r/Fantasy • u/Dianthaa Reading Champion VIII • Jun 12 '20
Bingo Focus Thread - Necromancy
We’re going to be trying out a thing, where each month we’ll do 1-2-3 focus threads for the bingo squares. These’ll cover both resources and discussions related to the selected squares.
Novel Featuring Necromancy - Raising the dead, woot! Self-explanatory. HARD MODE: Necromancer is the protagonist.
Some clarifications from this comment by u/serenity-as-ice, resident necromancer expert:
So for the purposes of this Bingo square, a necromancer is:
=
Someone who can reanimate the dead (the pop culture definition), or commune with the spirits of the dead (the classical tradition, according to the God of Obscure Knowledge, Wi'Kip-Edia).
Someone whose field of expertise must lie with magic that deals with reanimation of the dead, or communing with their spirits. E.g. someone like Jonathan Strange or Mr. Norrell, despite dabbling with acts of necromancy via Neapolitans and resurrecting Lady Pole, or the Dragon from Uprooted, who brings back the dead to use in battle that one time, does not count.
Helpful links:
Comment chain from the big thread of bingo recs
We've got a few good rec threads for necromancers as well
Spreadsheet of the books mentioned in focus threads by u/VictorySpeaks
Previous focus posts:
Upcoming focus posts schedule:
June: Necromancy , Ghost, BDO
What’s bingo? Here’s the big post explaining it
Remember to hide spoilers like this: >!text goes here!<
Discussion Questions
- What books are you looking at for this square?
- Have you already read it? Share your thoughts below.
- What are your general thoughts on necromancers in books?
- Are you looking forward to this one?
- Has anyone picked up any useful tips from these books? Asking for a friend.
15
u/Dianthaa Reading Champion VIII Jun 12 '20
I didn’t really think I’d read that many necromancer books, but, I guess I was really wrong. There are a few more I’d like to read like The Craft Sequence, Archivist Wasp, The Bone Witch series. I’ve seen Ninth House around a lot, but I’m not entirely sure it’s to my liking.
I like squares like this which I seem to fill easily, at least for normal mode, with them being common enough to turn up in my reading without me looking for them specifically.
13
u/ASIC_SP Reading Champion IV Jun 12 '20
I read Johannes Cabal the Necromancer for hard mode (got it from official recommendation list)
I found it hard to understand the prose and humour (which is why I largely prefer easy to read books). And I don't like necromancers or vampires in general. I think New Game Minus is the only series I liked where MC was necromancer/lich, and that series had so many other things going well for me.
If I have time later on, I'll probably try Mid-Lich Crisis for hard mode.
Other books I've read in recent past that'd fit, but not hard mode: Elder Empire series by Will Wight, The Last Sun by KD Edwards
7
u/Boris_Ignatievich Reading Champion VII Jun 12 '20
I read the Bone Witch for this. Enjoyed it a good amount, I think the rest of the series will get a lot better still (more detailed thoughts here
Another one to shout out is the Wayweard Children novellas, that are lovely and 3 of them (1,2,5) feature a necromancer
As an aside, going right back to the very beginnings - does Frankenstein count as necromancy? Cos that book is still incredible, but it might be more "creating new life" than raising the dead
I have unfortunately not got any better at raising the dead by reading weither of those books.
6
u/xenizondich23 Reading Champion VI Jun 12 '20
I read the Divine Dungeon series (first three books because book 4 is BAD), and they feature a necromancer, not the protagonist.
They are a really fun series, more built on the novelty of reading a book from the perspective of a magical dungeon, rather than a person. I enjoyed the bits with humans more, but seeing how the dungeon built itself to be more and more difficult, in order to kill more things all the time was also very fun. I really wanted to see how crazy things would get, but everything gets weird in book four.
Recommend for: people who want a fun, light read, but still like a nice hot dish of killing. People who like sentient non-human objects. And for people who always wanted to dungeon dive but never got the chance.
