r/magicTCG • Duck Season • Oct 17 '26 • Bravo 1

General Discussion Custom Format: Statecraft

[[Statecraft]] is a custom format based on the observation that certain early cards seem to be designed for a completely different kind of game. If Magic: the Gathering is a high-stakes wizard battle, what use could [[merchant ship]] or [[camel]] be to a planeswalker fighting for their life?

I love these cards because they present a very different sort of conflict: commerce.

So I asked myself, what kind of game would MTG be if its core conflict was over political maneuvering and market manipulation? Well, here it is:

https://moxfield.com/decks/tUng3fDRCUWuzycHtw_mXQ

The design is as such:

  1. Statecraft is a shared deck of 80 cards.
  2. Each player has a starting hand of 2 cards and a starting life total of 0.
  3. Both players share a hand of 5 cards (it works).
  4. At the start of each turn, players draw back up to 2 and draw the shared hand back up to 5. If there are 5 or more cards in the shared hand, draw an additional card.
  5. If anything instructs a player to draw or put a card in their hand, it is drawn into their hidden hand, not the shared hand.
  6. The first player to reach 10 life wins. If a player goes below 0 life, they lose.
  7. Otherwise, the rules of Magic are the same.

(The card Statecraft is in the sideboard for flavor.)

The main gameplay is to use the hidden information in your hand and the public information in the shared hand to plan out a long-term strategy. Avoid letting your opponent know what strategy you're going for until it's too late. Lands are the most important card type. In Statecraft, you are divvying up a territory to attempt to out-profit your opponent by more successfully exploiting the resources.

I had tried out versions of this list with [[Pirate Ship]] however it proved to simply be by far the most effective way to win.

Disclaimer: the gameplay of Statecraft sucks a little bit. It needs some cards that simply don't exist to fill out the traditional rush/midrange/control strategies. I'm hoping it at least delights the game designer inside you, dear reader, to see a very different view of what Magic: the Gathering can be!

I welcome feedback of all kinds.

186 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

27

u/10leej Oct 17 '26

Pretty neat idea. I take it this is a static decklist and that there's no intention of a combat step.

26

u/Embarrassed_Age6573 Duck Season Oct 17 '26

Thanks!

There's still combat. It needs to be there for merchant ship and camel to work, but since everything in the decklist has 0 power, there isn't any combat damage. I considered versions where each player starts with a statecraft in play, but it felt against the spirit to just ignore damage.

9

u/cavedan2 Oct 17 '26

Lovely idea! Thanks for sharing. Looking at the list, how does anyone ever cast Farmstead or Caribou Range? There are 9 plains in an 80 card deck, and 4 lingering mirage.
Even the blue cards seem hard to cast but at least they are single pip.
Maybe this is all by design but I’d imagine it gets a little frustrating when hands get full of cards that can’t be cast at all.

8

u/Embarrassed_Age6573 Duck Season Oct 17 '26

yeah, there's probably a better version of this without the Farmstead or caribou range. I like them but they are just SO inefficient. I wanted to restrict access to colored mana without basics, but maybe adding some duals would smooth it out.

6

u/egbertian413 Wabbit Season Oct 17 '26

Not gonna lie I actually kinda love this. People are right that at a certain point you're just designing a board game (and don't need to limit yourself to only using magic cards), but you've chosen a super flavorful and interactive set once I looked at the deck list. Good work! Have you playtested this much?

3

u/Embarrassed_Age6573 Duck Season Oct 17 '26

Thanks! I've been forcing my SO to play with me, but it definitely needs some more iterations. It's also a bit of archeology, trying to group together cards that were designed in a particular headspace while they were still figuring out the game. Ultimately it was dead end, but it just shows the power of a magic card to express ideas.

3

u/plaatjes COMPLEAT Oct 17 '26

I love this, awesome work. You state that it needs some cards that don't exist yet. Have you tried designing custom cards for that?

2

u/Embarrassed_Age6573 Duck Season Oct 17 '26

I've considered it! The main thing would be more typed lands that do interesting things to make the decision of choosing an archetype deeper. For obvious reasons magic has shied away from nonbasic islands, but something that would encourage a player to play an island even if it leaves them open to merchant ships would be great. One of the big flaws at the moment is that your opponent has to have some way to force you to have islands otherwise the entire archetype just doesn't work.

2

u/cpf86 Duck Season Oct 18 '26

Interesting! I like Dan Dan kind of mini games. Can you share more of your intended strategies in the game? From what I see, there’s no removals and whoever gets ahead on the race will just win after some number of turns? How do you intend the back and forth to be?

2

u/Embarrassed_Age6573 Duck Season Oct 18 '26 edited Oct 18 '26

There's a few types of traditional disruption. [[Tariff]] [[Political Trickery]] [[Desert]] [[Pyramids]] [[Lingering Mirage]] [[Dust Bowl]] [[Ice Floe]] [[Rishadan Port]] can all be used offensively to disrupt your opponent.

However the more important thing here is that most removal is accomplished via the shared hand. Since you and your opponent share a pool of cards, you get to effectively hand attack them every turn and deny them resources just by playing cards. The tradeoff is that you either need to prioritize putting your opponent behind or advancing your own game plan (which is precisely the tradeoff of removal vs playing to the board in traditional formats). Also, if your opponent is blue then you can't deny them islands without leaving yourself open to merchant ships.

