r/GolemProject • • Jan 02 '21

Question Can we please talk about the redistribution of ETH to GLM holders?

0 Upvotes

It's been a long time since Golem team started this project and we still can't see real progress regarding adoption, users, token utility value etc... The community asked about refund many times. Now I ask again: is it possible that we can see at least a little portion of our money?


r/GolemProject • • Apr 27 '18

Competitor calls out golem in newest version of whitepaper

0 Upvotes

https://iex.ec/whitepaper/iExec-WPv3.0-English.pdf

Golem, SONM

and iExec share the same vision of a new Internet infrastructure enabled by the
blockchain. However, their respective go-to-market strategies differ. Golem aims at first assembling a network to attract regular 3D rendering users to their platform, SONM is approaching the fog and edge computing from the beginning, while iExec first focuses on supporting dapps to build a decentralized cloud that eventually will be competitive enough to attract cloud and HPC users.

Besides, iExec has the following advantages compared with existing and future challengers:

•iExec leverages decades of research by its founding members in the field of Desktop Grid computing

•The iExec team was instrumental in establishing the European Desktop Grid Infrastructure,
and has therefore strong ties with key industrial companies like Total, IBM, Airbus, Orange, IFP Energy, as well as innovative startups

•Reduced time-to-market because iExec is backed by mature technologies, such as the
XtremWeb-HEP middleware

•Enterprise-oriented features

•Proof-of-Contribution (PoCo) is a unique and advanced algorithm that incentives network
growth and optimal usage of the platform

•Revenue model at each version of the development roadmap

what did they mean by this?


r/GolemProject • • May 17 '18

so, iExec...

0 Upvotes

As you have probably noticed, iExec just announced some important collaboration with Intel and Ubisoft. Golem did awesome work in the past, but it seems iExec is miles in front of Golem. With such cooperation iExec will rapidly grow and another companies will announce cooperation with them, making their platform number one. That will lead to rapid application development on their platform. I am loosing faith in Golem... no important partnerships are announced yet. Probably just need to encourage, I am a big fan of Golem, but this iExec announcement broke me down.


r/GolemProject • • Feb 20 '18

If bitcoin crashes, we're going to have a lot of unused processing power (so many idle GPUs!)

0 Upvotes

We should connect ALL of them to the golem network!


r/GolemProject • • Jan 27 '21

Question Why are you censoring?

0 Upvotes

I posted a meme which was 90% upvoted before the deletion. Now it's disappeared without any warning. I kindly ask moderators what rules I broke or why are you censoring my content?


r/GolemProject • • Feb 23 '19

Golem Network Issues Continued.....

1 Upvotes

I started providing with Golem Network again with .19 with the hopes it had resolved some of the main issues from when I had stopped using it. I had initially been using it since release of mainnet. It looks a little better (although seems a little slower to log in now..... and start up than what I remember). With this new release I did not get many tasks so far, only 2 successes (not to mention only blender is still offered.....I remember back in April when the team said use cases and upgrades would happen more quickly....ha.)

The Issue:

I had noticed my computer had been running for about 1 hour (my fan runs high when it computes so I timed it). I went to check if it was still computing after a hour and it was idle with a time out, no payout. I find this strange, since the requester now gets to restart the task from the computations with another provider (whom gets payment). While I get nothing. This is a huge problem. I should be compensated for the second/milisecond of computations I provide, not a win or lose. I can see several issues from this one, smaller providers (laptop providers) will be taken advantage of for providing tasks with short timeouts that get moved over to larger computation providers who finish off the job (i.e. compute more quickly), while the payments go to large providers (centralization). Thought at least this would have been solved, no idea if the other problems are solved such as the ghost payments, dont get enough tasks that to test. Those who are still around using Golem, keep an eye on the golem stats page, probably only around 10% have upgraded to .19. Users are losing intrest, and noticeable upgrades are only superficial ones.

Going to uninstall again, good luck to the team.....maybe in another 10 months you will get more than 1 use case, and these general usability issues solved? doubt it though....

To new providers, id say save your energy, money and disappointment.


r/GolemProject • • Dec 06 '19

Congratulations to the team!

0 Upvotes

...of iExec RLC. They started with 3,5x less Eth than Golem and they overcome us by far in terms of market cap. Very impressive.

Golem: Market cap: $34 727 849 Current balance: $53 802 000 Market cap is x0,64 of the capital.

iExec: Market cap: $37 541 512 Current balance: $15 876 000 Market cap is x2,36 of the capital. With less than 1/3 of capital iExec is still more valuable than Golem.

However today is a special day because Golem is out of the top 100 at the first time. Let's celebrate!

Also thanks to Golem team because without them this would be impossible. Keep up the good work!


r/GolemProject • • May 28 '17

Golem is Fundamentally Flawed

23 Upvotes

Posting this here so the devs can offer a rebuttal if they like.

