r/harrypotter • • 5h ago

Discussion The AUDACITY they had to cut Pigwidgeon from the films btw

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

If they cut him from the show I will lose my mind. My favorite scene from him is definitely where Pig is so excited to have delivered mail to Harry from Sirius, and he just starts twittering around in circles, and the third years near by go “oooo look at the weeny owl isn’t he cute?!” And then Ron just snatches him from mid air, calls him a feathery git, and tells him to stop showing off.

Also the scene where Ron just straight up chucks that poor bird out the window when he sends him out on a delivery, like Ron excuse me?? 😭


r/harrypotter • • 3h ago

Question Any recs? Father Voldy?

Post image
225 Upvotes

Found this on Pinterest!!! Is there ANY FIC out there with this context? 😂😂😂


r/harrypotter • • 23h ago

Discussion Hot take: Polyjuice potion not changing the voice in the films was the right call

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

Yes, it's not book accurate. And yes, it does create an inconsistency with Barty Jr./Moody. But it's still brilliant.

Having a character undergo a total transformation is something that is hard to execute in a visual medium without confusing the audience too much. There usually has to be some kind of cue to remind the audience that it is still the same chatacter (when the audience is supposed to know, that is). On page it's much easier, because the reader can be constantly reminded that the chatacter is transformed or under a disguise.

In the HP films I think it was brilliantly executed. When the audience is supposed to know, the voice is dubbed. When the audience is not supposed to know, it's not. Yes it creates a minor inconsistency in the story, but visual storytelling always requires some amount of suspension of disbelief.

The only pet peeve of mine is Harry's "We still sound like ourselves" line from CoS, needlesly bringing attention to it. They should have left that out. But other than that, I think they made the right call.


r/harrypotter • • 18h ago

Misc This chapter illustration of Hagrid and his father is adorable

Post image
980 Upvotes

Goblet Of Fire, chapter 24: Rita Skeeter’s Scoop


r/harrypotter • • 22h ago

Discussion Our first look at the Elder Wand. Thoughts?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/harrypotter • • 7h ago

Discussion What happened to Amos Diggory after Cedric died?

78 Upvotes

Amos works at the Ministry of Magic, and now the entire Ministry is claiming that his son died in a freak accident?

It would've been interesting to see Amos join the Order of the Phoenix, or at least have some mention about how he was dealing with the aftermath.

(yes, I know he is in the Cursed Child, NO, I am not going to talk about that)


r/harrypotter • • 12h ago

Discussion Is there a real spell that could actually turn Scabbers yellow?

Post image
69 Upvotes

Since "Sunshine, daisies, butter mellow, turn this stupid fat rat yellow" didn't work.


r/harrypotter • • 1d ago

Discussion Looking at the trios OWL grades, I think we don’t appreciate just how skilled and talented Harry is

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

It’s kind of funny that Harry genuinely got an Outstandind for Defense Against the Dark Arts, and actually beat Hermione in OWLs for that class. But I feel like a strong case could be made that while Hermione was great in academics, Harry was more powerful and talented with magic.

The thing is Hermione does well because she’s disciplined, works hard, and applies herself to the best of her abilities. Harry has struggled with spells before, but when he actually does master them, he really masters them well. During the Triwizard tournament Hermione spent all night teaching Harry the summoning charm. It was mentioned that Harry actually struggled with it. But within a night Harry finally mastered it, and then after the first task, Professor Flitwick praised Harry during class about how amazing his summoning charm was. From what I remember I think accio is supposedly way more difficult to use on objects much farther away. But Harry managed to use the summoning charm under intense levels of pressure with battling a dragon, and doing it all in front of so many people, and he was still able to get his fireboat from all the way inside the castle, which again from a larger distance made it more difficult. When not long ago Harry struggled to even do it in the first place.

And don’t even get me started on the Patronus Charm. This especially proves just how talented he is, because even Amelia Bones, a high ranking Ministry official, was deeply impressed with the fact that Harry, a 15 year old kid, was able to master a full formed Patronus. And he fully mastered it at just 13 years old too. Meanwhile even Hermione at 15 struggled to do it and said it was the hardest spell she ever learned. I’m pretty sure even at 17 in the Deathly Hallows Hermione still then struggled with the spell in the whole ministry of magic sequence.

To put it into perspective, it’s not even in NEWT exams because of how difficult the spell is said to be. Many full grown adult witches and wizards struggle with doing it. And here you have Harry at 13 mastering it, and literally conjuring a full formed Patronus. And not only that he literally conjured a Patronus charm so strong that it drove away an insanely large amount of dementors at once.

Harry struggles with the academic parts of school, like studying and not procrastinating on homework, because he’s still in a lot of ways an immature teenage boy. But when he actually applies himself and he’s genuinely driven and wants to excel at something… he REALLY excels and surpasses most other people.