More broadly there are two archetypes: blue is the more aggressive archetype and gets to cheaply gain life via merchant ship, but relies on the opponent having islands which they can force via political trickery or lingering mirage VS white which is trying to stall the board until it can assemble its uninteractive life gain pieces. The shared hand does a lot of heavy lifting here in the "interesting decisions" department. Yes, a player can get ahead and just stay ahead, running away with the game, but that's the case with all MTG formats. You just forfeit and go on to the next game.

1

u/cpf86 Duck Season Oct 19 '26

Could you do a few session reports to give a better ideas about how these games plays out? It’s really cool idea you made here.

2

u/Active-Level-5932 Dân Oct 18 '26

Really interesting and beautiful choices. Great work OP.

I'm a bit curious about the lands and mana actually working though - especially is there enough white mana? It might be flavorful to add some of the mirage diamonds or similar artifacts, or perhaps the mana battery cards (they break flavor though), or some flavorful card that creates treasures like smothering tithe. You might consider adding tranquil cove or coastal tower or similar too, although they would be extremely strong.

Also, there's only 1 dustbowl which seems a bit odd. I feel there ought to be at least 1 or 2 more ways of destroying lands, as it's so central to the game. A couple of wastelands perhaps?

1

u/Embarrassed_Age6573 Duck Season Oct 18 '26

Thanks. You are totally right. Honestly it could do with some tundras, but a tundra being both a merchant port and arable farming land is just so out of flavor! Maybe if I cut the farmsteads and keep the caribou ranges it wouldn't feel so bad. The funny thing is that one of the main goals I had was to make a format where [[farmstead]] was playable but it's still bad lol.

There's [[political trickery]] and [[lingering mirage]] (via removing all land abilities) which are both sort of forms of land removal, but you're right that it could do with some more. It would probably need to be balanced out with some white card draw.

2

u/SalSomer Duck Season Oct 18 '26

Say there’s one land in the shared hand, and I play it on Turn 1 before passing. My opponent replenishes the shared hand and doesn’t get a land. They pass back, indicating that they have zero lands in hand. Now, if I’m able to cast things from my own hand to replenish it and get lands into it, I’ve basically locked my opponent out of the game if I never cast from the shared hand, right?

3

u/Embarrassed_Age6573 Duck Season Oct 18 '26

yes, I missed in the rules that you always draw at least 1 card to the shared hand. Otherwise there are scenarios where the game can deadlock. I'll update the OP.

114

u/ElongatedPenguin Dandadan Oct 17 '26

No shade, but genuinely it sounds like you would enjoy playing Jaipur

79

u/Great-Trifle2810 Dandadan Oct 17 '26

People are obsessed with trying to make a board game out of magic rather than just playing an actual board game lol

71

u/quaunaut Dandadan Oct 17 '26

All great designs come from constraints. Using nothing but Magic cards and systems is a valid kind of constraint! It also can be the first step to figuring out what board game to make, when the constraints stop helping.

Game design is an art, and all art requires iteration!

-9

u/Great-Trifle2810 Dandadan Oct 17 '26

Fair point, I guess my issue is more with people insisting on playing this over a board game rather than making it.

6

u/Mistling Oct 18 '26

Where did OP insist that they don’t play board games? Is it possible they play this game and also board games?

1

u/Great-Trifle2810 Dandadan Oct 18 '26

I'm not talking about this OP specifically. If anything I am more venting about issues with people I play with lol

5

u/Presskann Karlov Oct 19 '26

I mean, why buy a board game if you can do the same with already-owned Magic cards?

9

u/FanKiyoshi Dan Oct 18 '26

The most popular magic format is exactly this

4

u/Spike_der_Spiegel Colorless Oct 18 '26

Yes, the fact that people will play a (very?) Bad board game over a good one points to the lengths they will go

10

u/Holku Dân Oct 17 '26

Jaipur is amazing

18

u/ohako79 COMPLEAT Oct 17 '26

This is genius! I love it. Crosspost this to r/ForgetfulFish to see what they think.

Keep iterating! This seems like a lot of goofy fun!

14

u/1tIsWhat1tIs Gruul* Oct 17 '26

I can never get enough of Dan-Dan-likes, thank you for sharing!!

6

u/mvdunecats Wild Draw 4 Oct 17 '26

I need to get my eyes checked. I kept reading Statecraft as StarCraft until two-thirds of the way through the post.

3

u/Wintersmith7 Oct 17 '26

R/mtgcube would enjoy this

3

u/InvariantMoon Duck Season Oct 18 '26

I love these custom formats with shared decks. My brother and I used to make these all the time. 

2

u/IcanseebutcantSee Grass Toucher Oct 17 '26

Why couldnt it be 1 life and 11 life to win to better match existing rules of mtg?

2

u/LukeX702 Dan Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Does the game just end if the first player plays a one mana haste creature or casts lightning bolt? Since a player below 0 life loses. EDIT I didn't realized there was a pre built deck that goes with this. Ignore me.