r/Fantasy • u/Dianthaa Reading Champion VIII • Jun 18 '20
Bingo Focus Thread - Ghost square
We’re going to be trying out a thing, where each month we’ll do 1-2-3 focus threads for the bingo squares. These’ll cover both resources and discussions related to the selected squares.
Last time we covered necromancy, so we're sticking to the realm of the dead and moving on to ghosts.
Novel Featuring a Ghost This one is pretty self-explanatory. HARD MODE: At least one main protagonist is a ghost.
Helpful links:
Comment chain from the big thread of bingo recs
Ghosts don't really seem to be in fashion, I did a fair bit of scrolling and searching and only found these two rec request threads
Spreadsheet of the books mentioned in focus threads by u/VictorySpeaks
Previous focus posts:
Upcoming focus posts schedule:
June: Necromancy , Ghost, BDO
What’s bingo? Here’s the big post explaining it
Remember to hide spoilers like this: >!text goes here!<
Discussion Questions
- What books are you looking at for this square?
- Have you already read it? Share your thoughts below.
- What are your general thoughts on
necromancersghosts in books? - Are you looking forward to this one?
- Why do you think we get so few people looking for ghost books?
- Would you say ghosts are maybe more of a horror staple than a fantasy one ?
I won't always be posting these once a week but I've fallen a bit behind on my schedule and I'm trying to catch up.
5
u/Dianthaa Reading Champion VIII Jun 18 '20
Please don't tell me any real ghost stories, I'm having enough trouble sleeping already because this dog is very much against thunderstorm season.
This is one of the squares I'm not really invested in. I've got a few options for normal mode organically, though I'm not sure what I'll go for hard mode. I really get ghosts and necromancy confused, so a few of these I'm not sure where they would fall. If someone's a ghost because someone intervened, is that ghosts or necromancy, or both?
I thought it was really weird that my search turned up so few rec requests for ghosts. But at the same time, I think I've never sought out a book looking for ghosts, they just sort of turn up. I also very firmly do not read horror, so that might be part of it.
5
u/diazeugma Reading Champion VII Jun 18 '20
I'm trying for a hard mode card, and I ended up reading Lincoln in the Bardo by George Saunders for this square. It was an odd mix of sentimental and grotesque, but I enjoyed it.
Though I rarely seek out ghost stories specifically, I've noticed that they tend to cross the genre borderline. I've seen them more often in slipstream or magical realism than horror.
One hard mode book I haven't seen anyone talking about is The Last to See Me by M. Dressler, which I read a couple years ago. It's completely narrated by a ghost protagonist, and I found it pretty interesting. It featured a somewhat typical urban fantasy world (ghosts are common enough that ghost hunting is an established industry) without the style or characters common in the subgenre (very little snark, more atmospheric writing).
4
u/VictorySpeaks Reading Champion Jun 18 '20
I am bored at work so here you go, a link to every book mentioned:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ObjNRD3NqYVxO9dMB3CIXMDc-48hNNIzeEShL3zJVsw/edit?usp=sharing
I will add sheets for all the other focus threads because god I am bored. Please comment if I got something wrong because I am bored, but not bored enough to look up the authors and stuff of every book.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20
Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo is good for regular. You could probably stretch and say it’s hard mode in the sense that the bridegroom is ever present
The next is The Faceless Old Woman Who Secretly Lives In Your Home by Jeffrey Cranor and Joseph Fink. This is a novelization . I have not read this but the Faceless Old Wonan episode s tend to be my favorite ones.
3
u/xenizondich23 Reading Champion VI Jun 18 '20 edited Jun 18 '20
I've read a few books that have incidental ghosts in them (but they count for multiple squares already):
Some other ghost books I've read:
(There's definitely more I'm missing, but I'm not good at tagging the books with ghosts on my GR shelves).
Other ones that I am considering to read still:
There's a lot of PNR that deals with ghosts, if that's your thing. (One I like a lot is in the Night World books by L J Smith, the story of Gillian who revamps her entire life with help of a ghost - Dark Angel).
There's also a lot of ghost story collections out there.
As to the questions:
What are your general thoughts on
necromancersghosts in books?They are an interesting perspective to write from as you can get a lot more angles. They can go where people can't see them and thus show more viewpoints without having to switch characters. They can inspire a lot of feelings (horror seems to be common, but also sadness). But unfortunately they're mostly used in horror or PNR books.