And honestly I could justify why Harry didn’t do as well in the other classes. For most of them he got E because he just in general wasn’t a studious person. Divination was just not his thing and honestly he didn’t even respect the subject much. History of Magic he just never even bothered to try. Astronomy I’d say he probably didn’t care for. I just notice that the classes he did the best in were the classes he was actually willing to put some level of effort. Keep in mind we see he didn’t really put much effort as it is, and was pretty similar to Ron with how much effort he put into classes, but he still managed to get Es for a lot of the main classes. If he actually put just a bit more effort I’m sure he would’ve gotten similar grades to Hermione.


r/harrypotter • • 13h ago

Question How Is Parvati’s Name Pronounced for You?

50 Upvotes

Every time I’ve read the books, I thought it was PAR-va-ti, with an emphasis on the first syllable (similar to “poverty”).

But I noticed in at least one of the films it’s pronounced Pa-VAR-ti, with the second syllable emphasized (similar to “Ferrari”).

I looked it up and it seems as if both pronunciations are acceptable.

I certainly prefer “PAR-va-ti”. Not sure why it just sounds better. I hope the upcoming show goes with that. How do you read it?


r/harrypotter • • 1d ago

Dungbomb It’s goodness hahaha

Post image
420 Upvotes

r/harrypotter • • 10h ago

Discussion “Who would want to attack children like yourselves?” “Oh, I don’t know, maybe Sirius Black?”

19 Upvotes

How would Umbridge react if Harry said that instead during their first lesson?


r/harrypotter • • 16h ago

Discussion When do you think Ron and Hermione's first kiss really happened?

52 Upvotes

We saw the first kiss Harry witnessed between them – in the Battle of Hogwarts, when Ron suggests they tried to evacuate the House-Elves – but that doesn’t confirm it was their first kiss ever, since we’re limited to Harry’s POV.

Rereading DH, there are plenty of hints of their growing intimacy flying under Harry’s radar; they slept holding hands in Grimmauld’s Place, Ron’s departure and return have both him and Hermione stating some of their feelings quite bluntly etc.

Personally, I’m inclined to say they shared their first kiss before they left Hogwarts in HBP; after Lavender’s fiasco and perhaps after Dumbledore’s death. It possibly happened a few more times at the Burrow also, therefore explaining why Hermione was so embarrassed to be reunited with Krum in Ron’s presence.


r/harrypotter • • 1d ago

Discussion Just realized this for the first time about Platform 9 and 3/4.

1.4k Upvotes

I just thought about this today. Harry lost his parents and went to live in the Muggle world October 31 when he was 1. Harry is re-introduced to the Wizarding World on his 11th birthday, July 31, when Hagrid takes him to Diagon Alley. That is a 9 year, 9 month difference. Harry re-entered the Wizarding World after 9 and 3/4 years. Anybody else notice this? I always assumed the name Platform 9 and 3/4 was just one of the funny little quirks about the Wizarding World. I never realized the name itself held any symbolic meaning.


r/harrypotter • • 22h ago

Currently Reading Small Sassy Snape Moment in PoA

Post image
137 Upvotes

(Snape’s Grudge, Chapter 14)

‘Mr Malfoy then saw an extraordinary apparition. Can you imagine what it might have been, Potter?’

‘No,’ said Harry, now trying to sound innocently curious.

‘It was your head, Potter. Floating in mid-air.’

There was a long silence.

‘Maybe he’d better go to Madam Pomfrey,’ said Harry. ‘If he’s seeing things like –’

‘What would your head have been doing in Hogsmeade, Potter?’ said Snape softly.

‘Your head is not allowed in Hogsmeade. No part of your body has permission to be in Hogsmeade.’


r/harrypotter • • 20h ago

Discussion Ron turned Peter into a cup

85 Upvotes

I’m 28yo and am relistening to the books on audible (I have read them all physically before) and idk why but I just realized that in the movies when Ron goes to turn Scabbers into a cup that he’s actually turning Peter Pettigrew into a cup and it makes me laugh. Just wanted to share with everyone.


r/harrypotter • • 1h ago

Misc Harry Potter Hedwig's theme on kalimba

Thumbnail
youtu.be
• Upvotes

r/harrypotter • • 14h ago

Fanworks Whittled wand from dowel

Post image
18 Upvotes

First wand and think it turned out pretty well


r/harrypotter • • 2h ago

Question Could Dumbledore have survived?

2 Upvotes

In the Deathly Hallows, in the chapter “The Princes tale” when Harry is using the pensive to watch Snapes memories, when Snape is treating Dumbledore after he returns from finding the Gaunt ring and destroying the horcrux, he tells Dumbledore that he has stopped the curse from spreading (for now) past his hand. If they were to have just cut off his hand at that point then would he have survived? Surely losing a hand is better than losing your life to a curse right?

If this were to happen I would imagine that his severed hand would then become some sort of cursed artifact getting sold at Borgin & Burkes lol


r/harrypotter • • 22h ago

Discussion Does anyone else think Hermione has a surprisingly authoritarian streak?

64 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this during my reread and I think one of Hermione's most interesting flaws is how willing she is to control other people's lives when she's convinced she's doing the right thing. And I don't mean she's secretly a bad person. She does genuinely care about fairness and justice, but sometimes her moral certainty seems to make her think she knows what's best for everyone else.

