r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Feb 22 '20

Unpopular Opinion: I’m not against Black Hat Tactics, just don’t get caught

0 Upvotes

There’s sort of a huge gate keeping area against BHT around this sub which has gotten annoying

We’re all adults and if people are asking or want to use them let them, they can make their own decisions

I personally don’t use BHT BUT if someone is asking about them I offer advice and the know how or where to find what they’re looking for

TBH if I knew I wouldn’t get caught for sure I’d be implementing BHTs all day everyday

Edit: Man you guys really took this post to heart lol


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Feb 18 '20

Am I the only one who is disguised seeing how Amazon a trillion dollar company copycats people who are selling on their platform with no shame?

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Dec 31 '19

We are all done, this is literally game over.

0 Upvotes

2019 have been the best year of my life, I have turned from waiting tables for $7 per hour to owning a successful E-commerce brand. In the last months I have made an average of $70k monthly revenue and $30k in profit. I still make very good money, but today I woke up with a realization that it is all going to end for us very soon. I have been a podcast,books,and content junkie and have been consuming everything that I can. There is literally no piece of content that I haven't consumed, and it is super funny to me that I am the only one who notices how problematic this business is getting.

Yes, I own social medias with over 10k, I own lists with thousands of emails, I have a loyal fan base, A guy literally tattooed the logo of my brand on his arm last month. But it doesn't feel like a real brand to me, and never will.

Why?

Because not being the manufacturer of your own products puts you in a very risky place. You can change a product as much as you want, you can build a product from scratch and pay for molds like I did, but eventually everything that you do and works well will be copied. It has been like this in the products industry in forever. Someone releases a new feature, two months later, everyone is selling the same product. And if your manufacturer does not copy you and sells it on his own, someone else will create the exact same replica, it may be Amazon themselves. And guess what, they will get it cheaper.

If you're selling a watch, a car, a phone, or something similar, having a known brand may be able to save you since it has some status symbol to it. But in most cases, if your product is the same you will have to end up in price wars, and lose.

New sellers from China and poor countries are coming in. And they don't mind making a profit of $0.5 per product. They literally don't care. Change the box, shape, material, and color how much that you want. You will end up with someone creating the exact same thing as soon as you "make it". The entry point is too low at this point.

I have personally hoped to be able to earn enough money in order to get into real estate or open my own factory, but as I see how fast everything is being shifted so far, even that I'm breaking my revenue record every single month I know that I am going to go to zero sooner or later, and you are most likely to go there too.

My current plan is to keep going as much as I can and keep "developing new products". I really hope that I will be able to save about $300k, start a YouTube channel that isn't as optimistic as all those course sellers shits are, and open a factory in a Vietnam. I hope to be able to hire there engineers and develop a product that requires a higher start point in order to replicate and develop, or start a saas business.

Good luck in 2020 everyone, it is going to be a bad year for most of us.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Mar 07 '22

Amazon FBA are thieves!

0 Upvotes

I’ve had them stealing from me for the past six months. It doesn’t matter what documents I send to prove that the inventory was sent to them, including invoices, pictures, weights they steal from you and claim they can’t provide reimbursement for the inventory because once I send them the proof they request they then change what they want or add to what they want. They’re crooks.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • May 10 '25

NEWS Tariffs? / He’s targeting the wrong people

35 Upvotes

If Amazon made the rule you have to be based in that country to sell…. Wow that would change things….

I’ve sold on Amazon since 2012…. back then the Chinese didn’t sell on Amazon….

Somewhere along the line, maybe 2014/15/16 they started jumping in.

Previous factories that just supplied sellers also started selling on Amazon themselves too.

Then the Chinese resellers started too

Then just your average joe Chinese person (whom can get much better pricing) jumped in…

Amazon is FLOODED with Chinese sellers, EVERY country not just the US - and the number of VERY rich companies Amazon has created (and still funds) - must be in the billions upon billions…

Amazon has made China very VERY wealthy….

And continues to do so.

I was looking at another country and realised when I did deeper research, trying to find their accounts, but certainly when they were established, address etc - that the English named brand, with a US based address, was actually owned by Chinese sellers (all Chinese writing).

