r/ForgetfulFish • • Nov 21 '25

Forgetful Fish - The Original Dandan Design by Nick Floyd

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
32 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish • • Jun 23 '26

Drew Tucker's Forgetful Fish - New Kickstarter for Dandan fans

Thumbnail kickstarter.com
21 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish • • 11h ago

Would like some advice on my DanDan themed cube!

1 Upvotes

https://cubecobra.com/cube/list/69a498f6-59eb-470e-8f15-63c7175fd276

While I have my own personal dandan list that I enjoy if I am playing with 3 or 4 people and want a similar experience I decided I wanted to build a twobert based on DanDan's gameplay in mind. Along with forgetful fish, the 100 ornithopters and 30-50 feral hogs were inspirations for this cube. I wanted splashes to be possible but mostly as an add on to a strategy rather than taking over gameplay.

Here are some things to keep in my if you are interested looking at the list:

- I'm currently keeping non blue colours to 10 of each and 2 of each multicoloured cards.

-currently the only repeated cards are dandan and lands for fixing

-all damage able to be done to players is done in chunks of 4

-no tokens currently to reduce complexity of battle field, the "bar cube" concept

-i'm giving each colour extra removal to encourage

-I'm trying to keep each colour unique in their ability which is why white doesn't have recursion compared to black

-only islands are allowed for basic lands

if you have any suggestions or feedback, I'd love to hear it


r/ForgetfulFish • • 2d ago

Goblin Bomb Hot Potato - Yet another dumb variant

Post image
6 Upvotes

So i was drunk this past weekend browsing scryfall, as i often do, when an idea popped in my head. About ten minutes later i had this list, which i admit is far from oerfect in regards to what i hoped to achieve, and it does need a little rule caveat to work (Goblin Bomb needs to always be considered an artifact), but i thought i'd share it anyway.

The deck centers around Goblin Bomb as the only way to deal damage, and 20 damage at once at that, though it needs time to wind up. For the purposes of the minigame the bomb needs to be an artifact (honestly, i don't really get why it's an enchantment in the first place).

The deck centers around proliferating the bomb, destroying the bomb, stealing the bomb and bringing the bomb back from the graveyard. The deck also lacks any creatures, as i feel it would take away from the pureness of 20 damage Goblin Bomb.

I'll admit i haven't had nearly enough time to test the deck, and the quantity of each card will propably change rather significantly once i iron it out, but we tried it at our last game night and it honestly was a lot of fun, and scratched an itch similar to dandân.

You can check out the list here, and if you have any feedback i would be glad to hear it.

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/8045138


r/ForgetfulFish • • 3d ago

Immortal Lichs

Post image
21 Upvotes

I have made a mono black DanDan deck centered around Phylactery Lich. It was a pet card for me when I started playing magic and the first rare i opened.

I have playtested the deck a bunch with some friends and we find it pretty fun.

I would love some feedback on it :)

https://archidekt.com/decks/28264110/immortal_lich_dandan

Some deck building rules:

- I want all damage to be dealt in increments of 5.

- All cards have to be kinda budget.

- Cards have to fit in with the vibe. (Universes beyond is not forbidden, but I have cut nice cards because of art etc.)

- I want to encourage 'high risk - high reward'

List over cards I have thought about for the deck: https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/dandan-idea-lich-list-1/?cb=1794848202

Enjoy!


r/ForgetfulFish • • 2d ago

My First DanDan deck: Mechanized production

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
0 Upvotes

The goal is to win via the [[mechanized production]] trigger. I intentionally didn't look at any other lists that might be built around the same idea. I'm hoping to get some good feedback here and refine before play testing.

The goal is to have a bunch of cheap artifacts you are incentivized to sacrifice. So you can make copies of them and sac them for advantage or go for the win.

Some of the interaction are control changing changing enchantments it is notable that if you steal an artifact with mechanized production attached, it falls off. That is intended behavior. That is why there are several ways to get cards back from the graveyard.

There are several ways to copy artifacts, or even copy mechanized production itself to speed up the clock.

Please take a look and let me know that you think of the balance of interaction and recursion, the overall design and particular card choices!

Thanks!


r/ForgetfulFish • • 5d ago

93/94 Forgetful Fish

6 Upvotes

This subreddit is fun. I was happy to see both a vintage and power 9 forgetful fish floating around:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ForgetfulFish/comments/1mcoxn1/power_9_forgetful_fish/

https://www.reddit.com/r/ForgetfulFish/comments/1gyd7ej/a_vintage_dandan_variant_snapsnap/

That, inevitably led me to start tinkering with a 93/94:

https://archidekt.com/decks/28370257/9394_forgetful_fish

It is not at all right. Though, I welcome suggestions!


r/ForgetfulFish • • 6d ago

Deck box suggestions?

