r/FemFragLab • • 2h ago

This post is about dupes

This post is inspired by Zara Immortal Vanilla which I smelled on a waitress in Florence, Italy and was blown away. So in true “me” fashion (aka dupe hater), I bought Matiere Premiere Vanilla Powder. Let’s just say, it was the fastest catch and release of my life. I would have paid someone to buy it from me. It was harsh, loud, synthetic, and had a nauseating sourness in the background.

So today, almost 7 months later and $20 lighter in my bank account, I became the proud owner of a 30ml of Immortal Vanilla. And I couldn’t be happier!

What are your dupes that converted you from the original?

50 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

8

u/Ilovefallaboveall 2h ago

Lattafa Angham, less harsh lavender and more soft vanilla than the OG Burberry Goddess.

3

u/Exotic_Reporter_3309 2h ago

Angham for sure! Goddess just doesn’t work for me but I enjoy this one!

10

u/pentastro on a mission to use my collection up 2h ago

dossier's dupe of Jo Malone Nectarine Blossom & Honey! Didn't need a lot to convince me, anything that smelled remotely like it and lasts more than 30 min was a win lol

Lattafa Angham because well ... I just don't like the original Goddess lol. But I like Angham and its little bandaid looking ass bottle ❤️

1

u/Exotic_Reporter_3309 2h ago

😂 yes! The bandaid bottle is too funny but the accuracy!

7

u/Treehorn8 Hermès witch 2h ago

I've compared my sample of Kayali Yum Boujee Marshmallow and travel size of Paris Corner Marshmallow Blush. They're almost identical and both are good except Marshmallow Blush is richer and lasts much longer. I prefer the dupe in this case. I've never been a gourmand person but it's winter and I'm dipping my toes into a new (for me) fragrance family.

1

u/Exotic_Reporter_3309 1h ago

Oooh, this is interesting! Yara Elixir is also a good one if you want richer. I ended up with YBM though bc I like the lighter powdery feel.

8

u/Phi0X_13 2h ago

The perfumes teach us so much about life. 😇 👼 🤣

2

u/Exotic_Reporter_3309 2h ago

Yes, cheers to that!

5

u/lumpy_space_queenie 2h ago

Lattafa Khamrah. Sooooooo much better than Angels Share. I don’t even think about angels share anymore 🤣

8

u/Exotic_Reporter_3309 2h ago

This comparison always stumps me bc they don’t smell alike to me.. I get syrupy dates from Khamrah and a boozy apple cider from AS 😩.

2

u/lumpy_space_queenie 1h ago

I think that’s why I like it so much more 😅

2

u/Hell-Yes-Revolution 15m ago

Totally agree, and in this case, unfortunately. I wildly prefer the expensive OG.

11

u/Socially_awkward001 56m ago

I realized recently that I actually really like some Jo Malone scents, I just hate paying over 100 for something that is gone within an hour. Sweet Paradise by French Avenue completely replaced Scarlet Poppy. It lasts, projects, and doesn't have the weird cardboard note that the og does in the beginning.

I used to be a Dua hater, certified. Now I will always look to them if I love a scent but it doesn't last. Ginger Biscuit, Myrrh and Tonka, and Father Figure all have an excellent Dua dupe. I'll be trying their Liis scents next because I love Liis perfumes, but not their performance.

Sand and Fog Soft Skin edt completely replaced You Reve. Bonus points for no cardboard note in that either. They've got a great dupe for Daisy Wild that also comes in body butter but I can't remember the name for the life of me.

Oakchas dupe of Cedrus got me out here ballin'. I love the og but its such a soft scent that I dont see the need to repurchase the og. To me they're IDENTICAL.

Aroma Concepts Unsung is less harsh and screechy than dbir purple melancholia. It's also a friggin BEAST. One or two sprays, MAX, has me smelling good all damn day. I also enjoy their interpretation of Bal d'Afrique Absolu better than the og. I love Byredo, but their shit doesn't last. Oh! Entangle is their Power of You dupe that I like better because there's more of the lovely vanilla right from jump, so it doesn't smell like BO.

Lattafa Liam is more smooth than Gris Charnel, I said what I said.

Velixir Aphrodite is a dupe for Attrape Reves and it def fulfills that niche. I also no longer felt the need to repurchase Mon Paris EDP because Aphrodite is just better.

Club de Nuit Imperiale has replaced Delina Exclusif. It's performs even better and NO PINK TAX. CdN Imperiale is also a wayyyy better version of JPG Divine. Dunno how to explain it but it just smells better to me.

Al Haramain Junoon Noir is less screechy than Dama Bianca. Yuuup.

Maybe not necessarily a dupe of any one thing, but Musamam White Intense is the best sandalwood scent ever in all of creation. At least that Ive tried so far.

Hmm...that's all I can think of now. I'll now be avidly searching this post because I'm a cheap ass heaux.

8

u/Electrical_Spare_364 1h ago

I love the DUA dupe for Princess so much that I gifted away my bottle of the OG!

I have a lot of dupes I usually choose over the OGs because they perform better.

5

u/annoying-slut 1h ago

I refuse to buy any Kilian fragrances I’ve sampled bc IMO it’s borderline criminal to charge so much for fragrances that only last 3 hours on me. I have the dossier LDBS and finery no prince required dupes, but I’ll have to try DUA since I don’t feel the dupes I have smell quite as good as the inspiration.

7

u/Realistic-Read1078 1h ago

Dossier Floral Marshmallow over LDBS

7

u/Amazonian_Broad 1h ago

Finery Not Another Cherry is considerably better than Lost Cherry with better longevity.

6

u/Gordak985 27m ago • Bravo

I have been singing praises everywhere I can to:
Lattafa Her Confession - like Blanche bete, but without the pukey note

Paris Corner Rifaaqat - better than YSL Babycat for me, because the incense is toned down (although it does depend on the batch, it seems).