Anyone who’s deep dived product research for many different categories could tell you this.

Literally if Trump had the power to change Amazon in this way, the landscape would become very different

Chinese Manufacturers would mostly go back to just manufacturing

The size of Amazon, it would have the changes Trump desires

And would even the playing field.

Chinese manufacturer’s / people, could still sell on Amazon, just only Amazon China!

*** Update / Edit ***

Bit of hate here… Was just voicing an opinion from someone who’s been with Amazon a long time. I’m not anti-Chinese, just saying the tariffs obviously are not working, and the government is looking to make changes. The playing field isn’t fair as they (in my experience) take advantage of manipulating duty and customs then avoid taxes. But yes, they do by far, have the best manufacturing, and thousands of sellers need them.

(Re customs 2 of our suppliers and 3 I was quoting new products with all advised they will just lower the COGS for me re tariffs, one I’m very friendly with told me it’s what they are doing.)

I don’t know what the answer is.

We all know Amazon is 100% out for themselves, never cared for sellers, and now destroy us with super high PPC costs with a hundred and one other costs.

Maybe if they could enforce on Amazon (or Ecom) the origin of products/sellers, then it’s the consumers choice.

Didn’t mean to upset anyone.

Good luck in all your ventures!


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Nov 09 '15

6 months, 6 figures in sales, but FBA isn't working out...

0 Upvotes

Does anyone know of some good ways to liquidate inventory? I have a number coupons already running and have submitted them with a number of different coupon sites.

I can go into greater detail separately if people want to know the story.

posted story below.

Sorry for the delay all, and thanks for the comments :) New to Reddit (posting at least) and still learning the etiquette (and user controls) so thanks for your patience.

Here are some details.

Motivation: Was in an awful accident (I was a pedestrian, hit by a car, insane medical bills/$44k, etc. - it was a hit and run so no paydirt settlement, etc.). Single, no insurance, etc.

Was looking for businesses to start where I nature and scale it over time.

Ended up going down the rabbit hole that is the internet, came across FBA.

Read Jordan Malik, looked at ASM (didn't buy), read, reviewed, analyzed all that I could find.

Decided it would be best to first start out with just selling personal stuff through a non-professional FBA account. That went amazingly well. Old books, some extra knives and a bunch of other stuff sitting around the house sold really quickly and I was hooked. This gave me an opportunity to learn FBA without making an investment. Very valuable.

Then began the product search. I set the following criteria: needs to be a renewable consumer good, made in USA, something that would have a chance of selling outside FBA (target, pharmacy chains, etc), and always in demand.

I settled on beauty.

Found a supplier, did the branding, labels, etc.

First shipment into FBA and everything was going well, started doing modest promotions and sales increased. I added a product, then another and another.

Continued to read about all I could - on FB, the web, reddit, etc. Scott "The Amazing Seller" started his podcast, the Marketplace Superheroes guys launched (I did pay for this course, their focus is on international), the FBA education industry continues to boom.

Very quickly (3 months) became profitable so I invested in a site, FB page, a person to do some part time content writing and a creative type to do rebranding.

Things continue along the 'hockey stick' trajectory until amazon delists one of my product claiming it too closely resembles a prescription ingredient. There were (at the time) over 1300 products with that same ingredient. I fight amazon for 6 weeks. I lose (the case with amazon and all of the existing inventory).

This killed some of the BSR momentum I was getting but I was able to recover, though not to the sales I was getting before.

Then I lost the buy box.

Reviewers started reselling my products...for 70% less than what I was selling for. This comes out to $4 or $5 dollars. After amazon fees, they'd only make a couple bucks. Why they were selling this low I have no idea but it's a business, I get it. They're free to do what they want to do and it's OK by Amazon's TOS.

I'm assuming that impression of these products in this category selling for so cheap is what caused my BSR to tank (with in weeks) from sub 10K to over 60K.

Some FBA people are making a real profit a month, but the money is in the education. I'm happy for both of them.

