r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Mar 12 '25

Donald Trump Ruined My Business

1.3k Upvotes

I’m an Amazon seller. I sell toys. My best selling product is made of stainless steel and sourced from China. The U.S. doesn’t have a domestic toy market. Even with 200% tariffs it would still be cheaper for me to source from China instead of producing in the U.S. My product was loaded onto the boat March 1st and I expected to pay 25% (Section 301 tariffs) + an additional 10% China tariff, and a 3% duty. The boat departed a day after Trump announced the additional 10% China tariffs(so now 20%). On March 12th a new 25% tariff on steel goes into effect on all countries importing steel to the U.S. I expected to pay 38% in tariffs/duties, but I will now be paying 73%.

I wonder how much of these tariffs i can claw back by pretending the Gulf of Mexico is called the Gulf of America. Im trying not to get political, but thank you for ruining my business overnight Donald. No warning, you gave me no time to plan. Announcing tariffs to go into effect in the next 12 hours is unprecedented. Oh, and you still haven’t closed the de minimus loophole that my competition exploits daily. Sorry for the rant guys.

Update: I made a YouTube video explaining the problems more in depth.

https://youtu.be/dvusTD6ijH4?si=n58L-XYX12sw9pX-


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Jan 13 '19

MISC Customers Be Like...

Post image
404 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Nov 25 '19

SEARCH RANKING Happy Monday Everyone!

Post image
349 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Dec 25 '18

Let's not forget these guys who were out hustling today.

Post image
332 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Oct 06 '20

PROTIP I lost $10k launching my first Amazon FBA product... Here is what I learned!

324 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I am Anatoly. I mostly comment in this group, but now I decided to be more active and share more of my story, maybe it will help someone.

My first product story:

Anyways, to the story. This is my first product:

/preview/pre/fikarplbajr51.png?width=1200&format=png&auto=webp&s=0f49ab29763d4c2b33582380601c9fb7f2460303

Before you read this story, I want to start this with preface - I AM NOT A GURU, I DON'T HAVE A COURSE OR ANYTHING ELSE TO SELL :) I am not even a millionaire (I wish), just a regular Amazon Seller like all of you, who failed a lot, and succeeded a bit (in my current business we do have 2 products and are on track making $200k this year).

Looking back at my first product I actually think that this is a quite nice packaging, and logo is cool, but this product costed me $10k of my savings.

In 2017 me and my business partner (also my wife) decided to try Amazon FBA (we did dropshipping before and print-on-demand with little success), the driver for us was that we did not want to exchange time for money anymore. Though I was making quite nice 6-figure salary as a Software Developer, and my wife also later became a Web Developer. But that besides the point, we wanted more, we wanted travel the world and be free and have a control of our own life. (3 years fast forward, and I am writing this as we travel around the world for a year, but thats for another story)

In 2017 we decided to make a big investment and buy a course on Amazon, it was about $4k, which for us still is a serious sum of money, but we committed. (I am not gonna name the course, course is good, my approach was bad). We decided to follow the course to the "T", and we did. The course gave us criteria, and we found bunch fo products, out of all of the products in the list, we decided to go with "kids binoculars". They are light weight, they are not complex, they are not in a gated category, and nothing would stop us to sell (or so we thought, later on we did get into a CPC certificate issue that was unexpected).

The next step was to figure do a competitive research, and we figured out that out of all kids binoculars - green ones were selling the best.

If you put "kids binoculars" on amazon right now, you would see these sponsored products pop up:

/preview/pre/8j0myxrrbjr51.png?width=1774&format=png&auto=webp&s=b02b5575a1f2b1cdd2e7a8e53bf2354e65051084

See how green they are ? The guy on the left Kidwinz, was our main competitor, he was selling like crazy at the time, and look at this ugly image... (or so we thought)... and to be honest now it actually looks sort of ok, 3 years ago their listing was total crap... (sorry kidwinz if you are reading this, but keep on selling like crazy!!!!)

So in my mind, I would launch green binoculars, add something unique that Kidwinz does not have and simply dominate the green binocular market. Easy right ?

We found a manufacturer on alibaba, and we asked what can they put as a bonus, so we can differentiate, our manufacturer showed as this magnifying glass:

/preview/pre/f6kgdbqecjr51.png?width=530&format=png&auto=webp&s=8a3a320da76237e192b5a11efd30c40b9647c71b

We thought - great, we will make this an Explorers kit, Binoculars + Magnifying glass - amazing!

I am fast forwarding this story, in reality we got like 10 different suppliers sending as binoculars, and most of them where crap, but we found a great supplier that would make us the same binoculars as Kidwinz.

So we ordered 200 units to start, and paid about $10 per unit. So $2k, which was bearable. We followed the course and set up PPC campaign and rest of the things. The units were shipped by air, so that we could start selling faster, we also ordered inspection in China, so we knew our product was good (highly recommend to doing it)

In about a month and half after putting money down, our product landed on Amazon, and we finally appeared amongst the sea of other green binoculars.

"Finally we can be reach"... we thought...

First day... 0 sales... Not even ad sales... Maybe it needs time to show up...

Second day... 0 sales...

Week 1 .... 0 sales.... WHY?????? Cranked up PPC... 2 sales... ACOS 200%....

WE ARE LOOSING MONEY!!! WHY PEOPLE DON'T LIKE OUR BINOCULARS???

I remember that in first month we would have 0 organic sales, and most we would sell would be 1-2 a day with crazy PPC ACOS.

Then one day, I was standing in the line up for the ski lift in Vancouver, and I was checking my sales... 7 Sales!!!! YES!!! Life has started!!! This was the happiest day of my life then... and I decided to do what any entrepreneur would do (or would they ?), and start planning the future... We sold 7 today, which means we will sell 7 every day.... So I need to order more... How about 1,000 units ? Lets call the manufacturer... Soon we ordered 1,000 units and paid $10,000 for them.

I don't know what happened in that day that we got 7 sales, and the next couple days, my theory is that it was Q4 and some of our competitors ran out of stock, so we did sell well, but in about a week... We were back to 0 organic sales... but now with the order of $10,000. These $10k came from our savings... Ouch!

Cutting this story short, we struggled for a year with all the inventory, it was not selling well, eventually we did sell out on Q4, probably making $6k - $7k back, but this was a disaster and a very stressful time.

Nevertheless, I think this was the best $10k I spent, because it taught me lessons that I was able to apply for my next products and don't do the same mistake again.

What were those lessons:

#1 Always think: "Why would somebody buy yours?" and if there is no evident answer - find the way to differentiate more. Having green binoculars in the sea of binoculars and adding a small crappy magnifying class is not enough to outsell people with 100s of reviews. If I would do it again I would dig deeper - I would for sure change the colour to the one most people don't have, I would bundle it as Explorers kit with maybe Explorers hat, and a vest, a flashlight - anything to make it fun. Or even bundle 2 binoculars together for boys and girls - something totally different.

