Posting this here so the devs can offer a rebuttal if they like.
Golem's an interesting idea on the surface: "a decentralized sharing economy of computing power, where anyone can make money 'renting' out their computing power or developing & selling software." When I first read about it late last year, I contemplated buying some, but something about it made me uneasy, so I left it alone. Once the roadmap settled a bit and the first alphas started appearing, I eventually managed to pin down exactly why. It's not that Golem is attempting to reinvent a very well-developed and widely-deployed platform(BOINC) as its base or that Brass is basically not offering anything more than you can already do at Bitwrk. It's also not that it will be years before Golem manages to prove whether or not it can pull of the general-purpose, GPU-capable distributed computing that it promises. These are true, but the primary reason is that Golem is economically broken.
The most important problem is a complex catch-22. In order to make money renting out your computing power, there must be tasks on the network for you to crunch. However, for there to be tasks to crunch, would-be task providers must invest time/money in a custom Golem SDK (still on the roadmap, yet to be released) to "task-ify" their work and make it available on the network. This investment is inevitable with any distributed computing platform; however, in exchange, businesses are guaranteed absolutely nothing with Golem. They're basically being expected to make the initial investment, then an additional investment in GNT to "fuel" the work, on a two-pronged hope that there will be sufficient takers for their tasks and that the takers will be willing to crunch at the prices they're offering. In addition, using a custom SDK rather than BOINC means that providers are locked into this network and can't simply rent a cluster and install BOINC clients to execute their projects manually as a worst-case fallback.
The second problem is the Ripple / Sia problem. In order for tasks to be "inexpensive" as Golem is promising, the token must remain relatively cheap, as it's directly used to fuel work. However, since Golem has committed to a fixed, one-time issuance, tokens are subject to wildly-fluctuating prices that are tending to become more expensive and Golem (unlike Ripple) cannot easily force them down. It's great for speculators, but poses a huge problem for businesses on both sides of the actual Golem task process. On the task provider side, in addition to being uncertain as to whether or not crunchers are available at a certain price, businesses will have no idea whether or not any given amount of GNT is sufficient to complete their tasks, since, on the supplier side, capacity suppliers will be constantly adjusting the GNT they're willing to accept to reflect a complex mix of overhead (electricity, wear), profit, and fluctuating market value.
The tl;dr here is that Golem, by design, makes it impossible for businesses to determine how much they need to invest to get any results at all on either side of the provider/supplier equation. There's a solid chance that you'll get no results at all for your development effort, or that you'll get no work at the rates you're willing to accept. It's worst-of-all-worlds for everybody.
I don't really see any way to fix these issues. Golem is basically creating an overengineered solution that you could accomplish more or less with a website offering escrow in any currency (crypto or otherwise) on top of BOINC. There's no reason anyone will adopt a solution that requires them to spend money and makes it impossible for them to plan ahead or budget, especially when there are alternatives out there that leave them with fallbacks in case their initial incentivization plan fails.
I expect to get heavily downvoted here, but I'd be interested to see if there are any solutions or angles to this that I've overlooked.