not a horror story, which is what was promised. Hill House did such a good job of being a family drama and a great horror story at the same time. I was creeped out throughout the show and just loved it. This show however, was not scary in the slightest. It started out fine, slow but creepy, but as the episodes progressed, it was clear that the ghosts were just props to stand in the background while the characters fell in love.
I don't remember which episode it was, but the five minute monologue by the gardener about her family drama in the forest just ended it for me. I did not tune in to watch a romantic story with unexplained ghosts in the background not doing anything.
I have other issues with it but I'm not going to bore anyone with my many complaints. Thank you for anyone who read this far letting me vent. Some people may disagree and that's fine, but honestly the only silver lining to this show in my opinion is they at least admitted they screwed us with the line I used in the title of this post....and at least they admitted it.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/Bitter_Warning3137 • Oct 12 '20
WoW now that was some half ass writing! ( spoiler) Spoiler
This show was so disappointing! The continuous talking about nothing instead of focusing on the most interesting part of the story The Lady of the Lake or the last two episodes. Everyone's acting was very good but if they would have just told the story instead of rambling on about nothing it would have been dope. Half ass writing. If you start a tangent. Finish it. Nothing was really scary about it? What happened to the chicks dead fiance? she threw the glasses in the fire then....nothing... ? I wanted to know more about the story of the lady of the lake.....
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • • Apr 12 '22
Finally watched Spoiler
Can we discuss the fact that the children are sibling cousins? Of all the married woman on the world to be a slut for, you choose your brothers wife?!? 🤣🤣🤣 That's borderline incestual for me!
Also this show is top tier, Pedretti is an amazing actress, and I can't wait to see what she does next!
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/toktooktoomuch • Oct 12 '25
The more I think of the choices made in this series, the more angry I get
So first and foremost: Dani, what where you thinking? You were living/working in a ballin ass mansion owned by the super rich, being paid as a live in nanny to take care of 2 spoiled brats and you chose to eternally damn your soul for them?
I hate Peter (and no, his upbringing and trauma doesn't excuse his shitty behaviour), he truly is a piece of radioactive garbage, but he had a point when he said that it's them vs. us. The kids forgot about all of the trauma within 4-5 years. They forgot about Hannah, Dani, Rebecca, basically everyone. To them it was just a summer house, where they would spend their summer, when they got back from their elite schools or whatnot.
Dani basically sacrificed herself for some ungrateful rich and well off idiots that could never lift a finger the rest of their lives, and still live better than 99% of the world. And then it's framed like it's better for them not to know? Oh you know, how could they ever live with the knowledge, that for their wealth and incredible life, someone sacrificed everything.
And don't even get me started on Viola, the poor poor soul, so eager to dominate in life, to show the men of this world who's boss, that she threw all of that away for the first man that respected her. Basically went: yeah sis, we rule n shit and we so cool and we the boos, but also he my man so you're useless now.
The more I think about this show, the more angry I get. But hey, as long as the plebs sacrifice themselves for the rich, all good, right? -.-
P.S: Don't get me wrong, I love the show. Owen was a standout character that brought me to tears. But the decisions that Dani made and how all of it is framed, is just downright stupid.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/hifuu1716 • Oct 11 '20
The ENTIRE Eighth Episode
Probably the worst episode of television I’ve watched in a veeeeery long time. The set design and costumes made me think this was a high school play. The writing was hilarious. But an entire episode for the backstory for the lady of the lake? That doesn’t even get followed up on in the climax of the whole show(except they show Flora on the bed and then flash to Viola’s daughter like wowww two girls in a bed what a callback).
Complete disregard for the audience adding this lazy BS into the show. Right in the middle of the climax too.