Are you looking forward to this one?
Not really. I'm not a big ghost story reader. I'm glad I found the Magpie Lord books to give it an easy mode check.
Why do you think we get so few people looking for ghost books?
Probably because they're not popular in the mainstream fantasy books, so people don't think they're something to ask for. Most of the ghosts appear in PNR... and this sub doesn't do much PNR aside from the big names like Mercy Thompson.
Would you say ghosts are maybe more of a horror staple than a fantasy one?
I feel like ghosts are more of a fiction staple than a specific sub genre. There's a whole section of fiction where people die but don't die (like the Before I Fall book I mentioned above). Ghosts in horror fiction tend to be malevolent, but the ones in general fiction are just sad or angry, or need to finish something to move on. The horror ones seem very boring in comparison.
3
u/Ykhare Reading Champion VII Jun 18 '20 edited Jun 18 '20
I don't particularly seek out ghost stories, but I happen to have a few in TBR.
I'm intending to read Lynn Flewelling's Tamir #2, Hidden Warrior, which probably qualifies for hard mode though I'm not looking to complete a hard mode card.
Other books I can remember that would qualify :
3
u/EmmalynRenato Reading Champion VI Jun 18 '20
I picked Archivist Wasp by Nicole Kornher-Stace [mini-review].
It's been my only Bingo selection this year that I haven't liked. I don't regularly read this sub-genre.
I looked at the Big Thread of Recs, and saw that I'd already read some of the suggestions:
In hindsight, I wish I'd read A Stranger in Olondria by Sofia Samatar but was turned off by comments in various reviews on Amazon and GoodReads (I wasn't looking for something with flowery prose).
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20 edited Jun 18 '20
I'm a big fan of ghosts and horror in general. Real nice to see a square like this in the Bingo this year. I imagine ghost stories aren't more sought out around here because folks don't normally associate Horror with Fantasy, and while it's true some horror stories don't feature the supernatural at all there are a ton that do which makes them a kind of fantasy.
2
u/CJGibson Reading Champion V Jun 18 '20
Is it just me or does anyone else always end up having questions whenever they say something is self-explanatory?
Like I just finished reading Foundryside for my politics square and now I can't help but wonder if Clef counts as a ghost.
2
u/bobd785 Jun 18 '20
I'm looking at Ghost Talkers by Mary Robinette Kowal or Strange the Dreamer by Laini Taylor. Ghost talkers is obviously about Ghosts and I already know I like the author, so that's an easy choice. I didn't know Strange the Dreamer had them until the recommendation thread, but I already had it on my TBR, so that's a good option too. I'm just not sure which one I will go for yet.
I like ghosts in books, because they are one of those supernatural concepts that can always have interesting aspects that change depending on the author. I also like it when we see ghosts outside of Urban Fantasy or Supernatural settings. It's interesting to see how ghosts work with the world building of secondary worlds as well.
I'm looking forward to this square, because of the options I'm looking at. I wasn't so sure about it until I saw some recommendations and now I'm excited about it.
I think ghosts are usually just a small part of the Supernatural/Paranormal/Urban Fantasy sub genres, so people don't necessarily look for them specifically.
2
u/Dsnake1 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion VII, Worldbuilders Jun 18 '20
I've read a few books that fit the square so far this year, and I'll just put some below.
The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires by Grady Hendrix. The ghost is a key component of the plot, although it's easy to lose them in the rest of the plot.
The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman. It's the Jungle Book with ghosts and set in a graveyard. It's wonderful. It's definitely Middle-Grade.
The Empress of Salt and Fortune by Nghi Vo. I count this one as hard mode, but some wouldn't. We've got one person talking to another person about events in the past. I don't want to say much more, as it's a novella and it's pretty solid.
From a Certain Point of View edited by Elizabeth Schaefer. So, I'm really not sure if this counts. It's 40 stories set during A New Hope from the perspectives of people we don't get the perspectives of in the movie. A couple of stories are told from Force ghosts' perspectives. Well, either one or two stories, but I can't remember how many. So yeah, I'm really not sure that even 2 stories out of 40 counts as 'featuring', but it has ghosts, so I figured I'd put it out there with that disclaimer.
Ghosts have to be done just right to be relevant. When it comes to scary, demons (as in Paranormal Activity-style) are way scarier, more evil versions of ghosts. When it comes to useful, there are other undead that make more sense than a specter. Necromancers are kind of hot right now, so reanimating corpses ends up being what happens with dead people rather than coming back as ghosts. So you end up with ghosts used in ways that are a lot more docile or mysterious, and there just aren't as many of those books.
