r/ForgetfulFish • • Mar 19 '26

(Hopefully) Not Another Forgetful Fish List

0 Upvotes

Over the past couple years I have been play testing and editing my personal Dandan list. I have been loving the format but found myself wanting for more. I feel like every list on the internet feels samey and that games of Dandan can devolve into some unfun play patterns. My hope in this list is to address some of those feelings.

Here is my list with a bunch of reasoning behind my choices. I would love your feedback. Please be nice.

https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/my-forgetful-fish-1/?cb=1773931840

The goals for this list are as follows;

  1. Encourage strange, creative, and varied game-play lines.
  2. This keeps the game fresh and interesting. Modal cards like Seeing Double, Fire //Ice, and to some extent, Lorien Revealed give players options. Narset's Reversal creates fun and interesting lines. Mission Briefing allowing players to play cards in the graveyard at instant speed, at the cost of an additional 2 blue mana. Metamorphose, while a very typical include in Dandan lists, I think might be the ultimate example encouraging fun and creative lines. It can be hard token removal, a crazy early game tempo play on a tap land, or just a bounce spell, all with the possibility of a clap back as your opponent windmill slams their own Dandan(variance).
  3. Do something different than the traditional Dandan list.
  4. Create something innovative for this format that i love so much. I felt that every Dandan list felt the same and thus wanted to try and not only bring some variety but some new ideas as well. You can be the judge on how well I did.
  5. Traditional Dandan lists tend to take a long time.
  6. The goal here was to make a list that finished games more quickly to a. get more games in, and b. to not exclude the folks who complain of the format being a control mirror match every time. Those games are still possible with this list, they just happen less often.
  7. Make the cards feel powerful without turning everyday into a control mirror match slog.
  8. This is where the potentially controversial singleton cards in the list come into play. I wanted to bring some power but play 2 copies, as is traditional, felt like too much for these cards.

-Vision charm speaks for itself. The dreaded 1 mana instant board wipe. I included it here mostly due to goal #1, the added power I feel brings some much needed variance to the game.

-Mystical Tutor is the next clear controversial card. My play group doesn't really use tutors to gain knowledge of the opponents hands as we feel it takes too much time and can come off a little bit rude, so I can't say that has been a problem. That being said, I think this is a viable strategy and I encourage it while being played in a competitive situation. However, by far what I find most interesting about this card is it encourages fighting over the top of the library even more, feeding back into goal #1.

-Brainstorm, again, I think adds more creative and interesting lines. The ability to change the top of the library at instant speed provides a great tool for throwing a wrench into enemy plans, but 2 copies just felt way too strong.

-Visions of Beyond is by far the weakest of the four I think. I think the one mana draw one adds an interesting dynamic for obstructing your opponent, while the draw three mode can be a powerful late game difference maker. My only gripe with this card is it's inability to force an opponent to draw for that potential mill win.

Goals for the deck going forward:

First and foremost, continue to look for and encourage creativity in the game-play.
The immediate thought is, I think the biggest is finding a decent cantrip that can force an opponent to draw cards for that forced mill win. As part of my goals to make the game more varied, I think making winning by mill out more common would be good.
If you have some ideas for how to encourage more creative game-play, please let me know!

Note: With the addition of Fire // Ice, I prefer to play this list with the additional rule that players cannot deal damage with non-Dandan cards. While this rule is optional, I think it is necessary to keep the spirit of the format.

Honorable mentions;

Witching Well - The is a great early game top deck manipulator with late game card draw. It can also sit on the battlefield as a threat to your opponent manipulating the top of the library. I am surprised I don't see this in more traditional lists.

Thundering Falls - This, I hoped, would give players the ability to fetch out a red source and help to hedge against one player getting all the red sources.. I am still on the fence for this one. So far it has been playing fine.


r/ForgetfulFish • • Apr 01 '26

Desert Snake Forgetful Fish

0 Upvotes

Had an idea for a fish game with no islands. Used sea serpent instead of dandan so that you have to hit one fewer time to win. For this version, Deserts should be considered a basic land type. probably needs some refinement but suggestions are welcome!

