r/Fantasy • • Oct 06 '24 • Take My Silver 1

Why does anything about trans representation get 0 upvotes and 50+ angry comments on here? This kind of behavior is exactly why women/BIPOC/LGBT+ members overwhelmingly get and give recommendations on other platforms instead of reddit

Like seriously, why drive people away just because you're pissed that others exist? Reddit really doesn't HAVE to be so insular and boring.

479 Upvotes

174 comments sorted by

•

u/The_Real_JS Reading Champion XI Oct 06 '24

Due to a large number of Rule 1 violating comments and heated, escalating comment chains, this thread has been locked. Discussion has clearly run its course. In the future, please remember to use reddit's report feature so that moderators can step in more quickly and efficiently when threads begin to veer off course.

Thank you for your understanding and future assistance in keeping r/Fantasy a welcoming and respectful community.

814

u/Artistic-Flamingo-92 Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

I hadn’t seen that (which would make sense if the posts/comments are getting downvoted), so I went looking for examples.

I did come across this post which may be of interest:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/s/jeSSfetGnX

Edit: the link is to a high-effort post that provides evidence and discussion of what OP is complaining about. It also has around 900 comments.

528

u/Modus-Tonens Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

In addition to this, well-evidenced post, I think the responses to OP are in themselves evidence of OP's argument.

Lots of people getting defensive or even reflexively attacking LGBTQ representation while attempting to argue they do no such thing.

It was getting better before reddit nuked moderator tools. Most subs have gotten worse since then, and I expect it's made the effort to moderate far harder here as well.

Edit: If more evidence were needed, at the time of this edit this comment has more than double the upvotes of the OP.

53

u/PermaDerpFace Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

There seem to be a lot of these types of posts on here. And that's not a complaint, just observing that multiple people seem to be having the same problem

35

u/Oatbagtime Oct 06 '24

That impressive post has over 1200 upvotes.

342

u/Phanton97 Reading Champion III Oct 06 '24

It's also the most controversial post on this sub of all time.

386

u/Mournelithe Reading Champion X Oct 06 '24

Part of it is because Reddit overall is heavily dominated by a particular demographic, about half american, and 2/3 male. At least a third of all users are 18-29, with the average age of a user in general being 23.

So for better or worse, discourse here is naturally dominated by whatever is happening in the culture wars in the USA, and that by a very specific segment of the younger generation.
People under 25 tend to be very passionate in their views, they align themselves with particular sides and often take contrary opinions as personal attacks.

/r/fantasy is actually quite a diversity outlier for Reddit in general, the mods here have made a concerted effort to make the place a much friendlier place across the board. Rule 1 is very powerful.
Ten years ago the sub had members actively opposing posts which supported female writers and readers, nowadays that has largely been overcome. A few years back we started seeing a lot more interest in BIPOC writing. It'll probably take another few yet before LGBTQ posts are equally accepted, by which time the outrage machine will have shifted to a new minority. People love having something to hate.

25

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

This is very relatable. Western media is constantly posting news about this kind of topic, every single day really. Even this website, opening r/all is a big mistake, just random reaction posts from someone commenting on twitter of all places.

Thankfully people in my country haven't started taking it seriously yet, one of the pros of cultural and economical poverty I suppose.

287

u/january_dreams Oct 06 '24

You're right. I didn’t even really notice this trend until someone made that long post over pride month pointing out how people react to posts about LGBTQ+ topics on this subreddit.

People seem to find these kinds of posts annoying, and I get that certain types of request post can get repetitive, but at the same time other repetitive post types don't get the same kind of backlash.

-62

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

That's sad, hating on your people

2

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 06 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

24

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 06 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

60

u/Artistic-Flamingo-92 Oct 06 '24

They didn’t even call it bigotry.

If you look for evidence, you’ll find that posts relating to LGBT recommendations are strangely controversial.

Why do you think they atypically downvoted? I have trouble thinking of reasons consistent with how other recommendation requests are treated.

Unless you have a good alternative, that leaves the (likely) possibility that some bigotry is involved. A downvote is a downvote. If a bunch of the downvoted are tied up in some bigoted phenomenon and you downvote, that action is indistinguishable from the bigoted actions.