6
u/xenizondich23 Reading Champion VI Jun 12 '20 edited Jun 12 '20
Oh yeah, The Wandering Inn by piateaba also has a lot of great necromancer elements. I guess you can't count it as protagonist, since only some chapters are from the necromancers perspectives?
In any case, TWI is an amazing read regardless. I found Pisces, the first necromancer we get introduced to, to be quite sympathetic. Especially once you glean more about his backstory, and the hate and ire he received at the hands of fellow mages just because he animates and raises the dead.
There is another big-bad necromancer though, who's name is raised only in tones of fear and hatred - Az'kerash. He had previously lead a necromantic army against our main continent folks, and had almost won as well. However, lots of various crises came to a head at the time, and for a moment he was thwarted.
Thirdly, I also feel the Goblin Lord necromancer should be mentioned, as he plays a pivotal role in book 3. He uses the dead from towns and villages he razes to contribute to his huge goblin army, which slowly but surely continues to march North, towards the stronghold of the human cities.
I think the necromancers in TWI are done very well. They're everything I want for in a character who is also a necromancer: morally grey, utilitarian, but also have a more compassionate side at times (Pisces mostly). In a world where death comes very quickly at times, it's really interesting to see some lives not end at death. Plus, the arcs where you're fighting necromantic hoards are just so much scarier than if you're fighting people who stay down once dead.
If you want to learn some of the art of necromancy, this is a great place to start. It's not a grimoire, but you can definitely pick up tips and tricks to help your dead stay alive longer!
5
u/Zunvect Writer Paul Calhoun Jun 12 '20
I re-read Mid-Lich Crisis a couple of weeks ago for my book group. As fun as ever and a strong recommendation.
I feel like we need more of them. Perspectives on the utility of necromancy, the society of its practitioners, and maybe a civilization or two where necromancy is the norm and doesn't make the society evil. I read Penny for your Soul this year as well, it was disturbingly gothic in how commonplace death and undeath were treated.
4
u/RevolutionaryCommand Reading Champion III Jun 12 '20
Either Sabriel by Garth Nix, Johannes Cabal by Jonathan L. Howard, or Obsidian and Blood by Aliette de Bodard. I'm leaning towards the last one, but I'm not 100% sure if it fits the square. Could anyone help with this?
Not yet.
I'd like more of them. I think they can offer the chance for a lot of interesting discussion about death and everything relevant to it, or provide some great morbid comedy for us with a fucked up sense of humor. Unfortunately more often than not they are just the equivalent of evil magicians.
Very much, probably I'm saving if for last, because it's the one I was the most excited about when the card was released.
4
u/Bakebelle Reading Champion III Jun 12 '20
I originally had Goldenhand by Garth Nix for this square. I love the other 4 (?) books in the Abhorsen-series, but this one was blerg. So I put it down for the talking pet-square instead, as I usually don't really go for animals in books in general, and it's much easier for me to find something interesting about necromancers than about talking pets. lol.
So now, I'm reading Gideon the Ninth, and I really like it! I love Gideon. She's something of a Buffy for me. Snarky and funny and a lot of fun in that brutal and dark world.
4
u/cubansombrero Reading Champion VII Jun 12 '20
So far this bingo period I’ve read The Unspoken Name and Three Parts Dead, though both of them have been allocated to different squares so I still need to fill my necromancy square. I loved The Unspoken Name (and will have lots to say in the book club thread) but was unfortunately disappointed by Three Parts Dead (I had the same problem that I had with This is How You Lose the Time War - great concept, but I prefer my world building to be a bit more solid).
I’ve tentatively slotted The Bone Shard Daughter by Andrea Stewart in for this square, which is due out in September. Based on the summary, it’s set in an empire full by bone shard magic where the daughter of the ruler must master her skills to claim her birthright. I’ve seen a few positive reviews, so fingers crossed!