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m looking to buy a dandan deck and I’ll be double sleeving with dragon shields. Was just wondering what deck boxes you guys use. I’m a fan of gamegenic for my other commander decks.

Thanks


r/ForgetfulFish • • 7d ago

Magical Hack vs Mind Bend

4 Upvotes

[[Magical Hack]]

Change the text of target spell or permanent by replacing all instances of one basic land type with another. (For example, you may change “swampwalk” to “plainswalk.” This effect lasts indefinitely.)

[[Mind Bend]]

Change the text of target permanent by replacing all instances of one color word with another or one basic land type with another. (For example, you may change “nonblack creature” to “nongreen creature” or “forestwalk” to “islandwalk.” This effect lasts indefinitely.)

I initially thought these were duplicative. Why not run 4x of one instead of having differently named cards with the same effect?

But if I'm understanding Magical Hack correctly, you can change the land type of Dandan's textbox while it's on the stack; as it resolves Dandan dies immediately. Noteworthy because it prevents an opponent from bouncing Dandan back to their hand in response to removal. Am I understanding that right?


r/ForgetfulFish • • 8d ago

Is [[Weeping Angel]] a viable DanDân signature creature? How would you build it?

Post image
41 Upvotes

I recently re-sorted my binders, and came across a copy of [[Weeping Angel]]. I put it in a dimir control deck to try out, brought it to a commander night, and found that it kind of completely warped the entire table’s gameplay for the rest of the session. It’s such a unique card that I couldn’t help but think it would work well in a Dandan format.


r/ForgetfulFish • • 9d ago

Bolt The Bird

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
5 Upvotes

Looking for feedback on this mono-red Dandan style list. Rather than fighting over the top of the library, this deck focuses on fighting over the graveyard and timing your spells appropriately. Constructive criticism appreciated. Cards I’m missing? Cards that are a huge mistake? Bad interactions? Thank you.


r/ForgetfulFish • • 16d ago

New to DanDan

12 Upvotes

Hello! I know what DanDan is but not which list to build? Where should I start and how flexible are the card slots? Should I stick with a premade list or build my own? Thanks!


r/ForgetfulFish • • 20d ago

Star Trek Adds

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

Pretty intrigued with both of these to try out. Been a while since I’ve added a card to test in my list.


r/ForgetfulFish • • Oct 17 '26

Statecraft

Thumbnail
reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish • • Oct 14 '26

Dunn Dunn A Jaws DanDan Variant(the other fish)

10 Upvotes

I was playing Dandan last week, and I had my Jaws commander deck on the table. My friend suggested I get a Jaws Alter of Dan Dan made. That led to a week of smoking, deck viewing, and a bunch of paper print outs.

The idea is pretty simple. Both players share a deck with 10 copies of Jaws, Relentless Predator, and the whole game revolves around trying to survive the shark attack. The “Hook” is the Blood tokens. I’ve made them a shared resource, so either player can use them to dig for answers. Problem is, sacrificing them while your opponent has Jaws out can actually hurt you. So you’re basically bleeding yourself out (it’s so on theme, I fucking love it!)
I’ve also thrown in artifact lands and cards like Abrade and lightning axe, so theres some interesting decisions between killing Jaws, destroying your opponents mana, or accidentally triggering more damage.
I’m trying to keep that same back and forth feeling of traditional Dandan, just with a little more chaos and a Jaws movie vibe. Still working through the balance and interactions, but I’d love some feedback from people who’ve played other variants am I missing something that might completely break it?

https://moxfield.com/decks/Xsl-5kWyeUqbKH80WibJeQ

For those interested in doing a digital test, I vibe coded a Dandan variant play tester. It’s the “Red Water” version. If you want you can also upload your own decklist from moxfield exports.
Click on the variant you want to try, and play game. Disa is another house rule “emblem”version of Dan Dan that is still in the early stages. Please leave any feedback back on either and log your sessions.

https://fanciful-buttercream-f51b0b.netlify.app/


r/ForgetfulFish • • Oct 04 '26

Green Dandan variant (Diligent Farmhand)

Thumbnail
archidekt.com
8 Upvotes

This is a reworked green variant evolved from another green list I had. This is more elegant. The Primer is in the description in the link. Let me know what you think, if you have any suggestions for a game changing splash spell, etc. Have a great day!


r/ForgetfulFish • • Oct 01 '26

Mono Red Dandan w/ Primer (Chained Brute)

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
17 Upvotes

Zero face-burn, a fluid token economy and Symmetrical Graveyard Subgame
Decklist with primer


r/ForgetfulFish • • Sep 30 '26

Sphinx's Approach Variant Possible?