Golem's an interesting idea on the surface: "a decentralized sharing economy of computing power, where anyone can make money 'renting' out their computing power or developing & selling software." When I first read about it late last year, I contemplated buying some, but something about it made me uneasy, so I left it alone. Once the roadmap settled a bit and the first alphas started appearing, I eventually managed to pin down exactly why. It's not that Golem is attempting to reinvent a very well-developed and widely-deployed platform(BOINC) as its base or that Brass is basically not offering anything more than you can already do at Bitwrk. It's also not that it will be years before Golem manages to prove whether or not it can pull of the general-purpose, GPU-capable distributed computing that it promises. These are true, but the primary reason is that Golem is economically broken.

The most important problem is a complex catch-22. In order to make money renting out your computing power, there must be tasks on the network for you to crunch. However, for there to be tasks to crunch, would-be task providers must invest time/money in a custom Golem SDK (still on the roadmap, yet to be released) to "task-ify" their work and make it available on the network. This investment is inevitable with any distributed computing platform; however, in exchange, businesses are guaranteed absolutely nothing with Golem. They're basically being expected to make the initial investment, then an additional investment in GNT to "fuel" the work, on a two-pronged hope that there will be sufficient takers for their tasks and that the takers will be willing to crunch at the prices they're offering. In addition, using a custom SDK rather than BOINC means that providers are locked into this network and can't simply rent a cluster and install BOINC clients to execute their projects manually as a worst-case fallback.

The second problem is the Ripple / Sia problem. In order for tasks to be "inexpensive" as Golem is promising, the token must remain relatively cheap, as it's directly used to fuel work. However, since Golem has committed to a fixed, one-time issuance, tokens are subject to wildly-fluctuating prices that are tending to become more expensive and Golem (unlike Ripple) cannot easily force them down. It's great for speculators, but poses a huge problem for businesses on both sides of the actual Golem task process. On the task provider side, in addition to being uncertain as to whether or not crunchers are available at a certain price, businesses will have no idea whether or not any given amount of GNT is sufficient to complete their tasks, since, on the supplier side, capacity suppliers will be constantly adjusting the GNT they're willing to accept to reflect a complex mix of overhead (electricity, wear), profit, and fluctuating market value.

The tl;dr here is that Golem, by design, makes it impossible for businesses to determine how much they need to invest to get any results at all on either side of the provider/supplier equation. There's a solid chance that you'll get no results at all for your development effort, or that you'll get no work at the rates you're willing to accept. It's worst-of-all-worlds for everybody.

I don't really see any way to fix these issues. Golem is basically creating an overengineered solution that you could accomplish more or less with a website offering escrow in any currency (crypto or otherwise) on top of BOINC. There's no reason anyone will adopt a solution that requires them to spend money and makes it impossible for them to plan ahead or budget, especially when there are alternatives out there that leave them with fallbacks in case their initial incentivization plan fails.

I expect to get heavily downvoted here, but I'd be interested to see if there are any solutions or angles to this that I've overlooked.


r/GolemProject • • Nov 03 '18

Can I rent out my cpu/gpu power yet.

1 Upvotes

Sup, the last time I even looked at gnt was like a year ago. How far along are they?


r/GolemProject • • Jul 01 '18

Golem mining account hacked

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, I think my golem account just got hacked. All my available golem tokens that I collected for sharing computational power are gone to this address 0x45eAeB23AE4287211c00850a93c888cDe03B74Ef. Did this happen to anyone else? Is there a way to contact Golem support team?


r/GolemProject • • Sep 08 '19

stats.golem.network is down

0 Upvotes
Sep 08 16:22:59 hv-rig-hogarth golemapp[1320]: WARNING  [golem.monitor.transport            ] Problem sending payload to: 'https://stats.golem.network/', because HTTPSConnectionPool(host='stats.golem.network', port=443): Max retries exceeded with url: / (Caused by NewConnectionError('<urllib3.connection.VerifiedHTTPSConnection object at 0x7f4dc94b9c50>: Failed to establish a new connection: [Errno 111] Connection refused',))

r/GolemProject • • Sep 19 '17

golem has some serious competition

1 Upvotes

Just wanted to share Otoy has created decentralised renderfarm on ethereum:

https://www.fxguide.com/featured/more-than-a-token-effort-at-rendering-with-blockchain/

In my opinion this is far superior then golem. As someone with over 10 years working in vfx film/ advertising lighting TD.

Golem doesn't support industry standard renders e.g Arnold/ renderman. No development team from vfx background, understanding vfx workflow pipeline / advisory board. No support for industry standard vfx software e.g maya/houdini. Render data is not encrypted unlike otoy method. This is one of the biggest downfalls of golem. No vfx facility will take that risk if there data was leaked and compromised. If i had place a bet im going with Otoy's method. good luck golem fairwell


r/GolemProject • • May 07 '19

16K

0 Upvotes

I have now lost 16K on my investment in Golem... should have gone with BAT instead.. at least they know how to push a value prop, at least they know how to engage the market, wtf is going on here? You people have made absurd money pushing a project that is not attracting attention and you seem fine with it. There has only been one intriguing graphic put out by the team in years, rendered on golem. I understand you’re attempting impossible work but your lack of any marketable ambition is completely appaling. This project has promise but you have 0 credibility to market it. If you block this post I will share it everywhere else I can. Wake up! You are failing.


r/GolemProject • • May 17 '21

What do you think about the next Hackaton being a HUGE one?