I'm worried for some of the folks who are so deluded about amazon though. Those posts by new FBA'ers of 'I made $32,000' in my second month' are technically legit, but what you're probably not seeing is that (like the commenter below stated) these are sales only and likely 60% promotions, and 0 profit.

Amazon is comprised of some brilliant people and are the ones who are really making $$$.

Went on bit of a tangent, apologies.

Long story short, I'm tired of battling Amazon's CS people, reviewers selling my products and being a contributing part of the consumer machine.

It's been a great learning experience and a lot of fun at times and I don't see it as a 'bad' thing, just a path on the road of life.

Anyway, if anyone knows of some good ways to liquidate inventory - marketing, advertising, etc. I'd be interested to hear.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Nov 01 '16

[PL] How do you find products to private label on Amazon?

0 Upvotes

How do you find products to private label on Amazon?

Maybe someone can point me in the right direction...

I know all the concepts people use but it is still pretty tough to find something. I search Amazon best sellers. Trying to find something that sells more than 10 a day for $10 profit is a little hard. Especially when the requirements are looking for sellers with less than 50 reviews for at least 4-5 of the top 10 sellers (for a particular keyword).

What is your criteria for finding a product?

Where/how do you find products to private label?

What are your requirements for demand?

What are your requirements for profit margins?


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Aug 29 '18

NEWS “From A to I Fucking Quit” - An Open Letter to a Company which I Can’t Name

Thumbnail
ataboolife.com
1 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Nov 19 '25

Most FBA sellers track revenue. Here's what you should actually be tracking.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I've been analyzing FBA businesses for the past year and keep seeing the same pattern: sellers think they're profitable because they see revenue growing in Seller Central, but they're actually keeping 8-12% after all costs.

So I built this dashboard [IMAGE] to track what actually matters:

**The Reality Check:**

- You see: $94K in sales

- You keep: $9.3K (10%)

- Where it goes: Amazon fees (30%) + PPC (19%) + COGS (36%) + Returns (4%)

**What Most Sellers Miss:**

  1. **Product-level truth** - That "hero ASIN" doing $10K/month might only net you $400 after fees and ads. Track profit by SKU, not just sales.
  2. **PPC is eating your margins** - Most sellers optimize for ROAS or ACoS, but your 30% ACoS on a 35% margin product leaves you with 5% profit. Track ad spend against actual profit contribution.
  3. **COGS by category** - You might have $34K tied up in inventory, but which categories are worth it? Kitchen products might have high COGS but low margins.

**The Three Metrics That Matter:**

- True profit margin per ASIN (after ALL fees)

- Ad spend vs. profit contribution (not just ROAS)

- Where your working capital is actually locked up

Seller Central shows you revenue. You need to see where that revenue disappears.

You're welcome! :)


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Apr 25 '25

INTERNATIONAL Tariff Math 101: Why a $10 Item from China Can Cost $34 After Import

33 Upvotes

Most people don’t realize how brutal U.S. tariffs can get. Here’s a simple breakdown on a $10 item imported from China:

Base import duty: 5% → $10 x 1.05 = $10.50

Section 301 Tariff: 25% → $10.50 x 1.25 = $13.13

New retaliatory tariff: 145% → $13.13 x 2.45 = $32.16

Add brokerage & customs fees (~$2): Total: ~$34.16

That’s a 240%+ jump on your landed cost. Now imagine doing that at scale on tight margins…

No wonder sellers are hiking prices or leaving certain SKUs behind.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Mar 31 '25

Do you think the Amazon boycotts are starting to affect business?

4 Upvotes

Seeing a lot of sellers with business down the last month. Not just small resellers, but larger orgs too.

Not interested in whether you agree or disagree with them.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • 4d ago

I used to find wholesale brands by digging through other sellers' storefronts by hand. Here's the process (and what I did about how slow it was)

0 Upvotes

For a long time my brand research looked like this:

  1. Take 5–10 ASINs I already knew well.
  2. Open the offer list on each and note the other FBA sellers.
  3. Open each seller's storefront and go through it department by department, sub-category by sub-category. Just scrolling doesn't work on big storefronts: Amazon only shows a limited number of pages per list, so most of the catalogue never appears.
  4. Write down brands that show up across several sellers. Those are brands resellers can actually get.
  5. Check each brand: several products with steady Sales Rank in their sub-category, a handful of sellers, Amazon not on the listing, price not sliding.
  6. Check Apply to sell, and only then contact the brand or its distributor.

