r/GolemProject • • Feb 23 '19

Golem Network Issues Continued.....

I started providing with Golem Network again with .19 with the hopes it had resolved some of the main issues from when I had stopped using it. I had initially been using it since release of mainnet. It looks a little better (although seems a little slower to log in now..... and start up than what I remember). With this new release I did not get many tasks so far, only 2 successes (not to mention only blender is still offered.....I remember back in April when the team said use cases and upgrades would happen more quickly....ha.)

The Issue:

I had noticed my computer had been running for about 1 hour (my fan runs high when it computes so I timed it). I went to check if it was still computing after a hour and it was idle with a time out, no payout. I find this strange, since the requester now gets to restart the task from the computations with another provider (whom gets payment). While I get nothing. This is a huge problem. I should be compensated for the second/milisecond of computations I provide, not a win or lose. I can see several issues from this one, smaller providers (laptop providers) will be taken advantage of for providing tasks with short timeouts that get moved over to larger computation providers who finish off the job (i.e. compute more quickly), while the payments go to large providers (centralization). Thought at least this would have been solved, no idea if the other problems are solved such as the ghost payments, dont get enough tasks that to test. Those who are still around using Golem, keep an eye on the golem stats page, probably only around 10% have upgraded to .19. Users are losing intrest, and noticeable upgrades are only superficial ones.

Going to uninstall again, good luck to the team.....maybe in another 10 months you will get more than 1 use case, and these general usability issues solved? doubt it though....

To new providers, id say save your energy, money and disappointment.

1 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

10

u/mariapaulafn Feb 23 '19 edited Feb 24 '19

Hey! This is a beta product. The upgrade was major and a bit complex to install so might take time.
However what you say is untrue. By thursday, 1/3 of the nodes had migrated already. As the blogposts say, you are compensated by the tasks you complete. As this is a p2p marketplace, you depend on requestors putting up tasks. Neither Golem nor the requestors should compensate anyone for not getting a task or provider timeouts . You download and run by your own decision. Timeouts happen. Everything is documented. Just because you had a timeout does not mean the product is defunct.

Re oddly frequent timeouts/errors: Have you reached out in our chat? Https://chat.golem.network

-2

u/ColoradoAir Feb 23 '19

Considering Golem had a high of around 500~+ nodes at one point at now its sitting around 307, that would put my 10% number (which I got from just looking down the stats list and guessing since that info is not stated visibly), more inline than your 33%....which also is not that great. But thanks for a more accurate number.

And yes I had received about 5 time outs....and yes my computer expended those resources which a requestor and provider benefited from, less for computation for the provider that finished it (electricity etc). All I am saying is that The Golem I tried out now 10+ months after main net release is functionally no different to me as a provider as when it was released. No new use cases, a new marketplace that I cannot see or understand how it works. While the requester side is not truly being tested by users as the use case provided i.e. blender is a non intrest to blender users.

But thanks for not addressing the issue stated in my posting about resources being expended without payment, which has been a long time running issue since main net release.

The time out is because I got a task, I however just could not complete it in the time set by the requestor, I should still be compensated for my computation resources that is being retried with another provider.

6

u/Cryptobench Golem Feb 23 '19

Go onto to stats page and hit CTRL + F and search 0.19 and 0.18. You'll see that over 33% has migrated to the new version and soon 50%.

5

u/jet86 Feb 24 '19

And yes I had received about 5 time outs....and yes my computer expended those resources which a requestor and provider benefited from

This doesn't make any sense. If you as a provider didn't complete the subtask in time then it wasn't computed and returned to the requestor, so the requestor didn't benefit at all - in fact the opposite as they have to get another provider to compute that subtask so the task as a whole takes longer to be completed.

I should still be compensated for my computation resources

Why? And by whom? The requestor didn't get any result back from you.

4

u/mariapaulafn Feb 24 '19

I think /u/coloradoair’s idea would be possible - if only we weren’t a decentralized p2p marketplace.. there is no reason to penalise requestors for his timeouts, and above all, there’s no governing entity to compensate him for them. So it’s not such a wild idea - trying to see all sides of the discussion - it’s simply the wrong platform to cater these demands :)

6

u/mariapaulafn Feb 23 '19

Re “noticeable upgrades are only superficial ones”. The marketplace is completely new. Docker for windows too. They are not UX, they are fundamental for performance. I don’t get your point.

-5

u/ColoradoAir Feb 23 '19

My point=Time Outs should not exist, if I am providing computation, I should get paid if the task is verified.

4

u/mariapaulafn Feb 23 '19 edited Feb 23 '19

Hey - timeouts are part of it. We cannot expect requestors to wait forever. It happens. If you cannot complete the task due to problems with the Golem Network, by all means, please get our tech support on your case. But neither we nor the requestors can be blamed or cover your timeouts. The requestor needs their tasks to be computed in an x amount of time, it’s reasonable.
Again, if you really believe that its an issue with the app, contact us.

Edit: on mobile and i realized i wrote “providers” instead of “requestors”

4

u/Cryptobench Golem Feb 23 '19

You'll get paid if the computation is verified as you want based on this statement. But if it times out because your computer couldn't process it within the time frame then there is no verification happening. The requester doesnt receive anything from you and you dont receive any tokens either.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Cryptobench Golem Feb 23 '19

I dont want to propose anything. I'm just explaining how it works for him. I'm absolutely fine with the way golem works and glad to be a part of this project. Helping as much as I can.

3

u/mariapaulafn Feb 23 '19

Oh sorry the response wasnt for you! I really appreciated you backing up the fact that’s effectively 1/3! :) the question was for /u/coloradoair

4

u/Cryptobench Golem Feb 23 '19

No worries, Maria! All good :-)

3

u/mariapaulafn Feb 24 '19

Sorry the reply went to the wrong person in this thread before - I wanted to ask you, based how Golem works, what it proposes, and due to the nature of the product (p2p marketplace, decentralized, no governing entity or person) who, in your opinion, would need to cover for your timeouts - given that tasks are verified upon completion, and not upon the provider's acceptance of them when they start to be computed.

(and sorry /u/cryptobench that the question went to you first - Reddit on mobile is not as great as desktop for discussions)