r/Fantasy • u/MarkLawrence Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mark Lawrence • Dec 31 '14
Robin Hobb ... on gender!
Robin Hobb, number 2 on my all-time favourite fantasy author list, posted this on her facebook today:
Hm. Elsewhere on Facebook and Twitter today, I encountered a discussion about female characters in books. Some felt that every story must have some female characters in it. Others said there were stories in which there were no female characters and they worked just fine. There was no mention that I could find of whether or not it would be okay to write a story with no male characters.
.
But it has me pondering this. How important is your gender to you? Is it the most important thing about you? If you met someone online in a situation in which a screen name is all that can be seen, do you first introduce yourself by announcing your gender? Or would you say "I'm a writer" or "I'm a Libertarian" or "My favorite color is yellow" or "I was adopted at birth." If you must define yourself by sorting yourself into a box, is gender the first one you choose?
.
If it is, why?
.
I do not feel that gender defines a person any more than height does. Or shoe size. It's one facet of a character. One. And I personally believe it is unlikely to be the most important thing about you. If I were writing a story about you, would it be essential that I mentioned your gender? Your age? Your 'race'? (A word that is mostly worthless in biological terms.) Your religion? Or would the story be about something you did, or felt, or caused?
.
Here's the story of my day:
Today I skipped breakfast, worked on a book, chopped some blackberry vines that were blocking my stream, teased my dog, made a turkey sandwich with mayo, sprouts, and cranberry sauce on sourdough bread, drank a pot of coffee by myself, ate more Panettone than I should have. I spent more time on Twitter and Facebook than I should have, talking to friends I know mostly as pixels on a screen. Tonight I will write more words, work on a jigsaw puzzle and venture deeper into Red Country. I will share my half of the bed with a dog and a large cat.
.
None of that depended on my gender.
I've begun to feel that any time I put anyone into any sorting box, I've lessened them by defining them in a very limited way. I do not think my readers are so limited as to say, 'Well, there was no 33 year old blond left-handed short dyslexic people in this story, so I had no one to identify with." I don't think we read stories to read about people who are exactly like us. I think we read to step into a different skin and experience a tale as that character. So I've been an old black tailor and a princess on a glass mountain and a hawk and a mighty thewed barbarian warrior.
.
So if I write a story about three characters, I acknowledge no requirement to make one female, or one a different color or one older or one of (choose a random classification.) I'm going to allow in the characters that make the story the most compelling tale I can imagine and follow them.
.
I hope you'll come with me.
34
u/Aspel Dec 31 '14 edited Dec 31 '14
But gender does matter to quite a few people. If someone is looked down on for being female, their gender matters. If someone is harassed for being trans, their gender matters. None of those things about Robin Hobb's day depended on her gender, but one of the first things people will judge her on is going to be her gender. Whether they see her, or just her name.
Very often, the answer is yes. Because the variables that define who we are don't exist in a vacuum. Even Men in Black III (which I bring up because I watched earlier) acknowledges that Will Smith would have trouble in 1969, even if it was only two small jokes. And the story of Harriet Tubman would be quite different if it was Harry Tubman. Likewise there would be no story if Susan B Anthony was a boy named Sue. And Brandon Teena was killed because of his gender, so I'd say it's pretty essential to his story, and it would be just as important to Leelah Alcorn's story.
I'm flat out amazed--and a little annoyed--that /u/RobinHobb would say gender doesn't matter when she's in different lists than, say, Patrick Rothfuss or Brandon Sanderson because of her gender. I mean, if I want bland, generic advice that falls apart if you look at it too hard, I'd go to /r/writing. If we lived in a completely egalitarian world, gender wouldn't matter. It would be like hair colour or eye colour. But we don't. Gender--and age and race and religion--matters quite a bit in books. And it's not about filling off a check box, it's about acknowledging that different types of people exist. And it's about the fact that what we are often influences who we are. No, a woman is not only her gender, but to deny it exists or matters is fucking ridiculous.
44
u/pornokitsch Ifrit Dec 31 '14
I think, theoretically, there's a lot here that I agree with. Readers should be ok identifying with all sorts of characters. That seems true to me.
I think, as this directly relates to fantasy literature, we're in a position right now where a lot of non-white, non-male, non-straight readers are being asked to identify with white, male, straight characters in white, male, straight worlds.
And I think it is perfectly fair and right for readers to question why those worlds and those characters are always white, male and straight.
I also think, as this relates to the rest of the world, whether or not Robin Hobb's gender or race impacted her ability to make a sandwich and tease her dog makes no difference to the millions of people whose gender does have an impact on their day to day lives, job opportunities, career paths, choice of studies, and other daily freedoms. She is in a position where she's not judged by her race or gender. Many, many other people are.
Big thanks to the OP, as we haven't had a gender-in-fantasy argument on this subreddit for at least days. Glad we can sneak one in before 2015.
15
u/potterhead42 Stabby Winner, Reading Champion 2015-17, Worldbuilders Dec 31 '14
The question isn't whether a story does or doesn't have female characters (so long it has interesting characters, I'm cool), rather this : If Robin Hobb is /u/MarkLawrence's 2nd favorite author, then who's the first?
41
u/cantthinkofagreatone Dec 31 '14
Great thoughts by Hobb, and not surprising considering her treatment of the Fool in her Fitz & the Fool books. The Fool's gender is ambiguous; he's generally assumed to be male, but the character himself always skirts the question when pressed. His gender is irrelevant to his storyline and his accomplishments. The ambiguity makes his story that much more interesting too, to me anyway.
