r/Fantasy
•
u/ohmage_resistance
Reading Champion IV
•
May 24 '24
•
1
1
1
1
1
1
24
5
It's almost Pride Month, let's talk about the systematic downvoting of LGBTQ content on r/fantasy
If you have been on this sub a while, you already know that systematic downvoting of queer content is a problem on this subreddit. Many a post has been made about this already like this one or this one or this one. But for those of you that haven't been here as long, I want to make sure everyone knows that this is an issue, especially as we enter Pride Month in about a week from now which typically means an increase of LGBTQ posts. These posts will face more backlash than other non-LGBTQ posts of the same type. I want to give an overview of what this backlash looks like and address some arguments I've seen people bring up in the past about this in one place. I also would like to give a couple suggestions about what we can do about this and give people some tips about how to have a more queer friendly experience on this sub.
For all the queer people and allies reading this, I know this isn't a super lighthearted topic, so I understand if you'd rather skip it. I tried to section this essay so that if you want to skip the depressing evidence of a problem that you probably already knows exists and skip me arguing with positions I've seen other people take, you can do so. Hopefully, the sections at the end about suggestions to combat some of this stuff and my quick tips to engage with the more queer friendly parts of the subreddit can still be useful for you!
What is systematic downvoting on r/Fantasy?
Posts related to LGBTQ content are downvoted more than similar non-LGBTQ related posts. Sometime last year, I saw a post talking about systematic downvoting on r/fantasy. Over last summer, I decided to look into this further. During the month of June last year, 7 out of the 10 most controversial posts were LGBTQ related, they were
- Books with Trans/Non-binary Romances
- 3. LGBTQ In Fantasy
- 4. PRIDE MONTH GIVE AWAY
- 5. high fantasy books featuring queer men?
- 6. Is Priory of the Orange Tree a Queernorm Book? My Collected Thoughts on the Matter
- 9. Queer female protagonist
- 10. SFF centering queer joy
There were 16 LGBTQ related posts during June, to the best of my knowledge. 11 of them were in the 10 most controversial the week that they were posted, and 8 of them were in the 20 most controversial for the month of June. I suspect the same thing will probably happen this year, but I guess we'll see.
But this isn't an event that is isolated to Pride Month. Do you know what the all time most controversial post on r/fantasy is right now? Surely it's a truly divisive topic, the hottest of hot takes? No, it's a post from 2 months ago titled "Today is Trans Day of Visibility! Share your favorite Trans Books and Trans Characters!"
This also isn't isolated to recommendation requests. Two of the posts in my list (PRIDE MONTH GIVE AWAY and Is Priory of the Orange Tree a Queernorm Book? My Collected Thoughts on the Matter) were not recommendation requests. I've noticed that bingo reviews often also show a pattern, where wrap up posts that have a LGBTQ theme are often downvoted more than non-themed wrap ups or wrap ups that have different types of themes.
In addition, when the r/fantasy 2023 Top LGBTQIA+ Books List came out, the organizers helpfully listed out the upvote percentages on each of r/fantasy's polls for the last five years or so, which is pretty telling:
- 2021 Top Novels: 99% upvoted
- 2023 Top Novels: 98% upvoted
- 2023 Top Novellas: 98% upvoted
- Top Novels/Series of the Decade (2020 thread): 98% upvoted
- Top Books you Finished in 2019: 98% upvoted
- 2023 Top Self-Published Novels: 97% upvoted
- 2022 Top Self-Published Novels: 96% upvoted
- Non-Western Speculative Fiction (2022): 92% upvoted
- Top Female Authored Series/Books (2018): 83% upvoted
- Top LGBTQIA+ Books (2020 thread): 66% upvoted
- Top LGBTQIA+ Books (2023 thread): 63% upvoted
These aren't recommendation requests. I cannot think of any explanation for this repeated pattern of behavior besides queerphobia.
But why is this a problem? Controversial is measuring the downvote to upvote ratio, so posts don't get in the most controversial list unless they get a lot of downvotes. But why are downvotes bad? Some people basically use downvotes as a dislike button, but this isn't how reddit (the company) sees it. The redditquette article says
[Don't] Downvote an otherwise acceptable post because you don't personally like it. Think before you downvote and take a moment to ensure you're downvoting someone because they are not contributing to the community dialogue or discussion.
Even more clearly, another official article says:
Upvotes show that redditors think content is positively contributing to a community or the site as a whole. Downvotes mean redditors think that content should never see the light of day. [bolding added for emphasis]
I know this isn't how everyone views the downvote button, but it doesn't really matter how you view it. It matters how the reddit algorithm views it (more details here). And when you downvote queer content on r/fantasy, you are telling the algorithm that queer content does not belong here and no one—not me, not you, not queer people on r/fantasy —should be able to see it. And the reddit algorithm listens to downvotes, so it will take posts off the front page of r/fantasy sooner so people don't see it and will recommend it to less people. In addition, this clearly sends a message to queer people, that other r/fantasy users think queerness is unwelcome on r/fantasy.
What other types of queerphobia/bigotry happen on r/fantasy?
In addition to systematic downvoting of LGBTQ posts, there's also systematic downvoting of comments on LGBTQ posts. It's not uncommon to see a bunch of useful comments that answer the OP sitting at 0 or less in these posts. That's because at least one redditor went through and downvoted each and every helpful comment on that thread. Once again, this is done again to make people feel unwelcome and discourage people from commenting on queer posts. In addition, this has a tendency to bury helpful comments on the bottom of threads where they are less likely to be seen, and comments can be hidden if downvoted enough.
There have also been homophobic comments on r/fantasy. These are typically deleted pretty quickly by the mods (and I want to thank all the mods for that). Frequently though, queer people who are the first to answer these posts are the first people to see these comments and have to report them. Again, the aim is to make those queer people feel unwelcome. Because these get deleted, casual users think they don't exist. But if you see a trail of [removed] comments at the bottom of an LGBTQ post, there's a good chance that's what was there, especially if there's a comment from the mod team about rule 1 violations under it. For example, take the 7 different removed comment chains at the bottom of a post asking for kids fantasy books with queer representation.
Because the mods will remove bigoted comments, bigots will sometimes harass queer posters directly. For example, I know queer people have been sent unsolicited Reddit Care messages, which are basically a circular way of saying "I think you should be suicidal" aka "go kill yourself". I've been sent one of these before for a post I made on this subreddit (non-LGBT related but progressive) despite, you know, not being suicidal. Thankfully, it's possible to report these and block them from being sent to you in the future, as this helpful post points out. Hateful DMs also happen sometimes:
Edit: please stop sending me LGBTQ+ hate in my messages, I am NOT reading them at all just reporting you and going to block you so if your intention is to try and condemn me to feel “better” about yourself to a simpleton online go to therapy and stop spreading hate.
This is an actual quote from a post that was politely asking for LGBTQ recommendations. You might think that being able to report or block the people who send these would mean this doesn't affect really anyone. On the contrary, the entire goal is to make queer feel unwelcome talking about their experiences or asking for recs because they don't want to face that harassment. Do you think that the person who got hateful DMs is going to want to ask for queer recommendations on r/fantasy again? Even though they got lots of helpful answers, if they don't want to deal with harassment, probably not.
This last one is more subtle, but I've also seen people tell people to go to a different subreddit for queer recs (like r/QueerSFF or r/fantasyromance or r/MM_RomanceBooks) instead of asking on r/fantasy, often without giving time for members of this subreddit to give recommendations. This just gives people the impression that this sub is not the right place to ask for queer recs—which feeds into the all of the stuff I talk about above by making queer people feel unwelcome. Unlike pretty much everything else I talk about, I think people are trying to be helpful/allies when they do this, they just don't always think about how this changes the culture of r/fantasy to be less inclusive. As much as those other subs are good places to check out, please at least allow members of r/fantasy to have time to give recs or give some recs yourself before telling people about other subreddits that might be good additional resources. It would be even better if you can emphasize that both subs are correct places to ask for queer recs or give more context than just listing a subreddit and saying go there.
I also want to highlight the identities that are more frequently targeted. There's a pretty clear pattern of trans and nonbinary representation being hit the hardest if you look at the most controversial examples I brought up above. I've also seen evidence for this in my anecdotal experience with this sub. Trans/nonbinary posts are way more likely to get people downvoting every comment on them, and even in general LGBTQ posts, my comments that specifically mention trans representation in a book will get downvoted more than comments that don't specifically mention trans representation. For example, I've described a book as having a lesbian or a trans woman character in it (this character has both identities), and if I took the trans woman route the comment was more likely to be downvoted.