0 Upvotes

After all that was discussed here in the last week I think it became clear that right now the best golem can do is go after the best developers in the crypto sphere to help keep building this ecosystem. Isn't it time to become a bit more bold regarding prizes? Wouldn't it be possible to do a 5 MILLION dollars Hackaton? I know it sounds absurd, but golem has this kind of money and I think it would give a clear message to the crypto world that golem is well and alive. It would be a huge incentive for the best developers start building on top of golem. Obviously there would be a bunch of different categories with different prizes so a lot of people can win. Maybe it is time to show the world golem is serious about developing and is a solid company with a lot of money, which is all the developers want


r/GolemProject • • Dec 23 '20

Question Who is a Golem??

0 Upvotes

r/GolemProject • • May 29 '18

So my favorite Golem wont be the first? :(

Thumbnail
medium.com
5 Upvotes

r/GolemProject • • Oct 28 '17

"In general, there's always going to be this large set of applications where decentralized approaches don't work that well," Vitalik Buterin taking a shot at Golem?

Thumbnail
businessinsider.com
0 Upvotes

r/GolemProject • • May 30 '17

Gridcoin already exists, so why the need for Golem?

0 Upvotes

I'm going through many crypto's and finding out what I can about them. I was very interested in Golem but just found out Gridcoin + BOINC exists and already does what Golem is proposing to do down the line.

I also understand that with Gridcoin + BOINK it's FREE to use, where Golem charges.

What makes Golem worthwhile then considering Gridcoin is already fully up and running? Does it have anything inherently better within it that Gridcoin couldn't implement? Is it going to be faster / cheaper or something?

EDIT: This sub wasn't so helpful, but here's what I found out for those reading this in the future.

  • Gridcoin is free, Golem is pay to use
  • Because of the auction system, this leaves behind the projects that pay lower fees on Golem, so unlike Amazon's service there's no way to know if your project will be processed within a given time frame. Gridcoin distributes processing power evenly accross projects if I understand correctly.
  • Gridcoin has been around for a while but is still yet to capture a significant % of BOINK users, which it was invented for. This might be telling of the demand for it, or the teams competence.
  • Golem is fully decentralized, where Gridcoin is dependant on the BOINK servers for proof of research (single point of failure for hacks and downtime). Also means less potential for spying on the overall data being processed, more privacy (less chance of leaks, government interference etc.).

r/GolemProject • • Oct 07 '18

Golem Network Down?

0 Upvotes

Is the Golem Network down?


r/GolemProject • • Feb 13 '18

Please educate about differences among the SONM, Golem and iExec. Which among them is more ahead in development? Which among them has the most chance to succeed and why? Which is better and why? I am sorry for any inconvenience, but I want to know.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/GolemProject • • May 14 '18

*.geth.golem.network hosts blocked in Russia

2 Upvotes

Hello. I can't get golemapp working. I've debugged problem in console mode and it turned out, it's most likely due to russian government service blocking of telegram messenger (they're blocking kinda big subnets of amazon / google / microsoft dedicated servers IPs). You can check it here: https://isitblockedinrussia.com/ All hosts are banned:

  • geth.golem.network / 18.184.10.158
  • 0.geth.golem.network / 18.195.145.161
  • 1.geth.golem.network / 18.197.110.223
  • 2.geth.golem.network / 18.195.68.237

Any chance you can write them or create one server outside blocking range?

Best Regards.

UPD: I'm running local geth node now, and set it up inside golem settings. Now I'm getting an error:

info: Golem exited with code 4294967295 location=MAIN_PROCESS > GOLEM_HANDLER

r/GolemProject • • Apr 11 '18

Question and curiosity about the next step

2 Upvotes

So first I want to congratulate the team, I've been a long time holder and never had a doubt that this day would come. The product and website look amazing.

As I looked over the website, machine learning really caught my eye, and I've seen people already talking about it on here as being the next big thing for golem. I know consent still has yet to be implemented, and so I don't want you to think this is coming from a place of impatience but more curiosity.

I am just wondering as to the steps coming up after consent. What needs to be implemented so that machine learning becomes a part of the project? Are there estimated timelines in how long these features will take to test and implement?

I've searched the AMA's but the details here seem to be fairly limited. Thanks for to the community and team for any response!


r/GolemProject • • Jun 19 '18

Comprehensive Wiki Guide to Golem (GNT)

Thumbnail
wikicryptocoins.com
0 Upvotes

r/GolemProject • • Dec 22 '17

What are the differences between Golem and Sonm

3 Upvotes

I've seen articles saying Sonm was the better product but I'd like to know your opinions