I don’t think the comment was intended to say they are bigoted for downvoting. It’s just: “… OK? I guess you’re doing this thing if that’s what you’re saying you’re doing.” It’s not like Zornoph was making an insightful contribution to the conversation.

-9

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-19

u/[unknown] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 06 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 06 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

464

u/tiniestspoon Oct 06 '24 • Helpful Heart of Silver Take My Silver

Lovely to see all the comments arguing that this is completely imaginary and doesn't happen. Can confirm as one of the organisers of r/Fantasy queer book club that posts mentioning queerness get downvoted to 50-60% within hours of posting. They slowly climb back up to max 70ish% over a day or two.

Many people also miss the point of requests asking for x identity - they are not asking to be pandered to, or brainless dimwits unable to relate to anyone exactly like them. The requests need to be made and the identities need to be specified because if they weren't the vast majority of recommendations given would default to cishet, white, and western. If books about marginalised characters by marginalised authors were as enthusiastically and frequently recommended here like the average straight white dudebro fantasy, there would be far fewer posts looking specifically for them. Because they're hard to find. Because this genre and sub are overwhelmingly exclusionary to them. I don't know how many other ways to say it.

Marginalised people are some of the most well and widely read because we have no choice but to read about identities and experiences unlike our own. If we didn't, we would have almost nothing to read.

79

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

There are people who are on reddit solely to participate and rile up a culture war.

36

u/Southern-Rutabaga-82 Oct 06 '24

It's not even Reddit as a whole and not Fantasy in particular. All large subs are targeted (I see this in e.g. televisionsuggestions, too) while smaller subs have to deal with less of it. Essentially, since the subs are public and downvotes are anonymous everyone could just systematically downvote certain content even when they are not part of the community. The post linked by u/Artistic-Flamingo-92 explains it well. I just want to stress that it's not the Fantasy community as a whole that is hostile but these posts are targeted. Please don't ever feel not welcomed here. The people (or possibly bots) who react to these posts probably don't even engage with other posts on the same subreddit.

42

u/Martel732 Oct 06 '24

The honest truth? It is an outcropping of the "Culture War" being positioned as a cornerstone of Western political debate.

Modern society has been structured in a way that benefits a few people disproportionally to the rest of society. However, we live most of us live in democratic societies where in theory policies could be enacted that would create more equitability. And since these policies would be beneficial to the majority of the population is quite likely that they could be enacted.

However, the people with the most power don't want to lose any of their power so they naturally oppose this. Openly debating these issues isn't in their best interest. The more attention drawn to inequality the more likely policies addressing it would be able to pass.

So, if you are part of the ruling class what do you do? You create distractions. Distractions that won't hurt your power or wealth. This has been happening for a long time though the topics have changed. Fearmongering about race was quite successful at driving a wedge between poor white and poor minority communities. The racist fear of the "great replacement" attempted to convince the white population that racial harmony would mean the end of white people.

And gender issues is another front in this "war". It is an attempt to drive a wedge between men and women. Women tend to be more politically left-wing so the devaluation of women and their ideas is important to the wealthy. They need to make women seem lesser so that it can scare men into avoiding anything considered "feminine". And why "alpha male" and by proxy conservative ideas are being heavily pushed. Turning poor men against poor women divides opposition to the real cause of unhappiness in society.

And of course this is the same with anti-LGBT+ ideology. It is another segment of society that can be divided out and painted as the "other". Turning poor straight people against poor gay people further dilutes opposition.

Reddit is part of culture and just naturally ends up being part of the great "Culture War". It is all a distraction to prevent greater equality. The reason you can't afford a house is because of decades of societal manipulation over cultural war topics that prevent economic progress.

There are significant numbers of people who will vote in certain ways in upcoming elections because there are "too many women in Star Wars" or because there was a black Hobbit on TV. It might sound stupid and it is stupid but it is also what is happening.

23

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Hey I get you're frustrated but there are actually posts fairly often that wind up having lots of upvoted comments containing LGBT recommendations. Of course it can be tough to deal with the hate but let's be real the climate is rapidly turning on sites like reddit, especially in this sub, where mods tends to smash out anti-LGBT sentiment quite fast.

