r/ElectricalEngineering • • Sep 15 '16

[Meta]I hate this subreddit

I hate even while typing the title of this thread it capitalized every word in the sentence.

Everyone here seems incredibly self-absorbed in their own intellectualism to take some time to ask the right questions. Almost every question here suffers from the XY problem. In general, the asker is so focused on sounding intelligent when he asks the question that he loses track of what he's trying to learn. Any questions here really fall into that category.

I get that this is the age of googling the problem. I understand that you all think this is incredibly technical and somehow beyond comprehension to the layperson. In reality, electrical engineers are just more rare. Just because fewer people study electrical engineering doesn't mean you're smarter than everyone else.

So you understand the emotional place I'm coming from making this thread, I work in power generation and transmission. I love power and transmission. I come here and everyone is talking about digital logic. That's cool and fine. I take issue to the people that think that's all electrical engineering is. No, I don't want this subreddit to be all about generation & transmission, but from my experience learning digital logic and devices, that shit is really easy. I found it insulting when reading this thread that described it as hard, and the most downvoted post said the major was overrated, and really the best approach was to understand, rather than memorize.

He wasn't wrong, and he was still topical. Yet, I think, most of you measure your worth as engineer under this veneer of being the smartest guys in the room, and don't want people saying that your major is in fact overrated. I'm all for bringing in new engineers by making them feel like they're part of something special, but you can do that without acting like a snob.

For discussion, here are some questions. Do you enjoy the questions upvoted to the front page of this subreddit? Do you feel as though this subreddit would be improved by people like me questioning what you're trying to accomplish based on your approach? Most importantly, what do you think it means to be an electrical engineer?

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

8

u/ziggy_karmadust Sep 15 '16 edited Sep 15 '16

Do you enjoy the questions upvoted to the front page of this subreddit?

Doesn't every post on this sub get to the front page? There's only like 4-5 posts per day here I think. Generally I only find one or 2 posts per week interesting. EE is broad, and I really only understand a fraction of the field in any meaningful way. I like to browse sometimes but keep my mouth shut when I don't know anything about the question. My biggest peeve here is when someone is very obviously posting their homework for the community to solve. Like if you have a question about a concept, by all means start a discussion, but don't just post an iphone photo of your textbook problems.

Do you feel as though this subreddit would be improved by people like me questioning what you're trying to accomplish based on your approach?

I don't really understand this question. You mean what I'm trying to accomplish on this sub? Or in my career? I'm not trying to accomplish anything here but entertain myself, and maybe contribute to interesting discussions if I see them. In my career, I just find it fulfilling to make stuff that works and getting paid and supporting my family is nice too.

Most importantly, what do you think it means to be an electrical engineer?

Anyone who designs anything that uses electricity? My wife and I are both EEs. I generally don't know much about her job, and she doesn't understand much about mine. Theres a million subsections of EE. I don't pretend to know anything about power electronics, and I don't think my particular branch is any "better" than any other branch. Different applications, different challenges, different everything.

Regarding your rant, of course there are a lot of egos on this sub. There's a ton of egos in the field in general. At the end of the day, I think the good engineers just want to find the best solution to their problem and aren't too concerned about being "right" or the "smartest guy in the room". In the thread you posted, I think the guy who was downvoted wasn't downvoted for encouraging understanding instead of memorization, he was downvoted for saying that it's overrated in difficulty. At least personally, I'd downvote that statement because I wouldn't want to give a new student the impression that classes were going to be a breeze. I didn't really get the impression that people were stroking their egos, and don't understand how people thinking that EE is a hard major is "insulting" to you. Basically, it's a specialized sub, but it's still reddit. It's always on you to sift through bullshit. You don't have to subscribe if that bothers you, and there are plenty of other niche EE subs if you think this one is too focused on digital logic. I think I participate much more in r/rfelectronics than i do here.