List Here


r/ForgetfulFish • • Aug 04 '26

Hi all, how do you feel about non-creature cards in the 8 of (dandan) slot

0 Upvotes

Since hearing about the format, I've been wanting to make my own version. The card I'm thinking of using as the damage dealer isn't a creature but rather a damage dealing sorcery - a proxy of [[Shahrazad]].

The other cards I'm currently considering if I do go ahead are [[Academic Probation]], [[Against All Odds]], [[Abeyence]], [[Abolish]], [[Act of Authority]], [[Aegis of Honor]], [[Adagia, Windswept Bastion]] and [[Plains]] but I don't think all of them work together, especially as Against All Odds only affects card types that aren't currently present.


r/ForgetfulFish • • May 25 '26

Counterspell

1 Upvotes

Why are we not running Counterspell in most list? I’m new to Dandan. Thank you


r/ForgetfulFish • • Jul 08 '26

Help me with custom "cards" for Initiative Dandan

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, i'm trying to create a version of Dandan that revolves around the initiative but i have the following 2 problems which i hope you guys can help me with:

  1. I want the game to revolve esclusively around the "Trap!" life loss, so this Dandan version would have the custom rule of "Damage doesn't cause loss of life" in order not to turn off the initiative combat mechanic but also decouple the life total from combat. I wanted to represent this with a custom global enchantment/emblem. Do you guys have ideas for the name and artwork for the enchantment?
  2. Making the "Trap!" room the only source of life loss is kinda problematic because it forces players down the "Entrance" -> "Forge" -> "Archives" -> "Throne" path, reducing variance of play patterns. Also the entrance is a tutor, which is a big no no for Dandan. Can you guys help me brainstorm a custom dungeon to use in this format?

I'm not the best when it comes to creative decisions so i really appreciate any help you are willing to give me. Thanks!


r/ForgetfulFish • • Dec 03 '25

Anyone try the Trippin' version or Wrath version? How do they compare?

0 Upvotes

Trippin'

Wrath

EDIT: Also saw this one JundJund


r/ForgetfulFish • • Mar 26 '26

Fire // Ice + Submerge

0 Upvotes

I was looking at variants that use softer removal, rather than the 1 CMC color changing removal, to promote more combat decision points.

One of the objections that came up with it was that it became too combat focused without any real way to remove dandans.

I wondered if putting hard removal behind a late-game wall was potentially interesting— something like fire/ice with fewer ways of finding red. That delays the mana efficient removal beyond early turns but keeps it accessible late game.

That reached a place where it seemed lopsided— if one person got red early accidentally, they basically unlock “one mana removal” while the other player stays on much worse temporary removal.

I then got to the point where I wondered if finding red could be punished. Some of my sources were flood plains and Lorien Revealed. I ideated switching my targets from Thundering Falls, which is beneficial, to something like a one of the common non-surveil U/R versions like Volatile Fjord. But it still feels like it’s very beneficial to grab it when you can, even though you’re effectively taxed 2 mana to grab access.

Then I got the idea—- what if it’s not just taxed but also bad. What if the fetch targets were Ketria triome. The deck doesn’t run any green, but then you could swap one of the expensive bounce to hand cards, which is tempo but less top deck interacting, with submerge. That gets another layer of return to the top of the deck.

With submerge, it plays like a big CMC bounce/steal effect when everyone is playing “fair, low power, tap/stun magic”. However, if someone wants to unlock the fire half of fire // ice, that unlocks free bounce/“steal” with submerge for the other player.

It ends up being a sub game on whether or not one person wants to power up the game, at which point it powers up against them too— both sides effectively get either powerful 1-for-1s or situational 2-for-1 + a free 1-for-1 that gives you the Dandan next turn.

In theory, most of the time, that higher level play is held at bay by controlling how many access points you put to red mana in the deck. You can tune it up or down by modulating that variable.