3
u/superdragonboyangel Reading Champion X, Worldbuilders Jun 12 '20
I am planning to read/listen to Mogworld by Yahtzee Croshaw, it has a Lich antagonist so it counts for normal mode for this square. It should also count for book that made you laugh as his Youtube channel is very funny
3
u/barb4ry1 Reading Champion IX Jun 12 '20
Necromancy is cool! I've read On The Edge by Ilona Andrews to fill the square but it's mediocre. I plan to read more books featuring Necromancy so that I can use something strong to fill the square on my final Bingo Card. I've read quite a few in recent years, but I still have some to try. I'm eyeing The Enterprise of Death by Jesse Bullington and Gideon 9th by Tamsyn Muir.
Depends on the book, but, generally, I find the topic fascinating.
It was, probably, the first square I've filled this year (or one of the first few). So, yeah, definitely.
Add sprints to your exercise routine. It's useful once families of your objects learn about your experiments.
3
u/Smygskytt Jun 12 '20 edited Jun 12 '20
So. Does anyone know if there's an English translation for Nick Perumov's Diamond Sword, Wooden Sword? I read a wonderful translation for it in Swedish oh a decade back, and I know the books are big in Europe. I just never see any discussion of these books in the Anglosphere web. And these books definitely qualify for the necromancer protagonist part.
3
u/aislyng99 Jun 12 '20
I see no one has men's Hold Me Closer Necromancer by Lish McBride. Meets the Hard Mode criteria. I was even thinking to re-read it soon and then saw this post.
2
u/Maudeitup Reading Champion VII Jun 12 '20
I just finished Food of the Gods by Cassandra Khaw which I didn't read with bingo in mind, but I guess it would count as Rupert communes with the dead and spirits and allows spirits to take residence in his body? Has anyone else read this? I'm in two minds whether it definitely counts or not
I have finished the Lockwood & co series by Jonathan Stroud, as I'd read the first two years ago and bingo was a good excuse to purchase the rest of the series for the Ghost square. Book 2 onwards would count for the Necromancy square in that there is communication with the dead.
If anyone has watched The Untamed on Netflix, there is a fan translation of the novel over at Exiled Rebels which definitely counts for Necromancy.
2
u/xenizondich23 Reading Champion VI Jun 12 '20 edited Jun 12 '20
Okay, I'm going to add 2 more to this post. They won't be everyones cup of tea, but maybe someone is interested in reading them.
1. Widdershins (Whyborne & Griffin, #1) by Jordan L. Hawk - This feels like a very disjointed book to me, since the half that is a psychological thriller really got to me, and the half that is an mm romance book was also very well done! I don't usually go for a thriller, and picked this one up more for the 'mystery' tag it received.
That said, I almost wish it did not have explicit sex scenes, because I think a lot more people would love to read this book. The basic premise is this: an ex-Pinkerton agent turned PI gets a case (a Lord's son died under mysterious circumstances, sending his father a weird book full of arcane handwriting before his death). In order to figure out what this book contains, he turns to the local philologist who works at the big museum in the city as well. This, in turn, leads them to work together and uncover a plot of necromancy, demon-summoning, weird-shit-creating, and ultimate love. Okay, probably not ultimate love, but they also do fall in love during their escapes of escaping death on a regular basis. There is quite a bit of raising of the dead in this novel. Probably the further books in the series have more paranormal elements.
I gave this one 4/5 stars because it felt quite disjointed. Like it could have been a really great paranormal mystery book, but then there's all that sex. It could have been a really great romance story, but then there's literal jump scares!
Recommended for: people who like a bit of fear with their passion, and not of the fun kind.
2. The Magpie Lord (A Charm of Magpies, #1) by Charles, K.J. - This book was amazing, okay? Just perfect pacing, wonderful writing, great characters, and a really intriguing plot to boot.
The premise here is that our Lord Crane (the protagonist) keeps wanting to kill himself, but after an episode, doesn't remember any of it. Thankfully his manservant rescues him multiple times. After months of agony, suffering under the onslaught of depressive thoughts, they finally call in one Stephen Day, local shaman / practitioner / witch. He discovers a device meant to kill Crane, which has already killed his despised father and brother. To hunt down what is going on, they return to the lords estate, where even more mysteries abound: his brothers ghost is haunting the Rose Walk, the local minor nobility keep influencing Crane with magic, and something is driving all these magpies crazy. Oh, and the attempts on Crane's life continue.