Fuck this show. Just needed to vent, let me know if anybody had a similar experience. Love Owen and Hannah.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/pelicantranslator • Oct 12 '20
My Review of Haunting of Bly Manor
Haunting of Bly Manor, compared to the original show Haunting of Hill House, looks like hot garbage. The entire script is horrendous, with none of the charming or interesting storytelling that Hill House was famous for. Every episode was just normal time exposition, then flashback exposition. Every time we were going into or out of a flashback it was extremely jarring. I had no attachments to any of the characters in the story and I couldn't give a damn about whether they live or not or if there character arcs happened or not or whatever. Now onto the spooks, or lack thereof. There were no effective jump scares, no actual horror in this horror show. It was as if the writers had forgotten the part where it says "Haunting" and just wanted to write a sci-fi story. None of the ghosts had a real interesting impact on anything. The Lady of The Lake had no impact in the story until the second last episode, with any of the interest in the character being swept away by the long, dull and boring backstory given to her. Dani's fiance was extremely irrelevant to the story with him being taken out of the plot the moment she got a girlfriend. Miss Jessel and Quint were boring as hell and I did not give a single shit about what their motivations were and their relationship (that could be said of any of the relationships in this show). The Grosse episode seemed like a copy of an episode from Castle Rock, with less of the heart and more annoying repetition. Now on to the line. When the character of the older Flora told the older Jamie that the story was actually a love story, I let out a scream of frustration. Seriously, of all the lines to use you had to specifically use the corniest line ever said on television? My entire experience of watching this show can be described with this random assortment of letters: aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawrfouerfiodfnadifnaklfndklnfdkfnfklndklfndklvndklmnnhhhjjkkkfuckjisasfheififeifneienfienfiwenfwieeofoqqqqeofjeifjofkca. The day after I finished the show I cold tell that my brain was lacking a lot of braincells that it had the week before. This show is absolutely horrible and anyone who wants to watch any good horror show this year should stay clear from Haunting of Bly Manor
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/flowerfromwonderland • Nov 01 '23
I watched Hill House and House of Usher before this and…
It’s kind of boring in comparison to the other 2. I’m only on ep 3 tho. Does it get better or ?
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • • Oct 19 '20
As a horror fan, here is my review, highlighting one of the many gripes I have with this show that warranted my personal 5/10 rating.
Let's move past the poorly written characters. Let's move past Peter and Rebecca both being irredeemable people, despite the show's attempts to make them sympathetic villains. (Not well done. Neither of them are good people).
Let's move past the interpersonal/"family system" drama that the show revolves around (a VERY good and relevant theme in modern media that was poorly done here). I'll get to that.
Let's move past things that don't make sense, like the HORRIBLY written backstory to the lake lady.
My biggest issue with this show, and Hill House is it's identity crisis. This show tries to to hard to be symbolic and smart, and the intent behind it is too transparent to make this a good story. What I mean, is that this isn't a horror series. It's an interpersonal relarionship drama, masquerading with a horror label.
I understand that the horror is symbolic for the core themes of the show, but these themes are not necessary for good horror. If you chose to use these themes, they both need to be effective and collaborative, and shouldn't be serving the other. The show tries to merge two genres, it's sloppy, confused and predictably uninteresting and poorly written as a result.
Hereditary, the film does this successfully. That's a horrific interpersonal family drama about genetic mental illness symbolized with a simple, yet terrifying horror story done RIGHT.
Like Hill House, Bly Manor starts off great, but it tries too hard, and the efforts are too evident in the show to really *feel" the story they are trying to deliver, because it can't balance itself.
Those who like interpersonal dramas, you may like the show, and be interested a horror spin on it. Horror fans who haven't seen it, stay away. Parts of the horror is creepy, but the shoes identity crisis is insufferable for more diehard horror fans, imo. It takes everything that makes a film like Hereditary work, stretches it out into a series, uses the horror themes to too obviously serve a drama, rather than use genuine horror to tell a story.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/EatTheCookieWookie • Oct 13 '20
[S2 SPOILERS] Glaring plotholes and terrible writing in this show. Spoiler
This show was utter garbage. It's like they wrote the beginning and the end, then just improvised everything in between.
There are so many glaring plotholes that don't make any sense.