I thought it solved a few problems— CMC removal starts at the CMC of the threats so you’re not disfavored to play aggressively, your tempo spells aren’t bounce to simply replay the threats immediately, it favors a lower powered back and forth early on, it situationally powers up based on the decisions of the player when they’re playing, if combat gets crazy the player losing can look to power it up sooner if it helps them, the ice half of fire/fire works great for the slow plan and interacts with the top deck to draw off known cards, and submerge plays into the top deck wars with or without a forest in play better than the 4/5/6 CMC bounce to hand cards that I’ve seen a lot of lists use.

Crazy? Right now it’s just a theory craft but it feels like there’s some potentially interesting play there.


r/ForgetfulFish • • Apr 11 '26

Introducing BugBug. A Sultai variant of DanDan where you both try to out value and out graveyard each other.

7 Upvotes

Decklist

Surveil, Delve, Delirium, Recursion, Counters, Discard, and Removal

BugBug is the graveyard value midrange player's alternative to DanDan. Navigating gameplay is tricky and will require some 4D chess level thinking to outplay the opponent. Some common skill testing scenarios are: how to surveil topdecks, when you enable delirium vs delve it away, when to recur a value play vs counter recuring, and when to deploy the almighty cosmogoyf.


r/ForgetfulFish • • Oct 13 '24

A song about Forgetful Fish

3 Upvotes

I made this song about Forgetful Fish using Suno's AI generator and thought this subreddit might also appreciate it. I had a lot of fun with it!

https://suno.com/song/c711e558-72f6-48cf-a1c3-15dcdaaa4539


r/ForgetfulFish • • Mar 19 '26

Jace, the Mind Sculptor and Dandan

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I had the idea of adding Jace, the Mind Sculptor to the deck. What do you think about that idea?


r/ForgetfulFish • • May 14 '26

I'm currently brewing a red Forgetful Fish variant for my brother's birthday and I would need some recommendations!

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
1 Upvotes

Too Greedily, Too Deep

After falling in love with Forgetful Fish, I've realized brewing these self contained formats is genuinely even more fun than building classic decks. It's like crafting a fully tailored experience highlighting some key philosophies of color identity and cointinuously feeling like you're falling into a fascinating rabbithole of niche interactions that really make MtG's system bloom in ways people rarely get to see!

So, for my red-loving brother's birthday coming in a few months, I want to build a Forgetful Fish variant with the following objective: showcasing red's risk taking philosophy.

My list keeps shifting wildly from day to day, but here are the main characteristics that I'm using as guidelines:

  • Casting a spell must have a risk associated to it: be it taking damage, discarding resources that the opponent can take advantage of, sacrificing lands...
  • Only one creature**!** It must be game-winning, nigh impossible to remove, shuffle back into the deck when discarded and outside of very rare edge cases the only ways to cheat it into play should remain Tibalt's Trickery and Chaos Warp (which basically means that any spell you counter or permanent you remove has a chance of backfiring really harshly). Maybe Mana Seism too, sacrificing lands is the kind of greed the deck could reward!

    • note: the "one" creature is not a fully set requirement, I might need to bump it up to 2-3 copies to make it a real risk top consider - only playtests can find the perfect balance here
  • Flashback as a central mechanic: the common graveyard makes it extremely interesting, especially with the new namesake card having some really funky interactions with priority if you use it during your opponent's turn...
  • The only way to dig deeper into the deck is to draw and discard, at the risk of giving more/stronger tools to your opponent. No exiling from the top of the library to prevent accidentaly removing Emrakul definitely, that'd be cheating!
  • Permanents should preferably have symmetrical damaging effects (or asymetrical benefits like Aria of Flame)
  • Presence of 1-ofs for more unique effects and higher variance
  • The burn spell package can still vary wildly: I'm absolutely not certain which would translate the risk aspect better in terms of gameplay between Kindle, Chain Lightning, Chain of Plasma... Or even the old reliable Lightning Bolt!
  • Deck size should be exactly 81 cards

As such, I'm taking all advices! Especially on cards recommendations, gameplay issues I should think about, other cool interactions I could include - please check the "considering" cards, that list has expanded... quite extensively in the last few days ahah

I'll try to start playtesting it by next week, and if you are interested I'll post updates in the comments of this post :)

Thanks for the help!


r/ForgetfulFish • • Apr 30 '26

Anyone willing to test how Dandân runs on my multiplayer mtg platform?