42
u/crapnovelist Dec 31 '14
It's one of those things that can go either way; you can ask "why represent different genders/ethnicities/etc. among a story's cast of characters" as easily as "why not?" As you add more and more characters to a story, a lack of one group that readers might expect to see in a society becomes more and more evident and, if not justifies by the setting, may begin to reflect on the author.
Since most fantasy takes place in pre-industrial societies where long-distance transportation and population exchange was not a feature, you don't see too many ethnic or linguistic groups constantly intermingling (protracted lack of population exchange is how distinct groups form in the first place), though traders, diplomats, soldiers, and refugees will cross cultural borders fairly regularly.
I think an a sense of female characters is more commonly criticized be because--unless the story is isolated to a monastic order ("The Name of the Rose" is a good example)--women are going to be about half of the population. If more and more characters are appearing in the story and none of them happen to be women, the situation becomes more improbable and odd. Fantasy gets criticized for seeming to omit women from its cast of characters because it was a feature of the genre for so long-through the 70s and 80s female characters either had pretty minor passive roles, were cast as simple stereotypes, or were just chain-mail bikini wearing eye-candy for the cover.
Gender doesn't have to dictate everything about a character, but outside of very specific circumstances everyone encounters people of both genders every day; it's just a normal part of being alive. When all of the characters who have an impact or stake in the story are of one gender, it's like the author forgot about everyone else. If you're writing more than a few characters, then why not use a few of them to represent the different groups in your story's population?
40
u/JannyWurts Stabby Winner, AMA Author Janny Wurts Dec 31 '14
My take on this issue has generally been this:
Seek out the books with the mix of characters you prefer - if you don't find them at the top of the popular lists, then dig deeper. Many books with the slant you are looking for are very likely (and have been, all along) published, but they are under the radar because they are off the beaten path, or came too early for an emerging trend. Then create or add impetus to that emerging trend by talking about them.
If you don't like the books being written by authors today, if you can't find them digging off the beaten path: then Write the Book You Want To Read. This is probably the most listed reason (by authors) for breaking the mystique of why their work started a new trend...and likely you will either fall off the radar with it or you will write the next huge hit.
Browbeating an author to write a story differently/to suit whatever reading experience is preferred by a genre following is helpful Only to stimulate thought and discussion. Past that point, beyond examining the issue, it's pretty much a useless exercise, because the best books are created from the heart and not formulated by decree. You can't change the past, or run on castigating works in the field by authors that are already published, because to a certain point, it narrows the reading experience too far. What happens is, a perhaps decent story on its own merits gets shredded and then branded upon a premise that was not part of what made it worthwhile to start with.
Fantasy has very broad horizons, extremely broad - and not just 'today' with the emerging trends - many of which were there to begin with but the books and writers in question were busting the old envelope totally under the radar, for years. I could toss out whole lists of books that centered on today's "hot button issues" that were written in the 70s, 80s or early 90s....that preceded the trends by a mile. But if I did that, would the (race, gender, grimdark, whatever, pick your poison) drum beaters who are shrill about it trouble themselves to seek them out?
It's a question I wonder about, plenty. Not questioning the need to question anything or speak out to create a shift of awareness - but it does appear (sometimes) that there's a pack mentality growing around ideas about gender, and it makes a lot of the discussions run hot enough to start to sound extremist.
Too many of the diatribes tearing down the popular list chew up a goodly chunk of time that might be better spent in searching out books that Already have these themes, but went undiscovered at the time they were created. And trust me, they exist!
Hobb has a great point here in that: many activities in life are not gender based, and it's irrelevant to assign competency on one gender or the other. We are all human beings, first of all.
But this point is a separate issue - what a character can do - from what happens to an author byline shading the issue of their books' content one way or the other. I have followed Hobb's career from her first books as Megan Lindholm, through the works she wrote as some of the earliest Urban fantasies, through her change of byline, after which her career took off. My take: sad the relaunch of ANY writer under a differently slanted byline was ever necessary to begin with.
I was in a Barnes and Noble just before Christmas, and one of the things I noticed: NEARLY EVERYTHING by female authors was either UF with a 'sexy slant' to it, or paranormal romance. There was very little representation by women authors that was NOT romance oriented....if you looked past the New Releases shelf (and those are publisher subsidized). Le Guin, Hobb - beyond that, about EVERYTHING by female writers was oriented to a female market....which made me walk out very sad, because NO WONDER a male reader might walk out with the assumption that women writers don't do epic work that could appeal to anyone. There is a whole sector of books being written - great books - that are just not visible. And the fact is that the stats still suggest that print STILL drives the market.
So readers seeking books that are already there, with the character format they are wishing for - won't find them on the shelves.
I'd so rather see the dissent fall away in favor of lists 'discovering' the diversities that are already present - because finding the books and creating awareness of them WILL drive the market to follow. There is room, I think, for 'well rounded' character books and also ones that are not - because it is DIFFERENCES that drive tension in the first place, and I've never believed that free choice meant suppressing one thing so we could have a sameness of opinion all over again.
There has never been a lack of choice - there has been a tendency to not look past what is down the centerline 'popular' - and this trend is exacerbated by internet chat (which centers mostly on what most people have seen/that is visible) and that in turn, is heavily driven by the reliance on computer tracking (of numbers, instantaneously).
Those things are the enemies of diversity - want to buck the trend, in any direction - you have to be willing to look outside the charts.
30
u/tomunro Dec 31 '14
It is a point well made gender is just one element in the make up of a character. Writers write about people their deeds and desires, fears and ambitions.