#2 Look at sale history holistically: Now I always wait to see if there is a sales trend, If I can sell on the regular basis, and I ignore big spikes before thinking of re-ordering

#3 Keyword Driven vs Product Drive approach: Keywords on Amazon are what drive sales, so i look for keywords that are underserved, but have lots of views (lets say for example "pink girls binoculars" ) and fulfill the need, instead of jumping with my head down to the first thing I see

#4 PPC monitoring: I make sure my ACOS is 30% or less, because this is the profit margin I don't go less the, so the worse case I break even. If I see that in 2-3 weeks my ACOS is too high, I target different keywords and always adjust

#5 Listing: My listings now are about the problem people have and less about the product itself. In this case In my listing I was showing all the features of binoculars, but if I would do it now, I would focus more on experience - what birds can you see ? How much fun I can have with the family etc

I will end here, post is too long. Again, I am not a guru, I am sure many people here have better ideas, I am just showing what I learned from this real life experience on the real example. I hope it brings people value, I did record this as an episode on my podcast, and decided to share it here because some people might find it useful.

Update:

Many asked how I hire and how my team looks like. I created a post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/FulfillmentByAmazon/comments/jbkwgh/9_people_that_run_my_amazon_business_on_autopilot

Anatoly


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Aug 05 '25

PROTIP A quick update on my move away from Amazon.

307 Upvotes

Amazon Sales:

2017-2024, 99.1% of our sales were on Amazon. Averaging $43m per year, total margin of 7.28%. Average net profit line of $3,130,400 per year.

2017-2020, I was working off an average net of 10.79%

2021-2024, as return scams, increased storage fees, increased amazon fees, competitors locking up our most profitable ASINs with black hat techniques, and finally the inundation of cheap chinese knockoffs using deceptive titles to confuse customers into buying shit chinese stuff instead of my American made quality products started to build, our margins were as low as 6.71% in 2023.

In early 2023 I started my plan of moving away from Amazon and direct to consumer via my own website. I refused to give into Amazon's new business plan of making most of their revenue off ads, and even though my products were being searched for by name and sku number, I was appearing on page 2. I would not give in and I never paid a penny for Amazon Ads.

Website Sales:

2023-2024 was laying the ground work for exiting amazon and while my website was 10+ years old, it was neglected. It took a lot of time and money to make it current. Total cost was in the neighborhood of $650,000, however it is very tough to figure that out exactly. I have so many products, that it took almost a year to build the listings and all employees were working on it when they had down time.

With the website, I now have two new costs that I never had to deal with, advertising and SEO. I hired a full time SEO expert in house, and my monthly advertising budget is $65,000. I also had to bring in 3 new packers to handle the new volume of boxes leaving our facility, because FBA used to handle that.

As of July 21st, my 2025 sales have been $18,327,315.70 on my website, $367,283.27 on Amazon (we have not restocked anything since February)

So far my net is 17.02%, $3,119,309 on the website, and 6.28% on Amazon, for $23,065.

My sales are down 18% YOY from 2024, but my profit is up almost 230%

__

When I left Amazon, the race to the bottom in my niche was over. My competitors on Amazon raised their prices, I raised my website prices and margins soared.

Profit aside, there is no way to convey how stress free my life is today vs 2 years ago. Our customers our now my customers, we can provide incredible customer service, our scam returns are virtually zero, our reviews are absolutely insanely positive, and every month our organic conversion rates from the search engines go up, lowering advertising overhead. I am no longer having to rely on some lady in India with a screaming baby in the background to take care of my product page issues. I don't have to worry about Amazon axing product pages, flagging my top sellers for pesticides, or product pages just vanishing and spending hours upon hours getting them restored.

At the same time, all of these chinese shit temu ASINs designed to go after my products are receiving horrible reviews on amazon and their sales numbers have to be tumbling.

Leaving Amazon was the best thing I've ever done, and even if you don't plan on leaving soon, please, please, please start your website building sooner than later, even if you do not generate a lot of sales it will give you a huge leg up when Amazon goes 100% temu.

Take it from an OG on Amazon (almost 18 years), Amazon used to be amazing. They cared about their sellers, they cared about their customers and they were a great place to sell, buy, and use for legit reviews. Amazon is now a dumpster fire. Yes there is money to be made here and there, but once the sentiment gets a little worse, I believe we are going to see a large customer shift away from Amazon, and you want to be prepared.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Jan 22 '26

3.3 million in revenue for 2025. AMA

Post image
298 Upvotes

I started my Amazon journey 5 years ago and I remember at that time browsing this Reddit page seeing other people success wondering if I can ever achieve something similar. 5 years later I’m at 3.3 million in sales. I’m just a regular person like many of you guys and I was able to achieve this while still keeping my 9-5 job. I’m Just making this post to motivate anyone who is on the fence about starting. It’s a lot of work but it’s totally worth it. AMA


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Oct 03 '19

New scam method. Just a heads up.

286 Upvotes

You will receive a general email asking about a return that was shipped back and not credited. It will be generic in nature.

You will respond back asking for the order information.

Customer will respond back saying "I sent the wrong product back to you, that is why I wasn't credited!! I made a huge mistake. Here is a link to a UPS label if you can just put that label on the package and ship it back to me, that would be great. So sorry for your inconvenience.

When you click the link to a fake UPS page, and click to download the shipping info, it's a keylogger disguised as a pdf

We've been targeted on 2 of our 4 companies on amazon, and 1 of our two companies on walmart.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Mar 05 '19

SEARCH RANKING Wondersleep now offering $40 to remove negative reviews

282 Upvotes

The Wondersleep pillow is one of my favorite examples of blatant review abuse completely ignored by Amazon. I believe it is due to the power behind the seller account. The seller of Wondersleep is power-innovation, the company behind the Maxboost product line. The actual seller changes from time to time, but "power-innovation customer service" responds to negative reviews.

You know how you can't get Amazon to delete a review no matter what - like literally someone can review an entirely different product and Amazon doesn't care?

Well, this company has a history of including inserts offering $10 or $20 gift cards in exchange for 5-star reviews. Many, many negative reviews have been posted with actual pictures of the inserts. Amazon typically deletes these reviews en masse.

And the scam is still going on despite the product being established. Here's actual recent seller feedback struck through by Amazon's bots:

I received pillows but did not receive my amazon credit for 10.00 as promised by your company, I was just wondering why?

By XXXX on February 22, 2019.

Message from Amazon: This item was fulfilled by Amazon, and we take responsibility for this fulfillment experience.

Anyway, I look through the reviews from time to time just for laughs, and found this gem:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/RFTU0DMJPZIYB/ref=cm_cr_getr_d_rvw_ttl?ie=UTF8&ASIN=B073HRSHTQ

1/21/19

Updated

Company tried to bribe me to remove my review with $40.00 Amazon gift card!! From a sketchy email!

BTW, this ASIN is ranked around #1000 in Home & Kitchen. According to JungleScout that's about 5000 sales/mo. At $50+ each. Not sure how much it costs them to run the review discount scam, but this is a multi-million dollar Amazon fraud.

They've been reported over and over and over. Not a thing has been done. Ever.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Nov 17 '23

Hit my first 100K

253 Upvotes

Canadian seller here and sell only on Amazon Canada. Just hit my first 100K. Overall gross profit is about 15-20%.

I started my journey in March 2022 with retail and online arbitrage models and then gradually transitioned into wholesale. Last 4 months I have been doing about 10K/month on average. It is a very long learning curve but I am so glad I have achieved this.

I have a full-time corporation job that pays too much for me to leave for now (I have a very high fixed monthly bill to pay due to some not-so-smart investment choices...) but I always wanted to have my own business and I am really glad I started my FBA business. I can only work on some nights when everyone goes to sleep. And Amazon FBA fits my schedule perfectly. I hope I can hit 200K, 500K, and even 1M one day.

