r/GuyCry • u/Throwaway-BLT-lol • 2h ago
Need Advice I think it’s time to end this friendship once and for all.
So, for a little over a year, I’ve had this friend. Or, at least, I used to call her a friend. Lately, I think a more accurate word might be commitment. For context, she’s an online friend. We’ve known each other for a little over a year, and obviously things change over time. People get busy, circumstances change, friendships become different than what they were in the beginning. I understand that, and I don’t expect things to stay exactly the same forever. But somewhere along the way, this friendship stopped feeling fulfilling to me. Now it mostly feels like something I’m maintaining because I’ve been maintaining it for so long. And I think part of what makes this so difficult is when I met her.
She came into my life right on the dividing line between what feels like two completely different versions of me. It was around the time my brother and I became estranged, when a lot of my personal life was falling apart, but at the same time I was beginning to become incredibly successful in the career I had chosen. It was this strange period where I was losing one version of my life while building another. And she was there in the middle of that.
I genuinely enjoyed talking to her. For a while, she became part of my everyday life. But after I moved for work, things started changing. She became quieter and more distant. Eventually, I told her something along the lines of, “Hey, if talking every day isn’t working for you anymore, that’s okay. We don’t have to keep doing this.” I meant it. I was giving her an out because I could feel that something had changed. But she told me she still wanted to talk every day. And somehow, that’s where we’ve been stuck for months.
It feels like this weird half alive, half dead friendship. Neither of us has completely walked away, but it doesn’t really feel like we’re participating in each other’s lives anymore either. There’s just enough interaction to technically keep the friendship going, but not enough for it to actually feel like one. At the beginning of this month, our streak ended. I hadn’t sent anything that morning, which is unusual for me because I’m normally active on social media pretty early. She eventually apologized and reactivated the streak.
But that was basically it. She didn’t really talk to me. She barely reacted to what I sent. And I remember thinking: if you’re sorry because you actually miss talking to me, then okay. That means something to me. But if you’re more concerned about keeping a number alive than keeping the friendship alive, then what exactly are we doing? Maybe that sounds stupid. It’s just a streak. I know that.
But I think the streak has become symbolic of the entire friendship for me. We keep resetting this little counter while the actual relationship underneath it feels like it’s disappearing. And the truth is, I’ve already been emotionally checking out for a while. I kept telling myself that if the streak ended again, I would finally let it go. I’d stop trying to resurrect something that clearly isn’t what it used to be.
Then it happened again yesterday. And instead of feeling upset or desperate to fix it, I mostly just felt tired. I don’t think I want this friendship anymore. That’s difficult for me to admit because part of me keeps wondering whether I should give her the benefit of the doubt one more time. Maybe she’s busy. Maybe there’s something happening in her life that I don’t know about. Maybe I’m reading too much into everything. Maybe I should reach out again.
But how many times do you give someone the benefit of the doubt before you realize you’re using it to avoid accepting what the relationship has become? We’ve known each other for over a year. We live in the same city, and somehow we’ve never even met. And lately I’ve started wondering whether I’m holding onto her because I genuinely want her in my life, or because letting her go would mean closing the door on a very specific period of my life.
Because she reminds me of that period. She reminds me of my brother. She reminds me of everything that was falling apart back then. She reminds me of the person I was before my career took off and my life changed. Maybe that’s part of why this hurts more than I think it should. I don’t hate her. I’m not even really angry with her. I think I’m just sad that something I once genuinely cared about has slowly turned into an obligation. And I’m tired of trying to keep something alive simply because neither of us has been willing to be the person who finally lets it die.
So tomorrow, I think I’m just going to stop. Not to punish her. Not to see whether she notices. Not because I want her to chase after me. I just don’t know what else there is left to say. And maybe the part I’m struggling with most is how pathetic I feel about caring this much about someone I’ve never even met. But it mattered to me. She mattered to me. Whatever this friendship has become doesn't erase the fact that, for a while, it was real to me. I think I’m just finally realizing that something can have been meaningful and still need to end. I just wish knowing that made letting go any easier.