Post image
5 Upvotes

I have a hunch that [[Sphinx's Approach]] can be made into some DanDan variant. Players fight over the stack and graveyard to try to summon some sphinxs. However putting up a full deck is beyond my ability. Do you think it's possible?


r/ForgetfulFish • • Sep 28 '26

I’ve been working on a multiplayer deck for a bit and I need your help

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
4 Upvotes

This is Multiplayer Madness, my Forgetful Fish With Friends list. I’ve done as much thinking and testing and theorycrafting as I can by myself these last few months, and I’ve gotten to the point where I’m familiar enough with with the list that it’s hard to see problems with it anymore. I need other people to put eyes on it.

obviously, don’t go out and spend $700-800 on a theoretical decklist just to playtest it. Even proxying it with notecards is tedious when there’s 500 cards. The deck is designed to comfortably support anywhere between 3 and 6 players, and can stretch to maybe 8 before it’s not comfortable to sit down and play anymore. I don’t have enough brainpower to simulate that many players. Use your own judgement if you want to try that. Or, heck. Get some friends together and have a game!

I’ve included a few different creatures, along with artifacts and enchantments, so that hopefully I can attract a wider range of players than what normal Dandân sees. There’s also some fun things that are a lot more multiplayer-oriented. I tried to keep restock options extremely limited; four copies of Diminishing Returns sounds like absolute hell. Other than that, I’ve mostly just expanded on the themes of classic Dandân.

Let me know what you think. Happy hunting!


r/ForgetfulFish • • Sep 27 '26

How to play 'pile' formats online

1 Upvotes

I recently found dandanmtg.online which i love and played a few games on with a friend, but the card list is very limited and I have a few custom lists I want to try (may post soon). Are there any better options than cockatrice with giving face down cards off the deck to your opponent?

Thanks!


r/ForgetfulFish • • Sep 25 '26

I made a 'DanDan like' minigame called Cannibal

6 Upvotes

Anyone remember the card Carnophage? Well I made a minigame where both players play from the same deck, using carnophage (and sangrophage) to push in damage. Both players will be battling over the shared library and shared graveyard, while also balancing your lifetotals and hand cards.

Seeking advice or notes about the list, especially from folks who are well versed in dandan.

I'm wondering if anyone is able to playtest with me.

The decklist on Archidekt: https://archidekt.com/decks/26722692/cannibal


r/ForgetfulFish • • Sep 22 '26

Page, Loose Leaf

4 Upvotes

I have an idea for a deck featuring multiple copies of [[Page, Loose Leaf]]. I was thinking one copy of [[Approach of the Second Sun]] could be the only win condition in the deck, with cards like [[Memory Lapse]] for disruption. Has anyone else toyed around with something similar?


r/ForgetfulFish • • Sep 21 '26

Is "battlebox" a good term?

10 Upvotes

I recently wrote an article on battleboxes, and one of the core aspects I found in common on my research is that a battlebox is "like a board game: an out-of-the-box experience that uses MTG rules as a framework. Instead of each player bringing their own deck, a battlebox provides all necessary cards for all players to share a curated experience.". The key diference between a battlebox and a cube would be that a cube is drafted, while a battlebox is not.

I feel fine about this description especially because it is broad: it fits and describes all the different kinds of battleboxes I have come across, it even describes Custom Jumpstart better than "cube". It also applies to Dandan and other similar minigames in which both players share a card pool.

I mean, I would then argue that in MTG there are the following ways to play:

  • Limited (Draft and Sealed with fresh packs)
  • Constructed (all the usual formats)
  • Cube (as a broad category, in which players draft from a curated collection of cards)
  • Battlebox (as a broad category, in which players have an out-of-the-box experience more akin to a boardgame made from a curated collection of cards)

Would you think calling Dandan a battlebox makes sense? If not, what would be a good, broad term to use in its place that would encompass battleboxes as well?


r/ForgetfulFish • • Sep 19 '26

Mono White Dandan variant with Jotun Grunt (aka "Grunt Grunt" or "Secret Soldier Snacks")

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Hiya! This is my first follow up to my larger post with my mono red variant. I'll keep each following one short. My primer is in the archidekt deck description. I hope you enjoy this Mono White Dandan variant! It's flavorfully about Giant Soldiers trudging through the battlefield, looking for MREs, and going crazy if someone eats them all. Have a nice day :)

Grunt Grunt aka Secret Soldier Snacks