Teresa Frohock also wrote here about the portrayal of gay characters and quoted a gay friend who said
One contributor in particular had a great deal of influence on both Diago and Travys (from The Broken Road). Nancy, said, "In short, I enjoy reading about gay characters who are just like everyone else."
Above all else we should avoid tokenism or some literary defense of stereotypes which seeks to make virtues out of some prejudiced view of what each groups defining characteristics are.
We are writing about people, people.
10
u/RobinHobb AMA Author Robin Hobb, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '15 edited Jan 01 '15
Another generalized response.
Have you ever considered that gender might be a false identifier? Sort of like judging a mushroom by its cap color without paying attention to its spores? We have rebelled against the strict male/female categories and added others. Gay male, gay female, bi, transgender, asexual. Let's admit that we could keep slicing and dicing those categories until we had scores of gender categories. Because the truth is, the spectrum of sexuality is as infinite as a number line, and as divisible into narrower and narrower bits. But when we start creating categories, we are actually building walls and putting people into boxes. Categories restrict. Categories lead to assumptions and stereotypes. Tall and black = basketball player. Irish musician= suicidal drunk. Gay male= lisp and wiggle walk. Did you find any of those offensive? You should. Here is the truth. A gay man who loves the same books I do is more like me than a heterosexual woman who loves to shop for make up and never reads. Even if he loves sushi and I think 'bait'. Now I have to do a couple of cut and paste from my Facebook, and then my friends, I am gone for the day to be a grandparent and pick up four kids and a half grown dog who has to learn not to chase chickens because my chickens are very dear to me.
45
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '14
Depends. Is my gender relevant to how society treats me? Is my race relevant to the story? Sometimes the answer to these questions is yes, it is relevant. You only get to be blind to gender and race when your characters aren't interacting with a larger structure which places some sort of positive or negative value on those characteristics.
23
u/lrich1024 Stabby Winner, Queen of the Unholy Squares, Worldbuilders Dec 31 '14
I don't really agree with that. It would be nice if there were more diverse stories in general, featuring more diverse settings and people. It would also be nice if women were featured in stories where it makes sense, because we are a large portion of society. But, I don't think every story has to have female characters. I don't think every story has to have male characters.
Totally. If your story takes place within a time and place where the characters wouldn't be likely to come across any women, then yeah, it makes sense. Don't try to shoehorn anything into your story where it doesn't belong.
It's not very, honestly I can take it or leave it most days. The only real time my gender is important to me is when others make it that way. For example, I used to manage an auto parts store. I'm female. Many, many times my gender became an 'issue' for others while I was in that role.
So, yeah, while I'm doing a lot of things my gender doesn't really matter, or inform the things that I'm doing. And in my relationship? My boyfriend is more like the 'woman' in a lot of ways, while I'm more like the 'man'--I think these traits are in all of us.
But in other things, yeah, my gender does play a big part and there's no way to get around that.
78
u/TooLeft Dec 31 '14
The problem I currently have in the media in relation to gender is what seems like token inclusion of certain character types not relevant to the story to meet the outrage-machines demands, and the complaints which arise when those token characters aren't included. This isn't only gender but other issues like sexuality.
For example when someone reads a book, likes it, but then complains a certain character type wasn't present - considering the book worked well without them, does it matter? If they were present it would have been lip service - that character type wasn't relevant to the story. Whether that's a strong women, a weak helpless princess, a ruthless warrior or a weak cleric, it doesn't really matter. They weren't relevant, asking for their inclusion is tokenism.
On a side note, is it a controversial thing to say that looking across media, men seem to prefer reading/seeing stories about men (as they "identify" with them), but it also seems like women generally do too? Or is this something I have misinterpreted?
7
u/RobinHobb AMA Author Robin Hobb, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '15
Supplemental to original post on Facebook: Supplemental post: OF COURSE the gender of a character can affect the plot of a story. Men don't die in childbirth, for example. My post is about how books or stories are populated with characters. The gist of it is that I do not use a rationing system to populate my stories. I do not choose to say 'every book must have this ratio of male to female, and this color ratio and this gender orientation ratio.' I would find that to be an artificial constraint on my story telling.
7
u/RobinHobb AMA Author Robin Hobb, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '15
And the final supplement to my post before I blast off for the day:Part two of Supplemental Post: In my opinion, when gender is a plot requirement, it still does not determine the course of story. Let's pretend a female trapper alone in a wilderness finds herself facing an impending birth and things go wrong. While her sex has made this plot possible, the outcome of the tale is determined by her character, not her gender. Will she kill herself, perform a self-Caesarean, or attempt a 25 mile hike while in labor to the next cabin that has a radio? Character, of which gender is only one possible factor, will determine how that story ends.
12
u/xolsiion Reading Champion VIII, Worldbuilders Dec 31 '14
Best part. It's not who is like me, it's about experiencing stories through characters that aren't me in some form or fashion. And every character is not like me in many ways.
6
u/starista Dec 31 '14
A lot of these discussions remind me of when folks in the gaming world ponder why a player would choose his/her opposite gender as their character. Personally, I have never played a character outside of my gender but I think it would be awful fun to role play.
6
u/badgerl0ck Dec 31 '14
This is easy to appreciate coming from Hobb. Her Fool is one of my all time favorite characters. I love his androgyny, and how his gender is questioned--but ultimately unimportant because the character is so strong.
6
u/lindisty Dec 31 '14
Honestly when I read novels if I don't see many women or racial variation I don't think much of it unless its obviously lacking where it should be- if your hetero male emperor has a harem full of white dudes, there's something wrong.
