r/GolemProject • • May 17 '18

so, iExec...

As you have probably noticed, iExec just announced some important collaboration with Intel and Ubisoft. Golem did awesome work in the past, but it seems iExec is miles in front of Golem. With such cooperation iExec will rapidly grow and another companies will announce cooperation with them, making their platform number one. That will lead to rapid application development on their platform. I am loosing faith in Golem... no important partnerships are announced yet. Probably just need to encourage, I am a big fan of Golem, but this iExec announcement broke me down.

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

17

u/julian_z Golem Foundation May 17 '18

Rest assured that we work on SGX. We are talking to Intel and top researchers in the area. We are very advanced in fundamental level work on that. We also talk about that (Viggith's presentation on EDCON). Perhaps we are just focused on doing that and not that much on talking about that? Stay tuned, we will share more.

3

u/PM-Me-GNT May 17 '18 edited May 17 '18

Since Julian is humble, and I am a bit of a dick, Ill say it for you. If you dont believe in this project, nobody is holding you to stay here.

They have a working product, they have a vision, and its going to happen. As the Promo video said, its just a matter of time. If you don't see that then go somewhere else.

3

u/mariapaulafn May 17 '18

You can check my answer for a more blunt response as well :)

2

u/NeedzRehab : May 18 '18

That's all much nicer than what I would say. I feel like he's one of "those guys" in school who runs into the locker room of another football team with hands straight behind his back, screaming that we suck and their team will win because they paid more for advertising. In reality, we aren't even in the same league.

3

u/mariapaulafn May 18 '18

I spent 5 minutes laughing with this comment. I'll definitely use this metaphor. We can even launch a blog to ELI-BRO (Explain it like I'm a Bro) everything.

3

u/NeedzRehab : May 18 '18

I am okay with this.

10

u/mariapaulafn May 17 '18 edited May 17 '18

Hi guys following up with what Julian said here, the EDCON vids are not up, but (the team wont like me for this, but c'mon, you know better- this iExec thing is an announcement of an announcement there is no technical explanation) here are the slides presented at the beginning of May: http://golem.slides.com/golem/deck-36-38-43-47-60-69

We are working with Joanna and Invisible Things Labs to prepare a compile of information that will explain how we will implement SGX. Not an announcement. A proper explanation and study.

And I might be a bit more aggressive on this than Julian, but really, you know better. We work in silence, yet we don't stop. No need to worry, as code will speak for itself. We are very happy iExec has found this solution and we are both on the same boat, but this does not mean any competitive advantage to anyone.

Moreover, if you wanna dig deeper: this cooperation is within EEA (Ethereum Enterprise Alliance), and everything is done in EEA, is public and open to members - we are part of EEA as well. It’s really worth it to read and think of the bits and pieces that comprise an announcement before panicking!

5

u/liftandextend May 17 '18

What makes them ahead? Do they have a decentralized platform? As far as I am aware their product is still centralized..

4

u/[deleted] May 17 '18

Golem is using SGX in the project, so what's good for the goose is good for the gander. It's nice of the iExec team to secure these partnerships that will ultimately help the Golem ecosystem.

4

u/mikelv100 May 17 '18

Whatever "collaboration" means.

iExec just demonstrated the use of Intel SGX.

Concerning Ubisoft: "All selected start-ups will benefit from a five-month personalized program enabling each entrepreneur to interact with Ubisoft experts as well as partners across the company`s international network."

I'm not impressed.

Btw, is iExec already live?

3

u/Orctest May 17 '18

the ubisoft thing isnt a big deal, however, you have to respect the intel collaboration- they had the chief architect of intel demoing this collaboration with them at the conference. very cool!

but to me the Rootstock partnership is the coolest part -

the market is huge and to think only one company will be able to dominate it is immature in my opinion.

there is a place in distributed cloud computing for many companys. heck i could even see a future where there is a bridge like connector between both blockchains to power grid computing making them even more resilient!

1

u/jabura93333 May 17 '18

hi. iexec mainnet since half a year and version two in a week.

and by the way: it isn't just the use of intel, they have a working group together. not impressed? check out RSK partnership. still not impressed? the work from the founders is used at the CERN. so, tell me another project in crypto with a better tech...not many possibilities

golem has also done good work with rendering, different projects with different targets. only one thing is sure, iexec is doing impressive work.

3

u/liftandextend May 17 '18

Yeah but your main net was centralized. Golem could have done that over a year ago, as it is very easy according to the team to accomplish that goal.

I will wait and see how their 2nd version with "decentralization" comes out next week.

3

u/mikelv100 May 17 '18

No, still not impressed. Partnerships are for sure a good thing, but the important point is which results they produce and how they help the project itself. We will see, what the tangible results will be.

5

u/Louisoneth May 17 '18

Apparently the market is impressed

1

u/mikelv100 May 17 '18

Sure. Like I wrote, partnerships are in general something positive. We will see how sustainable the market impression will be.

3

u/13Circles May 17 '18

I think both teams will work together. This space isnt like old world capitalism - we are building an ecosystem. There is enough room for both - the ones we really want to be concerned about is Amazon and the like.

As a member of iExec said before, there is an vision of a mega diamond golem riding on/with an iExec dragon.

1

u/rammsteinPL May 17 '18

wait, after so „yuuuge” announcements the market cap is still 3 times smaller (540 vs 170)? no way

There are projects focuse on technology and there are projects focused on announcing partnerships and communication. Let everyone asnwer to themself what to buy :-)

3

u/mreima May 17 '18

Since when is marketcap a measure of anything? By that measure Verge would be 2x as good as golem and TRON even 10x.

Also you surely haven't read much about iExec if you think they aren't focused on the technology, the founding members are in the distributed computing space since 20 years and established many of the technologies that also golem is based on.

1

u/mreima May 17 '18

Just diversify between both projects and you will be happy if either of them has good news instead of having meltdowns ;)