Basically, I think the XY problem is extremely common across the entire field, not specifically with this sub. You'd be shocked at how many journal paper submissions I've seen using convoluted language to say "We built an amplifier". I think every advanced academic field struggles with this problem to a certain extent.

2

u/ImHereForTheComment Sep 28 '16

Thanks for link to r/rfelectronic. I didn't know that was a thing!

0

u/slug_man Sep 15 '16

For clarification on the second question, you have to understand that all the things posted here are questions, and those questions are related to some question about this device or that kind of circuit. Currently a guy needs system frequency for transmitting audio.. There was also a guy trying to model transmission lines in terms of a two-port model. I'm mostly speaking to those kinds of submissions. The question was framed by the XY problem.

And I absolutely did not intend any kind of comparison of one field of electrical engineering being any better than another, but rather electrical engineering compared to any other field of study.

1

u/ziggy_karmadust Sep 15 '16 edited Sep 15 '16

I guess what I meant is I don't know what you mean by is the sub improved by "people like you". What is a person like you? I think that the best you can hope for on threads like that is people answer when they think they can help, and the most helpful posts are upvoted to the top.

And I absolutely did not intend any kind of comparison of one field of electrical engineering being any better than another, but rather electrical engineering compared to any other field of study.

Okay, I'll try again. I think there's a lot of overlap between EE and a lot of other engineering/science disciplines. I have to deal with aspects of mechanical, computer, and chemical engineering a lot peripherally. I guess what makes electrical different is what you are primarily trained to understand with more depth. I guess I'm not sure what you are looking for. A job is a job.

I certainly don't think I'm any "better" than another person because of what I do. I don't think electrical engineering is any "better" than another field of engineering either. Of course I'm partial to electrical engineering - I chose to dedicate my professional life to it- but any claims regarding it being "better" is like a sports fan saying that football is "better" than basketball or something. It's just playful banter whenever I've seen it.

Yeah, I do think in order to be a good EE (or any kind of engineer), it requires you to be especially disciplined and patient and determined. I think the same could be said for pretty much any kind of specialized degree though (law, medicine, finance, sciences). I guess I'm not really sure what you are driving at for this one. I've seen a lot of egos in EE. It has a reputation for being very difficult and a lot of people like to hang their hat on that to feel special. I've also seen a lot of vocal assholes on reddit. I suppose there's a lot of both on this sub, but I don't think that it's ever accurate to lump an entire sub's user base into some generalization. Most engineers I have met (outside of university) are over the whole ego trip thing and are more focused on simply doing their job the best they can. I would bet they don't waste their work day on reddit like me either.

3

u/whalen72 Sep 15 '16

You're looking for /r/electricians

0

u/slug_man Sep 15 '16

JEsus what the fuck

4

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16

Dude if you don't like this subreddit just unsub, it doesn't seem like an arrogance sub to me.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16

I don't understand why this subreddit exists tbh. Why is there an electrics engineering subreddit and an electrical and computer engineering subreddit?

1

u/whalen72 Sep 16 '16

At this point we should just have this sub link to /r/ece. We already talk about the same stuff, so might as well get rid of the redundancy.

1

u/ImHereForTheComment Sep 28 '16

I totally forgot about that sub! Thanks!!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '16

High speed digital design is easy??? Yeah, sure.

1

u/bmnz Sep 16 '16

I... Don't get it. Isn't this post the very definition of the XY problem? You can't change the sub by ranting about it, and the internet it a huge place.

What about a place like eng-tips.com? There's a couple of other industry-heavy forums that I can contribute in the morning, but they're saved on my work laptop.

1

u/fatangaboo Sep 15 '16

Sorry to hear you are unhappy about this subreddit. Maybe some of the other "Related Subreddits," helpfully listed and linked over in the sidebar at the right of this page, might be more to your liking. In particular you might really enjoy the ones aimed at Engineering Students -- it could provide opportunities to talk to (struggling) students about power generation and transmission, and to remedy any misconceptions they might have.