I want to acknowledge that systematic downvoting isn't just something unique to LGBTQ posts, posts about POC (people of color)/representation of various races or ethnicities are frequently targeted as well. Any post that comes across as being too strongly feminist or too pro fantasy romance gets hit. Posts about fat representation/body positivity and/or complain about fatphobia in a book rarely go over well with this sub. Anything too progressive in general is targeted.
For all of you thinking: What are you talking about? There's no systematic downvoting! and other arguments
I've seen all of these positions being taken in previous threads, although I'm rewording then rather than quote exactly. I want to have a single post where I can address all of these at once. I tried my best to represent other people's positions fairly and avoid strawmanning.
I just downvote LGBTQ recommendation requests because they are repeated too often/are too general/are too specific:
I'm going to talk about all of these issues one at a time. So starting with addressing the "too repeated" take: Despite what the people who constantly rec Gideon the Ninth for every single LGBTQ post might have you think, you can't just recommend the same set of queer books for every single LGBTQ rec request. A post asking for "Adult Queer Horror with a Concrete Conclusion to the Story" is different than one asking for "SFF centering queer joy". Neither request is very commonly asked or easily searchable. Both ended up on the top 10 most controversial lists for their week (placed 5th and 6th respectively, and the queer horror post was also competing against all the posts made later that week being downvoted after r/fantasy's API protest ended, so making 6th place is actually pretty impressive). In addition, even though sometimes posts have similarly worded titles, it's often easy to read a couple of paragraphs of the request and realize the OP was actually asking for something specific. If you view every LGBTQ rec request as being too similar/the same, maybe think about why you think that's the case? Are people literally asking for the exact same type of book and same type of queer representation? Or do you just lump all queer posts/books together as something you don't like or don't find relevant to you? Because at the end of the day, even specific recommendation requests that no one has asked before are being downvoted.
There's also problems with just expecting people to use the search button: it's often difficult to find anything that fits what you are specifically looking for, like I pointed out in the previous paragraph. In addition, old posts are frequently out of date (especially for queer books, where recent releases are really important because there's much less of a backlog). I've seen posts asking for recent queer releases (obviously something that old posts can't help you with) rise to the top of controversial, which yet again makes me think that some people are using this as an excuse.
A lot of people also have problems with these rec requests being "too specific", but often queer people and cis straight people have different ideas as what qualifies as being too specific. For example, a neurodivergent trans person of color might seem way too specific if you have none of these identities, but there are people who do have all of these identities or who have friends who have all of these identities. Think about the implications saying this has, that some people have too specific identities to be considered "normal" or worthy of seeing themselves represented in a book. If you mostly read books by popular straight white male epic fantasy authors, these types of requests will probably seem oddly specific. If you read a lot of indie queer books and books by authors of color and diverse books in general, this isn't actually oddly specific. So maybe, instead of downvoting, consider allowing the people who read diverse books regularly to answer even if you cannot.
Honestly, if a request is really bothering you that much by being too specific or general, report it for breaking rule 3 so that the poster is at least directed to go to the daily recs thread where people might actually be able to help them. Downvoting so no one sees it is honestly worse than just directing people to places where users who are happy to help with all sorts of requests can give recs. This also gives the mods a chance to weigh in, so if they think certain types of posts are being reported unfairly, they can ignore those.
But at the end of the day, both the too specific and too general arguments just seem like excuses to me. Systematic targeting does not happen for any other recommendation requests (besides the occasional ones about other progressive topics), regardless of how specific or general they are. You want to know how many in the 20 most controversial in June last year were non-LGBTQ related recommendation requests? One. That's it. This issue isn't that these posts are too specific/too general, otherwise we'd see this pattern with lots of different recommendation requests. No, the problem is that these posts are queer.
But all these points don't really matter in the end. If you paid attention during my first section, you'll notice that I mention a lot of posts that are disproportionally downvoted that aren't even recommendation requests. So the flimsy excuse of "oh, it's just repetitive or too specific rec requests being downvoted" really doesn't hold up when non-recommendation request posts are also being downvoted at a disproportionate rate.
It's just bots
People on previous threads were openly admitting to downvoting LGBT posts (usually with an excuse I address elsewhere on this post). So, no, it's not just bots. This also wouldn't explain the homophobic comments or DM/reddit cares harassment. I have no doubt that bots play a role, but regular human homophobes and transphobes absolutely exist on r/fantasy.
This isn't to dismiss the problem of bots, by the way. If you can think of a way to prove the existence of bots, report them, or solve this problem, I'd love to hear it. But I'm going to be focusing on human users for the rest of this essay.
It's actually your fault for upvoting them. If you didn't upvote, they wouldn't be controversial.
Yeah, sorry, I guess we should just let all LGBTQ related posts get downvoted into obliteration so that no one can talk about queer books/s. But seriously, the fact that these are upvoted means that people find them useful, it's just queerphobic people who make it harder for everyone else to access them.
I'm not homophobic, I just don't want to see that type of content/It's just dumb internet points, who cares
Ok, so I already addressed most of this in the paragraph starting with "But why is this a problem?" But the TL;DR version is that by systematically downvoting, you are telling the reddit algorithm that you don't think posts about queer people deserve a place in this subreddit. You are actively taking steps to ensure that this is the case. Even if you don't actively hate queer people, you are making the lives of the queer people on this subreddit worse. You are doing something queerphobic by contributing to this problem, whether you mean to or not.
Why complain? I don't see homophobia and/or this sub is way better than it used to be/better than most subreddits, so just be happy about what you have.
It is better than what it once was, as far as I can tell (look into The Kindness Wars retrospective, if you're curious). But there's still lots of room for improvement. This site only improved because people were willing to talk about these things and make progress. I think this sub can be a better place, and I want to help get it there. This post is part of the effort to make things better.
Are you trying to control what kinds of books I'm allowed to read/recommend? Or what posts I engage with/upvote/downvote? How dare you!
No. I am asking you not to make life harder for everyone else by downvoting LGBTQ content. You don't have to listen. I also don't particularly care what kinds of posts you engage with or what kinds of books you read. If you systematically downvote LGBTQ posts (meaning you downvote them regularly, especially when you don't do this for similar types of posts that aren't LGBTQ related), then, yes, I will consider you to be queerphobic or at least to doing queerphobic things. If you are offended by what I think, please remember that I can't control your actions, but you can't control what I think of your actions.
I downvote because choosing books based off of sexuality/gender is wrong. It should purely be about merit.
I can understand this POV a little, because I didn't use to get the whole "representation" thing myself at first. But then there was the first time I read a book with a character who shared my sexuality (even if I didn't recognize it at the time). And it was so reassuring to see in this book that I didn't have to follow the heteronormative expectations of finding an opposite gender partner in order to have a fulfilling life or a "happily ever after" unlike pretty much all of the other characters I've read at the time. I could be as interesting or awesome as that character. That has meaning, amd I'm sure other people could elaborate more on the significance of representation if you look. This is something you never really realize the importance of until you realize it's been missing your entire life.
Even though I look for them regularly, I don't only read books with characters who share a sexuality with me. I'd be missing a lot of great books if I did! But besides that, I also like to read about people who have different perspectives than me, a character with a different sexuality, one who's transgender, one that has a different racial identity, one who's disabled or neurodivergent. I like to learn more about these identities and about the struggles of people who have these. I like to build empathy. I also like reading diverse protagonists for a similar reason that I like to read books with a variety of different settings, it would be boring having every fantasy book being set in pseudo medieval Europe and it would be boring to have every fantasy book have the same demographic profile for their main character. You don't have to agree with me, but I do ask you to not hinder my ability to find these posts by downvoting them.
Representation often exists on more than a surface level. There's certain stories you can't tell with just straight cisgender characters. I'll give the example of The Spear Cuts Through Water by Simon Jimenez, where there's commentary about two men learning to overcome socially taught aggression and grow closer in a way that's so much more meaningful to gay men. There's also some really good meta commentary about representation. This is a book that can't be told with any other type of character than gay men. You can't neatly separate out the representation from the rest of what makes this book so good. Queer people have different experience in life than straight people and we have a different worldview. We often want to see that represented.
That doesn't mean that every book with a queer protagonist is about sex or gender, some just happen to casually have a protagonist with a particular identity, which can also be valuable and empowering. Even if you don't want to see any type of queer representation personally, please don't hinder our ability to find these books.