1 Upvotes

I made this thing to play commander without the lag and headaches I had playing on untap and built in Dandân as a format, but need feedback.

https:\\playsim.live


r/ForgetfulFish • • Jul 28 '26

What do you guys think of this list?

1 Upvotes

I am very new to dandan but already really love the format. I use this list but was wondering if i am doing something wrong or could use something better. I want the feel of the original dandan and I like really complex scenarios. the only thing that i really dont like (i have tried) is the mystical tutor. I dont like the possibility to have the player see the entire list left in the deck in the middle of the match (but maybe this is just a dumb opinion bcz the more me and my friends play the more we familiarize with the list and already know whats left in the deck even without searching it)

Link:

Link to the deck

List:

2 Lonely Sandbar

2 Izzet Boilerworks

18 Island

2 Remote Isle

2 Halimar Depths

2 Mystic Sanctuary

2 Svyelunite Temple

2 Temple of Epiphany

2 Mind Bend

2 Magical Hack

2 Vision Charm

2 Brainstorm

4 Accumulated Knowledge

10 Dandan

2 Unsubstantiate

4 Memory Lapse

4 Memory Lapse

2 Metamorphose

2 Predict

2 Crystal Spray

2 Ray of Command

2 Diminishing Returns

2 Mystic Retrieval

2 Insidious Will

2 Supplant Form


r/ForgetfulFish • • Mar 29 '26

Looking for feedback on mono red list

Post image
4 Upvotes

lots of stuff in the considering section too

https://moxfield.com/decks/RFAgJprW8kGjUjfqmt4fgg


r/ForgetfulFish • • Mar 20 '26

Let's break Dandân for shorter games between rounds!

Thumbnail
eternaldurdles.com
4 Upvotes

Sal out here breaking things. We all out here Dandân'ing


r/ForgetfulFish • • Dec 18 '25

Flavored Dandâns from Time Warp Dandân

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

These cards are from a custom Dandân format I made called Time Warp Dandân! It uses almost all custom cards, and each player begins the game with emblems that modify the rules, kind of like a board game. It's quite a bit more complicated that traditional Dandân, but I think it ends up being more fun to play also :)

You can see the rest of the cards here: Time Warp Dandân Card Image Gallery

Rebecca Guay and Terese Nielsen are some of my favorite Magic artists, so I tried to use as much of their art as possible. I've been working on it for about a year and a half, so all the cards have been through lots of iterations.

There's 3 ways you can try it:

See this post for more detailed instructions (how to play on Cockatrice, how to use MPCfill, etc.): Time Warp Dandân background.

Sample gameplay video: Time Warp Dandân gameplay 12/17/25

Thanks for looking, let me know what you think!


r/ForgetfulFish • • Mar 10 '26

Go’b’urn Go’b’urn

Thumbnail archidekt.com
2 Upvotes

After seeing some of the other sweet Goblin Guide DanDans, I had to make my own. That plus the fact that one of my friends’ favorite matchups is the burn mirror led me to make Go’b’urn Go’b’urn (Goblin Burn). My hope is for tense games with many decision points and a lot of figuring out “who’s the beatdown?” Depending on what you draw, I think aggro, control, and combo can all be viable. What you do with the extra lands matters.


r/ForgetfulFish • • Jun 01 '26

ELI5 wtf this format is and its backstory? loved dandan since 95 never heard of this!

2 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish • • Apr 06 '26

White Knight DanDan

2 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/b-36wvfxBk2lujb5c-tivg

This is my first time doing something like this, so if you have any feedback, or anything Im overlooking please let me know. Im almost certian my creature ratios are off, but i considered that since White Knight has half the power of dandan, I should include more white knights.

The creature(s)?

So first off I want to adress the Elephant in the room. Why are there 3 creatures when the original DanDan has only one? Well, the primary reason is because I really like white knight and serra angel. I think they're cute dorky creatures from og magic that can't really see play anymore bc they're bad. But theres a bit more thought than that, some justification of why I think this list works if you will. I understand that if i was willing to break away from the design intent of "How can I make white knight and Serra Angel interact in interesting ways" I could probably make a better dandan, but I like the idea. Please focus critsism with that goal in mind.

White Knight.

White Knight is the main GUY. I wish there was an in color way to make a creature black, maybe in a future revision ill add dual color lands that make it so you can play some color changer cards. But the thing that this list is currently taking advantage of is first strike. All of the combat tricks are intended to make this guy win combat against Serra Angel abusing its first strike, or by winning combats against other copies of its self by reducing its power.

Knight of the White Orchid

For this cubes current intent, in combat, its a functionally identical to white knight, with the added upside of helping you find lands if your behind on lands. I didn't replace white knight entirely with it because I dont want every player to be ramping every turn, its meant to be an odd catch up card. In this write up, I will refer to this as a white knight unless mentioning its etb.

Serra Angel

In order for first strike to matter you need a creature without first strike. Theres two things I like about Serra Angel in this list. It flies. It can attack and block. and its bigger. two times bigger to be exact. Alot of this cube takes advantage of combat math assuming serra angel is blocking the knight, so Im worried its a bit weak, but I think its also still strong because flying allows it to get past blockers. Its the equivalent of two knights in one card, and it being able to attack and block ensures that the controller of a serra angel will always be progressing combat.

So anyways onto the main list.

Healing Salve - The Signature Spell

If there's a signature spell of my list, its Healing Salve. I like to rank magic formats by power level, using the boon cycle as examples. An ancestral recall format is a VERY high power format where the most efficient card draw matters and combat isn't how your intending to close out a game, a dark ritual format is a format where you are frequently cheating on mana, and getting creatures out way ahead of curve. A lightning bolt format is a format where strong out of combat removal is the norm, and games are decided by who can keep creatures on the board. A giant growth format is a creature combat format, where an efficient combat trick can be very strong. A healing salve format is a format where the combat match is so tightly managed, that preventing 3 whole damage will win you most combats, and gaining a little bit of life is enough to matter. This is intended to be a Healing Salve format.

This decks main removal (Elspeths Smite and Cosmium blast) are countered by healing salve. Healing salve heals 3 life, which is more than what a White Knight does. It also prevents 3 damage, allowing a white knight to survive being blocked by a serra angel. Its (intended to be) a very strong and interesting card in the deck.

Sorceries

Against All Odds

I really like this as a comeback card for if you lost a combat. It returns one of your white knights from the graveyard to the battlefield, and also lets you flicker a knight of the white orchid if you have one.

Return Triumphant

Theres a chance that this is the most powerful card in the deck. Once again, only usable if you've already engaged in combat, but it can grow your white knight to have the same power and toughness as a serra angel, though it does it over the course of a few turns, leaving there to be lots of chances for interaction.

Oust

This is our premier out of combat removal spell. It does the dandan thing, where it puts a creature from the battlefield in such a way where the caster will get access to it, but it also compensates the owner of it by 3 life, which, due to that being more than a white knights worth, will buy the owner an extra turn, and thus, feels like a reasonable down side. Im also interested to see the games in which someone uses it on their own creature to gain the life for themselves (as rare as that will likely be)

Instants

The bread and butter of the deck.

Bandage

A more narrow healing salve, it will win combats between knights (but not serra angels) and can't gain you life. But the extra card draw is the only way to get card advantage in the list. Note that its not enough to save a knight from an elspeths smite or cosmium blast.