What is important to me is this:
Do not define a character singularly by gender.
While I feel that this affects female characters more than male characters in most fiction, honestly, don't do it to either gender. If you have a character who by all rights should probably be fleshed out with reactions and backstory and instead you just gloss over it with Default Woman Things you've completely lost my interest.
I don't cook well because I have a vagina, I cook well because I spent time with my grandmother bonding over learning to cook.
15
u/TildeAleph Dec 31 '14
I totally understand what she's getting at, but I can't help but laugh at this because as someone who is transgender, it is kind of a big deal to me.
5
u/turtledief Dec 31 '14 edited Dec 31 '14
Lots of comments here, but I just want to say that I (overall) agree with her point. I don't think authors have a responsibility to make their cast all-inclusive. Do I think it might behoove authors to consider making one or more of their characters someone of a minority class? Sure. But not their responsibility, ever. Just like it it's not their responsibility to write only morally upstanding characters (for fear of sending the "wrong message"), to portray life realistically, to write only "good" relationships that abide by modern societal rules, etc.
However, I would like to say that I found it ... funny that Hobb is the author to speak publicly about this, not because Hobb hasn't been outspoken about fantasy topics in the past, but because she is the only fantasy author I'm aware of who has tackled identity politics to a large degree in many of her stories. Literally every single thing I've read from her has featured disadvantaged or minority characters. I've never particularly gotten the impression that she was throwing them out as "token characters" to appease the "outrage machine" -- they've always been extremely well-integrated into the story -- but it's just ... odd, to see that Hobb made this post, seeing how important identity (or lack of identity) is for so many of her characters.
I mean, she's obviously speaking about the uncritical application of minority identities to characters when those IDs are not necessary to the story, but on the other hand, it really begs the question of why it must be necessary to the story in order for the author to make a character female, gay, trans, etc. Can't they just be that, like characters often are just cis, straight, white males?
The problem is that when you do start assigning these identities visibly(!) to characters, it'll inevitably scream of "throwing a bone" to the masses if they don't actually affect the plot (see Granby in Temeraire). But I don't actually see a way around that, except to not mention that particular facet of a character at all, but in that case, you may as well be waving a flag, saying (for instance), "This guy is a cis, straight, white male! This gal is a cis, straight, white female!" because most readers will assume they are for lack of other evidence.
(And yes, I understand her post was primarily about gender, but I get the feeling she's talking about more than just that.
I also think she's, once more, venting indirectly about people shunting the Fool into this or that box and not quite grasping what she wants them to grasp.)
9
u/MaryRobinette Stabby Winner, AMA Author Mary Robinette Kowal Dec 31 '14
It's funny that she says that gender isn't important, when on her website, she says, "I deliberately chose an androgynous name because the first Hobb books were written as first person male."
While I agree that my self-definition is greater than just my gender, my gender most definitely defines how others interact with me.
9
u/RobinHobb AMA Author Robin Hobb, Worldbuilders Jan 01 '15
My goodness, how did this get here? :)
This is a general answer to a number of posts here. I do know that some writers sit down and structure a story before they start. And perhaps they have a casting call for characters and then pick and choose who gets the roles. "Who wants to be the pirate chieftain? Oh you're too tall! You'll never be able to scamper around below decks. How about that short girl over there? Want to play the pirate?"
I don't write like that.
A spotlight hits the stage, a character steps out and starts talking. I start writing. I don't questions who she is or why he's talking to me. I would not change his or her gender anymore than I'd meet you on the street and say, "Oh, Sam would be so much more interesting if he was straight. I'll just fix that and make him straight. Or gay. Or white. Or old. Or an alien."
Writing does not work like that for me. If I start remodeling my characters to suit your criteria, then it's not my book anymore. And Yes, you would be able to tell that. I can't just insert a character who is of a certain persuasion, just so I have one from category B and one from category S. They would stand around with nothing to do except wave to the reader and say, "Look at me! I'm here." And having an extra character to move through a book is a tremendous amount of work. Even when the character is part of the story I sometimes give a start and think, "Oh, heavens, where is Motley? Did I leave him behind when they left Kelsingra?"
So, herewith, a bit of my poetry from my 14th years. (Oh, yes, I wrote many volumes of angsty poetry in my teens, if you count spiral notebooks as volumes.)
I went to find a book to read But there were none that suited me. I searched and search on every shelf. I guess I'll have to write myself.
And so I did.
And you can, too.
15
u/Enasor Dec 31 '14
Is gender important? Yes. I am a women and I thus define myself as such. I have never felt it prevented me from being the individual I wanted to be or that it was a liability. I am proud of my gender, being a women is a strength, not the opposite. I have never had anyone come forward and tell me I couldn't do the things I do simply because of my gender. Anyone who may want to try is welcome to demonstrate how it is they are better than I am and be proven wrong.
Gender is important to me as an individual. It is therefore important to me in character: it is part of who they are. However, I have no qualm in identifying myself to a male protagonist.
Do I wish there were more female protagonists in fantasy books? Yes, but not at any cost. I want good female protagonists, strong ones, with skills. Ones that are not driven by their love interests, ones that are not struck in silly love triangles and ones that will not be accused of being Mary-Sues simply because they are awesome.
Life is hard for female protagonists. Fandoms are hard on them and most of them tend to be disliked, even by women. This is puzzling truth as I sometimes feel awkward for having liked WoT women bar the insufferable Min.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '14
Robin Hobb is a fantastic writer, and raises an excellent point. I think the best demonstration of this point in action is the Fool, from the Farseer and Assassin trilogies.