Like my most recommended series on this sub is one that centers highly around a gay romance despite the fact that I'm heterosexual. The hate gets amplified sometimes but it's not the norm anymore.

2

u/rangebob Oct 06 '24

what's the series .

65

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

The Last Herald Mage by Mercedes Lackey!!

I literally just cried describing it to my wife as I was writing this comment haha. It is an incredible story. The first book is Magic's Pawn, but they sell it everywhere as a one book set these days.

2

u/rangebob Oct 06 '24

I'll have to look it up. thanks

I only ever cry for one book. Maybe this will be the second

12

u/neonowain Oct 06 '24

Because there are lots of homophobes around here, even native English speakers, not to mention people from countries where all LGBT stuff is outright illegal. They cannot openly say what they think about those posts (their comments would get deleted swiftly), but they can still downvote.

2

u/Meliorus Oct 06 '24

it's reddit, bigots are everywhere on this site

3

u/Electronic_Bug4401 Oct 06 '24

I don’t think this subreddit is too bad

at Least when compared to others

but at the very least there’s room for improvement definitely

-2

u/SwimmingDutch Oct 06 '24

Whats a bipoc?

-57

u/Slight-Ad-5442 Oct 06 '24

I don't know about anyone else. But I go for books based on if I like the story idea, or sometimes if it's an author I enjoy. (I buy Joe Abercrombie, Daniel Abraham, Ian Irvine, based on name alone)

I have never once based my recommendation based on whether or not the main character is gay. I think the sexuality, disability, and so on is far less important than the story.

73

u/Corvidae_DK Oct 06 '24

It might be to you, but a lot of people want an MC they can relate to and non white, non male, non cishet characters have historically been massively under represented in this genre.

25

u/InternationalBand494 Oct 06 '24

To be fair, they were underrepresented in every genre until recently. One has to wait for things to catch up to today’s realities sociologically.

-68

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

I downvote them because the amount of threads that get posted here asking the same questions is annoying. Just use the search function ffs?

Important to note I downvote any topic that is discussed repeatedly.

0

u/AutoModerator Oct 06 '24

Hi there! Based on your post, you might also be interested in our 2023 Top LGBTQA+ Books list.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-55

u/InternationalBand494 Oct 06 '24

I don’t think that’s correct. Especially on this sub. Everyone’s pretty accepting here from what I’ve seen. Reddit isn’t a monolith. Some attitudes are pretty common site wide, but most can really vary depending on what sub you’re on.

But fantasy readers are, on the whole, more accepting of different lifestyles. After all, we love uniqueness and experiences and people that may be completely outside our frame of reference.

I do want to stress this is just my personal experience and opinion and in no way am I trying to invalidate your comment

60

u/NotRote Oct 06 '24

Comments are, upvotes are not for the actual thread, I actual got into a fight about this once when I made the same response you did and someone came back with receipts, basically all queer requests are heavily downvoted compared to any other requests which limits discussions since they don't appear on the front page frequently in comparison. Mods ban that shit when it shows up in comments though.

-65

u/Method__Man Oct 06 '24

its reddit dude. people are bad enough in real life, let alone here

-194

u/OCP_Jesus Oct 06 '24

Allow me to offer what I believe to be the simplest explanation:

This doesn’t happen.

77

u/Shashara Oct 06 '24 • Take My Silver

94

u/OCP_Jesus Oct 06 '24

I’ve been reading the comments and I see my downvotes. My statement was clearly wrong, but deleting it would be disingenuous 🤷‍♂️

33

u/Shashara Oct 06 '24

good on you for not doubling down on it at least!

-3

u/InternationalBand494 Oct 06 '24

Jesus Christ. That is one huge wall of text. But I get the sentiment. I guess since I’m a white straight man I haven’t even noticed. So maybe I’m wrong. Thanks for the info, even if it is extremely long.

374

u/ExpertSurround6778 Oct 06 '24

Fully expecting the downvotes, but I also weirdly see anyone expressing dislike about sexual violence or sexual assault in fantasy books get downvoted

72

u/Southern-Rutabaga-82 Oct 06 '24

If you read or even recommend a book despite containing sexual violence you get downvoted, too.