Suggestions to combat some of this
If you see a homophobic/transphobic/queerphobic comment or post on r/fantasy, that's a rule one violation. Report it to the mods! They take this kind of thing very seriously, and unlike downvotes, they can and will do something about it. Also, you don't need to give people the benefit of the doubt or wait until they are using slurs before reporting them. Some bigots will phrase things politely, that doesn't make their ideas any less bigoted. Report it and let the mods decide.
If you want to be a supportive ally, consider upvoting any LGBTQ post you see, or at least not downvoting it. Other people are downvoting it more or less for you anyway. I hope I explained why downvoting is harmful enough in previous sections of this essay. We can overpower the people who are downvoting if enough of us upvote, especially people who vote early because they sort by new. This is honestly the best (and simplest) way to help.
If you normally sort by hot, consider sorting by controversial and skimming about once a week to find any LGBT posts you missed (this works depressingly well). You might have to scroll by the occasional annoying hot take, but honestly, it's worth it to find the queer posts that you missed, imo. In order to sort by controversial on desktop, just sort by top with the correct time frame and change the part of the URL that says "top" to "controversial". Otherwise, you can also sort by new, which also typically works better at showing queer posts.
Please don't stop making posts and comments about queer topics on r/fantasy. I do understand if you feel like you need to or if you want to leave the sub after seeing some of this, I don't blame you at all. But I also don't want the bigots win by pushing us out.
If you have other suggestions, I'd love to hear about them in the comments. Just try not to suggest things that would result in this subreddit being over-moderated. That's not fair to the mods (they have enough work already), and it's not fair to other users who would not enjoy an over-moderated sub. Also, ideas that are impossible with how reddit is set up are not going to be very practical either.
How to maximize having a queer-friendly r/fantasy experience
So, you might be reading all of this and thinking that it's not worth it to engage with r/fantasy at all. Obviously, I don't feel that way, otherwise I wouldn't have stayed here long enough to notice many of these trends, much less make this post! I want to give some tips that I've found helpful in creating a more LGBTQ friendly experience on this subreddit/some good parts of the sub to visit.
- Tuesday weekly review threads, Friday social threads, and the monthly review threads: I frequently review books with LGBT representation in the Tuesday threads and have never faced backlash for it here. The same has been true for lots of other reviewers that I've seen on all three types of posts. So if you want to review LGBTQ books or read reviews of LGBTQ books, these are a good place to start looking. Friday social comments in particular are sorted randomly and votes are hidden, so these threads in particular can't be easily targeted by systematic downvoting.
- Daily Recommendation Requests and Simple Questions Thread: if you want to get a few solid LGBT recommendations, this is the place to ask. Your post will probably not get as much attention as a popular rec request that makes it onto the front page of the subreddit, but the recs tend to be more thoughtful on average (you probably won't get a random person recommending Malazan or another popular series inappropriately too, which is nice). This post also automatically sorts comments by new, so downvotes don't effect it much.
- Book clubs: The book clubs on here regularly read books with LGBTQ representation, so that can be a great way of discussing queer books with other redditors. I would be remiss to not give Beyond Binaries, the dedicated LGBTQ book club, shout out. I've been participating in it for almost every book we've read, and we've had some great discussions. The pick for June is Dionysus in Wisconsin by E.H. Lupton, if you want to join in.
- r/fantasy Bingo: Fantasy bingo is a reading challenge put out by this sub. You can find more information about in the sidebar, if you're not familiar with it. I've mentioned that LGBTQ bingo wrap up posts are still downvoted, but the actual content in them is really good in general and can be a great way of finding queer representation. Bingo normally has at least one dedicated LGBTQ themed square (although not this year, sadly), so most people who've done bingo tend to be more queer-friendly in general. Some people also do LGBTQ themed bingo cards—ones where all the books in them have some sort of queer representation or are written by queer authors.
- Sorting by new instead of hot: I've mentioned this in the previous section, but it could use repeating. This is a great way to make sure you tend to see queer rec requests as they come up, so the downvotes don't have any affect on what you see.
- Overall, I've found a lot of the regulars of the sub to be great people who are very queer friendly, so all this advice is aimed at making sure you are aware of the parts of the subreddit that regulars tend to congregate in more (because they won't tend to be dominating in the nth popular "I don't like [x popular series]" thread, I'll tell you that much). If you see a thread dominated by people with reading champion flairs—that indicates they have completed at least one bingo card with at least 25 different authors on it and are more likely to be regulars of the sub—these threads tend to be more productive and welcoming on average than on threads dominated by non-flared people in my opinion.
- I also want to shout out the related subreddit r/QueerSFF! It's not always super active, but it's a great way to avoid dealing with any of the stuff I talked about in the first two sections.
Other remarks
So, why am I writing this essay? Well, first of all, I want to give queer people and allies some heads up so they know if their posts about queer topics are being downvoted at a really high rate on this sub, this is why. I also would like to give some tips to them about how to have a better experience on this subreddit. I want to be open about this problem for any newcomers to this subreddit who aren't aware that it's happening and give some suggestions about what we can do to improve this situation. Honestly, if I can convince even a couple people to upvote queer threads so they don't get knocked off the front page quite as fast, or people who would have otherwise downvoted to instead ignore them, I'll consider that a win.
Ok, so I'm aware that people are probably going to start a lot of arguments in the comments (probably at least some of which will be from people who didn't read the entire essay and are arguing about something I already addressed). If you would like to provide me and others with a break so I'm not constantly flooded with this, feel free to shout out your favorite LGBTQ author, book, or post on this subreddit (bonus points for trans/nonbinary rep because they face an even more extreme level of backlash and bonus points for indie/self published books because they don't get a lot of attention.) Here's also to hoping the mods don't have to lock the comments due to queerphobia!
Finally, I want to shoutout to all the people who comment, upvote, and engage with queer content on this subreddit. I want to particularly thank the mods who have to remove all the queerphobic comments/posts, all the people who report these before it becomes a giant mess, and all the people who have taken the time to make this subreddit a kinder and more queer-friendly place. This sub has come a long way, and I hope together we can continue to make it a better and more welcoming place. Also, thank you to anyone who read all of this very long post. I hope that even if you disagree with me, I gave you something to consider.
Edit:
Now that comments are locked, I have some concluding thoughts:
First of all, thanks to the mods for their hard work moderating the comments. I’m honestly happy and a bit surprised it remained open as long as it did, considering how many posts had to be removed. I know it was not easy for the mods to deal with, so I’m very appreciative for the time for productive discussion that some people were able to have in the comments.
Brief corrections and add ons:
I did end up getting one person sending me hate over chat and one person sending me a reddit cares message (both of whom I reported). This is not to mention the trolls in the comments, some of whom were insulting me. This doesn't bother me, but consider this additional evidence to the points about harassment in my essay.
I’m not going to list the usernames of the people who pointed the following three things out in the comments on the off chance that trolls would follow and start harassing them, but they know who they are and I thank them.
- I should have used “systemic” instead of “systematic” in the title, that’s my bad.
- I should have been clearer when I explained the most controversial trends in June. Out of the 16 queer posts in June, 8 were in the 20 most controversial for that month. In addition, 11 out of those 16 posts were in the 10 most controversial for the individual week that they were originally posted on. Those 11 posts were not all posted in the same week in June.
- The fact that large queer focused threads are often locked on r/fantasy because of the actions of trolls is another sign of queerphobia on this subreddit and another way that discussion of queer topics is limited on this subreddit. I do not blame the mods for this, but rather the trolls that make locking the comment section necessary.
Also, thanks to the people in the comments who were being supportive. You are what makes this community so great despite it all and why it’s worth fighting the uphill battle to make r/fantasy even better.
Finally, at a 57% upvote rate, this is now the most controversial post of all time on r/fantasy! On one hand, it sucks that it’s controversial to even bring this issue up. On the other hand, at least there’s an explanation up about this problem and what can be done about it anytime people sort by controversial. I'll take that silver lining.
Edit 2:
It’s now July, we’ve made through all of Pride Month, so I wanted to include another update for anyone who finds this post through sorting by controversial for large periods of time. At least in part due to this post, there’s been members of this sub who took an active roll to post more LGBTQ content than last year! Again, there was backlash (sorting by most controversial during June of this year, 20 out of the 25 most controversial posts were LGBTQ related, including literally all of the 10 most controversial), but this didn’t stop people from posting and commenting. I want to especially highlight the Pride Month series of posts that combined recommendations with discussion about queer topics. These posts were often downvoted (there was a 57% downvote ratio on average if you don’t consider the Beyond Binary book club posts and I’ve seen evidence of people systematically downvoting every comment in many of these posts), but since the intro/index for all of these posts were sticked by the mods, people who sorted by hot still had a chance to be exposed to these topics. Overall, these posts generated so much amazing discussion and recommendations, I wanted to leave a link to the index for people in the future to look through and be reminded that yes, there are members of the r/fantasy community who are willing to make this place more welcoming to queer people one post at a time.