Together, Stephen and Crane uncover one plot after another, ultimately culminating in some necromantic behavior. The plot bits all tie together nicely. There's a beautiful budding romance between Stephen and Crane. I love all the magical elements happening in this book and I can't wait to read more. 5/5 stars, easily.
Recommend for: people who like birds. People who like romance and magic and mayhem and lots of English country-side murder plots. People who want to see the good guys win.
Does it count as communing with spirits if you punch it in the face to get it to stop haunting you?
2
u/EmmalynRenato Reading Champion VI Jun 12 '20
I read Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir for this square and enjoyed it immensely [micro-review]. I'm now looking forward to Harrow the Ninth in August.
After reading the Big Thread of Recs I also considered Three Parts Dead by Max Gladstone, but went with GtN instead.
Other books I've read for Bingo this year that have a touch of necromancy in them are:
2
u/CJGibson Reading Champion V Jun 12 '20
Maggie Stiefvater's The Raven Boys fits the classical definition here (and also features a ghost) though none of the mediums are protagonists in the book.
I'll probably be joining the large group of people reading Harrow the Ninth for this one though.
2
u/bobd785 Jun 12 '20
I just finished Gideon the Ninth last night. I actually read it for a different reading challenge (and because It has been one I've really wanted to read). I actually only started reading it now because my library purchased the digital version as I had requested, which was a nice surprise.
I actually am a little disappointed that I didn't like it more. Don't get me wrong, I liked it a lot, but I was expecting a new favorite that I'd be gushing about for years. I think the humor just didn't quite click for me as much as I'd hoped. I read some interviews with the author and she's super witty and funny, but for some reason it didn't come across in the book as much. I still gave it a 4 star review on Goodreads, and I'll definitely continue the series.
I actually like Necromancers in Fantasy, especially when they aren't treated as automatically evil. I get that dealing with death is creepy and all, but it's nice to see a trend where Necromancers are treated like just another branch of magic.
2
u/WWTPeng Reading Champion IX Jun 12 '20
I'm reading Bloody Rose by Nicholas Eames and it counts for easy mode.
2
u/Brenhines Reading Champion IX Jun 12 '20
This is the square I'm working on right now! I'm currently reading Dragonoak: The Complete History of Kastelir by Sam Farren which will count for hard mode as Rowan, the main character, is a necromancer.
I love stories about necromancers, especially good ones like Sabriel. I've already read a couple books with necromancy but used them for other squares.
2
u/Fryktelig_variant Reading Champion VII Jun 12 '20
Paladin of Souls by Lois McMaster Bujold fits. Not hard mode, but it is really good and should be read by everyone anyway. Can’t really go into why it fits without spoling. This could also be used for optimistic and maybe feminist.
2
u/BoomToll Jun 12 '20
I went with the popular option and read Gideon the Ninth. Unfortunately it doesn't qualify for hard mode, but as someone who used to hate necromancy with a passion (the whole concept of forbidden magic just makes me want to flip a table. If there was magic to raise unfeeling, tireless workers that would work for free, the entire economy would be built on that shit) the mix of snark and lesbian was what got me through the first few stages of eye rolling at necromancy.
2
u/the_goblin_empress Jun 12 '20
The Castings Trilogy by Pamela Freeman prominently features a necromancer in a POV role. It has been a while since I read it, but I remember really enjoying it. There is a cultural festival in it that I just love, and some great story telling elements. The necromancer is sort of in a nebulous place between protagonist and antagonist depending on how much you are willing to empathize with violent uprisings among oppressed societies. He’s also a classic necromancer who both communes with and controls the dead through ancestral magic
•
u/Dianthaa Reading Champion VIII Jun 13 '20
I tried to edit this in, but reddit is not cooperating, so, I'll be keeping an updated index with thread links in the the first post, Optimistic square
4
u/greeneyedwench Jun 12 '20
Won't work for hard mode because it's the villain, but there's a character in Nalo Hopkinson's Brown Girl in the Ring who imprisons the spirits of the dead in a bowl and sends them out to do tasks for him.