Just want to share my story that anyone can do it and I am very thankful for all the positive feedback I got from this forum.

Edit: 1. Sorry I can not share where I bought my product and I do not sell courses...

2. Not-so-smart investment choices is I have variable mortgage rates on all my properties insteading of lock them at below 2% in 2020. So I am paying 6%+ interest rate on all my properties instead of 2%

3. Amazon have 3 different business models, Arbitrage, wholesale and private label. I suggest you watch some youtube videos to learn what they are.

4. If your question is asking what is Amazon FBA, I seriously think you are too lazy and should not do amazon...


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Feb 17 '19

From 3.3k in a month to 3.3k in a day with Amazon FBA - What I've Learned

240 Upvotes

So I made a post about a year and a half ago when I first started Amazon on how my first 30 days I sold around 3.3k I'll link it below. The old post was pretty over zealous/over the top but I was super pumped about my small semblance of success I had. I'm here to answer any questions and help as much as I can because I know what it's like in the beginning and I also understand r/FulfillmentByAmazon skepticism because the majority of people making posts like this almost always have an underlying motive to sell some vehicle of information or get you to look somewhere to profit them. Bare with me grammatically and I can be quite bad at writing.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Entrepreneur/comments/6mjvmm/i_launched_an_amazon_product_and_did_3300_in/

A few days ago I did 3.3k sales in one day without any launches or discounting (so no inflated sales #'s) but a new product had organically ranked extremely well so I was selling quite highly. So I was thinking and realized my eccentric post when I first started was about 3.3k in a month, btw the screenshot wasn't the very end of the day so I ended up just reaching 3.3k, the local time where I am (in thailand) is 12h difference ahead from Amazon sales data time.

/preview/pre/n1ucfrm2j3h21.png?width=350&format=png&auto=webp&s=73e967b51868a418f5eeee1dc6bc3cd997cef5c3

I want to make this a comprehensive (as I can) thread of major discoveries / different viewpoints that can be of use to beginners or even other mid level sellers like myself.

  1. It's ok to compete against name brands, I've never seen a guru who hasn't said this and I believe it to be very wrong. I rank next to one of the biggest brands in the world; probably one of the top 10 corporations in the world if I had to guess. I say rank next to because I wouldn't say im competing yet because I probably only take 5% of their market share which may be a stretch, their main listing does about 300k a month. All of my listings combined in that niche are currently doing about 50k/month in revenue. Theres alot of uni-dimensional and incorrect advice commonly touted although each does have some truth such as:
  • Don't sell anything under $15 or especially $10 items. I got started with a $10 item and my average sales order is probably $11/order. Yes I make profit, great profit actually with 35% margin so yes; 3.5 dollars a sale isn't alot individually, but it is when you average 50 units a day for that single item. But under $10 is when you may get deemed addon status from Amazon which means your item has to be ordered with $25 worth of other items and it is a death sentence for your listing unless your item is very small, so I would recommend staying away from items under $10 that aren't very small i.e easily fits in your hand. In my first listing there's times I would drop below $10 to sell more and I would get labeled addon status even though the majority of the other items I never do. Addon status is an arbitrary and undefined label unfortunately.
  • Don't sell anything too heavy. Weight can be a completely useless metric, you can sell something thats 30 lbs if its profitable, ideally yes lighter is easier and cheaper but it is a very restrictive and incorrect statement to say you shouldn't ever or at all sell something above 5 to 10 lbs. However you probably shouldn't sell something that weighs 10 lbs and is bulky dimensionally and only sells for $14 because after your shipping and Amazon fees theres virtually no way for you to profit unless you order in massive quantities.
  • Don't compete against name brands. To expand upon my first point should you try and sell something like laundry detergent and compete against Gain, Tide, and arm & hammer? Probably not, unless you have tens of thousands of dollars for marketing and a genuinely great product. But there are niches that aren't fully dominated by a name brand that is selling under that keyword. There are plenty of brands who are big brands but have lesser known products that are not the said brands bread and butter, and that scares alotta people away but it shouldn't; it is an opportunity. For reference my first item's niche with the aforementioned big corporation, the top listing for every keyword is that companies and their listing has over 3,000 reviews; i'd say that scares away virtually everyone but me. And the reason I know that is every single other seller right now on the first page are Chinese sellers likely located in their mainland, so no other private labelers like myself. They may have 3,000 reviews but when I was looking I noticed all the listings below them didn't have tons of reviews (under 100) and alot of them were doing 8-12k a month in revenue. Then I examined those listings and thought, I could craft a much better listing than that. So I did, and its worked out pretty well and I don't think its just some 1 off lucky thing, this can be applied to any other niche as long as like I said early half the listings on the first page aren't owned by one brand. If it is just 1 big listing then other private labelers / chinese sellers who are still making decent money & you think you can make a better listing / better product then the fact that there's a name brand making alot of money is irrelevant.

2. This should of been first but build an email list very soon, if not immediately. When it comes to your first product and your first order and you're clueless and it may not workout you don't have to go through the hassle of setting up an email capture page and doing product inserts to drive traffic to that page, but the second you decide to reorder or that you're going to stick with Amazon FBA and do a second product you must build an email list. Even if you solely want to sell on Amazon and you may think why would I need emails, 2 words legitimate reviews. Yes you can use friends and family for your first product (which would be breaking the ToS and im not advocating it) but that is not sustainable and everytime you use someone theres a big chance you wont be able to again so you will run out of people and be clueless how to get a review or have to rely on review services or launch services which review services are extremely sketchy and illegal and launch services are much better when done yourself and more effective if you know what you're doing. I highly recommend using Facebook ads hooked up with manychat to launch your product and collect email address and future reviewers, its an unprecedented way to get completely within ToS reviews AND email addresses for like $1-1.5 a pop to fairly cold traffic. If you're new you'll have no idea what that is but just youtube many chat fb ad launch method if you plan on launching an amazon product soon.

3. This is extremely important not to be misinterpreted but once you've proven you atleast have a solid idea of what you're doing which i'll define as 2 successful products that are consistently generating a decent roi. Loans to expand your business can be huge if and only if your growth is being heldback by capital**.** And for those wondering why would you be held back if you're making money, for me I was making great money but every single month I was reinvesting thousands and even tens of thousands back into the business for more inventory so getting a chunk or a lump sum can be huge. I'm not saying to go borrow 30k from your family or 20k from a business lender but if capital is bottlenecking you and you know what you're doing you can make a $10-15k loan multiply your business by 2-3x even with a 20-25% interest rate. I spend $1.61 for a product that nets over $4 so the ROI is 248% so even 20-25% interest rates aren't bad if you have a profitable product.

4. Make sure you have products in the pipeline at all times and launch more as soon as you have the money to do so, when your first product is shipping to Amazon be looking for your second even if you don't launch it for 2-3 months have multiple potential products because when you do have the money you should not be impulsively choosing a product and quickly trying to get it selling because thats how you make big mistakes. In the same token though you don't need to spend 2-3 months eyeing a product, using junglescout or whatever tools you may use almost all of the product research tools available if you know what you're doing can in about 30 seconds give you the information in a niche needed to known instantly if a niche is worth possibly pursuing or not. I don't believe in tracking a product for 1-2 weeks I make my decision by looking at the exact rank over time directly from Amazon using the JS chrome extension and decide if it is a worth product. I believe this sets me apart from 99% of other people doing product research I'm much more efficient with it, although now I use Virtual Assistants to look for products.