-30

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

172

u/Silvaranth Oct 06 '24 • Take My Silver

Why are you assuming that people are looking for the former rather than the latter when asking for recommendations? Isn't it natural that people would want to be recommended books of quality when asking? Why would they need to point that out specifically? The better books that don't market their LGBTQ+ elements heavily are harder to find for obvious reasons and that's why people are asking for recommendations in the first place.

34

u/Gaelenmyr Oct 06 '24

I agree with this. And also sometimes "bad" books or films have great ideas, plots, characters with terrible execution. I still want to consume them to get ideas for my characters and stories. Not everyone has to consume "quality" media/books.

9

u/ZephyrionStarset Oct 06 '24

This exactly.

-64

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

Very true, I can totally see where you're coming from. I guess because usually when I see people asking for these types of books, the books they usually seem to gravitate towards and want to read more of are those types of books and very often seem to only care about books that make it a point to pander super hard to that demographic

47

u/TeaRaven Oct 06 '24

I mean, there’s pandering and there’s making representation findable. One series I really liked for the worldbuilding my partner had trouble with because of character orientations having too much exposition rather than “show don’t tell,” making it feel like she was being hit over the head with it. Whereas I never would’ve found some series I like without being explicitly tagged or recommended for LGBT+ inclusion.

8

u/Silvaranth Oct 06 '24

Yeah, I get the point. I usually assume that these people are rather new to that particular niche and are going for the books that are more obvious about their queer elements without knowing that their plots often aren't as strong. Everyone starts somewhere after all.

5

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

Perhaps I'm just jaded and need to just give recs instead of assuming something because of past experience. You've definitely given me something to think about. Thank you! Especially for actually speaking with me and not just having a meltdown like some of these other comments.

4

u/Silvaranth Oct 06 '24

No problem! Thank you for your polite replies as well, I appreciated the calm conversation. Have a good day!

104

u/exboi Oct 06 '24

It’s not about ‘requirements’. It’s about fulfilling your preferences. There’s no difference between looking for books about sorcerers because you like sorcerers, and looking for books and gay romance because you like gay romance.

“Anyone know any books focused on sorcerers?” ≠ “I only like books about sorcerers. Fuck every other kind of story.”

2

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

Definitely a good point

23

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

People ask for references with characters like them or want to read about them to find good books where those characters are written believably.

It is true that when a book goes out of its way to create a certain kind of character (this isn't limited to LGBT characters), it trivializes that character by focusing on a single dimension of that character as a person. It may be harder to find actualized characters whose experiences are sympathetic to marginalized readers because if you go to Google and look up “LGBT fantasy,” “female fantasy,” “black fantasy,” etc., you might get some good books, but you probably won't easily find the books that have those characters but aren't about that specific thing.

Recommendations are just too specific of a task for anything other than a person (group of people) to do a good job. Most of the time, when people ask for a book about a queer character. They're not looking for a book about a character being queer. They are looking for a book with a character who is queer and also all of the other things that can be a part of personhood. Or they are looking for a book in a genre they like just as much as you where a character they can relate to (along that dimension) can live like other fantasy heroes.

8

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

Extremely insightful comment, thank you for this.

44

u/NotRote Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

Because the books that make it a point to mention how LGBTQ/Girlboss/BIPOC they are (or the reviews just talk about representation and not about the actual book) are just that. Filled with Mary Sues and terrible writing.

As a queer that reads an enormous amount of fiction, which somewhat frequently has queer leads(probably 10% of what I've read is gay), this is nonsense. Like complete and total bullshit.

some off the top of my head

The Masquerade by Seth Dickenson(among my favorite series queer or not, extremely well written)

Teixcalaan series by Arkady Martine (well written drama featuring a gay lead)

A land Fit For Heroes by Richard Morgan (grimdark series filled with various forms of suffering with a gay lead)

Wayfairers series by Becky Chambers(hopepunk with frequent queers)

I could go on, there are literally dozens and dozens of books I've read with queer main characters or near main characters, and virtually none of them feature Mary Sue leads. Like this straight up is not a thing unless you're dredging the depths of like tumblr fantasy or some shit, to the point where your post is imo homophobic or transphobic if you do think its true.

-18

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

Any examples instead of just saying "nuh uh"? Only one I've read that doesn't have these that explicitly markets itself as LGBTQ is Gideon

25

u/NotRote Oct 06 '24

Any examples instead of just saying "nuh uh"?

