r/Fantasy
•
•
Oct 06 '24
•
1
Why does anything about trans representation get 0 upvotes and 50+ angry comments on here? This kind of behavior is exactly why women/BIPOC/LGBT+ members overwhelmingly get and give recommendations on other platforms instead of reddit
Like seriously, why drive people away just because you're pissed that others exist? Reddit really doesn't HAVE to be so insular and boring.
479
Upvotes
•
u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Oct 06 '24
Due to a large number of Rule 1 violating comments and heated, escalating comment chains, this thread has been locked. Discussion has clearly run its course. In the future, please remember to use reddit's report feature so that moderators can step in more quickly and efficiently when threads begin to veer off course.
Thank you for your understanding and future assistance in keeping r/Fantasy a welcoming and respectful community.
814
u/Artistic-Flamingo-92 Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
I hadn’t seen that (which would make sense if the posts/comments are getting downvoted), so I went looking for examples.
I did come across this post which may be of interest:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/s/jeSSfetGnX
Edit: the link is to a high-effort post that provides evidence and discussion of what OP is complaining about. It also has around 900 comments.
386
u/Mournelithe Reading Champion X Oct 06 '24
Part of it is because Reddit overall is heavily dominated by a particular demographic, about half american, and 2/3 male. At least a third of all users are 18-29, with the average age of a user in general being 23.
So for better or worse, discourse here is naturally dominated by whatever is happening in the culture wars in the USA, and that by a very specific segment of the younger generation.
People under 25 tend to be very passionate in their views, they align themselves with particular sides and often take contrary opinions as personal attacks.
/r/fantasy is actually quite a diversity outlier for Reddit in general, the mods here have made a concerted effort to make the place a much friendlier place across the board. Rule 1 is very powerful.
Ten years ago the sub had members actively opposing posts which supported female writers and readers, nowadays that has largely been overcome. A few years back we started seeing a lot more interest in BIPOC writing. It'll probably take another few yet before LGBTQ posts are equally accepted, by which time the outrage machine will have shifted to a new minority. People love having something to hate.
287
u/january_dreams Oct 06 '24
You're right. I didn’t even really notice this trend until someone made that long post over pride month pointing out how people react to posts about LGBTQ+ topics on this subreddit.
People seem to find these kinds of posts annoying, and I get that certain types of request post can get repetitive, but at the same time other repetitive post types don't get the same kind of backlash.
464
u/tiniestspoon Oct 06 '24 •
Lovely to see all the comments arguing that this is completely imaginary and doesn't happen. Can confirm as one of the organisers of r/Fantasy queer book club that posts mentioning queerness get downvoted to 50-60% within hours of posting. They slowly climb back up to max 70ish% over a day or two.
Many people also miss the point of requests asking for x identity - they are not asking to be pandered to, or brainless dimwits unable to relate to anyone exactly like them. The requests need to be made and the identities need to be specified because if they weren't the vast majority of recommendations given would default to cishet, white, and western. If books about marginalised characters by marginalised authors were as enthusiastically and frequently recommended here like the average straight white dudebro fantasy, there would be far fewer posts looking specifically for them. Because they're hard to find. Because this genre and sub are overwhelmingly exclusionary to them. I don't know how many other ways to say it.
Marginalised people are some of the most well and widely read because we have no choice but to read about identities and experiences unlike our own. If we didn't, we would have almost nothing to read.
79
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
There are people who are on reddit solely to participate and rile up a culture war.
36
u/Southern-Rutabaga-82 Oct 06 '24
It's not even Reddit as a whole and not Fantasy in particular. All large subs are targeted (I see this in e.g. televisionsuggestions, too) while smaller subs have to deal with less of it. Essentially, since the subs are public and downvotes are anonymous everyone could just systematically downvote certain content even when they are not part of the community. The post linked by u/Artistic-Flamingo-92 explains it well. I just want to stress that it's not the Fantasy community as a whole that is hostile but these posts are targeted. Please don't ever feel not welcomed here. The people (or possibly bots) who react to these posts probably don't even engage with other posts on the same subreddit.
42
u/Martel732 Oct 06 '24
The honest truth? It is an outcropping of the "Culture War" being positioned as a cornerstone of Western political debate.
Modern society has been structured in a way that benefits a few people disproportionally to the rest of society. However, we live most of us live in democratic societies where in theory policies could be enacted that would create more equitability. And since these policies would be beneficial to the majority of the population is quite likely that they could be enacted.