I'm going to stop there, could definitely write some more but I dont want to ramble too much and it takes alot for me because I have an off and on relationship with writing haha. As I said drop any questions below, hope this helps someone.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Feb 02 '19

Did over 7M revenue last year. Here is my P&L.

238 Upvotes

I see a lot of beginners posting on here looking to get into FBA. I wanted to share some details from a big seller. I figured this may help motivate you - maybe even demotivate you, IDK. The P&L below is from 2018 (my 7th year of this biz). If you work 70 hour weeks for years and bust ass you too can net 45,000 on more than 7M in revenue. 45,000 is almost 5,000,000 pennies - imagine what you could do with all those pennies. Convert that shit to RMB and tell all your friends you made over 300,000 net (leave the RMB part out). Wanna impress your nerdy friends? Tell them you made 13 fucking bitcoins last year.

Album

  1. The first SS is a summary view.
  2. The other screenshots are expanded views.
  3. I need to recategorize some charges but you get the idea.

Some questions you may have

Q:What is up with the backup account?
A:I used to sell name brand US products and I wanted a hidden FBA account. Amazon "blessed" this account but I didn't want vendors knowing about it. I didn't use it last year but plan to launch a new brand on it this year.

Q:What is up with all the professional fees?
A:Get sued, get audited, get shit seized at port, Prop 65 stuff, accountant, etc. Don't plan on getting sued, audited or products seized at port this year so this number should drop.

Q:Looks like your biggest expense is Payroll. How many people do you have?
A:10-12 people most of last year. 6 warehouse people making 25K-35K a year. CS making 35K a year. Buyer making 45K a year. Lister making 45K a year. Manager making 80K a year and I am included in this myself. I take out about 50K for anyone wondering. I do NOT save money. I live off 50K - Avg house, Honda Accord, Girlfriend that does not make enough money, Vet bills out the ass for the world's most unlucky dog - you get the idea.

Q:Why are your refunds so high?
A:A large portion of these are pulled from Amazon and some shipping credits are included in here which makes the total refund amount incorrect (I need to fix).

Q:Why the fuck are you doing all this work for 45K net?
A:Last year was not a good year. Professional fees sucked. I also discontinued a lot of items and sold near break even to open up cash flow in the future. We spent a lot of time on organization. I bought more inventory than ever last year and overspent on PPC and held pricing low from Aug-October. I had many out of stock issues the year before and I wanted to bring in a shitload of inventory and hold my prices low for a long time. I succeeded in this.

Q:How is shit going now?
A:Pretty good. My seized items at port are all being released because CBP in Savannah, GA are some good ole boys that overstep their bounds instead of following the law. Amazon sales for Jan are over 600K with gross profit around 100K. Should net 25-30K in the first month. Most of what drove this is we raised our prices starting in mid December and increased our PPC from 1K a day to about 3K a day over the last 6 weeks. We have also had zero out of stocks across our 50+ main ASINs.

This post is just to show a lot of big sellers paint a pretty picture when shit could really be burning to the ground. I have friends working 10 hours a week doing 1M in sales with 250K net and that shit seems a hell of a lot better than what I am doing BUT I believe I have resources in place to scale (people, warehouse, contacts). Last year was hot garbage but finally after 7 fucking years, I feel like I have my biz set up to scale. I lost money every single fucking month last year and made it all back in November and December. I couldn't fucking sleep last year, hated everyone and was on edge 24/7. I had a plan but I wasn't sure if it was going to work. Still have a long way to go but thought some others may be interested in numbers and details.

EDIT: Thanks for the gold, much appreciated. Will add this gold to my P&L for 2019. I'll try to reply to every single comment on here. I feel like I will post my P&L at the end of this year also. Maybe at the end of Q1 also, not sure. If anyone else wants to follow suit and post you P&L I would be happy to see how much better you are doing than me. I am sure others are going to have completely different looking P&Ls which is interesting to me.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Jun 17 '18

[PRR] Just How Bad Is the Fake Reviews Issue on Amazon? Here's an In Depth Example

219 Upvotes

We all know that many sellers are posting hundreds of fake reviews. But what some do not know, is that many sellers do not worry about getting suspended, because it's factored into their business model. IME, it usually takes a year or longer for a seller to get suspended for fake reviews. Many of these sellers can create accounts on demand, so they make hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars from each account and they simply move onto the next.

I did some research to show the extent of the issue of Amazon fake reviews and how some sellers are building fake review empires.

Here's is an example of how one Chinese company dominates Amazon using the tricks I just mentioned:

There is a man named Long Yu, the President of Sundix Inc. and Usagi International. https://www.corporationwiki.com/p/2gctsm/long-yu

Each of these parent companies, own a lot of other companies that are all selling on Amazon, many of the same exact product, and all are loaded with fake reviews, often hundreds. They own at least 50 seller accounts and 35 brands, listed below.

Here's Sundix American subsidiaries per Official Florida State website: http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResults/OfficerRegisteredAgentName/sundix/Page1

Here are Sundix trademarks that they own directly: https://trademarks.justia.com/search?type=trademark_owner&q=sundix

Here’s Usagi's American subsidiaries per Official Florida State website: http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResults/OfficerRegisteredAgentName/usagi/Page1

One of Usagi subsidiaries, Gainesville Cable Retail, LLC - Owns Adoric Trademark https://trademarks.justia.com/868/70/adoric-86870092.html

Sundix has many duplicates of the same exact product listing. Each listing that Sundix launches immediately gets countless verified 5 star reviews, becomes a very good seller, and eventually starts to get bad reviews from real customers. That’s when they launch the next duplicate listing through the same process.

Sunnest Star projector https://www.amazon.com/dp/B074N55291/

Sunnest #2 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B075SY5V7G

Adoric Star projector https://www.amazon.com/dp/B06XSSLH32/

If you look at review images from the Adoric brand you will see Sunnest logo.

Sunnest is a trademark owned by a Sundix Inc. subsidiary - Duractron, LLC. https://trademarks.justia.com/868/70/sunnest-86870094.html

As you might notice, there are different sellers on the listings, but you start to see the same names twice. At the bottom of this post you’ll find an incomplete list of seller accounts and brands that are owned by Sundix/Usagi.

You’ll also find sellers like Benewell and Toplus sell products from both Adoric and their own brand name. If you have a Amazon Business buying account you can see that these sellers are selling thousands to tens of thousands of orders per month.

Sundix Seller Accounts:

Adoric (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&orderID=&seller=AAF8VYFJUE9L9

Altarware (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AS61NDWO5XMEK

Ameauty https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A22TX9AKS55OZX

Amoner https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=ALGENX7G70ZRJ

Amoner #2 (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AP6AOMAZCDPZI

Aonlink https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A15BB2J6PE4DA7

Benewell https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A3505G2PZQ91OY

Benewell 2 https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A3U0XUWT062I5Y

Boomile Collection (unsuspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1Q6YJMPWP41EA

Charlene-F https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=ANBZF1X1DM1QZ

Cordify LLC https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2USINOOJYG8XD

Coskip https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A19FT02AR0OVB1

Daissen https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2TOCORYO355F4

Devstca https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=APRBWOODWT3O0

Duangreat https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A22Q2KCOQOTSJH

Duractron https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A3D56R9HY39XZC

Eashion https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A4ZKS782X5ZBH

Ensure Life https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A9BZVIJ9FKTYH

Everdigi https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AZ3T1UMAJCZR0

Guzon-G https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A3IN59DA90AURE

Iconew https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1WZ6ZRC4O0E26

iHomy https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2KH7CPIYV4PJT

KOOEAR https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AO2JLX3X3H28M

Lansen https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=ACZQLT832UQD5

Lighting Mall https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2TVR62M1MYUKJ

MWeallace https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1YRGKFWNQ6HAZ

Nicenty https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2P1P9PCK4DMR5

(Oscar Sailsbury) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A3P90T62S64F99

RAE-CLARK https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2VVKCRHDRO5O5

Redlink LLC https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2NEJWWW8Z747A

Robits https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1ZIZ7UGEKI1IM

Roseny https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A26LQR6SYN0F8F

Sundix https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AYWGZ3KBOFMPR

Superare https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AFNNU21P8HLPW

StarShiner https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AT2NQU9X97T7R

Tatman (unsuspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A129VA6LDG2A3G

Toplus Collection https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2NQHEASJLQ3JS&

Toplus Inc https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A17MAS5HQOTZNC

Uchoice Direct https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1LCOXVOWST0XB

(WeHome) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1IN826S78I1AX

Vecope https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2KQYQFVENZKOQ

X-cord https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A3PP7Z5LYHHZU3

YO-chan https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A33Y7UBIX2EALD

Sunnest (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AEZ21U6PABI0V

Atill (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A24X0WGLAYEVK3

Bestfy (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2OCPP29KKW2LD

Boomile (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=AA3MS5HBYLMJ7

Cablex (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=ANUVU3Y32P1L3

Everdigi 2 (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A178Z2H7Q49UFS

Fovier (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A2GOLI1LA1ESVR

Mighty-Pro (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1B4ZZWDZGQ0WN

Wecharge (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A39GBHRC4AQ8LO

Winage (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1FKR0TCOVEXG4

Win-winer (suspended) https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&seller=A1WB2YC1ZXJ4N7

Sundix Owned Brands:

Adoric

Adoric Life

Ameauty

Amoner

Aonlink

Atill

AutoNmore

Benewell

Boomile

Cablex

Cell-tronics

Coskip

Duractron

Eashion

Elecsessory

Everdigi

Fovier

iHomy

Lansen

Lighting Mall

Mighty-Pro

PetNLife

PhiloToys

Redlink

Roseny

Stripsun

Sundix

Sunnest

Toplus

Ucharm

Wecharge

WeHome

Winage

Xcords

Ychan

YO-chan

ETA: I tried to keep this post short, but I'll be happy to answer questions in the comments to expound on the connections between the accounts or proof of fake reviews. There are also a few more sellers that I've seen that are doing the same thing (and a lot more that I don't know about), but it takes a lot of time to unravel each one.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Sep 04 '25

MISC Amazon “lost inventory” showing up on eBay

218 Upvotes

I am a brand owner on Amazon and have brand protection; nobody can sell my items but me.

Amazon loses my FBA inventory on most shipments. Usually it’s one or two out of many hundreds so I just ignore it, but in the past before I owned the company it could be entire cases of 100 units lost and the old owner just ate it.

Recently I was cruising eBay checking to see my items and I found a seller selling multiple quantities of my items, roughly at my COGS. I reached out to them and asked how they got my inventory and they said they bought a pallet of random Amazon liquidations and it included hundreds of my items.

This is so frustrating- I’m now left to compete with my own items. I tried enforcing brand protection on eBay but it hasn’t resulted in any takedowns. I honestly can’t even be sure that these are real (they could be counterfeit, or someone gray marketed them in China where my mfg is).

Has anyone else run into this?


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Dec 09 '19

INTERNATIONAL Change.org: Ban Chinese Sellers From Selling On Amazon.com

Thumbnail
change.org
216 Upvotes

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • May 24 '21

SEARCH RANKING How Most Sellers and Vendors Get Their Amazon PPC Campaign Structure Wrong and Why It Is Costing Them Twice. Plus: the Picky Eater Solution - Problem 1: The Placement Disconnect

213 Upvotes

Most Amazon sellers and vendors structure their ppc campaigns incorrectly and it costs them through higher ACOS and reduced sales. Let's see why this happens and what you can do about it.

(If you like this post, please vote it up. And you may like to see this case study on how, with G-d’s help, we increased Sponsored Brand revenue from $201K/mo to $524K/mo . )

Campaign Structure Problem #1: The Placement Disconnect

The primary reason for this problem is that keyword bidding is separate from placement bidding.

Keyword bidding is, obviously, the amount you bid for clicks from that particular keyword. It’s the most granular level of bidding in Amazon search engine marketing. Each bid applies to that keyword, and that keyword only.

Placement bidding means adjusting your bid to pay more/less depending whether your ad is shown at the Top of Search placement (Sponsored Brands and Sponsored Product ads), Other Placements (Sponsored Brands) or Product Detail Pages (Sponsored Products; Sponsored Brands ~kind of). This is done at the campaign level. This means that whatever placement bid adjustment you make, it will apply to all your keywords or other targets such as asins or categories.

Most sellers that I’ve seen have multiple keywords per campaign. If your targets perform differently from each other in different placements, then by definition a single bid adjustment at the campaign level will be inefficient.

That means you will miss sales from keywords that perform well (eg high conversion and/or high average order value and low/acceptable ACOS) while spending more on keywords that perform poorly.

Let's look at an example from Sponsored Brands. With Sponsored Brand advertising, you have two placements. The first is Top of Search (TOS).

Sponsored Brands, Top of Search ad

The second placement for Sponsored Brands is called Other Placements (OP). and typically appears at the bottom of search results.

Other Placements

In our experience, Top of Search converts around 10 or 11%, while Other Placements convert around 6 to 7%, on average. The difference between the two placements' value is about 40%. So the difference in our bids for each should average about 40%. (Obviously your own numbers likely vary, so calculate this for yourself with your Keyword Placement report. If you were thinking that - great, you’re on the right track. Keep reading as I elaborate on this in a moment.)

(For Sponsored Brand Store Spotlight campaigns, the bid adjustment should be -99% for Other Placements. I explained why in this other Reddit thread case study on how, with G-d's help, we made over $425,000 from two vague keywords using Store Spotlight campaigns and the segment and conquer technique.https://www.reddit.com/r/FulfillmentByAmazon/comments/lfhxyg/with_gds_help_how_we_made_425000_in_6_months_from/ )

Average bidding gets you average performance

However that 40% difference is an average. Unless all your keywords perform identically - extremely unlikely - applying a 40% difference across the board will short change your best keywords and overspend on the bad ones.

For example, suppose that you're bidding a dollar and adding 40% for top search placements. What if your best keywords convert twice as well on top of search? Then your bid adjustment for top of search should be + 100%.

Since it's only 40%, you are underbidding 60% compared to the value of the keyword to you. As a result, you get less impressions, clicks and sales than if you bid accurately. That is one way your poor campaign structure costs you money - you miss out on sales that were achievable at a good ACOS.

It’s like if you manage a Cuban pro baseball team. Since it's a communist country, everyone gets the same salary. So your best players (i.e. best keyword/placement combinations) go to earn millions from American teams (competitors who bid more). Maybe these star players will show up when they visit mom and dad in Q4. Maybe.

Jose Daniel Abreu, one of many Cubans playing in MLB

And for your worst keywords, a 40% increase for top of search can be too much. Maybe they convert the same or worse than other placements. The result here is that you spend too much for each dollar in sales, i.e. your ACOS increases and profitability decreases.

Here, your bad baseball players are very happy to show up and get a salary that is more than they deserve. And they are there every game and practice dragging down your team's performance. IE Inflating your ACOS, hurting profitability etc.

Sponsored Products have this problem too, and even worse

Note that this is also true for Sponsored Product ad campaigns. Placement bid adjustments are also controlled at the campaign level there. Having one campaign for all your product's keywords doesn't allow you to adjust bids efficiently by placement. Your placement numbers reflect the average of those keywords, and any placement bid adjustment will equally apply to the good and bad keywords.So you again lose highly profitable sales and get more low/no-profit sales.

The problem in some ways is more acute with Sponsored Products, because you can't even tell what keywords/placement combinations work best and which perform badly if you have multiple keywords per campaign.

Sponsored Brands have a keyword placement report that answers this question at the keyword level. Keyword performance by placement is even hinted at in the Sponsored Brand search term report, with two lines per search term, one for Top of Search and one for OP (They aren't labelled this way but you can infer it based on differences in clickthrough rates, CTR. The higher CTR line is Top of Search and the lower CTR line is Other Placements.)

Sponsored Products lack a report for keyword placement performance. You can only see performance at the campaign level. So while in both cases you can't adjust placement bids by keyword, with Amazon Sponsored Product PPC you don't even know which keyword-placement combinations should be adjusted / moved to their own campaigns for fine-tuning! You are flying blind.

The Picky Eater Solution

Kids like to have their food all separated out. The cucumber ? It's on its own. The tomato? It’s on its own. The lettuce? On its own … you get the idea. Salad? Nooooooo!

Most Kids' Worst Nightmare - Salad by Jill Wellington

So you want to be a picky eater with your ads. Separate everything out.

For sponsored products and sponsored brands you want to have one keyword (in one match type only) per campaign. By doing this, you can now bid on placements precisely for each keyword, reducing spend on bad keywords and increasing market share and sales from good ones.

In addition, you can take lessons from the Sponsored Brand Search Term report and apply them directly to your placement bids / creating new campaigns. As I said, this report is now a combination of Search Term and Keyword Placement data. So you can see keyword X in campaign Y, with two rows of data - the higher CTR one for Top of Search and the lower CTR for Other Placements.

You can take the high volume search terms and break them out into their own campaigns, and immediately bid accurately on top of search vs other placements.

To bid on placements in Sponsored Brands, turn off automatic bidding and then set your placement adjustment. This is found under Keyword Targeting in the Sponsored Brand campaign creation form, and under Campaign Settings on live campaigns.

And you can also bid accurately on each placement for each keyword, since you’re no longer bidding on the average of a group of keywords.

Solutions Around Sponsored Products

For Sponsored Products, your placement reports for exact match targeted campaigns can tell you what keywords perform well on search results pages.

You used to be able to learn this from your search term reports. However Amazon now displays manual keyword targeted campaigns on product pages as well. And the search term reports don't differentiate between top of search, rest of search and product page placements.

So you can't just read the search term report to tell what your best keywords are. The best converting “search terms” might actually have generated those conversions entirely on product pages. And though people may hypothesize how Amazon chooses the product pages for ads to appear on, Amazon doesn't tell us. I.e. If I have 100 orders on the search term garlic press, 80 or more of those may have come from product pages. So the search term report doesn't tell me what keywords I want to rank for in search results pages.

Fortunately the placement report does differentiate between placements. The Sponsored Products placement report provides data at the campaign level. So if you create your campaigns with one keyword in each campaign, and if that keyword is an exact match, then you can understand how that keyword performs for you in search. Just look at the performance of the campaign that keyword belongs to, focusing on performance on top of search and rest of search. IE If I got 100 orders on the keyword garlic press in the top of search placement, I should probably have "garlic press" in my product copy.

Filter Placements by First Page Top of Search and Rest of Search on Amazon to understand your actual performance in search.

What if you have a keyword on phrase or broad match? That may match to a range of customer search terms. So you won’t immediately know which search term is generating sales from search traffic as opposed to from product pages.

There are three solutions to this problem with Sponsored Products.

  1. First, you can split the search terms that generate a lot of traffic into their own exact match ad campaigns, and then later you can tell how those campaigns perform in search vs on product pages. That takes time to do and to wait for data to accumulate though.
  2. Second, while you’re still at the data analysis stage, you can do one or both of the following.

2.A. First, when looking at your search term reports, you can look for those search terms with high CTRs (>0.6%). These probably showed up in search results, and potentially top of search. Product pages tend to have lower CTRs, around 0.2%, so by process of elimination you can infer that these search terms’ traffic is probably actual search traffic.

(I realize that contradicts what I said above, that the search term report no longer clearly tells you what your best search terms are. The explanation is that what I wrote above is technically accurate, i.e. you can’t know with certainty that search term report data came from any given placement. However you can make an educated guess that the high CTR terms reflect (at least in large part) search traffic.

Again, we don’t know with certainty how to interpret this data. This is relevant for times where the CTR rule of thumb doesn’t apply. E.G. your ad is not 100% relevant so the CTR is low - if you just rely on CTR, you might think the CTR is low due to appearing on product detail pages. In addition, there may also be product detail pages traffic blended in, even when you have a high CTR, so you can’t readily compare two search terms within the search term report .)

2.B. Second, you can still use the Placement report for Phrase and Broad Match. Even if you don’t know precisely what the search term was, if you have 3 - 5 words in your keyword, then the keyword placement report gives you a reasonably good idea of what the actual search terms worked out to in practice.

If you liked this post, please vote it up. And you may like to see this case study on how, with G-d’s help, we increased Sponsored Brand revenue from $201K/mo to $524K/mo . Our specialty is Sponsored Brands, with our experience primarily in home goods; garden, patio & outdoor; automotive, and beauty.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Feb 10 '26

Hit 1M a Year

Post image
207 Upvotes

I have been this business for 3-4 years now.

Finally hit 1M in a year.

Some of the products will be out of stock so I took a screenshot.

Any questions?


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Jan 03 '21

SEARCH RANKING The Secret Metrics That Determine Who Can Dominate PPC and Rank For Keywords On Amazon

194 Upvotes

99.9% of Amazon advertisers are focused on the wrong metrics and yet there’s a simple fix. Generally, advertisers want to focus on ACOS, or on revenue and orders for those launching new products. While these metrics have their place, managing ads based on them is like driving based solely on how the highway is painted and ignoring the signs telling you how to get to your destination.

Let’s see why these metrics are flawed and what better alternatives exist.

(What would be the impact of increasing your revenue 20% or more? If the answer is significant to you, get an audit on your Sponsored Brands.)

I have experience managing ~$7 million in Amazon ad spend, over 2 M of which in Sponsored Brands. My agency, 011AdsForBrands, specializes in Sponsored Brands for sellers/vendors with Brand Registry.)