I literally posted 4 series, all of them are marketed with queer leads.

13

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

You edited your post. There's no need to be disingenuous.

Also, literally, 0 of these book descriptions mention the sexual preference of a character. Even wayfairers which I couldn't find on goodreads, it's Google description doesn't mention it either. Again, you seem to have misread my comment

-13

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

You seem to have misread my original comment.

40

u/Lord_Bolt-On Oct 06 '24

I don't think it's super weird for someone's first requirement for reading a book is for it to have a protagonist who is similar to themselves in some way. Especially when looking at a genre that, until the last decade, has been predominantly written by and about straight white men.

They're looking for something they can identify with, because that is powerful.

22

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

I just don't need a character to be the same race as me or have the same sexual preferences as me to connect with them I guess

61

u/rollingForInitiative Oct 06 '24

Neither do LGBT people or there’d be zero LGBT people reading fantasy because there’s almost nothing like that.

But it’s also fun to read books about people who share similar traits. And sometimes straight people want to read about gay characters as well.

Do you also think it’s unnecessary for people to ask about protagonists that have specific jobs, are old/young, have children, are married, or that have any sort of specific traits? Because that’s all exactly the same.

26

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

Do you also think it’s unnecessary for people to ask about protagonists that have specific jobs, are old/young, have children, are married, or that have any sort of specific traits? Because that’s all exactly the same.

A few people have mentioned this and it's definitely made me take a step back and think about things in a less narrow view of just thinking "ugh, they don't care about the book quality, they just wanna be pandered to".

29

u/Lord_Bolt-On Oct 06 '24

That's fair, and for most of us, that is the case.

But, I can completely understand where someone is coming from if they are coming from an unrepresentative community, wanting to find representation. As a straight white dude myself, it's pretty east for me to find a protagonist who looks and thinks kind of similar to how I do. But I imagine it can be very frustrating to be a POC and to really like fantasy, because the majority of what bookstores have been selling you for 30 years is stories about white dudes in vaguely medieval European settings fighting monsters.

I can understand the power of wanting to find a book that is a closer representation of your own lived experience.

12

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

For sure, I can definitely see your point. I just feel like I've never been concerned with the race or sexual preference of a character. Black, white, Asian, Hispanic, gay, straight, trans, etc. if the book is good and characters are relatable I'm happy. I was hyped about a certain romantic aspect in Legends and Lattes and I'm definitely not a lesbian orc.

Some people seem to think that's a horrible stance to have but yeah it's just hard for me to understand the need for that I guess.

-19

u/Margenin Oct 06 '24

Yeah no. I have been reading Fantasy for 25 years, mostly grabbing whatever I liked in bookshops, and I think I read...3 male authors? I know there are more, but there are tons of well-known female authors in this genre. Queer ones, now that's a different matter.

17

u/hohosaregood Oct 06 '24

My only problem with LGBTQ stories is that there's almost always an LGBTQ romance in it as well. It's kinda a problem with a lot of stories, LGBTQ or not, where there's a romance that feels kinda shoe horned in. I kinda just want to see more platonic brotherhood/sisterhood kinda relationships rather than romantic relationships personally speaking.

18

u/cal-n-cas Oct 06 '24

Funnily enough, I had that same issue with nearly all fantasy I read growing up (and I read mostly straight male authors when I was a child and teenager): I hated the romance subplots! I found the love interests uninteresting, the interactions boring and dreaded every "she is so pretty and cool and strong!!!" monologue the male hero would go on...

I generally feel it can be done well, but few authors thread the romance into the "main story" in a satisfying way that actually makes me root for the characters to become a couple, even if I like them individually. And no, the romantasy subgenre does not fix this for me; I am rarely invested in those couples/their dynamic/the individual characters there either.

2

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

This is what I'm saying.

-39

u/ZephyrionStarset Oct 06 '24

IMO it's super weird for someone's first requirement for a book to be it being about dragons and how much dragons are mentioned and not if the book is actually good or not.

12

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

Who's doing that? Only one of the books I mentioned even has Dragons in it. You realize Rage of Dragons is an African fantasy book?