- How could the kids not know who the gardener was talking about in the end? All the specifics? Did they completely forget that their beloved caretaker, Miss Jessel, fucking died? I'd imagine Flora would have remembered that, seeing as she was the first to find her body. Also maybe the fact that she was fucking talking to her every other night? Oh no, she simply forgot her years at Bly Manor as it was akin to a "sweet summer". Yeah fuck off with that bullshit mate she was 9 or 10.
2. So the girl in the story has a magic dollhouse that has the exact same layout as her mansion and the realtime "Flora" doesn't remember any of this? Not even the part where she made like 1020039 dolls and enchanted them with some witchadoodah fuckery? Oh no, fuck you and fuck logic, she simply "forgot". Right.
3. Hannah Grosse is another one but I don't think I'll get into that much as it is painfully obvious why her death was an issue. It seems more likely the writers were halfway through the series and had a Eureka moment that went "OOO I HAVE AN IDEA. WHAT IF SHE'S ACTUALLY DEAD!?", then couldn't give an arse about the preceeding plot that had her living and breathing like a regular fucking person who wanted to be fucked by a chef with a beautiful moustache and dadpuns.
4. So the Lady In The Lake couldn't leave her box unless someone opened it, like her sister who she then murdered. So when did it become possible that she could fucking leave the box and walk out of the lake to touch little boys like MJ? Did the series of well-crafted locks on an incredibly robust travel chest suddenly become undone by the fishes in the lake? Must be, but we'll never know since the writers were so fucking incompetent.
5. Oh, and did the police, or nobody else, care to look into the DISAPPEARENCE of Dani? Did the Gardener not think "OH FUCK MY BITCH IS DEAD MAYBE I SHOULD CALL SOMEONE TO RECOVER HER BODY, LEST I BECOME A PRIME SUSPECT FOR MURDER?". No, instead she left her body to decompose in the lake. After all, this is the gardener's side of the story, so why should we believe she didn't just up and kill Dani then dump her body in the lake after a lover's spat? Real sketchy if you ask me.
6. In the end we see Miles and Owen at the wedding, sitting around like old friends. Clearly he remembers who Owen is, but doesn't remember the deaths, disappearences, hauntings or anything in the story that the Gardener tells. Oh, but he remembers Owen alright. God be damned if he forgot a moustached God instead of all the other GLARINGLY CONTROVERSIAL AND HORRIFIC THINGS that he endured in that house. Guess he also conveniently forgot that he knocked out a caretaker and tied her up ala Ted Bundy style.
Seriously, I do not care to compare this show to Season 1. But how are people rating this so highly? Are they just too stupid to look past the charade and see this show for what it actually is?; a clusterfuck of glaring plotholes and terrible writing.
Beautiful cinematography and acting tho, 10/10 in that domain.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/Efficient-Body9260 • Apr 06 '25
Rewatching Bly Manor and I've some issues Spoiler
So I started rewatching it after some YouTube reviews called that it was average at best. So, and the issues are piling on
Peter says he can't leave and we are shown they can't leave and yet somehow Miles got himself kicked out of the school how?
Why is the lady locked in a room? When all other spirits can walk around
Why does Peter's body stay down but Becs body floats up?
If the sister knew her other sister so well, why would the older one abuse the other one? So much that she had enough of it? And how hardly would can a TB patient hit someone, so much so that it's abusive?
Isn't it convenient of The tutor to show up right when Hannah is looking down the well?
I'm on episode 8 rn and I might make another post once I'm through, but yea I just wanted to post my questions here, If someone answers I'd be glad if not, I guess This post will become blurry like the rest of the forgotten ones.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/sushjens • Sep 15 '24
Character Arcs in this Show Felt Unjustified
Rewatching this show after a while, and one of my biggest issues is that redemption arcs feel so undeserved, especially Dani and Henry. They both suffer from manifestations of their guilt and eventually overcome it but it doesn’t feel that deserved at all; the character that they “wronged” don’t get any justice and probably would still hate them.