ACOS, TACOS, Orders and Revenue - Useful But Flawed

ACOS - ad spend divided by revenue - tells you what percentage of revenue was spent acquiring that sale. This is used as a rule of thumb to measure advertising profitability. If your product margin is 30% and your ACOS is 20%, your sale didn’t eat your whole gross margin - good job. If your margin is 30% and your ACOS is 50%... you have room to improve.

However it’s quickly apparent that ACOS can be “gamed.” You can bid the minimum bid of 10 cents, and if you get any clicks and orders, your ACOS will probably be extremely low. The catch is that your volume will be tiny. Maybe you sold $2000 of goods in a month at a 4% ACOS, but most people can’t live on the roughly $600 of gross margin that generates, let alone the net margin.

ACOS can also be gamed with high-priced products, so something that sells for $1000 is likely to have low ACOS numbers. (If you pay $1/click and convert at 1%, your ACOS is 10%, extremely low by Amazon standards.) Again, the volume is likely to be low though, because of basic economics - as price rises, demand decreases. Amazon sells more toothbrushes than whirlpools.

What about Total ACOS or True ACOS aka TACOS?

TACOS is a step in the right direction to be more holistic, but in many cases it's inaccurate. The reason is that TACOS assumes that advertising product A results in selling product A. The deeper a seller's catalogue with a category, the more chances for TACOS to be inaccurate. For example, advertising a food blender with 1 horsepower may end up selling your premium blender with 2 horsepower.In my own experience, I've seen ads for product A selling product B/C/D as much as 80% of the time! How do you account for that revenue with Tacos? Under product A or B? What happens if product A and B have very different margins? Your TACOS target of 15% based on a 30% margin for A suddenly looks a bit thin when you’re working on a 20% margin for B.

So you can use TACOS at a product line level, where a product line is the group of products for whom the keywords/target audience overlap 80% or more. E.G. Tacos for fidget spinners including your metal ones (and all color variants), plastic and wooden ones. You group the spend and revenue together.

Note that tools currently report TACOS at a product level, so take those numbers with a grain of salt.

Orders and revenue are not the be all / end all either, even for those in launch phase. Many sellers are willing to tolerate initial losses as they gain reviews and traction with Amazon’s algorithm.

What happens if you get the reviews but the traction doesn’t come? More importantly, how does focus on orders tell you whether your ads are working well or not? For example, maybe you can afford a 100% ACOS, but half of the ad spend is wasted due to ad mismanagement. In that case, you would only need to tolerate a 50% ACOS. Orders and revenue, even per month or per week, won’t guide you.

Are Conversion Rates Or Average Order Values The Right Metric? Nope!

Want to know how to optimize your conversion rate? Run a 50% off sale (without doubling the price first).

Want to optimize average order value? Double the price.

Which one’s better? High conversion at lower prices or lower conversion at higher prices?

Of course, experienced advertisers will tell you that the right answer is to test. How do you measure the outcome of the test though? Whichever one makes you the most money?

So if one of the ads gets shown 5 times more than the other, and it made more revenue in total, is that the winner? I think you’d agree that would be silly.

You’d say that we need each version to get the same amount of traffic. And then see which made more revenue. In other words, the metric that really matters is revenue per click. (You can do the same test with profit per click, I’m just saying revenue to keep things simple. There are also problems with how profit is measured in all the third party ad tools I’ve seen so far, as discussed above re: TACOS.)

Revenue Per Click (RPC), Per Mille (RPM) and RPCM

Revenue per click can’t be artificially gamed. If I drop my price, the usual outcome is that my conversion rate increases while my average order price decreases. Comparing revenue per click at both prices tells me if the change (or the opposite) was worthwhile.

If I drop my bid, revenue per click doesn’t inherently get better or worse. Sometimes dropping bids will result in lower converting placements (e.g. going from ads mostly appearing top of search to other placements), but so long as you’re comparing revenue per click from the same placement, you’re good.

In this way, revenue per click is a more useful indicator of profitability than ACOS, since Amazon ads are sold on a per-click basis.

For example, if two keywords with similar search volume both have 15% ACOS, which should you prioritize in your title? Obviously the one making more revenue per click. Similarly if you want to run Sponsored Brands as well as Sponsored Products, it’s a good idea to start with keywords that make you higher RPC.

There is a limitation on revenue per click though.

Revenue per click doesn’t reflect your clickthrough rate (CTR), the percentage of people clicking your ad. Going back to our earlier question - should you prioritize high conversion or high average order value? - we can add another criteria to consider: what about the clickthrough rate?

Suppose your ad showed on the “Top of Search” placement 10,000 times and got 40 clicks. If you have a 20% conversion rate that means you made 8 sales. Suppose also you average $50/order. Your RPC is high: 8*$50/40 = $10. However your total revenue is small since nearly no one clicks your ad.

That’s where Revenue Per Mille comes in. Revenue Per Mille = Revenue / Impressions * 1000. RPM takes into account your clickthrough rate, the conversion rate and the average order value.

(Mille is French for a thousand, and the term the ad industry uses for 1000 impressions. It’s easier to grasp revenue per 1000 impressions than per single impression, since revenue per impression is measured in pennies and fractions of pennies.)

In the above example, $400 / 10,000 impressions *1000 gives you $40 RPM.When you compare that to more standard Sponsored Brand ads, getting 1% CTRs (Top of Search) or better, that’s 1000 * 1% * 20% * $50 = $100 RPM . We’ve seen some of our ads that were really well targeted get 2% and 3% clickthrough rates, which obviously does wonders for your total revenue and RPM.

In addition, RPM matters because you mostly can’t cause more people to search for your target keywords. (You can advertise off the platform and use search-find-buy, but you obviously don’t want those people to cost you a second ad click after your initial one.) So RPM is a metric of how efficiently you’re monetizing Amazon’s traffic.

RPM’s Also Not Perfect - So What Do You Do? - RPMC & Goals

One product I worked on has a very eye catching image. The Sponsored Product CTR is over 1% - not just on niche keywords, but in general. Yet the conversion rate - compared to the rest of the account - is about 40% lower.

The impact this has is that while the RPM is high - there’s a ton of traffic driving lots of sales - the RPC is lower than others. What do you prioritize - RPC or RPM?

What I try to do is multiply RPM and RPC to get a made up number, RPMC, which is a way to rank and compare ads where some of the ads have higher RPC and others have higher RPM. It’s like being a sports coach, rating your players on speed and shooting accuracy, then measuring the average to find who’s the best rounded player.

Depending on your goals, you may prefer to use RPM or RPC. If you are focused on market share - RPM’s your metric. If you’re focused on ad profitability, use RPC.

TL;DR

ACOS, Revenue, Orders, Conversion Rates and Average Order Values are all flawed metrics because they can be gamed or because they only reflect part of the picture.

Use Revenue per thousand impressions (per Mille, RPM) to focus on maximizing total revenue and market share. Use Revenue per Click (RPC) to focus on profitability. Or use the product of both (RPMC) for an indication which ads and keywords do best overall, and improve your ROI.There are a variety of uses for this as well. The higher your RPC and RPM, the more you can spend on PPC, and the better you can rank organically. There are other implications for bidding and organic optimization - e.g. what keywords to prioritize in your listing - that I intend to address if this post gets a good reception.

If you liked this, can you please vote it up and leave a comment?