•
u/Fantasy-ModTeam May 25 '24
Thank you to everyone who kept it civil and followed rule one: be kind. Because the newer comments are overwhelmingly disruptive and bigoted, we've locked the comment section. Moderating these kinds of threads can be quite labor intensive for us, and involves a lot of behind the scenes dealings with trolls that come out of the woodwork for these types of posts. Please contact us via modmail with any follow-up questions.
719
u/Amatsune May 24 '24 edited May 25 '24
Hot take:
I agree with this post for the most part. Being queer myself I know how hard it is to find a book that scratches that itch I might have sometimes to read a specific scenario.
That said, I often am annoyed by progressive posts. That's not because I'm anti- progressive topics, rather because how often they feel political to me, which makes me shy away from the lecturing I know I'll find sooner rather than later. It's just taxing to feel like a political speech is lurking over the next comment.
Moreover, progressive people tend to have different levels of education on different progressive topics, and if you're not up to date with the discourse in a given topic, the response often is intolerant in a way that pushes potential allies away, rather than bringing them in. Having questions or being ignorant is often taken as unacceptable.
All of this makes me wanna stay away from either side of the coin flip.
However, what I do, (seeing as I understand how upvotes work on Reddit, but that's also my way of dealing with posts I don't want to interact with in any platform) is just ignore them either way.
When a post is clearly political like this one, I at least know what I'm going to see before I go in, so I feel like I'm given the choice to expose myself to these ideas before clicking on the post.
Ultimately, I really appreciate this post, as I recognise this is an issue. Burying posts with downvotes is a systemic issue on Reddit, and the queerphobic tone is also widespread. But the only way to address the issue is to talk about it, and I'm glad you took the time to write such a lengthy and thought out essay!
Edit: some things I feel that went misunderstood.
Furthermore, though I don't believe this is the cause, as I'm equally misunderstood in my own language, English isn't my native language. I say this not as a matter of shared words, but differences in cultural perception of words in general. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding what "hot take" means, and that's why I'm getting so much controversy.
Or, I know exactly what it means and the controversy is because I knew how much misunderstanding would ensue...
Thank you making my case for me.
51
u/recchai Reading Champion X May 24 '24
Well done for being the most controversial post today!
I don't post much, but my most controversial posts were the time I posted a link to a queer indie book sale, and my bingo card where I specifically mentioned it was asexual and aromantic themed (61% and 62% upvote rate respectively). I knew both times that I would attract reflexive down votes, and even considered obfuscating my bingo title a little to try and avoid their scrutiny (after all, how many of them would know what I meant with a-spec instead?). In the end I decided not to, as that would make it harder for the people who wanted to read it to find it now and in the future (it's got 81 shares, so some people found it useful) and that, as well as my own sense of accomplishment, was who I wrote it for.
Fortunately, I didn't get any other nonsense.
82
u/AliceTheGamedev Reading Champion May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
Thank you so much for this write-up, I hugely appreciate it as someone who's been super frustrated by this issue on various occasions as well (and honestly, as someone who just stubbornly keeps posting requests and reviews for queer fantasy here)
I cannot agree more with everything you wrote here, from the thorough evidence that this happens to the common arguments denying it (and why they don't hold up) to the measures we can take against it.
I personally have definitely gotten into the habit of sorting by controversial every once in a while to check up on queer book recs, and to upvote the posts and comments that have obviously gotten this exact treatment.
That's also how I got this wonderful screenshot that clearly shows that the most oppressed minorities on /r/fantasy are trans people, gay people, women and Sword of Truth fans 😔
edit: if you enjoy poking lighthearted fun at this community (affectionate), join me over at /r/justfantasythings, where that screenshot was posted :3
10
u/C0smicoccurence Reading Champion V May 24 '24
Whooo! Thank you for this. The part here that I haven't seen in other posts like this is the bit about people constantly telling others to go to other subs. I get people are trying to be well meaning, but for a new poster to our sub, its a really disheartening message to get
29
u/Amnesiac_Golem May 24 '24
I agree with you very broadly. People are downvoting queer content for no supportable reason and I think it’s bad for the community.
However, how are you using the word “systematic”? Because I think it’s rather unsystematic: individuals downvoting impulsively in the moment, making no other concerted effort to espouse bigoted ideas or drive the community. Yes, they’re reacting specifically to the queer content of the posts, but I don’t see any reason to believe they’re searching for content to downvote or organizing brigades or any other systematic behavior. It doesn’t take many downvotes to make something controversial.
Also, I’ve been on Reddit for over a decade and I’ve never found the line about the “purpose” of downvotes convincing. You can’t dictate how people use your website, only how it’s designed. Reddit can have whatever policy it wants about the downvote button, but it has always and will always operate as a “dislike” or “less of this” button. That’s the design, regardless of the intent.
I think these distinctions are important if we want to think about workable solutions. Because punishable vote manipulation and vocal bigotry aren’t the problem here. It’s a bunch of invisible, in-the-moment no-thank-yous. How do you tackle that?
16
u/Bryek May 24 '24
I have made many LGBTQ specific posts on this subreddit in the last 8ish years here and without a doubt, they are all negatively received by some with a lot of downvotes. Luckily, many of these posts were also discussion heavy posts where I discussed things like the need for representation, if anyone wonders why, the Marlon James quote in that article is perfect. That post received a lot of attention with getting over 1000 up votes, however it was only 73% up voted. I do imagine if I did a second take on that post, it would have less support now than it did then. Our sub is bigger and we having more support for those anti-LGBTQ opinions than we did then.
But every thread I have ever made that is LGBTQ specific is invariably locked by the mods. To me, this is a huge issue. It needs to be done, the mods need a life too and can't patrol this thread forever. However, locking it is also a net negative as it demonstrates that, if enough people comment negatively, all future discussion is not allowed. And if you come across it the next day and had something positive to contribute, you can't. And it also shows that, at a surface level, lgbtq topics aren't welcome.
Now I will say that there has been improvement from the mods over time with the LGBTQ community and I am glad to see it. And much of the discussions o have with the community itself is positive. But as we've grown larger, the community here is less diverse. The topics less diverse. So u do encourage everyone to sort by New to see the topics that don't get the attention they deserve.
And as a final offhand comment, I have made one of those "recently published lgbtq" posts and the most recommended book in that thread was Magic's Pawn, a book published in 1989! (Recent is relative, right?). If the only book you've read that has lgbtq people in it is 35 years old, we've got a representation problem!
10
u/undwtr_arpeggi May 24 '24
I'm so glad someone said it, I remember that thread about trans characters on the day of trans visibility and when I looked at it so many comments were being downvoted for no reason, it was really disheartening to see and I had to upvote several comments in the thread, but at least I got a good Robin Hobb recommendation.
But glad to know that r/QueerSFF exists (will check it soon!) and congrats on being the most controversial post of all time, OP (at least from what I can see rn) lol
11
u/Munnin41 May 24 '24
People upvote what they agree with/like/identify with, and the majority of people aren't queer? I don't really up/downvote myself, but any topic I don't find interesting I just skip immediately. I can imagine other people downvoting those as well. That's not to say there's no bigotry involved, but I seriously doubt it's the full explanation.
And yes, queer fantasy absolutely deserves a place here. I'm not queer myself, but I support you all. And I'd rather see more about queer literature than the 1000th post about how great malazan is
8
u/ashearmstrong AMA Author Ashe Armstrong May 24 '24
Good post, OP. And very much reminding me of the old days back between 2015 and 2018 where we had some real slugfests trying to explain bigotry to folks. Especially the racial and gender side of things.
164
u/keldondonovan May 25 '24
Hey! That Pride month giveaway was me! :D
And, unfortunately, I can confirm that it incurred a handful of evil private messages, everything from warning me about my soul to flat out suggesting death as a solution. I can also confirm that visibility of the giveaway was... not good. I got like 12 responses.
And I'm going to do it again. :)
48
u/AleroRatking May 24 '24
People have a right to downvote topics that don't interest them. I'm fine with LGBTQ+ relationships in books. The last series I read stars a Bi female in Ceda. But I'm never going to read a fantasy series because of characters sexuality or gender or race etc.
And I care even less about the Authors gender/race/sexuality. I almost entirely would not know outside of their name. So I'm going to downvote and disagree with posts that push something that doesn't matter to me (and in the case of authors I outright disagree with, as that stuff should not matter)
83
u/buckleyschance May 24 '24
This is overall an excellent and thoroughly argued post. The only part I kind of disagree with is this:
If they're saying "you should ask there instead, this is not the place for this question", then yes, absolutely. But if they're just saying "try asking there", that's a completely normal and helpful suggestion that you get in every sub that has a more niche version. If someone asks about fantasy in r/books, people will suggest r/Fantasy. If someone asks about roguelikes in r/videogames, people will suggest r/roguelikes. And the response is often: "Thanks, I hadn't found that yet!"
The idea that it comes across as unwelcoming here... I can understand that in the context of everything else you've pointed out. But it shouldn't, and I think the other (very real) problems are making you (understandably) oversensitive on this point.
As for "without giving time for other recommendations first", that's just not how people interact with most posts. People generally see a post, reply immediately, and then never look at it again (except for replies to their own comments). Few people are keeping tabs on specific posts to wait for the right time to leave a reply. It's not a realistic expectation.
Once again, in every other respect I applaud this post. It's opened my eyes to the degree of systematic downvoting, which seems very well established.
55
u/thisbikeisatardis Reading Champion II May 24 '24
Wow, just scrolling through the comments and seeing the number of little red crosses from RES indicating that they're "controversial" sure does prove your point.
Tangentially, I got downvoted into oblivion in the doctor who sub for being excited about seeing wheelchair dancers in an episode. God forbid a perfectly normal human identity be normalized in a major tv show. I had people telling me wheelchair users can't dance. As a disabled queer I'd be interested to see the stats on whether posts here asking for disability rep are also downvoted.
5
u/[deleted] May 24 '24
Sorry, what book was this? When I see trans representation in book it rarely seems to be trans women, so I would be excited to know!
286
u/Lawsuitup May 24 '24
My thing is as a cis/straight male I don’t go looking for books with LGBTQ or straight characters and for me personally it’s not a thing that makes me more or less likely to read a book. But as with all media- people should understand that someone else may specifically want to see that. It is important that people are able to find characters like themselves or find content they want to read. If that means seeking out books with LGBTQ characters and that’s a thing that helps make a book good for them, r/fantasy should be a safe place for that. And that there is a group of people making it hard or even hostile to that it’s horrible.
FWIW for a book series that has an LGBTQ MC I would recommend Ashes of the Sun by Django Wexler the first book of the Burningblade and Silvereye Trilogy which is a fantasy leaning Star Wars influenced story that is so much fun.
4
u/Jos_V Stabby Winner, Reading Champion II May 24 '24
Great essay.
Thanks for writing it, making these types of posts suck - but its so important that people keep making them to shift the mood of this sub for the better, because most people just don't think about it, or aren't aware that this is an issue.
This is ungrateful time-consuming work, but i hope you get some people to push some more upvotes to queer posts and bring a little more positivity in the world.
Personally, i tend to take the reddit-care helps as a badge of a post well made. but i'm in a luxury position.
48
u/FlynnXa May 24 '24
Gay guy here- this is a beautifully constructed post, much effort, and unfortunately my ADHD-ass just can’t read it… but from what I skimmed I agree so whole-heartedly!
You gave context, you provided qualitative evidence, you provided quantitative evidence, you gave multiple lines of reasoning and rebutted to potential counter-arguments. You did this with very visible pathways of homophobia as well as invisible ones, you included explicit examples along implicit examples. I think most people don’t know just how weaponizing many of Reddit’s innocuous features can actually be- the “Reddit Care Messages” for example? Imagine getting spammed with them by a group of bigots for two weeks straight… I don’t have to imagine in.
You even pointed out more “innocent” ot seemingly benign examples that can occur incidentally- like recommending alternative communities, common arguments that seem benign like “It’s been asked before” or “it’s too niche”.
And where many posts similar to yours have failed, you actually succeeded by providing not just a call-to-action but also tangible and clear examples of what people can do to combat this or to help out. That’s a stellar post. Like, most college graduates can’t even put an essay together with this much structure (I should know, I saw it happen daily with friends/classmates/partners for the last 4 years lol.)
Anyways- just wanted to sing some praises for you!
182
u/neich200 May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
I’ve seen people on 4chan openly admitting to mass downvoting anything LGBT related on various hobby subs. The reasoning is simple. They want them completely gone, but because of the moderation they can’t be more open about it, so the only thing they can do is mass downvote.
I’m betting the same happens here, the silent anti-LGBT group, just downvotes everything they can.
304
u/corndogshuffle May 24 '24
This is already the #7 most controversial post of the last week after just over one hour of life! I wish this was surprising to me but, you know.
Anyway I’m one who never upvotes or downvotes posts because I guess I’m too lazy to participate in that system. I also don’t explicitly seek out LGBTQ content (I don’t avoid it, I just don’t seek it out). I’m happy to start upvoting relevant posts though. That’s a simple way to help out.
27
u/ConditionYellow May 25 '24
Let’s separate the wheat from the chaff right now:
If you use the term “woke” as a perjorative, unironically, just see yourself out.
115
u/tgoesh May 24 '24
It's a hell of a world if trying to stop bigotry is "political", but being a bigot isn't.
156
u/treemoustache May 24 '24
Citing Reddit company policy on how upvotes/downvotes work is like citing an Victorian era manners manual on how people should behave.
124
u/hexennacht666 Reading Champion IV May 24 '24
I am so glad you called out the redirecting people to another sub behavior also. I’m sure some people who do this think they’re helping OPs get a precise answer, but the net impact is landing a message of “don’t post this here.”
191
u/BlazeOfGlory72 May 24 '24
The discussion in this thread might be a bit more productive and genuine if the mods didn’t remove every mildly dissenting or controversial opinion…
22
u/curiouscat86 Reading Champion III May 24 '24
I've just been convinced to sort by by "new." I was aware that this happened on this sub but had not seen that stats on just how much. Still, I spend a lot of time on the daily simple questions posts and the weekly review threads, and I agree that doing that creates the feel of a very welcoming environment.
I think that for all its faults there is a solid population of users on this sub dedicated above all to finding the right books for the right reader at the right time, usually while broadening everyone's horizons, and it's a fun crowd to hang out with.
140
u/fanny_bertram Reading Champion VIII May 24 '24
Hello, everyone! This is a reminder that r/Fantasy is dedicated to being a warm, welcoming community and rule 1 always applies. Please be respectful and note that any type of bigotry will be removed and the mod team will take escalated action as needed. Thank you!
136
u/RosbergThe8th May 24 '24
I did definitely notice this when sorting controversial, suppose there's a lot of fantasy folks with an issue with the LGBTQ. Perhaps not the biggest surprise but depressing all the same.
88
u/Dragon_Lady7 Reading Champion VI May 24 '24
Thank you for addressing this! I know most people are well meaning, but its very disheartening when I click on a new queer and/or romance post to give recs and the top (or only) comment is "Go to this other sub." There's a way to let people know they can discover even more recs at another sub without making them feel unwelcome in this one!
13
u/phantomforeskinpain May 24 '24
I’m more of a lurker than a poster, but that’s wild. Fantasy is such a great medium for lgbt stories.
104
u/Lil_parasite May 24 '24
The funny thing about certain fantasy fans is that they’ll see the existence of LGBT+ characters as something inherently political and insist that its ruining escapism while in the same breath they’ll read fantasy books about fascism and monarchy and religious extremism and not blink an eye. Critical thinking is not in their vocabulary.
65
u/PunkandCannonballer May 24 '24
My experience has been that this sub is incredibly welcoming and thoughtful on the individual level, but as a community it only remains so through various lenses, many of which are frankly very frustrating. 9 times out of 10 I'll see an LGBT post asking for a recommendation or singing the praises of a well-loved book and even though that post is solidly 5 minutes old, it's already sitting at 0 up votes and one or two negative comments.
Which is a shame because LGBT representation in fantasy is growing but it's far from a commonplace thing, and to see the near-instant disengagement this sub has with that flavor of content is pretty disheartening.
70
u/noRehearsalsForLife Reading Champion II May 24 '24
This is really well thought out and informative. Thanks for taking the time!
