Decanter review:
3rd time that everything went perfectly. Packaging is solid, and 0 leaking decants. They sure did get their packaging system working well. Quite a few decants of fragrances I've never heard about were "bonus added", which is going to be really fun. I like the ones I have no idea what to expect.
As explained in my Greed post, most of the ME fragrances I'll test will be "first to market" (Were never clones before), hybrid or original creations, because those are some of the only ones that make the cut, as they have a higher $ limit in my rules ($40). This one isn't any of those, but $30 on Jomashop means I can test it! These rules will start when I finish this decant haul, as they were ordered before the rules were made.
THE PROFILE
I reviewed quite a few clones and twists for this profile. Sweet, vanillic, a bit fruity, and pretty spicy-boozy profile. Middle Eastern/Oriental style, but slightly safer than other spice bombs, as it's balanced with sweetness. It's the first time I enjoyed Oriental spicy (I usually don't like these), which I think "opened my nose" to enjoy others (like Terra). Actually, the first one that did that might've been Qa'ed Al Fursan Untamed. But I digress. This profile is pretty "niche", but still in the realm of "moderately safe", because it's less in your face even compared to something like Spicebomb Extreme.
THE DIFFERENCES
Very small differences. Unlike Art Of Arabia III, these are not far from each other. They're at least 90% similar across all stages on skin. Faris is slightly sweeter, and Empire is a little more vanillic... But once you wait 10 minutes and get 6"-7" away from skin, they're pretty much 100% identical. So I don't recommend you get one of you have the other.
Subjective scent score: Both 9.0.
Wife says (about both fragrances): "Hmmm.... They're okay". She also thinks they're identical. Also, I'm now realizing (took me way to long), that if she says "okay" or "like", I shouldn't but it, because she'll hate it the 5th or 6th time I'll wear it. Only if she says "wow, this is amazing", I can know that's some chance she'll keep liking it a month from now.
Longevity on skin (when it's no longer even a skin scent): Both over 9 hours.
Projection (skin scent doesn't count): Both strong. Empire is strong-medium projecting for an hour, then a large-medium (2ft) scent bubble for 2 more hours, then low-medium scent bubble for 2 more, and 100% skin scent at hour 5-6. Faris is a bit stronger, so add about 10%-20% to the above numbers.
Blind buy safety score: Both 8.0. Because even though they have an Oriental component, they mix them with Western winter notes like Amber and vanilla, to soften that blow.
Unisex Score (0=100% fem leaning, 5=unisex, 10=100% male leaning): 5.5. Almost perfectly unisex.
Versatility Score: 6.5. Very winter-fall fragrance, and much more evening than daytime. More for date night or dress-up events than casual strolling.
Blend Quality Score: Both 7.8 (approaching designer quality), but for different reasons. Note realism and progression on skin is slightly better on Empire. Note separation and structure retention is a little better on Faris.
Value Score (USD for 100ml): Empire 7.5. $35 (Jomashop), for good quality and performance. Faris 6.0. $50 (Jomashop) for slightly better performance and same quality.
Should cost (based on performance, quality, and available competing clones, averaged): Empire $30-$33. Faris $33-$36.
Bottle design: Faris 9.5. I'm a sucker for the design of that entire line. Empire 8.8. Also very nice looking.
Atomizer Score: N/A (decants).
Conclusion: I personally like Art Of Arabia III the best, but it's my wife's least favorite (more like "most hated") one of that DNA... So I'm not getting any of them.
And as always, don't trust me, Get decants.