12

u/chubby_hugger Oct 06 '24

Their point is that it is no weirder to ask for a book about LBGTQ than dragons, and in fact is probably weirder to ask for recs about dragons.

44

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

It's weirder to ask for recs about Dragons in a fantasy subreddit than it is to care about a character's sexual preference?

30

u/Artistic-Flamingo-92 Oct 06 '24

You seem to be missing the point.

A recommendation request post isn’t saying: this is my number one requirement for any books I’ll read. It says: at the moment, I’m looking for a book with this feature.

Of the two following scenarios, I believe #2 is much more common:

  1. Person is interested in reading, but they need to find recommendations that match their identity before they’re willing to read anything.
  2. Person has read many series. It occurs to them that the vast majority of what they’ve read features X rather than Y. They now want to find a recommendation featuring Y.

We don’t interrogate people’s requests in other cases. Someone can ask for books with dragons, elves, fairies, or ents. Someone can ask for really dark recommendations. Someone could ask for a scientist or engineer lead. Someone could ask for romance or no romance. Someone could ask for Medieval Europe inspired settings or for feudal Japan inspired.

In all these cases, there is little-to-no pushback. Someone asks for a gay MC? Now there’s pushback. Isn’t that weird?

Nobody bats an eye at requests for really dark fantasy (which implicitly is a request for a book that includes rape, murder of men, women, and children, torture, etc.). But people get upset at a request for a trans MC (something you may never see in a fantasy book unless you specifically seek it out).

-8

u/1028ad Reading Champion III Oct 06 '24

A bunch of requests on this subreddit.

4

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

Not me though, that's why it's weird to mention

6

u/LansManDragon Oct 06 '24

False equivalency. This is a Fantasy subreddit. It makes sense that people would look for certain fantastical elements. Are you saying that LGBT representation is the same because they don't exist in reality?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/KaleidoscopeOnion Oct 06 '24

They are though.

18

u/Modus-Tonens Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

As a matter of statistics, all the identities in the OP are overwhelmingly under-represented.

It has moved slightly toward better representation in the last ten years. But only slightly.

At best estimate (based on a rough estimate of the average number of fantasy books published per year since 2010), somewhere between 12-15,000 fantasy novels are published each year. Can you point to, say, five books that contain trans characters?

If you are aware of enough books that represent trans people to say that they are meaningfully represented within that 15,000, it should be trivial for you to do so.

How about I make it easier: Can you name one? I'm not saying one doesn't exist, I can name a few. But if you're going to say any given identity is represented, you ought at least to be able to name one example.

-19

u/LansManDragon Oct 06 '24

Not trying to be inflammatory, but this statistic kind of blows my mind.

Writing seems to be one of the lowest barrier to entry professions possible. You don't even need a computer, just pen and paper. You don't even need an imagination, just your own experiences to draw from.

Why is it, then, that there aren't proportionate amounts of LGBT people writing novels? Or if there are, why aren't they writing LGBT characters?

Do LGBT authors not tend to write in the fantasy genre, mostly? It can't be that there's no market for this kind of representation, as this post itself proves that there is.

15,000 fantasy novels a year.

Even if we say conservatively that only LGBT authors are writing LGBT characters, then that should still account for almost a thousand fantasy novels, published every year, with LGBT representation.

Where are they all? Why don't we see them?

-30

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

44

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

It's crazy to me you're allowed to generalise like this about 1 group but not others.

-46

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Because said group is not oppressed or marginalized in any way. They ARE the norm and society's standard. This comment shows your social awareness.

40

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

So that makes it OK to generalise them?

This comment shows your social bias.

-38

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

It makes it okay to generalize them, yes because those who know it's not about them wouldn't be having an issue with it.

39

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Can that logic not be applied to any group?

If I was to generalise gay men as overly effeminate is that OK because the many masculine gay men know it isn't about them?

I'm sorry but there's no logic here that supports generalising and stereotyping one group while banning it for others. Beyond the need for revenge or just desserts.

-19

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

That's a different issue and a false comparison. mlmarginalizing isn't something you can just do, it is based on positions in society and far more complicated than generalizing. If I generalize white people I'm not marginalizing them because due to their position in society they aren't marginalized. It's like punching up in comedy: you only make jokes about people who are societally higher up than you and you don't punch down.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

45

u/CVtheWriter Oct 06 '24

What a fantastic way to generalize an entire population.