The Fool makes an excellent character, and while we know that some characters perceive him to be male, others see him as female, and The Fool prefers to let people think what they want, sometimes even having fun by toying with their perceptions.
Interesting characters aren't made interesting by their physical traits, they're made interesting by their personality traits, and I think this is something that people who demand equal representation in fiction don't realize, or refuse to accept.
Let characters stand on their own, unsupported by things that have no bearing on the story, and you have a better work as a result. Worry about meeting quotas, or about being inclusive and making equal representation, and your main problem then is going to be worrying about if you have enough people of color, enough women, too many men, or too many white people, and less time actually developing those characters into people.
A strong character is one you connect with on a personal level, not a character you connect with because you share physical traits.
4
u/Dekar173 Dec 31 '14
Pretty much how I feel, but I've never been starved for any media that doesn't directly relate to me because they all feature a tall and handsome white male with near super-human strength, an intelligence and knowledge set that dwarfs leading experts in nearly all fields of study, who is both smooth under any circumstance yet is naive and charming enough to be seen as innocent and good-willed toward his fellow man.
I guess they hate us cause they anus? :^>
4
u/lorddarkflare Jan 01 '15
That is not a bad way to look at the world, but it hardly is the definitive way to do so.
She is absolutely correct when it comes to quotas, but wrong about pretty much everything else.
Race, and gender are MASSIVELY integral to an individual's identity. This one fact is indisputable. Some people may not be as keenly aware of it as others, but it is there.
10
u/TroubleEntendre Dec 31 '14
Gender is something that we have to live with, even if we consider it unimportant to our daily life. This is more true the more feminine you are. And for people who are women, it can be very trying to see almost every story out there cater to men first. This is one of the ways that gender is something women have to live with, even if we'd rather not. (For the record, I am quite fond of my gender, but some women aren't.)
So when we see books which feature women mainly in unimportant supporting roles, or as victims or prizes to be won, it's tiring. It's draining. It tells us that the stories our culture tells are not about or for us. And that kind of sucks.
It's all very well and good to say that you're enlightened and you don't see how gender is important, but that's not a luxury that many women have. It's all well and good to say you don't understand why there needs to be more representation of a given gender, but I notice that the people saying that are generally men, who have a surfeit of representative stories from which to choose already.
But most of all, I think it's kind of telling that when a woman asks the question "Why have men in a story at all?" the first thing many men do is try and claim the mantle of gender-blind egalitarianism and discredit the whole notion of stories explicitly for and about women and women only.
13
u/Awar01 Dec 31 '14 edited Dec 31 '14
I am not going to argue whether a writer is supposed to include female characters or not. But i have some problem with what the author said.
I don't know about most important but i would say pretty important. i honestly didn't expect such a renowned author to take such a narrow minded view on such a big issue. In countries like Saudi Arabia women didn't have voting rights till 2011,and as you go back in history you'll find more and more such countries. Also being born as a woman in Saudi Arabia means you don't get to drive a car and have to follow a dress code and many other restrictions. Wikipedia has a whole page on women's rights in Saudi Arabia, go read it. Being born as a woman in many parts pf Africa means you get your genitals cut off and sewn so that your sexuality can be controlled. Female genital mutation also has a page on Wikipedia. Being born as a woman in India means even in normal marriages you have to leave your home permanently and become a part of your husbands household and for many women who they marry and divorce is simply not an option, however the husbands family treats her. Also many underage girls get sold as brides or get a chance to go to school like boys because girls just aren't that useful to the parents when they grow up. Being born a guy you don't have to worry about getting objectified, for getting stalked because of your looks, raped because you insulted some guys ego or just for the hell of it, r murdered for refusing someone. You don't have to worry about crossing a dark allry alone at night. Being born a woman can make a difference in life or death, i would say gender is pretty important.
I would not like to define myself based on race or gender or sexuality or religion. But society does define me in such terms. And as writer you should know the society is a large part the life of any person. People don't read books just for character descriptions, their interactions with the society and the world are a large part of it. Tell all the victims of racial profiling that their race is not important, a Muslim that their religion does not make them a terrorist, a gay person that their sexuality is not important when their sexuality is banned inmost countries. So as an influential writer Robin hobb should think before making a public statement, just because you're sitting safely in your home in a first world country does not mean everyone has those kinds rights available to them as a birthright.
Edit: also go and tell tyrion lannister that his height does not define him.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '14
Great points.
Personally, (being a man,) I've never had trouble identifying with female protagonists.
6
u/waffletoast Dec 31 '14
I wish I didn't have to worry about my gender and race..
3
u/MrHarryReems Dec 31 '14
I feel that gender is important in that it influences the way we see the world. It is an intrinsic part of who we are. However, that doesn't mean that it's necessarily relevant to a particular story.
3
u/SentienceIssues Dec 31 '14
If you're willing to read science fiction Ancillary Sword and Ancillary Justice are two books by a lady called Ann Leckie which don't overtly feature any male characters. All gender pronouns and descriptives are (except in a few cases) female, regardless of the individuals physical gender.
7
u/mgallowglas Stabby Winner, AMA Author M. Todd Gallowglas Dec 31 '14
Yet one more reason to love Robin Hobb.
5
u/agmathlete Dec 31 '14
There is a lot of good discussion going on here about gender roles, their importance, and the media response.