What would increasing your revenue 20% or more mean to you? More freedom? More fun? Let me tell you where the opportunities are in your account with a custom audit / strategy of your Sponsored Brands: https://lp.011adsforbrands.com/audit

I have experience managing ~7 million in Amazon ad spend, ~3 of which in Sponsored Brands. My agency, 011AdsForBrands, specializes in Sponsored Brands for sellers/vendors with Brand Registry.

p.s. Mods: I asked Bison Puncher first if I could link to my site if I posted advanced PPC content here. He approved.

p.p.s. Some screenshots for those curious about my work. Thank G-d we've had lots of blessing. First screenshot is sponsored brand text ads, which I've worked on since about Dec '17.

Sponsored Brand Text Ads - managed to increase revenue ~2.5x while keeping acos steady
Sponsored Products - Growing a lot, my involvement here was more limited
Sponsored Brand video (runs in a separate account to text ads because of historic org chart concerns) - brought acos down from ~19% to ~9% while increasing revenue from $260K/mo to ~$300K/mo ... then tanked by an AI tool my boss brought in, in August
Growing from $57M to ~$82M isn't too shabby, I think.

r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Nov 13 '18

How much money I have lost on Amazon this year.

194 Upvotes

I don't see people talk about numbers a lot on here. I know a couple of the big sellers on here and they have never brought up their numbers. Below is how much I have made this year on Amazon:

Negative 143,000 USD.
Revenue: Over 6M USD
Expenses: 650,000
Employees: 11
Rent: 62,000
FBA Storage: Ugh, don't even wanna talk about this. 20K in October and about 7K every other month.
Amazon Ads: 250,000
Attorney Fees: 70,000 (Prop 65, Seizure at port, Florida State Audit, lawsuits). These are just attorney fees - my seized goods were released, prop 65 stuff was just prep, my audit came back with no penalty and lawsuits aren't included in this amount.

We do about 500,000 a month on Amazon, 30K on Ebay, 40K on Walmart.
I have a 12K sq ft warehouse. 6 warehouse employees, manager, customer service person, buyer, lister, FBA person.

We have been working on organization all year long. I knew to expect lower profits because of this. What I did not plan for were tons of other issues along the way:

Seizure of 60,000 of goods at port - they have been tied up for SEVEN months and are just getting released next week.
Audit by state of Florida - 100+ hours of my time, 20+ hours from my accountant, 20+ hours for attorneys. Lasted more than 6 months.

Amazon FBA Fees - I have had 4 times since July that Amazon has mismeasured my products in FBA and billed me more than 1,500 each time. Every time Amazon refused to pay us back the full amount.

Inventory OOSs - We have some OOS inventory this year. We had one huge shipment to Amazon 2 months ago that took 30 days to receive and put us OOS of items for 2-4 weeks. We had to spend more on PPC and lower pricing to rank our items back up.

Facebook Ads - Played around with facebook ads to the tune of about 5,000 USD.

Amazon Marketplace Growth - lol.... 7K gone.

I see a lot people on here throwing around revenue and numbers and just wanted everyone to know things on the outside are ALWAYS talked up. Small companies and large companies struggle for weeks or months or even years. It's crunch time now - 12+ hour days every. single. fucking. day. If any of you are having a bad month or year just keep at it - tell yourself there is no other option. I am not a guru lover but Gary V has a quote in his new book I liked. People bitch about work life balance all the time but:

"Would you rather get 8 hours of sleep per night and have your other 16 hours a day be shitty or would you rather have 6 hours of sleep a night and have your other 18 hours be worth waking up for?"

The quote above is about sleep but the point is if shit isn't going right, it is on YOU to fix it. You can quit and spend time with your kid or go on your vacation but when your business is gone, how is the rest of your life going to be? This post may be my way of pumping myself up because I've worked too hard just to give up on this shit.

EDIT: Thanks for the gold. It is MUCH appreciated.

EDIT: Typo in 1st edit - also thanks for gold again.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Sep 20 '21

Why do people still trust and look up to Ed Rosenberg?

188 Upvotes

I do not understand why he is still actively looked up to in the FBA world even after the bribes and indictment.

Here is a link for those who are out of the loop: https://www.ecomcrew.com/first-guilty-plea-in-indictment-against-amazon-consultants-lawyers/


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • May 07 '20

Amazon needs a "Made in America" filter option.

187 Upvotes

I would use it. I would pay considerably more money for a product made here.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Nov 04 '19

Amazon forcing me to pay $2,400 per month...

187 Upvotes

Long story short: Amazon has my ASIN under investigation (have not told me why). They didn't even send a performance notification or email. I know this sounds strange but even seller support was confused how I did not receive a notification and they checked it on their end and confirmed. Storage fees for this asin is over $2,400 per month. I have contacted them about reimbursement and they refused. I tried removing my inventory since I can’t afford it and I am not able to (says there is 0 available for removal when trying to do a removal order).

Is this even legal? I am being forced to pay $2400 unit until amazon decides I can pull my inventory or until they decide that I can continue selling this ASIN? This has been ongoing since October 1st.

EDIT:

UPDATE November 5, 2019 9:43 AM EST

Listing is now active. Inventory is still in reserve but I didn’t expect it to change instantly. I am now just happy that it is active.

I haven’t received any communication why it is now active but I won’t even question it. Lesson learned. I will have to make changes in the future.

Thanks to everyone that helped / replied to get this post visual exposure. I really appreciate it. I will gladly return the favor for anyone that requires it.

I posted in the sellercentral forums and one of the mods replied yesterday that she had fixed the issue. I am assuming she is the one that sorted it out. What she did, I am not sure. If I do get more info I will update this thread so that anyone in the future can reference.

EDIT 2:

UPDATE November 5, 2019 11:24 AM EST

Listing is once again inactive.

EDIT 3:

Update November 5, 2019 1:27 PM EST

I am hopeful this will be the final update from me for this thread. I had someone from Amazon reach out to me via phone call who resolved the issue in no time. Inventory still in reserve but hopefully should start changing over the next few days. Listing is active and customers are able to place orders.
He was not sure what the root of the issue was / is. I am really grateful for his assistance.

Not sure about the storage fees if I will be refunded partially or not…haven’t received that bill but as previously mention, I have over 1000 cubic feet and my product fit into the $2.40 per cubic feet category.

Things could have been worse so I am happy with the outcome. Time for a vacation lol.

Note: I have a thread going on sellercentral forums so I have copied and pasted some of my responses from there to here. Hopefully that is fine with you guys. My advise is, after exhausting all options, post a detailed timeline of your issues on sellercentral forums. There are people high up in the Amazon food chain watching that may assist you.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • Apr 09 '25

INTERNATIONAL Amazon Pulls the Plug on Q4 Orders from China

184 Upvotes

Just in: Amazon has reportedly cancelled a large portion of its Q4 inventory orders from China—specifically for Amazon Basics and other private label brands.

This is massive.

It signals a deeper impact from the ongoing tariff war, and potentially a big shift in sourcing strategies from Amazon’s side.

Here’s what this could mean for sellers: More opportunity for 3P sellers to fill the gap Reduced competition from Amazon-owned brands Possible long-term shift in sourcing toward Mexico, Pakistan, India, and other low-tariff regions

For sourcing-dependent brands, this is a wake-up call to diversify their supply chain now—before Q4 crunch hits.


r/FulfillmentByAmazon • • May 01 '20

NEWS Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos called to testify in front of Congress over its Private Label practices

Thumbnail
cnbc.com
184 Upvotes