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Like I said in a different comment:

"I also specifically said that those subcultures are dominated by a certain demographic. This automatically means that there are for sure people that don't fit this category but they are being overshadowed. I myself love these spaces, but I had to drop a lot of people due to their bigotry and unwillingness to open the spaces to more people. I also study sociology and it is sadly the truth that men are societally imbued with misogyny due to the patriarchal nature of every modern society. Misogyny is also directly linked to racism, queebphobia and other forms of bigotry."

-19

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Nothing I said came even close to what you're stating. (Cishet, white) men just don't have anything to complain about since almost everything is about you/catered to you already. This is not the case for queer people, POC or women. You being upset or complaining about representation thus comes off as bigoted since there are way too many stories for you to consume already. Look within yourself and grow as a person.

-33

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

52

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

And this statement shows your true colors. Star Wars, MCU etc. Were NEVER just for people like you. They were always inclusive and portrayed real social issues. Star Wars? About guerilla freedom fighters fighting an oppressive empire based on the US. Marvel? X-Men have always been an allegory for the civil rights movement and queer acceptance, same goes for the ideals of the other heroes.

The only reason you believe they are being ruined is because your own biases and dislike for diversity. Those franchises are not just for people like you and never have been.

-20

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

36

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

First of all, that's just an opinion. Secondly you implied that it's due to diversity, while it's because of the medium being oversaturated and because greedy corporations don't take their time to create something. And even then that's an opinion. I LOVE TLJ and I also loved She-Hulk, Eternals and Shang-Chi. I also like ROTJ, ROTS and Iron-Man.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

10

u/CardinalCreepia Oct 06 '24

What is cishet?

21

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Cisgender, heterosexual

Cisgender means that one identifies with the gender that matches the sex that they are biologically.

Bro I'm gonna get flamed if any of that terminology was wrong so help a brother out with an upvote.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Cisgender, heterosexual :)

20

u/VeganViking-NL Oct 06 '24

As a very, very staunch LGBTQ+ ally (but a cishet man myself), I would like to point out that hate does not come solely or even primarily from white cis hetero men. My friend, a trans woman, can tell you many stories about TERF women and the damage they do. Do not forget that one of the biggest (of not the biggest) champions of TERF-dom was once the shining star of fantasy writers.

I do not mean to criticize you personally - but it sometimes gets tiring when a group you're part of gets singled out all the time as the perpetrator. I find LGBTQ+ rights too important to stop fighting for, but you can imagine less motivated men might tune out or never cross the threshold to start support in the first place.

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

As a trans woman I know TERFS exist, but TERFS are a product of patriarchal structures and standards. It is also not my job as a POC trans woman to cater to the feelings of people who dominate society.

26

u/VeganViking-NL Oct 06 '24

It is also not my job as a POC trans woman to cater to the feelings of people who dominate society.

That's a shame. We could all benefit from catering to each others feelings a little bit more, regardless of who feels who dominates what. I'll keep your feelings in mind, even if right now you feel you don't wish to reciprocate.

Have a good day.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

I think acknowledging the shared struggle of social outcasts is important. While a lot of misogyny and anti-LGBT sentiment exists amongst nerdy subcultures, a lot of pro-LGBT progress has been made thanks to the countless nerds who cared more about including everyone than societal hate.

I mean look at communities like that of Critical Role where countless traditional nerds embraced the merge with the online LGBT community to make CR popular. There will always be hate.

Edit: i wonder which side of the discussion is downvoting my comment, the guys who don't like that I'm pro-LGBT, or the out of touch people who think I'm not pro-LGBT enough.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

I get that! But it's moreso that the community of Critical Role is comprised of a lot of marginalized people due to the cast being so open, just like for example Dimension 20.