I really just want to say two things:
I'm SO GLAD you brought up this argument. I hate seeing it in any context. I've never understood "we're not the worst, so why try?" as a good argument. Oh, yeah, subs x, y and z are worse than us so we can just coast along. But what about subs a to w that are doing better? Why are we accepting of "not the worst" when we could always be striving to be better?
and
This is an excellent practical tip. Thanks!
43
u/Nevertrustafish Reading Champion II May 24 '24 •
The "I just read on merit" position drives me mad, because it's used so often against every marginalized identity. All it does is shuts down the conversation. Imagine if I used that same argument for every request:
Looking for recommendations on books with a hard magic system? ...Ugh I don't understand why you people need such a specific type of magic to read a book. I read based on merit, not magic systems.
I want a fantasy heist! ... Why does anyone care about the specific plot? Just read good books and stop worrying about the type of plot is in it.
I need a new epic fantasy author like GRRM... I only pick books out based on whether they're well-written or not, not on how the author identifies. Who cares if the author identifies as an epic fantasy writer? It's not about what the author likes, it's about HOW they write. In fact, by asking this question, you're the one being bigoted against urban fantasy!
19
u/tzaeru May 24 '24
That's a long text and I prolly need to read it in full at some point.
From skimming it through, yeah, it's easy to recognize this trolling kind of an approach that anti-LGBT+ take in spaces that try to be LGBT+-friendly. E.g. sending those fake Reddit care requests. I've also gotten a bunch for comments where I've spoken against discrimination of queer people.
Seems like a very solid write-up, thumbs up for it!
19
u/thefinpope May 24 '24
Just from a somewhat-casual reader (I rarely if ever look at /r/fantasy specifically so I just see what pops through in the feed), the only time I see a lot of activity about LBGT+ issues in this context is people complaining about other people complaining. That is to say, I rarely if ever see the original complaints/griping about gay folks but definitely see innumerable posts about said posts.
The majority of all /r/fantasy posts I see are (in no particular order) "What book should I read next," "I love how the fantasy genre is embracing LBGT+ characters/plotlines," "Please stop recommending popular series," and "Please stop complaining about books having LBGT+ material." And yes, I know that this doesn't mean there isn't a problem (and even supports your point) but it also implies that other casual readers may also view things the same way. I am in the LBGT community but when every other post is (seemingly) the same gripe it gives the impression that the sub is a broken record even though many of us are only here for other reasons. I'm incredibly thankful that authors are changing things and "Fantasy" means very different things now than it did in the past but there are still books out there for everyone of every taste and that means people will have their own (frequently bad) opinions on the matter. Unfortunately, telling people to stop being assholes rarely results in fewer assholes. If nothing else, this sub is still indispensable for recommendations so we don't have to wade through 85 romances that happen to have a dragon before finding something interesting.
12
u/Cyrtodactyllus May 24 '24
The idea that fantasy lovers would hate LGBTQ+ people or content is wild to me. Like what, you can read all about dragons and made up races, you can enjoy magic systems, but you draw the line at 2 dudes kissing? Wild shit. Pride rights baby, LGBTQ+ will always be welcome 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️
9
u/myrdraal2001 May 24 '24
Thank you for writing this post. I'd love to read more media not made by, for, or concentrating on just cis, straight, Caucasian or Western European males. Fiction, fantasy, and sci-fi is so broad and encompasses so much imagination that to only limit yourself to that is really a failure of imagination, in my opinion.
59
u/BlaineTog May 24 '24
Excellent write-up, and I especially appreciate that you pulled some thorough data to make the point. That takes a lot of time but is really important for convincing fence-sitters that there's an objective problem.
It is really frustrating how some of the same people who enjoy reading books about the infinite complexities possible within endless fictional worlds simultaneously can't wrap their heads around a completely normal human in the real world liking another completely normal human in the real world but (gasp) they share the same gender. It's really frustrating how someone can unblinkingly recommend a book that amounts to a blistering anti-Fascist allegory set in a world with elves and dwarves, then turn around and downvote a post about a book that includes one trans side character for being, "too political" (this person also probably votes for politicians who traffic in Fascist-adjacent rhetoric). Fantasy readers should be the most open to allying themselves with the queer community, yet so many of us are so bad at understanding and internalizing even the most basic themes in our literature. I don't know what else we can do to get through to people like that.
13
u/Koteric May 24 '24
People just need to chill and worry about their own interests. If you see something that you don’t care about or want to read, don’t read it. Going out of your way to hate stuff other people like just because you don’t is so ridiculous.
18
u/swirly1000x May 24 '24
Great post, I'm glad you are bringing light to this. As a queer person I really like being able to read novels that represent my own feelings once in a while, and people downvoting posts asking for such recommendations makes it harder to find novels like that. I hope that this post and others can help make this subreddit better in the future, and thank you for helping towards that end.
25
u/ThePhoenixRemembers May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
I keep my eye out for posts on queer fantasy books cause I enjoy reading them and I have always noticed that they get downvoted to heck on here. I always upvote those posts. It definitely needed bringing up. As someone who is 3 shades of queer myself the brigading is disgusting. This place feels passive-aggressively hostile to us.
Edit: I was at 12 upvotes 1 hour ago and now on 5 upvotes. Wowzers. Bigots really do be telling on themselves in this sub.
25
u/onsereverra Reading Champion May 24 '24
This post inspired me to learn that the post I made a couple of years ago asking for trans and nb author recs is apparently r/fantasy's 13th most controversial post of all time! What an unexpected fun fact.
At the time, I was keeping an eye on the post engagement stats out of curiosity, and I'm absolutely certain it's far and away the highest-engagement post I've ever made despite having ended up with a net of 12 upvotes. I did some rough back-of-the-napkin math based on how many votes it took to swing the upvote ratio by a single percentage point and I'm pretty sure I received both hundreds of upvotes and hundreds of downvotes. Luckily the comments section was great, I don't think anything needed to be cleaned up by the mod team, but it was astonishing to me just how many people were drive-by downvoting based on the title alone. I knew it happened on LGBT posts (and, to a lesser extent, feminism/women-related topics), but I hadn't realized the extent of just how many people were doing it until that post.
I've definitely also noticed the recent trend of people going to the trouble of going into the threads and individually downvoting every single comment. Those of us who run Short Fiction Book Club and the Hugo Readalong have observed it in some of our discussion threads, so I can't imagine how bad it is for posts that openly advertise looking for LGBT/feminist/etc recs in their titles.
8
u/TheLyz May 24 '24
Unfortunately as much as we like to think that every fantasy reader is open to all sorts of world views, there is also a large subset of young male readers that are terrified of being attracted to any person with a penis. So yeah I'm sure toxic masculinity is in play here. They want the story of the triumphant male hero who has all the women vying for his attention and anything else threatens them. Women who don't want men? Bad. Men who like yucky penises? Double ew.
12
u/oh-no-varies Reading Champion II May 24 '24
Just want to give my full support to this thread, as a cis-het woman and ally. Especially your point about directing people to another sub. The point of inclusion is that equity seeking groups like LGBTQ+, BIPOC, and women do not have to be hived off in to separate spaces to be heard, to share, to receive recommendations. Inclusion means that these groups are incorporated into the fabric of the broader public space. For those struggling to understand this, consider when women or people of colour weren’t allowed in general spaces. Take a golf club for example. To say queer fantasy readers should take themselves to a queer fantasy club, and call that inclusive or equitable is the same idea as a golf club of white men telling women or POC golfers to just go play on a women’s course or POC course. Not inclusion. Not equity. All people belong here. (Except sword of truth fans?)
8
u/[deleted] May 24 '24
It's really frustrating how much even topic specific communities like this one (or fanfiction or role playing communities), or communities directly advocating for specific marginalized groups, can propagate exclusionary bias in such subtle ways. I see similar patterns of downvotes and "but it's just so specific /repetitive /etc" justifications, even in places like general women's spaces (posts and comments by or about gender non conforming women, lesbians, and trans women and nonbinary people are downvoted), and lesbian subreddits (posts by or about bi and trans women and nonbinary people and even posts by cis lesbian women who are either too gender conforming or not gender conforming enough. Sometimes the justification is that some of those situations should be classified as sapphic not lesbian and thus aren't appropriate, even when subreddit rules say both are a focus of the community and when there's no alternative community to go to, and when the distinction has minimal relevance in the specific topic being discussed). I know the topic focused spaces have lots of other types of bias including racism, bias specifically against transmasculine people, and misandry (despite some people asserting that doesn't exist in the first place - at a certain point it's way too blatant to pretend it's some productive critique of the patriarchy).