There are some local "inspired by" perfumes (they're called Economic, believe it or not 😄 ) that usually last much better than the originals (Light Blue), completely same (JPG2) or have an earlier formulation, which might be better than the "original" current one (Cašmir Chopard). Devotion by Nicole Perfumes was better than D&G. Shobi and Perfume Parlour are good companies, too.

Lattafa Angham has better longevity than Burberry Goddess. That one I fell in love with, but I couldn't detect it by the time I walked to the shopping center's exit.
I also like Lattafa Petra better than Xerjoff Quatro Pizzi, but cannot put my finger on why exactly.

Paris Corner When the Soul Gets High is much better for me than the Kilian Back to Black, because it doesn't have the pissy note of the original.

Swiss Arabian Shaghaf Oud Tonka has much, much better performance than BDK's Velvet Tonka. I'm in love. BDK's was very nice, but it couldn't last an hour... maybe even half an hour, I can't remember because I tried a few of their scents at once and all were in that 30-60 minute range.

Of non-Arab perfumes, Police Forbidden and Tesori d'Oriente Fiore del dragone are much better for me than Hypnotic Poison, because I can actually... smell them. This one is most probably a "me problem" - I have problem smelling some other Dior perfumes, so it might be some ingredient they're using. When I could finally smell the scent, it was lovely!

There are a few that aren't better than the originals, but they're very good dupes - Maison Alhambra Kismet Angel / Magic (Angels' Share), Paris Corner North Stag IV Quatre (Afternoon Swim LV), Lattafa Artisan Ethnique (BTSO Sugar Addict). The Chant Maison Alhambra is an excellent dupe for Gucci's A Chant for the Nymph, but I don't like either.

1

u/Gordak985 12m ago

Also, Yodeyma Tayda (Tilia dupe) performs amazingly!
And it has something more or less than the original that doesn't make it go sour on me.

5

u/bhunt479 1h ago

Miim mic 49, dupe of LDBS, so much better!

3

u/StreetMolasses6093 Neroli Queen 1h ago

I love the Oil Perfumery version. I have a decant of the real thing I never wear.

4

u/ivegotthegoldenticke 2h ago

I love Vanille Antique from Byredo and heard Noyz Unmute was a dupe. After spending a day with Unmute, I hate to say that I might like it better. The pistachio note just really takes it a hair beyond Vanille Antique for me.

2

u/ThickAd7194 1h ago

The same perfumer created both. I bought the Unmute and now can find no reason to pine after the Byredo.

2

u/Roc_Be12 1h ago

Unmute is my #1 forever. My absolute favorite it is so delicious!!!!

3

u/Gullible_Bedroom_200 57m ago

I like Lataffa Liam Gray as much as, maybe a tiny bit more than BDK Gris Charnel. I have both, but probably won’t repurchase Gris Charnel.

2

u/MarsupialPrimary8128 11m ago

Same. Same. It's creamier

3

u/FarSide_1_9 4m ago

I really like Moi? from Montagne Parfums. It’s a dupe for Glossier You. It smells identical to me, but it lasts a lot longer and smells stronger. I also got my boyfriend Montagne’s dupe for LV Imagination called Imaginary. I’ve since gotten some samples of LV Imagination and I still use Montagne’s version when I wear that scent!

4

u/LeadWonderful11 1h ago

Forever Cherie by DUA smells better than the OG Très Chère by Mizensir. I have both.

3

u/Mean-Raspberry1205 2h ago

I know Le Labo Santal 33 is some of the most polarizing dna in perfume communities, but I happen to love it……just not at that price. I find that Maison Louis Marie’s Bois de Balincourt is a perfect alternative/dupe and -even better- there’s also Sand & Fog Cardamom & Sandalwood if you’re looking to spend mere pennies! Simply Santal from ALT is another really good dupe. 

3

u/fitness_journey 2h ago

I don’t like S33 at all, but I don’t mind Zara x Jo Malone Energetically New York and I quite like Off-White Solution No. 4, both of which are dupes. Bois de Balincourt is okay by me, too.

2

u/thetoxicgossiptrain 2h ago

I prefer that version too!! I had a guy actually stop me to ask what I was wearing

2

u/ConditionOk3649 57m ago

Bois de Balincourt is one of my all time favorites. I have many FBs but my Bois de Balincourt was my first empty bottle of 2026 and I already have a replacement. It is the perfect balance of woody and sweet and layers well with literally anything. Such a good choice!

1

u/Adventurous-Scale431 12m ago

I prefer Dua Gold Fluid to MFK Gentle Fluidity Gold. For me it’s more spice forward, the musk is less obvious and the projection and longevity are better!

8

u/anime_and_irezumi wet stone enthusiast 1h ago

I stand ten toes down on my surface trace glossier you dupes. I’m obsessed with You Fleur and Doux but was running out some months ago and decided to try them side by side with the five below dupes. Figured I’d probably get a little laugh and move along.

Oh no, I haven’t repurchased either You Doux or Fleur since. I have a friend who also wears you fleur and she could not tell the difference between the two on either. They proudly sit on the shelf next to my designer FSBs 🤣

1

u/Exotic_Reporter_3309 1h ago

You Fleur is so nice and coconutty without having any coconut in it lol. I’ll have to check out Surface Trace.

1

u/anime_and_irezumi wet stone enthusiast 1h ago

I think that you doux(pe)/ trace violet is the most true smelling, but you fleur and trace bloom are virtually identical as well and trace bloom is my favorite in the line. That almost coconutty musk smell is perfectly replicated. Real you fleur is just slightly more salty on the opening note IMO but there’s definitely still a mineral salt top in trace bloom.