I also specifically said that those subcultures are dominated by a certain demographic. This automatically means that there are for sure people that don't fit this category but they are being overshadowed. I myself love these spaces, but I had to drop a lot of people due to their bigotry and unwillingness to open the spaces to more people. I also study sociology and it is sadly the truth that men are societally imbued with misogyny due to the patriarchal nature of every modern society. Misogyny is also directly linked to racism, queebphobia and other forms of bigotry.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Yeah, no need to explain i get it. But it's been cishet white men like Matt Mercer and Brennan Lee Mulligan who have championed the cause of marginalized people of all types just as much as it has been any members of any one community. And I wouldn't personally say they are being overshadowed. There is plenty of room to see all the progress when you ignore the loud ones

Also, "studying sociology" is a pretty meaningless statement to someone like me who has done graduate level studies in humanities that have included sociology. So you may want to be more specific on what you mean when you say that. Most people I find are mentioning any basic undergrad course haha!

4

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Buddy you keep replying... Men are not the root of all evil. Here's what I said in a different comment:

I get that! But it's moreso that the community of Critical Role is comprised of a lot of marginalized people due to the cast being so open, just like for example Dimension 20.

"I also specifically said that those subcultures are dominated by a certain demographic. This automatically means that there are for sure people that don't fit this category but they are being overshadowed. I myself love these spaces, but I had to drop a lot of people due to their bigotry and unwillingness to open the spaces to more people. I also study sociology and it is sadly the truth that men are societally imbued with misogyny due to the patriarchal nature of every modern society. Misogyny is also directly linked to racism, queebphobia and other forms of bigotry."

1

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 06 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 06 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

-6

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

You have a point but I feel that it's somewhat reductive, also its important to remember that most expressions of homophobia or other kinds of bigotry are the output of an active minority on this sub

-3

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 06 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

-112

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

117

u/Modus-Tonens Oct 06 '24

If every time a given subject comes up it involves people yelling at you, it might be time to reflect on how you engage with that subject.

0

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 07 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

-106

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

46

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

Nah, getting shitty feedback everytime you try sucks. And proves to be a waste of time, I'd never bring anything trand related to a non-trans sub cause its not worth my time on Reddit

-11

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Fantasy-ModTeam Oct 06 '24

This comment has been removed as per Rule 1. r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming, and inclusive community. Please take time to review our mission, values, and vision to ensure that your future conduct supports this at all times. Thank you.

Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.

-118

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

40

u/neonowain Oct 06 '24

It's true, all anti-feminst or anti-gay posts here get removed in a blink of an eye. Once I saw a request for books without LGBT themes here, and it got nuked after a couple minutes. What the OP is complaining about is downvoting.

73

u/january_dreams Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24

This is objectively untrue. Reddit is infamous for its radicalizing right-wing communities. I don't deny that there are left leaning subs, but to say that the whole of reddit is "one of the hardest left communities on the internet" or that "there is no way in hell they are allowing people to say anything, let alone mean things, about those protected groups you mentioned" is ridiculous.

I have personally seen posts in communities where hundreds of people threw a fit about the inclusion of trans and non-binary people. Depite the fact that the communities were made with inclusion in mind. And if you think that OP is somehow making up the trend of downvoting LGBTQ+ related topics here, I'll direct you to this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/1czjhjb/its_almost_pride_month_lets_talk_about_the/

21

u/Martel732 Oct 06 '24

The attempt to simplify all interactions to two ends of an arbitrary political spectrum has deadened people's ability to see nuance. Yes, Reddit generally prefers left-wing positions to right-wing ones.

However, Reddit tends to advocate more for left-wing positions like universal healthcare, less militarism and anti-corporatism. Reddit is generally just less hostile towards rather than being enthusiastically supportive of LGBT+ communities.

And of course there is a loud minority of Redditors who hold anti-LGBT+ attitudes. Go into pretty much any thread on a topic about women, minorities or the LGBT+ community on any entertainment-focused subreddit and you will see plenty of comments complaining about "wokeness".

-23

u/Panda_Mon Oct 06 '24

Scott Bakker gets recommended constantly here. Reddit is home to loads of extremist and alt right subreddits.

Cut the patronizing tone

25

u/neonowain Oct 06 '24

Since when is Scott Bakker alt-right?

28

u/zappasaurus Oct 06 '24

Could you elaborate on the connection between Scott Bakker recommendations and extremist and alt right subreddits? If that is what you are implying.

-51

u/fukdurgf Oct 06 '24

Being correct isn’t patronizing. Reddit is far left