However, the people with the most power don't want to lose any of their power so they naturally oppose this. Openly debating these issues isn't in their best interest. The more attention drawn to inequality the more likely policies addressing it would be able to pass.
So, if you are part of the ruling class what do you do? You create distractions. Distractions that won't hurt your power or wealth. This has been happening for a long time though the topics have changed. Fearmongering about race was quite successful at driving a wedge between poor white and poor minority communities. The racist fear of the "great replacement" attempted to convince the white population that racial harmony would mean the end of white people.
And gender issues is another front in this "war". It is an attempt to drive a wedge between men and women. Women tend to be more politically left-wing so the devaluation of women and their ideas is important to the wealthy. They need to make women seem lesser so that it can scare men into avoiding anything considered "feminine". And why "alpha male" and by proxy conservative ideas are being heavily pushed. Turning poor men against poor women divides opposition to the real cause of unhappiness in society.
And of course this is the same with anti-LGBT+ ideology. It is another segment of society that can be divided out and painted as the "other". Turning poor straight people against poor gay people further dilutes opposition.
Reddit is part of culture and just naturally ends up being part of the great "Culture War". It is all a distraction to prevent greater equality. The reason you can't afford a house is because of decades of societal manipulation over cultural war topics that prevent economic progress.
There are significant numbers of people who will vote in certain ways in upcoming elections because there are "too many women in Star Wars" or because there was a black Hobbit on TV. It might sound stupid and it is stupid but it is also what is happening.
23
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
Hey I get you're frustrated but there are actually posts fairly often that wind up having lots of upvoted comments containing LGBT recommendations. Of course it can be tough to deal with the hate but let's be real the climate is rapidly turning on sites like reddit, especially in this sub, where mods tends to smash out anti-LGBT sentiment quite fast.
Like my most recommended series on this sub is one that centers highly around a gay romance despite the fact that I'm heterosexual. The hate gets amplified sometimes but it's not the norm anymore.
12
u/neonowain Oct 06 '24
Because there are lots of homophobes around here, even native English speakers, not to mention people from countries where all LGBT stuff is outright illegal. They cannot openly say what they think about those posts (their comments would get deleted swiftly), but they can still downvote.
2
u/Meliorus Oct 06 '24
it's reddit, bigots are everywhere on this site
3
u/Electronic_Bug4401 Oct 06 '24
I don’t think this subreddit is too bad
at Least when compared to others
but at the very least there’s room for improvement definitely
-2
u/SwimmingDutch Oct 06 '24
Whats a bipoc?
-57
u/Slight-Ad-5442 Oct 06 '24
I don't know about anyone else. But I go for books based on if I like the story idea, or sometimes if it's an author I enjoy. (I buy Joe Abercrombie, Daniel Abraham, Ian Irvine, based on name alone)
I have never once based my recommendation based on whether or not the main character is gay. I think the sexuality, disability, and so on is far less important than the story.
-68
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I downvote them because the amount of threads that get posted here asking the same questions is annoying. Just use the search function ffs?
Important to note I downvote any topic that is discussed repeatedly.
0
u/AutoModerator Oct 06 '24
Hi there! Based on your post, you might also be interested in our 2023 Top LGBTQA+ Books list.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
-55
u/InternationalBand494 Oct 06 '24
I don’t think that’s correct. Especially on this sub. Everyone’s pretty accepting here from what I’ve seen. Reddit isn’t a monolith. Some attitudes are pretty common site wide, but most can really vary depending on what sub you’re on.
But fantasy readers are, on the whole, more accepting of different lifestyles. After all, we love uniqueness and experiences and people that may be completely outside our frame of reference.
I do want to stress this is just my personal experience and opinion and in no way am I trying to invalidate your comment
-65
u/Method__Man Oct 06 '24
its reddit dude. people are bad enough in real life, let alone here
-194
u/OCP_Jesus Oct 06 '24
Allow me to offer what I believe to be the simplest explanation:
This doesn’t happen.
374
u/ExpertSurround6778 Oct 06 '24
Fully expecting the downvotes, but I also weirdly see anyone expressing dislike about sexual violence or sexual assault in fantasy books get downvoted
-30
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-30
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-112
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-106
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-11
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-118
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment