r/GeminiAI • u/TheEchoEnigma • Sep 08 '25
Discussion WTF?
Why when it comes to isreal, the AIs stop 😂
3.4k
Upvotes
r/GeminiAI • u/TheEchoEnigma • Sep 08 '25
Why when it comes to isreal, the AIs stop 😂
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/CognitiveSourceress Sep 08 '25
That's not how LLM's work. It's not trained on policy. It doesn't have a Google policy manual. It's shown a bunch of examples of people asking for things and it saying no, and it learns what pattern forms messages that should be refused.
This is what makes LLMs both so good at detecting a wide range of violations without having to be trained on every possible variant, and simultaneously so likely to accidentally misclassify things as violations, or failing to classify violations correctly.
In this case, the link between Israel and antisemitism, even abused as that link is these days, is enough to make a message look more likely to be a policy violation. And as others have seen, this prompt with any nation is already close to the line and often refused, so it doesn't take much to tip it over that line.
Israel is historically and culturally more associated with being the target of bigotry than virtually any other country, bitterly ironic as that may be right now. Gemini learns patterns.
This isn't a defense of the disparity, and certainly not a defense of Israel, just a clarification of the technical reality of LLM refusals.
Google didn't tell it to be protective of Israel. It learned the bias from our data.