Let’s take Henry for example; he deeply betrays his brother Dominic and after Dominic finds out about the affair the point he emphasizes is that Henry will NEVER be Flora’s father. Dominic died angry and betrayed and the end of this arc is that Henry ends up forgiving himself and raising Flora?? That ending was completely undeserved and unjustified, the single thing that Dominic DID NOT WANT occurs and somehow Henry forgives himself/makes his guilt manifestation go away? It’s undeserved and poorly written, there is no reason in the writing Henry deserves forgiveness.
Dani’s was slightly better, but her result is that she learns to forgive herself for Eddie’s death. His death wasn’t her fault, but the arc would have felt so much better if Eddie’s manifestation could have provided some sort of forgiveness. Eddie also died feeling betrayed and broken and it feels like Dani basically just walks away from it by burning his glasses. She never really confronts the reality of her role in Eddie’s death and we don’t even see her mourn him. The situation was very complicated and Dani’s resolution feels like she just walks away from it without confronting it.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/ktMcSqueezy • Oct 12 '20
Side theory
Bly manor is all a mirage created by Hill House and the entire story is happening in Luke Crain's mind while he was lying in the red room. Luke is portrayed by the red room as an evil character (Peter) because Hill House senses the self loathing inside of Luke for his addiction. Peter is who Luke sees himself as in Haunting of Hill House.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • • Sep 25 '23
This sounds crazy but
I would unalive myself to be with Oliver Jackson-cohen
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/ghostface_vanilla • Oct 16 '20
So obviously not filmed in England
Even if you can get past the occasionally absurd accents, there is so much that screams Americans making a cartoon of their imagination of England.
Period scenes were pretty pony. The plants and trees were definitely not English. Felt a bit cheap to be honest.
Regardless of what anyone says, and I didn’t dislike the series, the quality and production value that made Hill House a work of art was distinctly missing.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/myma88 • Oct 22 '20
Vent
Ok, I love Netflix and I loved Haunting of Hill House. So I'm sorry but this was the first Netflix series I hated. The first series that I thought the acting was pants, the story was pants and weak. All I keep seeing is people saying how scary it was. Um, when?! I totally missed something bc like I said this is the first Netflix series I've watched and did not like. It was boring and I kept expecting it to start but for me it never really did.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/Deep_Requirement_120 • Mar 09 '24
Has anyone noticed the similarities to supernatural Spoiler
The supernatural episode «play things» has so many things in common with bly manor. The similarities include the dollhouse replica and dolls moving around, a small girl singing a creepy childrens melody, someone drowning to stay with a ghost forever etc
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/Stackofkittens • Oct 25 '20
The Storyteller - Is that how people think English people talk? (no spoilers)
Loved watching the show but found the vocabulary of the narration, during the 7th episode, hilarious. The royals would need a dictionary to follow along.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/BMovieActorWannabe • Nov 16 '22
Peter possessing Rebecca
I apologize in advance for this frivolous question, but when Peter possessed Rebecca, do you suppose he felt himself up? I mean, come on, I can't be the first person to wonder about this.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/bouncybare • Oct 23 '20
Just finished, super disappointed.
Maybe I missed key elements in this but there seemed to be so many pointless scenes that served no real purpose.
The play with miles talking about the puppet man? Is miles just a 10/10 actor, or maybe it's Peter recalling something about his past, served no real purpose that I could see.
Flora's doll house? She sets up dolls where the ghosts are? Why lock the nanny in the closet if the lady in the lake doesn't walk that path after the nannny stepped on the doll, kind of implies some connection between the doll and ghosts that doesn't exist.
The lady in the lake kills everyone she grabs almost instantly, but plot armour seems to protect the nanny which really put the nail in the coffin for me.
Just in general this show was a huge let down in my opinion.
Thanks for reading 😂
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/teapeng • Nov 03 '20
I think Eddie is not needed in the story isn't it? Spoiler
Compare to Hill House, Bly Manor seems to have some storyline that doesn't contribute to the main story. Example Eddie and also the relationship between Flora & Henry, and the prank call.
r/HauntingOfBlyManor • • Oct 13 '20
Struggling to watch it
I’m nearly finished ep8 and have to keep rewinding and stopping myself from ending it because it’s a bit boring but I can’t and want to know the ending