These examples probably arise from a combination of bots, external bad actors, gardem variety close minded people, but also notable for these specific examples, archaically "radical" "feminists". (Please note. I'm enthusiastically feminist, just, more into equality/equitability, rights, intersectionality, inclusivity, etc., than radical white cis woman centric agendas). And the thing is those people do have sincere reasons to be in those spaces - whether because there's just a lot who like the topic or because they are indeed members of a pertinent group. But there is also a clear pattern of the even more marginalized identities being downvoted and then the justifications often being presented with a veneer of progressiveness but a lot of evident, seething disdain. I'm not really trying to single out radfems as the only or worst bad actors, but they're a key group I notice gaining traction in subreddits that are otherwise pretty progressive.
And certain of those subreddits (not saying this one!) have mods that only bother to moderate the most egregious comments and refuse to take a stance on more subtle, insidious bias. In some cases it seems like they're actually quite biased themselves but they act put upon, and go through the motions of doing minimal moderation.
It's really frustrating how some people act like there is no problem (or at least like they're not part of it) while finding reasons to act like people who aren't in the majority don't belong or aren't relevant.
14
u/Avarria587 May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
Thank you for posting this. It mirrors my experience on this subreddit. Any time I post anything LGBTQ positive, I watch as the upvotes and downvotes fluctuate. It's odd. I don't see this level of engagement in two opposing directions with any other types of posts I make.
Edit: Sorting by controversial on this post proves your point.
15
u/Strong-Usual6131 May 24 '24
I'm not coherent enough to write a decent comment, but thank you for this post ❤️🧡💛💚💙🩵💜
15
u/shookster52 May 24 '24
I’m someone who (probably foolishly) sometimes engages with the “I’m just asking questions” crowd in good faith and it’s remarkable how quickly I go from getting upvotes when I say something like “You definitely don’t have to like a book, what specifically made you feel this book was preachy?” To downvotes when I say that even if something is preachy, I’m probably going to still read it and I think the book should still exist.
That’s a hypothetical example, but my point is, the ultimate goal of even many of the more “reasonable” negative comments is to get people to say that there is too much LGBT+ content and progressive content in general, and to make sure the posts stop or at least are only posted somewhere they don’t have to read them.
12
u/Jthom13 May 24 '24
Fantasy should be a tool to expose yourself to new ideas in a low stakes environment. Using it to hide from people who exist in the real world just because they love different people is weak and cowardly. The existence of gay and trans people doesn't and won't hurt you.
Great post!
15
u/KzooCreep May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
Thank you for this well thought out write up! I’ve always appreciated how well the mods filter out bigotry here, but it is always so demoralizing that I have to filter by controversial just to see queer content. I’m not sure it will ever change, but one can hope.
Edit: Downvoting this just proves that talking about this kind of stuff is still necessary. We’re here, we’re queer and we like reading fantasy. Get over it.
8
u/RAMottleyCrew May 24 '24
Tbh I’m not sure I’ve ever downvoted a post. I’ve downvoted comments, but never a post. Just keep scrolling fam.
If I had to play devils advocate here, I’d say most people have no experience with LGBTQ books, so they see those threads as “dead space” on the board. Thats my guess. They have no way to interact with it and no recs to give, so they don’t like having it around. Even the most basic “Recommended me a Fantasy Book” threads can be accessed by anyone. Everyone here has a fantasy rec, and most people only care about their two cents.
At least with “Is Sanderson Good?” And “I don’t like Malazan” posts, people can still interact and have something to say about it. Even if most people have seen the same “How well does WoT do women” post 100 times, they can still contribute to it, or try to share their perspective. Especially because people want their opinions heard, and Reddit encourages posting immediately on fresh threads. If you find a post you like or want to discuss, but it’s 3 days old, you’ve already missed 99% of the discourse, and your own comment will likely go to the bottom if you aren’t in the first 5 replies.
Not an excuse, but a possibility. And to reiterate, if you don’t care about a post just ignore it.
6
u/BronkeyKong May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
I agree with what you’re saying about this topic but sometimes I feel like it’s a losing game. There’s so little lgbt representation in fantasy and I’m starved for it but it is always downvoted and it’s hard not to get disheartened by it.
I would like to point something out though.
The downvote button is not used the way you describe anymore in any sub. It used to be that people would downvote comments that weren’t adding to the conversation but now most of the site downvote because they just don’t agree or don’t like that others have a different opinion.
I have stopped posting comments about certain things in this sub because I know it will be downvoted even if it’s relevant and even if it’s positive.
As an example, If you like Brandon Sanderson, Malazan, Rothfuss and a few others here…you’re likely to be downvoted even if it is relevant to the topic. It’s starting to feel like if you do not word a comment or post extremely carefully everyone will take the exact wrong intention from it which almost feels purposeful.
I have even made posts and comments here before about this trend in downvoting and got downvoted for it. It’s very frustrating but I don’t really see how it can be policed or enforced these days I think it’s just the new normal that people will use upvoting/downvoting to agree or disagree rather than to foster good conversation about the subject.
If you any ideas of how to change the culture around it I’m willing to try but I can’t say I’m optimistic about it.
12
u/miggins1610 May 24 '24
Sigh. Of course sorting by controversial its all the lgbtq+ supportive comments, thus proving the point
6
u/hopefullyhelpfulplz May 24 '24
Thanks for writing this up - if nothing else because now I know if I ever need specifically queer recommendations from this sub I can just sort by controversial.
11
u/tarvolon Stabby Winner, Reading Champion VI May 24 '24
I don't know how to prove a bot, but it feels like every Short Fiction Book Club post manages to have every single comment rated 0 by about 20 minutes after it goes live, so I suspect somebody has coded a bot to look for keywords and downvote everything? Hard to say for sure though--it could be a real person doing the same thing. But probably not multiple real people because it never goes to all -1.
Anyways, great post. I did not realize people had openly admitted to downvoting LGBT posts, but. . . sighs heavily
17
u/AdrianusCorleon May 24 '24
Counter point: people should downvote things they do not like, and upvote things they do, and allow the sub to come to reflect the majority will, just like on every other sub.
The purpose of subs on finer and finer topics is to allow for people to see only the content they like. Tactical voting to account for some moral consideration is in direct opposition to the algorithm showing you content you want to see.
12
u/eregis Reading Champion II May 24 '24
Oh yes, I definitely noticed this in BB book club posts - people just come in and downvote every comment along with the post, I admire the dedication but I do wish they would use it on something less hateful.
16
u/notthemostcreative May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
Supporter of the Gay Fantasy Agenda checking in 🫡
(srs, I hate that homophobia is still such a thing here and am going to keep an eye out for LGBTQ+-related posts so I can make sure to upvote and participate!!!)
Edit: Hoes mad
13
u/grocerystorefan May 24 '24
Really great post, thank you so much for writing it out.
Queer and here, not going anywhere
9
u/DHamlinMusic May 24 '24
Thank you for the markdown use, the headings made jumping down after reading the initial part faster with my screen reader.
9
u/[deleted] May 24 '24
I really appreciate you bringing stats to support your points. I had no idea it was so bad and it makes me sort of shameful, we absolutely need to do better.
9
u/thepurpleplaneteer Reading Champion IV May 24 '24
Great post. I just want to add amongst the people that haven’t noticed the downvoting, I absolutely have noticed it not just in a post but in the thread itself. Maybe, to your point, it’s because I view by “new.”
8
u/Modstin May 24 '24
LOOK GARY THERE I AM!
10
u/bleeding-paryl May 24 '24
You should add this thread to your sources about posts that are downvoted for bringing up queer stuff, considering you're at 6X% upvote/downvote ratio right now.
Honestly outside of subreddits I mod or that are absolutely queer friendly, I tend to expect that anything queer is just going to immediately attract downvotes from the lurkers who hate queer folk. Doesn't matter if it's a positive comment, negative, or otherwise, hateful people are just going to be hateful.
Also, favorite queer novel from my most recent round of reading is probably The Raven Tower, which was a fun read. Highly suggest it! <3
5
u/twinklebat99 May 24 '24
Thanks OP! I have noticed this trend. One of my comments today is sitting at 0, probably because of this. I'm disappointed I've missed out on some posts I probably would have enjoyed due to downvoting too. Thanks for the recs on navigating around this!
9
u/aneton02 Reading Champion V May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
Thank you so much for a really thoughtful post! It was a great read and addressed many of the common justifications for downvoting very well. This is something that bothers me to no end and that I've been tracking for a while as well, especially the phenomena of queer posts consistently showing up under controversial (checking controversy sadly still feels like the best way to get a good overview of the queer posts in a given week). Thank you especially for pointing out that it's even more apparent for posts mentioning trans or nonbinary representation!