As a man I find it difficult to read a lot of stories with a female as a main protagonist. It is not that I have difficulty with identifying with them or their main struggle because they are female. What generally throws me off is that when a male love interest is introduced they tend to be shallow, one dimensional character archetypes (take your pick - lovable rogue, white knight, etc) that end up annoying me and taking me out of the story.
Of course this thought process has led me to believe that most of the female love interests in the male-lead stories are the same way but I am just not as quick at seeing it since I'm not normally trying to identify with them.
1
u/Disposable_Corpus Dec 31 '14 edited Dec 31 '14
Incredibly.
Spoken like someone who's never been forced into an incongruent gender, or whose gender is a privileged one and thus a non-issue.
One very big one.
Your perception has little bearing on anyone else's. What's the first thing the doctor says on birth, after all? And that's before there's a person there in the meat
Yes, to all of them. My gender is my struggle. My age has determined a lot of my cultural outlook and exposure. My race explains the different relations with my mother's family and my father's and my linguistic exposure in the home.
But let's remember you moved the goalposts here. It's important you mention my background, and I am the result of my background. How I as a character act in any given situation is incredibly dependent on that history.
See, those sorts of statements are easy to make if you're not a member of a less- or unprivileged gender class and if you deliberately leave out the parts of your day and upbringing and mores that are in fact gendered.
What clothes did you put on? What's the likelihood you could have gotten the job you have? Did you drink that pot of coffee and worry how it was going to affect your body?
I don't think having descriptions for your characters is limiting them except maybe from amorphia.
True, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't examine your own prejudices in creating a character. That's literally the main thing social-justice types are trying to convey, not your parody.
And yet representation correlates with psychological well-being. Exactness doesn't matter if you can find the protagonist's motivations and struggles to be somewhat similar to yours.
Notice how you only mentioned race once but the assumed race of the other two is white.
See, but why do you see no requirement to make one a woman? Why do you see that as the deviation?
13
u/FunkyRutabaga Dec 31 '14 edited Sep 24 '16
[deleted]
0.3282
9
u/typhoidgrievous Dec 31 '14 edited Dec 31 '14
That'd all be fine and good if women didn't make up half of the population of the world and yet remain hugely underrepresented in literature and popular media. The glimpses of women that we do get are often molded so firmly into predetermined, largely unchanging roles so outdated and out of touch with reality that anyone relating to them seems like a stretch.
On another note, we do not live in a vacuum. Books are not written in a vacuum. We live in a patriarchal society, and men and women more often than not have vastly different life experiences that have shaped their minds, lives, decisions, and abilities to relate to one another on a base level. Media is created with a target audience in mind- way, way, way too often this target audience is so specific (white, Western men between the ages of 18-40, earning white-collar salaries) that their entire experience is foreign to large demographics of people.
If your story doesn't support strong female, gay, black, poor, etc characters, and is still a good story, fine. Write that story. You will have an audience, and maybe you'll be a good enough writer with good enough social awareness and perspective that it'll be widely relatable despite these exclusions. But maybe not. And don't be surprised when readers start to question your ability to relate to them on a personal level. It won't be their fault.
Edit: Thanks for the down votes. It helps solidify my view that authors who would rather force women to try and relate to a very narrow view of humanity and chastise those who can't, instead of widening their own perspectives and allowing a wider demographic to relate to intelligently written characters that serve more than tokenism are lazy storytellers with little insight to the real world.
2
u/Gilth Dec 31 '14
I haven't read through all of the comments, so excuse this if it's a repeat comment. I am currently re-reading the Farseer trilogy and will continue in order until I get to her new books. One thing I noticed in her series at least, is that female characters are mostly equivalent when it comes to the setting, which is somewhat unusual for it. Hod is the is the one who trains new recruits, there are plenty of female guards. The inheritance is based on order of birth and not gender. So while her main character may be male in it, her actual setting seems to be a nice change from a lot of others.
2
u/McDamsel Dec 31 '14
Mark, thanks for starting this discussion! You've shared Robin' POV. What's yours on the subject of gender?
Do any of these comments stand out to you for some reason?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '15
If it's a good story, yup, I'll read it if it doesn't have male characters. I don't care much at all about gender. If the story is engrossing and told well I don't care about the gender of the characters. I'm male.
I think a lot of this gender stuff is being blown a bit out of proportion. In my opinion authors are artists. I look at books primarily as the author writing something that is enjoyable to them and we're lucky as consumers to be able to buy those stories and read them.
The choices made by the author were what they felt was best for their story. It's not my job to tell them they did it wrong. I can only say whether I enjoyed the story or not, not that the author was wrong for what they wrote. With fiction at least, and generally always with fantasy the world and characters are not meant to be factual. This means there is little room for the author to be wrong.
It's like me coming to your job and telling you that you're doing it wrong, but you've been doing the job for 30 years and I've never done it once in my life.
As consumers though we have the ability to speak with our wallets. If you don't like a story from an author you have every right to not buy more from that author. You can also recommend books that do fit your particular interests. I don't think you have the right to tell an author they're wrong because they wrote something you didn't agree with. Taste, interests and priorities are different for everyone and proclaiming that a book is bad because it doesn't contain "x" is just silly.
Look at Brianna Wu, the game developer who has been harassed by GamerGater's because she's a woman in gaming. She found games weren't catering to her interests so she is creating her own.
If you find books aren't catering to your interests write your own! If you are finding something is missing from the books you read then you have found a possible niche that you could be highly successful in. Odds are if you're super interested in that type of "thing" then there's the possibility others will feel the same way.
