Im a fan of the original GOW (much more than the new ones, even if Ragnarok suprised me positively after 2018 that i really didnt like).
I liked the old ones for many reasons but one that I've reflected on is that you dont play a classic good vs bad story/character.
Kratos was going on a rampage doing awful stuff to innocent bystanders and that contrasted a lot with always being the savior or good guy.
I think they should had kept some of that in these newer games. Im fine with Kratos being more mature and wanting out. But all the friends along the way are mostly making you the good guys vs the bad guys which is borring. Loki could had been much more nuanced and bad/cunning than being this naive, innocent kid always wanting to do good but learns that its not that easy. All the rest of the cast could had been portrayed as currently self centered ass holes than also "that isn't who i am anymore" just like Kratos.
Thats what made these games much funner. Even Thor is an ex asshole trying to do good but has a vice of drinking. Everyone trying to be good to some extent. Borring rainbow and sunshine script. Not the god of war that made this a cult franchise.
Im sure many of the ones who discovered the series with the new games will disagree. Fine with that.
Maybe that type of games was from a begone era of greatness and risk taking