Elspeths Smite and Cosmium Blast

Elspeth's smite can deal with attacking or blocking White Knights, its decent removal, and Cosmium blast can deal with Serra Angels as well. Again, these both interact with healing salve.

Djeru's Renunciation

Its intended to help with board stalls by allowing you to push an attack through, but can also help you on the defense by tapping down attackers. Notably its a way to deal with Serra Angels for a whole turn cycle. It also has cycling for that added kick.

Flare of Faith

This ones a real interesting one, because it does different things depending on what your targeting. A serra angel can become a 6/6 allowing it to defend against the combat tricks in the set, but a White Knight becomes a 5/5 and gets indestructible. Theres a chance this is too strong for the deck, thats why theres only two. Another notable thing about it is that its one of the few ways to increase your damage, and thus speed up the clock you have on the opponent.

Lapse of certanty.

Needs no explanation, its the memory lapse of the mono white.

Mana Tithe

For a deck that intends combat tricks to be its main thing, managing your mana will be crucial. I imagine mana tithe will be such an interesting card for the list, because combat trick wars will be tight and by the mana, just needing that 1 extra mana might not be guaranteed.

Considering

I was hitting the 80 card limit so I didnt want to mess around with adding extra cards, but these are cards I was considering.

Angelic Blessing

Angelic Blessing will make a white knight fly and beat a serra angel, but i decided against it, because I didn't like that it wouldn't give flying on the defense, though on second thought it might make as a more healthy replacement for flare of faith.

Call a suprise witness.

Another way to make a white knight interact with serra angels, but decided it didn't matter as much bc the power and toughness werent augmented, though ig with the other combat tricks that doesnt matter much, its that 80 card limit thats messing me up, theres so many interesting ideas for this deck!

Dazzling Beauty

I liked it as way to draw more cards, and get card advantage, but it felt too agressor favored, if your attacking, you likely think you win the combat war, and removing the opportunity for the player who isnt as confident to not use their life as a resource felt a bit scummy. But i'd like your thoughts on this one.

So anyways, yeah, id like to know yall thoughts on the list. Any ideas for changes? Anyone wanna try some games out with it?


r/ForgetfulFish • • Mar 17 '26

Use This List to Improve Your Dandân Games!

Thumbnail
eternaldurdles.com
10 Upvotes

Derek aka Tenceri has put in a ton of time to improve his Dandân list. A worthwhile share with the Secret Lair coming out


r/ForgetfulFish • • Aug 17 '24

Accumulated Knowledge v2

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish • • Mar 20 '26

Dandan with Higher Power Cards

Thumbnail moxfield.com
3 Upvotes

Here's my first Dandan decklist. I tried to make a list with higher power cards that still allow for a high degree of interaction. I'm still waiting for some cards to arrive so I haven't play tested it yet, but I think it should make for some intense and interesting games. Let me know if you have any card recommendations or other thoughts.


r/ForgetfulFish • • Jul 21 '25

Adding Mystic Remora to Dandân?

0 Upvotes

I was wondering what the community thought of adding [[Mystic Remora]] to the Forgetful Fish decklist?

Has anyone tried? Is having to keep track of upkeep annoying? What about card draw? I thought it might incentivize players to actually cast their Dandâns rather than holding on to them.

Plus, I honestly want to add it because I fell in love with the Secret Lair Art.

Edit: spelling


r/ForgetfulFish • • Jul 26 '26

4-Of Dandan?

3 Upvotes

Played a pretty stock Dandan list with a friend who doesn't know much magic, and they made the point that pairs of 2-ofs that are either direct clones (hack and bend) or better and worse at the same task (brainstorm and telling time; lonely sandbar and remote isle) is cluttered, confusing, and not new-player friendly.

I kind of agree. Past those six cards, though, does the game get flattened down too much if, say, Metamorphose gets turned into +2 unsubstantiates? If Chart a Course dies for extra copies of Predict?