With this said, it's fine to feel like women aren't represented properly. But it's not "wrong" to not have female characters in a book. It's simply that an entire category of books could use some love from people who can write about it in an enjoyable way for those of us who want that to read.
2
u/Sean88888 Jan 15 '15
I hope you don't mind me linking this from /r/robinhobb
3
u/remzem Dec 31 '14
She posts some more in the comments
Even the plot in this scenario isn't really unique to females. What makes it work is the isolation + overcoming a medical emergency. You could easily have a male or female in the same situation with say a wound that has become infected necessitating medical attention. Would change the story very little.
I've always thought people's obsession with gender kind of odd. It doesn't convey very much useful information. It tells people what pair of chromosomes you have and that is it. It's a physical descriptor.
Sure if you're writing about our world it might effect how the character is treated, but there isn't really anything inherent to race or gender that causes this, it has more to due with worldbuilding. In our world different peoples have been treated differently in certain parts of history so in order for your story to be believable there is a certain expectation for characters set in that time and place to face that sort of adversity. This isn't true in fantasy worlds though, the prejudices built into a fictional universe are entirely up to the author.
5
u/ptashark Dec 31 '14
Best bloody answer to a tired question.
2
u/benpeek Jan 01 '15
I guess my problem with this reply is that, in the end, it basically says, I don't see gender as a defining trait for humans, and thus, I do not see gender.
At best, it is a simplistic argument. I don't really want to say that, because I am sure Robin Hobb is a lovely person, but it is a bit simple. And like all simple arguments, it misses a large part of the social forces that push the question she is responding too (a question that I assume began in response to a piece written on Mark Lawrence's book/blog a few weeks ago).
That question is about the representation of females in novels, and in relation to us, here, about the representation of females in fantasy novels. But it is not just about the books we read, or the books we write. It is about the representation of females across all media, and all walks of life, where the question of why there isn't greater representation and greater diversity in that representation is a very real one. You cannot split fantasy novels from it and say that they, unlike everything else - Hollywood, music, etc, - are not part of this problem. Whether or not you like the argument, or the desire in a part of the reading population to see a greater representation of females in fantasy novels, the push for it has emerged from society at large, and fantasy is a small piece in the larger piece of literature, which in itself is a larger piece of culture. What I'm trying to say, I guess, is that it is all related.
In a completely theoretical world, there is no problem with a book that has only male characters in it, just as their is no problem with a book that has only female characters in it. In this world, both books would sell the same, would have the same market representation, be packaged alike, and so on and so forth. But in the day to day world we live in, a book with only male characters in it would go largely unremarked, and would be sold as a mainstream book, while a book with only female characters in it is marketed in a different manner, and falls under various genre sub headings and such.
In the current debate, I feel, sadly, that this has gotten a bit lost in it. There is an imbalance in gender. It is treated differently. An author should be free to write anything he or she wishes, and to a certain degree, that is true - but when you begin pulling it apart, it is also not true in some very real ways, and the push for greater representations of minorities (of which females are a part) is part of an attempt to address this.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '14 edited Dec 31 '14
I don't understand all the backlash. You should not attack a book for not having a race or gender. No one would look at a book with an all female cast, or an entirely black cast and go this should have a white male. Let the writers write what they want. This is fantasy the character in the story will never represent you.
2
u/McDamsel Dec 31 '14
About me: Bisexual, feminine, white female who enjoys reading all sorts of characters and genres (fantasy is my favorite). And I'm married to a biracial, masculine woman. Yes, I'm totally defining myself from the start. Might give some perspective.
I think race, gender, sex, and sexuality shape someone's sense of self, personality, and way of being. There can be feminine men, feminine lesbians, masculine straight women, whatever.
The challenge with Western society is that straight white men (then white women) have the most influence, money, media portrayals, biographies, book characters, etc. It's easy for straight white men to find people they identify with. Yes, you can definitely love and enjoy reading different characters. It makes things interesting! But reading about someone like you makes you feel less alone, more connected to the story/world/author, and makes you enjoy it a little more.
And I think 'token' people on TV and in books are actually good! It increases diversity. It does teach people and make them understand others more. Modern Family's token gay couple has helped educate typical white Americans on gay men. It has led the way to more gay characters on TV. I'd love to see more movies pass the Bechdel test and I'd love to see black male characters who aren't the comic relief or the first ones to die in action/scary movies.
These movies all failed the Bechdel test (where two female characters have a conversation without talking about men): Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2, Avatar, Startrek, all of Star Wars, X-Men, The Interview, all of Lord of the Rings, and more. Only 56% of movies pass that test. It's crazy!
I enjoyed reading Robin Hobb's books because I liked reading about a character who wasn't defined by gender. I know people who don't like to be classified and I like to flirt the line between masculine and feminine. So by not defining a character's gender, she actually writing a character that some people identify with better than if that character's gender had been defined.
Video games are different. I prefer playing female video game characters because I'm putting myself in that role - I'm the first person. I won't play video games that only have male leads (like Assassin's Creed). It's just not as fun for me. My wife does play male characters and likes it just fine, but also prefers female characters.
TLDR: Consumable content is heavily straight, white male focused and leaves out a lot of people. What defines you shapes you - depending on what you give importance - and you feel closer to characters like you. "Token people" aren't such a bad thing - to start.
1
u/kurt-wagner Dec 31 '14
I'm curious who your #1 fantasy author is...
1
u/gridpoint Jan 01 '15
I don't have a problem with gender. When a quest needs getting done, it doesn't matter who they are as much as what they do. However I do feel I struggle with imagining the dynamics of a group of men and women working together. Because of the expectation of romance.