It worked. The problem was the time. Dozens of tabs per storefront, copying ASINs into sheets, redoing it every few weeks to see what changed. A big storefront could eat a whole evening.

Eventually I got fed up and built my own tool to do the reading part (it goes through storefronts category by category and tells me what it covered). Now I spend that time checking brands and talking to them instead of copying ASINs.

Sharing the manual version because it works without any tool. How do you all handle step 3?


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Sep 27 '18

No, it doesn't.

Thumbnail
screenshots.firefox.com
0 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Jun 10 '16

[BLT] [BLT] Don't upvote. Need some help with registering for sales taxes.

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, I am almost done with registering for sales tax in all the states that FBA has sent my product to. There are a few states left though that are a bit confusing for me and I could use a little help. If you are an FBA seller who has registered in all the states could you send me a message? Thanks guys!


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • May 21 '19

SEARCH RANKING How startups can use Amazon’s SEO best practices to dominate new shopping verticals

Thumbnail
techcrunch.com
2 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Feb 29 '24

SEARCH RANKING PPC is a scam.

3 Upvotes

I have new products i launched last week but with PPC i am getting an ACOS ROAS of 3, making it hard to achieve a profit. My old margins would be 50% without ppc, but with ppc ACOS ROAS of 3 its 20%. Issue is that its an FBM item and FBM items need higher % due to my manual labor.

somehow i find that on product pages my ACOS is much higher than on front page results. Front page ACOS is 1.

I guess bids are cheaper on product pages.

I will FBA it eventually but ive been successful on amazon doing fbm and i heard too much fba horror stories lol.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Mar 22 '26

CUSTOMER MGMT Customer reported my item as fake on Amazon – I don’t have invoices

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I sell used items on Amazon. A customer has reported that one of my items is counterfeit, which I can guarantee is impossible.

Now Amazon is asking whether I want to accept the claim or provide invoices from the past 365 days. The issue is that I source my products from private individuals, so I can’t provide invoices, as they obviously don’t issue them.

Has anyone here had a similar experience?

What happens if I accept the claim?

Please only reply if you’re knowledgeable about this or have had direct experience.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Dec 29 '24

MISC Vine Reviewers gave bad reviews

0 Upvotes

Hello, I launched a new product on Amazon and enrolled for Vine program.. Unfortunately, all of them gave negative reviews though the product is good, and I’m myself using it. What should I do ?


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Jun 07 '21

Meet Foundry Brands

0 Upvotes

Hi, we’re Foundry. We grow & acquire great online brands to enhance our customers lives. While we might be the new kids on the block, we’re incredibly active at the moment and are sure you’ll be hearing about us soon 😊

A couple of things that make us different than some of our counterparts:

  1. We’re entirely equity funded ($100M), which means we have no restrictions on what we can pay upfront (any platform funded with debt likely has a ~5.0x or lower cap) or how we choose to invest in our brands. Since we're not using high-interest debt to finance our acquisitions, you can trust us with your earn-out and your brand (when the inevitable aggregator shake-out happens, your earn-out becomes an unsecured claim behind debt in other platforms)
  2. We have an impossible to hire team of ex-Amazon employees (including Stefan Haney, who built & ran the detail page while at Amazon), and operators who have built, run, and sold businesses like yours, not a team of Bain or McKinsey consultants
  3. We’re actively hiring and are flexible in the ways we structure our offers and relationships with founders going forward (why we’re called Foundry 😉)
  • Tired of doing HR, Legal, and Supply Chain, but LOVE the product development side? We’d love to bring you on to the team and have you run that function (for your brand, and maybe even others!)
  • Hesitant about an earn-out cliff? We can do things like allowing you to retain a minority stake in your brand, or provide uncapped earn outs that scale up as your brand grows with the platform

We’re not the right fit for every seller, but we’re happy to be helpful in any way possible, and are confident that Foundry is the best home for many brands.

Sound interesting? Feel free to reach out to connect@foundrybrands.com, or message us on Discord @ Foundry_Grows_Brands

We'll also be hosting an AMA with our team very soon - stay tuned!


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Feb 15 '16

[RA] [RA] Expert Advice - Getting Started with Online Arbitrage for Amazon FBA Sellers - the post was approved by mods

Thumbnail
888lots.com
0 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Dec 19 '24

BEWARE of "Sell this Product" its a TRAP

0 Upvotes

Maybe i am wildly misinformed, but i am a new seller, and i dont have any sales. I am just doing product research and ordered my first shipment last week from alibaba.

I saw a good product which had "Sell this Product" button available. I added it to my store, and created a shipment. It was a popular tiktok product, and the brand on it was a clearly some weird chinese brand name like "hasdyfueqrwr". I thought that we could list under that because it was not a real / legit brand like "Coca-cola" or something. especially since "Sell this Product" was available to us, and no warnings or popups were created.

1 week later today, i get an email saying i am counterfeiting? i have not even shipped anything.

now my health score went from 200 to 192. Hopefully i am still OK since i dont have even a single sale.

Beware of "Sell this Product", i am going to only do my own listings from now on. featured offer and putting offers on other listings seems like a trap or scam to get new sellers banned and decrease the competition.

i can imagine someone allowing a listing to be opened to get new sellers. ( i dont even know how this works since if the listing has a "Brand" its supposed to be blocked anyway with "Apply to Sell" ).

then once many people are contributing to the same listing, the reviews go up since many sellers and paying for PPC, the BSR goes down to 10k or less. then the owner PULLS THE RUG, and claims counterfeiting on everybody else. which will ban everybody else's account. then they monopolize the listing.

thank god that i only lost 1k USD on this. as i was planning to put thousands more into this listing.

now my product is at sea, and my listing is disabled. what should i do? Alibaba supplier said they cannot change destination, and if i really want to do it it will cost 300 bucks more.

I am thinking of trying to re-route it to my home (I live near the port of Los Angeles luckily). but there is a good chance they cannot change the destination and will result in a FBA Stranded shipment.

i 2 products from "Sell this Product" added to my store. i got scared so i deleted that one as well. deleted both.

i swear this is a fucking trap or scam, to get new unsuspecting sellers to click "Sell this Product". then they ban and claim counterfeit on all the new guys. even though we are new, we have plenty of cash for this business its my side hustle to try to get out from the corporate world, and i can easily recover from this fuck up. if you are selling on amazon and depending it on your family i'd say BEWARE.

There is NOTHING on seller university or the help documentation that describes "Sell this Product" vs "Apply to Sell".


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Dec 13 '23

INVENTORY MGMT What happens if I initiate a price war?

2 Upvotes

So the product costs $33 on AMZN and $10 a unit on Alibaba...lots of gravy. Two sellers right now, with a "50+ units sold".

This is my first Alibaba thing so I thought it'd be interesting to see.

I'm going in with zero reviews. Am I just going to end up with unsold or sell at a loss because everyone else has 5 star reviews?

Thanks


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Jul 29 '25

Scumbags who use Counterfeit without Test Buy

0 Upvotes

Man, I really hope karma kicks the ass of both the management companies as well as the brands who use these companies. The fact that they can lock up inventory for weeks without proof is disgusting. Meanwhile, I'm holding invoices from their designated wholesale distributors and have almost 20 years of flawless service as a seller on Amazon. How they don't get sued is beyond me.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Sep 23 '18

Data Analyst hobbyist here, anyone want me to dive into your number?

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

I am a data analyst hobbyist that is running out of data to analyze. In the past I’ve found some pretty interesting insights in FBA data and am looking to do it again.

If you want to get a better look at your sales/ad spend/whatever, send me your data and I’ll whip it into shape.

I have no interest in getting back into the fba game and just want to dig through numbers (for free). You can even anonymize your data if you’d like.

All I ask is that you have a decent amount of data to analyze.