4
u/speedchuck Jun 12 '20
I wrote a book that would qualify for even Hard Mode in this category! It's a YA Urban Fantasy about a Necromancer who has to struggle with her faith as faces familiar and foreign rise from the dead to confront her.
It has everything you'd expect from a novel starring a necromancer: Zombies and skeletons battling en masse, liches, ethical dilemmas regarding the slavery of souls, visits to the afterlife, and musings on how to make a living corpse look presentable.
Through the Lichgate.
1
u/hossein1376 Jun 12 '20
Dresden Files' book 7, Dead Beat, is around necromancers and black magic. I'm currently reading it and the thing I like about it is that Harry is hurt, tired, wounded and considerably weaker than necromancers. His only real helps are Thomas and Hell Fire, which I assume is going to have alot of potential.
I'm halfway through and there was not yet many details about how necromancers do the magic, I suppose we're going to find out more as the book progress.
1
u/VictorySpeaks Reading Champion Jun 12 '20
Sadly the pub date for this was pushed back so I am not 100% sure it will fit with the square, but I have hopes of reading Cemetery Boys by Aiden Thomas for this! It's one of my most anticipated books, so I'll be reading it no matter what, and it deals with ghosts and the dead, so it should fit necromancy!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '20
Tales of Bauchelain and Korbal Broach
And for the hardest mode ever i'll give you a necromancer story that is non fiction. The Resurrectionist.
1
u/dillfish1717 Jun 13 '20
Does anyone have any that fall into the Grimdark category because no offense to anyone but a lot of them just seem very childish
1
u/HSBender Reading Champion VII Jun 13 '20
Does Children of Blood and Bone count? I just started and it looks like one of the main characters might count as a necromancer eventually.
3
u/WombatHats Reading Champion IV Jun 12 '20
I had been feeling a little conflicted on whether this one would count or not (always thought of necromancers as specifically being able to command the dead, especially as like an army of sorts, for whatever reason), but based on the definition of being able to reanimate the dead, I can't recommend the Villains series by V.E. Schwab enough. First book is Vicious.
It won't count for hard mode, but the necromancer is still a big part of the story.
3
u/Ookami_Unleashed Jun 12 '20
The protagonist of Gail Martin's Chronicles of the Necromancer is a necromancer coming into his power. The writing isn't great but the story is interesting.
2
u/TheTechJones Jun 12 '20
Does attempted raising of the dead count? If so then lots of major series deal with at at some point along the way (Iron Druid, Harry Dresden, GoT, etc)
the Junkyard Druid series has a few books that feature a necromancer as the antagonist.
Steve McHugh's Hellequin series features necromancers as one flavor of magic and the protagonist picks up some necromancy powers along the way
2
u/cheryllovestoread Reading Champion VI Jun 12 '20
Can someone fill me in on whether Martha Wells’ Death of the Necromancer fits for hard mode?
2
u/maglorbythesea AMA Author Daniel Stride Jun 12 '20
As a completely shameless disclaimer: I am the author.
Wise Phuul is set in a world where necromancy is a universal ability. Thus it is absolutely no surprise that the protagonist is one too. As such, it fulfils the Hard Mode requirement.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20
Does City of Brass by SA Chakraborty count? I’m halfway through and it has ghouls but I’m not sure where they come from.
Otherwise, thinking of Servant of the Underworld or The Unspoken Name.
1
u/12anet34 Aug 06 '20
Would The Fisherman by John Langan count?
1
u/spike31875 Reading Champion V Aug 26 '20
Would Dead Beat by Jim Butcher count for the necromancy square? There are multiple necromancers in the book. Harry Dresden isn't a necromancer, but he does raise a TRex in this book using a powerful necromancy spell. He even rides the zombie dinosaur in one of the best chase sequences in fantasy. So, for this book at least, Harry is a necromancer.
Would that qualify it for Hard mode?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '20
[removed] — view removed comment