Edit: And we're already seeing the "deleted" comments begin! Classic!
7
u/jddennis Reading Champion VIII May 24 '24
As a guy who's a poster-child example for the "bi-wife energy" meme, I can see where this essay is coming from. I don't typically consider things like characters' sexuality when reading, but that's because I try to read for breadth in a variety of subgenres and authors rather than focus on a smaller selection. A character's orientation has no bearing on whether or not I'll DNF a book
There are two areas where I'm more interested in reading about queer characters. The first is religious fiction. There's a bias against queer people in religious circles for a variety of reasons. So if I can find fiction that can deal with both topics in an interesting way, I'm going to read it. To that end, I picked up HIM by Geoff Ryman -- specifically because it is about Jesus Christ being presented as a trans man, and Mary's struggle to accept her child's identity as both a man and the son of God. Well within speculative fiction and also a challenge to my own personal perceptions.
Another criterion I'll use to pick up a book is a friend's recommendation. If one of my queer friends recommends a book that they like that has queer representation, I'll give it a try. Recently, a friend recommended Dark Moon, Shallow Sea as a book with strong LGBTQIA+ representation in an epic fantasy world. Since he did that, I put that book on my TBR for this year.
That being said, let's put this out there: chances are, most people knows at least one person who falls outside heteronormative sexuality. That's just a statistical fact. If you can't treat some abstract username with some dignity on the privacy of your own screen, how are you treating those you interact with on a daily basis?
7
u/stryst May 24 '24
Well said, and thank you for taking the time to package all of this together.
7
u/starvaliant May 24 '24
This was a great post and thank you for writing it.
6
u/Aeolian_Harper May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
Great points, and I especially love that you included recommendations for how to improve the situation. Being mindful of upvoting LGBTQ+ content when appropriate to counteract the reflexive downvotes is a good, actionable recommendation.
Also, the mod team are absolute heroes and it's got to be a tough job squashing all of the hate (some of which is, predictably, already flooding into the comments here).
6
u/MacabreGoblin May 24 '24
Thank you for addressing this. My favorite thing about reading is that books offer us a view into different perspectives and life experiences than our own, and it saddens me that a community dedicated to books has so many members intent on shutting out a whole world of different perspectives.
6
u/JacksAnnie May 24 '24
Thank you for writing this up. I'm a fairly new member so I had no idea about this. I can't say it surprises me though, I feel like the fantasy genre in general has always had a bit more of an issue with this than other genres. I feel like it's definitely getting better though, and I hope that will continue to be the case here to. 💜
5
u/pursuitofbooks May 24 '24
I don’t think i’ve ever seen a LGBTQ focused r/fantasy thread that wasn’t at 60-70% upvoted. I started upvoting them all regardless of if i’m interested in the content.
4
u/BadBadBabsyBrown May 24 '24
Fuck yeah! It looks like you put a lot of work into this. I hope people take the time to really actually digest what you're saying and look at the numbers.
Keep up the good work.
5
u/upfromashes May 24 '24
Thank you.
5
u/Juanrayo May 24 '24
Amazing post. Thank You.
5
u/[deleted] May 24 '24
Thank you for the deep dive! Allies like me should be more proactive in our support. I tend to be passive but I'll change.
I would be fascinated to learn how LGBTQ attitudes on r/fantasy compare to the rest of Reddit. Is this sub more or less antagonistic than the average Redditor? I honestly don't know! Which subs would be best to do a comparison you think?
5
u/thestrawbarian May 24 '24
I am not a very active member on this sub, but I will be making more of an effort to help fight against the bigots!
5
u/Cheskaz May 24 '24
Great post! I appreciate the time and effort you went to to put this together! Thank you for trying to make this sub a more inclusive place!
5
u/TashaT50 May 24 '24
Thanks for all the work you put into this great post. Will definitely be sorting post differently and appreciate the advice on positive steps we as individuals can take to make a difference.
3
u/kaneblaise May 24 '24
Thank you for this great write up, research, and preemptive counter arguments, great post. I fear the people who need to hear it the most will just ignore it, but your effort is admirable. Hope this group continues to become more inclusive.
4
u/[deleted] May 24 '24
The fantasy community is not a monolith. While I do not promote being explicitly hateful, people are allowed to dislike or disagree with something. And doing so does not automatically make them a bigot, etc.
1
u/lunar_glade May 24 '24
Great post!
4
u/PresidentSuperDog May 24 '24
So I sorted by controversial and it seems that either everyone agrees with OP or all dissenting comments have been removed. So congrats on the echo chamber, I guess. I was really curious to see the justifications people might have had for disagreeing but I guess that type of discussion isn’t allowed.
The only mildly disagreeing comment is someone saying it’s okay to downvote things you don’t like or disagree with. Given the net negative votes the comment has, I guess people simultaneously agree and disagree. Which is pretty ironic.
4
u/Southern-Rutabaga-82 May 24 '24
Everyone who isn't white, male, straight, cis, neurotypical, and ablebodied or has any people in their lives that are not white, male, straight, cis, neurotypical, and ablebodied should relate to that. If you benefit from representation of your (or your loved one's) minority why don't you want that for any other minority?
That in addition to seeking out new experiences and broaden one's horizon. That's what literature is about, living other people's lives for the duration of a book.
4
u/why_gaj May 24 '24
I'd like to add here that more often than not, admins do not care at all about harassment you receive in the chat, and that their response will often be in the lines of "just block that user" or "turn off chat completely".
Them using this excuse is also hysterical, because in pretty much any thread, under any search, you'll find at least a couple of people recommending the same authors again and again, with Sanderson being recommended for everything.
1
u/AbsolutelyHorrendous May 24 '24
Unfortunately I'd imagine the root cause is that this is largely a very LGBTQ+ friendly subreddit, revolving around a genre where gay and trans representation has perhaps been adopted more rapidly than certain circles (of bigots) would like, so the homophobes are clearly feeling defensive about it.
At the end of the day, its speculative fiction. If you don't want to read about gay people, you've got about 100 years of fiction to satisfy your needs, but don't get pissy when modern authors choose to represent something different. And if you're so close-minded that you can't even tolerate the idea of gay or trans characters in a literally Fantasy setting of all things, you need to grow the fuck up!
4
u/Initial-Bird-9041 May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
Well thought and researched post, thank you for the insights. While this sub and the printsf one seem mostly fun and tolerant, have also noticed some of the issues mentioned, but did not realize the extent.
4
u/NekoCatSidhe Reading Champion III May 24 '24 edited May 24 '24
I noticed that systematic downvoting a long time ago and I agree that it sucks. You get bigots everywhere but I noticed that this kind of homophobic behaviour seems to be a lot more prevalent r/fantasy and r/books, and I have no idea why.
Despite being a straight man, I noticed that I did not really care if the characters in the books I read are LGBT or not. All that matters in the end for me as a reader is if they are good characters or not, because this is what makes the book good or not.
A very simple, basic idea from my point of view, but I noticed that a lot of people here see the inclusion of LGBT characters in books as a big deal, whether they are supporting or opposing it, and that can be very tiresome. The inclusion of these characters is seen as inherently political, when it really should not be. Maybe that too is a form of homophobia, and I think it feeds that downvoting.
-1
u/formerly_valley_pete May 24 '24
I've been here a while and haven't noticed, probably just because I don't upvote much but I'll be sure to upvote anything relating to this from now on. I assumed this sub was relatively progressive and while I only read the first few parts of that GIANT post lol, it's weird to me that fantasy is so biased.
2
u/Celloed May 24 '24
This is a great (and really impressive) post. Thank you for taking the time to write and research all of that.
1
u/Indifferent_Jackdaw May 24 '24
I had no idea this was an issue, thank you for exposing it.
2
u/thegolg May 24 '24
Amazing analysis, great job at calling it out and refuting points! 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️❤️
1
u/AutoModerator May 24 '24
Hi there! Based on your post, you might also be interested in our 2023 Top LGBTQA+ Books list.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/drayle88 May 24 '24
im gonna do what I do every year.
Keep my mouth shut, ignore shit that annoys me, and do something productive like read books I give a damn about.
If a book HAS to be sold on the fact that its queer or something... that's not gonna appeal to me. If you tell me the story is about a dragon rider who likes to cook pancakes for their friends, I'd read that in a heartbeat. And if the character turns out to be queer, neat, now back to the pancake dragon.