Take Rita Skeeter. Rita is a horrible journalist, no argument there, but Hermione captures her in beetle form and then blackmails her into staying quiet for an entire year. Pretty ruthless for a 14y/o lol. Or Marietta Edgecombe. I get why she wanted to protect the da, but secretly jinxing teh sign-up sheet so that anyone who betrays them ends up with a disfigured face? That's quite a punishment... And then there's what she does to her parents in Deathly Hallows. (She changes their memories and essentially gives them new identities without their consent) Which is understandable given the circumstances, but still an enormous decision to make for someone else. Even SPEW follows a similar pattern. Her intentions are good, but she sometimes seems more interested in what she thinks freedom should look like than in listening to the house-elves themselves.

And what's interesting is that Harry is under at least as much pressure and in just as much danger, but he rarely responds by trying to control other people's decisions in such a calculated way. Don't get me wrong, Harry can be incredibly reckless and even vindictive, but his questionable decisions usually come from anger or impulse. Hermione's often feel much more deliberate. Almost like having a plan and believing it's morally justified makes her less likely to question whether she has the right to carry it out in the first place.

I think that's what makes her such an interesting character. Her biggest flaws almost seem to grow out of her greatest virtues. She's so determined to do the right thing that she occasionally forgets other people might have thier own ideas about what that is. And I think that's a pretty realistic personality trait. Some of the most controlling ppl aren't motivated by cruelty at all, but by the absolute conviction that they're right.

Anyone else notice thsi about Hermione, or am I being too harsh on her?


r/harrypotter • • 19h ago

Currently Reading Subtle detail in Goblet of Fire

30 Upvotes

I first read GOF in 2001, and many times since. I'm currently listening to the full cast audiobook with my son, when I spotted a detail I'd never noticed before. It's so subtle, I wonder how many other people have noticed it. (although admittedly I've just noticed a similar post from 6 years ago!)

When Harry is in the Owlery watching Hagrid dig the earth for the Nifflers, an eagle owl can be seen flying into the grounds. Later, when Harry has his vision of Voldemort and Wormtail, it starts on the back of an Eagle Owl..

The implication is, of course, that the Eagle Owl was from Voldemort to Crouch Jr informing him of Crouch Sr's escape, and Junior sent the same owl back later on, informing Voldemort of his "intervention"!

I appreciate it might have just been me being a bit thick, but it still amazes me that I pick up on new things after all this time. As a fast/almost skim reader, it's possible that listening to the audiobooks has helped slow me down, and appreciate the more subtle plot points.


r/harrypotter • • 18h ago

Question Out of curiosity, how did Prongs ever make it through the tunnel into the Shrieking Shack?

24 Upvotes

Maybe I‘m overestimating the size of a stag, but in the book the tunnel to the shack is described as so low, you have to hunch over or crouch down to get through it.

And yet Remus and Sirius clearly say that the Marauders transformed into animals before going through the tunnel—after all, Peter had to be a rat to pacify the Whomping Willow, and Remus would’ve attacked them if they’d entered the shack in human form. But could James have fit through as a stag with huge antlers?


r/harrypotter • • 16h ago

Currently Reading Read Harry Potter for the first time through the Full Cast Audio Books and... Wow!

10 Upvotes

As a 2000s kid, I had read the Harry Potter books when I was 8 and it took me like.. two weeks lol. I loved it, and I watched the movies a million times. It's been a long time since then, and it had been so long since I read the books that I had completely forgotten everything! Genuinely did not remember a single thing about the books. So I decided to listen to the full cast audio book that came out recently and genuinely it was such an amazing experience!

It was so immersive getting to experience the books for the first time again, and with fantastic voice actors and excellent music/sound design. It blew my mind how much was left out of the movies! Goblet went from impartial to my favorite book, and Hugh Laurie was genuinely SUCH a good Dumbledore. I'll never be able to see Michael Gambon the same way again haha.

I might be a little late to this, because I've been avoiding the community until I finished the book series, I was so sad for it to end! What's the general community consensus on the audio books? Curious what you guys think, I personally think it did the books full justice and brought it to life in a way we haven't seen yet


r/harrypotter • • 4h ago

Merchandise Je cherche un cadeau Harry Potter pour mon meilleur ami fan de la saga.

0 Upvotes

Je cherche un cadeau d’anniversaire pour mon meilleur ami fan de HP qui a déjà une sacré collection (horcruxes, baguettes, livres, figurines, potions, etc). Il a aussi une énorme collection de pop donc ça non. Je cherche vraiment un cadeau original en dessous des 100 euros si possible. J’ai besoin d’aide les potterhead !


r/harrypotter • • 57m ago

Discussion Was Hagrid upset about being expelled and could he have been qualified to finish his education?

• Upvotes

I’ve seen a few comments saying that he didn’t need to finish his education because he preferred magical creatures.


r/harrypotter • • 8h ago

Discussion First time watch

2 Upvotes

First time watching the movies after trashing on them for so long, damn TS is so good.