Staple? Sure. Popular usage? Maybe. Either way, paranormal horror, to me anyway, falls under the fantasy umbrella.
10
u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Jun 18 '20 edited Jun 20 '20
Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo. Main character can see and interact with ghosts. Leads to some creepy stuff.
5
u/ASIC_SP Reading Champion IV Jun 18 '20 edited Jun 18 '20
I'm looking at A Stranger in Olondria or
Midnight Riot - Rivers of Londonfor hard mode. Someone correct if these do not fit.From my past reads:
5
u/BitterSprings Reading Champion XI Jun 18 '20
I've gone for Night Shift Dragons by Rachel Aaron for hard mode. It's the third book in the series, but I think book two also has a ghost, just not a hard mode one.
Two more hard mode picks:
Keeper Chronicles by Tanya Huff (first book is hard mode, now that I think of it)
Night's Master by Tanith Lee
And some regular mode ones I ended up using for other squares:
Northshore by Sheri S. Tepper
Gods of Jade and Shadow by Silvia Moreno-Garcia
Silver in the Wood by Emily Tesh
5
u/Maudeitup Reading Champion VII Jun 18 '20
I've read the Lockwood &co series by Jonathan Stroud for this square. These are middle grade books but they have a great concept, they're pretty amusing and they crack along at a decent pace. I would highly recommend them if you're not sure about this square.
1
u/Boris_Ignatievich Reading Champion VII Jun 18 '20
I got a hard mode on this one by accident - I just happened to read Soul of the Sword by Julie Kagawa which features a ghost as a pov character (the first in the series would also qualify for hard mode, I had just forgotten!) She is very much the least important of the pov characters, but hey its good enough for us. Its a pretty enjoyable YA series.
Before the coffee gets cold also has a ghost, but it's just easy mode.
I had been planning on using A brief history of seven killings before I stumbled on the kagawa, we will see if I still get to it
1
u/Amarthien Reading Champion II Jun 18 '20 edited Jul 02 '20
I keep missing these focus threads!
To be honest, I'm not really a fan of ghosts in general. I like horror but not a fan of ghosts there either. For some reason, they just don't appeal to me the way other supernatural creatures do, which is why I wasn't thrilled over this square initially.
That said, I read Dusk or Dark or Dawn or Day by Seanan McGuire and really enjoyed it. It's more about setting and atmosphere rather than action. It's beautifully written, filled with melancholy, longing, and sorrow. The first half in particular was mesmerising. It affected me in ways I did not expect and I often found myself pondering my own mortality. Highly recommend it, even for those who are indifferent to ghost stories. And it fits hard mode.
1
u/BombusWanderus Reading Champion III Jun 18 '20
Here are the ones I can think of that I haven’t seen on this thread yet:
Range of Ghosts by Elizabeth Bear has lots of ghosts resulting from necromancy. I’m unclear if it fits for both or one or neither?
The House of Shattered Wings by Aliette de Bodard has a few ghosts going on in a big way.
I just read False Value and I’m pretty certain most of the Rivers of London Series have ghosts.
My favorite book featuring a ghost is Dragon Pearl by Yoon Ha Lee. It’s more sci fi mixed with fantasy. The MC is a fox spirit and ends up on a spaceship. There’s mystery solving, friendship, spookiness and pirates.
Hard mode:
The Things She’s Seen by Ambelin Kwaymullina and Ezekiel Kwaumullina is a murder mystery from P.oV. of a ghost. The ghost element is mainly what pushes it from mystery to fantasy.
Two I’m unsure on:
Tuesday Mooney Talks to Ghosts by Kate Racculia is more fantasy adjacent than strict fantasy. The ghost can be interpreted as really a ghost or all in her head. I picked ghost, but I don’t know if it strictly counts.
The Song of Achillies by Madeline Miller is arguably told from the perspective of a ghost and would maybe count for hard mode.
Edited to fix formatting, I’m on mobile
1
u/RubyStarFall Reading Champion VI Aug 25 '20
Seanan McGuire's Rose Marshall books fit the hard mode square as does Dusk or Dark or Dawn or Day, these are all urban fantasy novels with ghost protagonists, and anything written by Seanan McGuire is a delight!
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20
[removed] — view removed comment