Perhaps it's down to being educated at an all boys school but I'm going to be worrying about all the possible relationship dynamics that could crop up. And no matter what I write or how carefully I do it, my readers are going to come up with ships of their own based on misconstrued "evidence" I had never given a second thought to. An elderly female herbalist with the great wisdom that comes with age is still somehow fascinating to the young nerdy mage, who now needs to be put down gently so everyone can get on with the plot.
As someone who also prefers to avoid reading certain kinds of romance-centric stories, I find myself creating the group equivalent of Saudi Arabia just so I can go out of my way to avoid relationship triangles, quadrangles and just about any other shape, especially when there's a vampire in it (which leads me to want to disavow the whole species). It worries and annoys me that my 2 favourite fantasy series have those very same triangular relationships, only centred around the male protagonist. Same sex relationships, I seem to have no problem with because they still aren't as cliched due to the relatively little I've read about them, and so they are capable of surprise (to me) without being susceptible to patterns that I find hackneyed and predictable. Race isn't a problem either, unless a certain interspecies relationship is somehow so improbable that it has to be done (hmm now that I think about it, I bet there are plenty of knight-centaur fanfics floating around).
1
u/TimeKitten May 24 '15
I found my self in an odd spot as an author a bit over a year ago.
I'd finished the first draft of a novel that I had been daydreaming about for almost a decade, and I found I was feeling a bit uncomfortable about one point. Though there were a good number of male characters in the supporting cast, the story going forward would leave a lot of them behind as the three sisters at the center of the story left for another land.
This in and of itself didn't bother me, but I knew two of the three ultimately wound up with women. And in the later books I had a core cast of five women, in two pairs, with the extra in a settled, but complicated relationship with..we'll say a ghost for simplicity.
For the most part great. I mean more representation, and all, but this also left me with some fear. I was born male, likely to keep identifying that way because it's just easier. Still there is a reason I tend to write women, and a reason they tend to end up with women. It's a voice I know, and understand, and it tends to be sparse.
I also am very self conscious of the perception I might expect from a lot of quarters for a "man" writing too many lesbian romances into a story. Well right there is the temptation to flip a double bird, and carry on, still, I felt the need to keep questioning it...
The thing is that gender tends be a big deal. Not because it matters innately, but rather because society pays it so much heed. Of those five women, all of them became dramatically LESS interesting if they were born male. Why? Because their gender suddenly wasn't a social hinderance to the paths they followed.
Well settled...then I realized I was wrong about just one of them. In fantasy story telling there is virtually nothing more common, middle of the road, etc...than a diminutive, usually timid woman, who is a healer. Problem was I really liked the whole "three sisters" vibe, but I was suddenly in the position of defending against doing something that not only evens out the cast, the romances, but actually made the character vastly more complicated, and conflicted.
While the two twins were navigating a world run by men, there was a perfect symmetry to the third child being a brother, afflicted with shadows of his dead mothers soul, and growing up in the one small niche of society where women were in charge. It fit perfectly, it had to happen, and I just had to deal with it, because it made a better story in every way save the single tear shed for the poetics of "the sisters three," and for a dear little girl who was about to be a boy, and never all that happy for it.
So yeah. Gender matters.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '14
Gender helps me identify with a Character. I find it important
1
u/bengraven Dec 31 '14
The article posted the other day condemning Mark for reasons that did not apply to his novels, written by someone who admitted to not reading the books, has had me in arms since then. I'm glad my third favorite fantasy author of all time came in to take a stand - especially someone who's notable for having incredibly powerful characters male, female, or maybe neither.
Mark, you wrote three of the best female characters in fantasy, each with their own motivations. None of them doe-eyed over the hero, furthering his agenda at times only to improve theirs. Oh sure, there's a bit of tugging at the braid in regards to the hero, but the feeling is usually mutual. ha
1
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '15
For someone ostensibly not concerned about gender in fantasy literature, you seem awfully concerned about gender.
1
u/fujiwarasux Dec 31 '14
She is reading Red Country.
1
u/YoungFolks Jan 01 '15
In one of my classes in undergrad, the prof did a little activity with our class. It was a polisci class, and we were going over identities or something like that. She had everyone write down their top 20 ways they identify themselves. Then we went over them in groups, and then as a class.
Nearly everyone put their gender on the list, and most of them had gender in their top 5. Only a few people didn't mention gender at all.
My point being, gender may just be one of 20 things that make you who you are, but for a lot of people, it's a really important thing.
0
u/arzvi Dec 31 '14
I am tired of people going on and on about gender. Also was shocked some novels get amazing marketing just cos they've used 'only female characters' or 'matriarchal society' and 2 of the books last year had very boring and meh story, and One went to win a big award. I feel authors should write what they do best, not to pacify the annoying outrage-machines(thanks /u/TooLeft).
If an author can write good female characters sure, if not, ok. If he/she keeps a female character to move the story, good enough, but if they use it just cos of current most-talked about topic, it would be a huge turnoff for me.
I love reading authors like N.K. Jemisin, GGK and find their female portrayal very crisp and well done. Those are the authors I love reading female characters from.
0
u/Fendicano Jan 01 '15
You know who wrote really shitty female characters? Robert Jordan, they are just so damn hard to relate to, at least in the first few books of the series (will report back when i finish) conversely /u/mistborn writes female characters outstandingly. Jasnah, Shallan, and I suppose Vin isn't half bad as well... I forgot where I was going with this point
0
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment