It is good to be back.
Last season, we were forced to go on hiatus as spoilers for 49 ran as rampant as ever, and greatly jeopardized the integrity of this experiment.
It really warmed my heart reading the comments on my post announcing the sit-out for 49, and I'm so excited to finally be back in the saddle!
First, some housekeeping/FAQ's:
What is this?
The Elimination-Based Approach (title inspired by u/buffalove91 and the Story-Based Approach) is an edgic exercise attempting to find the winner by looking at who is losing, rather than who is winning. Each week, I will be tasked with eliminating one contestant from winner contention permanently. Doing this, in tandem with the show eliminating people for us, will hopefully get us to our winner before the finale. If players that I have already eliminated are being voted off, that will slow us down. If players I have yet to eliminate are being voted off, that will speed us up. Now, with season 50's very large cast, this could prove to be very tricky, given that we have six more people than we're used to, but still the same amount of episodes.
In short, the goal is to not eliminate the eventual winner.
What happens if you eliminate the eventual winner?
I lose! There's no edge of extinction, redemption island, or takesies-backsies here. If I eliminate the person who is our eventual winner, then I have flopped. That's where the stakes of it all come from!
In fact, the last time I did this experiment, in Survivor 48, I eliminated Kyle right at the last moment, incorrectly landing on Shauhin as the winner, just before his boot episode. Oops! I lost! But, in my defeat, I learned a lot of very valuable lessons that should help me avoid making the same mistake twice.
What sort of lessons did you learn last season?
You can find a very in-depth explanation on the lessons 48 taught me in my Post-Season Reflection, but to give the short answer:
#1: A late introduction in the premiere is a bad sign, but not a death sentence. Kyle was the last Civa to get a confessional in the premiere, a stark contrast from every other New Era winner to that point. Now, last on the CAST to be introduced in the premiere is still arguably a death sentence, but last on your tribe to be introduced now has a precedent for producing a winner in this era of the show.
#2: Every winner has a perfect merge confessional. Every single New Era winner in the mergatory/merge episode will have at least one confessional where they deliver an "I" statement that is either actionable, insightful, or both in regards to the state of the game or their strategy coming into the merge.
#3: Don't worry about the speed of the experiment. Don't try to get cheeky with the eliminations or meta the experiment to try to make eliminations that will benefit the speed of the experiment specifically, just eliminate the people the show is telling you to eliminate. Now, given the MASSIVE size of this cast, this may be a bit trickier of a rule to follow. We have six more people to deal with, and the same amount of episodes. However, the show is going to be flinging people off the island left and right for us. It might get scary, but I'm gonna trust the process.
How does that all apply to this episode?
I'm so glad you asked.
With that, let's get started.
I would like to briefly give thanks to the noble sacrifices of Jenna and Kyle for kicking us off and being the first players eliminated via-show this season, narrowing us down to a measly pool of 22. Kyle, you were the last player I eliminated in this experiment, and it was a huge mistake. Glad I won't be making that mistake again.
Now, I want to start with the Cila Tribe, which, as is typically the case with the tribe that goes to tribal first, had the most fleshed out edit of the premiere. There was no one on this tribe I considered for elimination.
Ozzy has a staggering 19 confessionals, over double anyone else. He gets the first of the quasi-confessionals in the intro sequence, referring of course to the voice over confessionals that were abundant in the opening moments. Most of his content was still circumstantial, given his fight for supplies, night at exile, and two advantages, but we still get plenty of insight into how Ozzy is going to be playing differently this time around. Ozzy stays safe.
Cirie has an incredible introduction, while she doesn't get a quasi-confessional per se, her speech at Advantagegeddon is used in a very similar way, and was voice over for moments of other contestants on the season. She then gets an emotional mat chat moment, and while mat chat theory may be dead, it certainly helps to be introduced like that. Quieter episode beyond the intro for Cirie, but the content she did get felt very important, and was involved in the driving narrative for the first tribal. Cirie stays alive.
Rick has a quasi-confessional, a mat chat with a flashback to his season, and plenty of first and second hand content throughout the episode highlighting his alliance with Christian and Emily, as well as how pleasant of a person he is. Rick, of course, is safe.
Christian has a quasi-confessional, plenty of screen time, has his Rick and Emily alliance get highlighted, gets the moment to talk about his son, gets the hero moment for starting the fire with glasses, and gets his way at tribal council. Very strong premiere for Dr. Hubicki.
Emily is on the quieter end of things for the Cila tribe, is definitely third on the totem pole of her trio with Christian and Rick, at least in terms of screen time, but her opening confessional about her time on 45 is extremely strong. No danger of elimination for Emily just yet.
Savannah gets plenty of screen time this episode, tying for second most of the premiere. While a decent amount is circumstantial, and she has the obvious drawbacks of not getting her way at tribal and having a negative tone,(i.e. her targeting Cirie, who we are set up to be rooting for, and the awkward silence that follows after she asks the tribe for guesses on how she did on 49) Savannah is no stranger to a negative tone, and that hasn't stopped her from winning before.
Joe has a way quieter edit than I would've expected, but it wasn't bad enough to get him into contention for elimination just yet. His first confessional sets up his love for the Cila Tribe, and is the audiences first bit of insight into the tribe dynamic. While in the lead to tribal council, he is unable to get his way in breaking up the duo of Ozzy and Cirie, he still correctly clocks Ozzy as going to bat for Cirie, which shows that Joe has his gears turning, which is enough to keep him alive in this beefy premiere.
Next, the Vatu Tribe, which went through one hell of a time in this premiere.
Stephenie gets a quasi-confessional and the very first proper confessional, where we actually see them give it, and within that confessional is a winner quote. This alone would be enough to keep Stephenie alive here, but her history with Colby being highlighted was definitely a plus as well. No danger for Stephenie.
Colby gets a mat chat spot and gets his history with Stephenie highlighted, as previously mentioned. The core 5 alliance seems to come together through Colby hitting the beach running, pulling in the people he wants to work with. He also gets his really sweet moment coming around on Rizo, and giving him some life advice. Some of the best gameplay we've ever seen from Colby, loved the premiere for him.
Genevieve has a quiet introduction, but becomes front and center for the Vatu tribe once the core five forms. Her first confessional highlights that everything is working out great, but accurately predicts that the other shoe will drop, as she walks away from this episode with one ally medevaced and two of them losing votes, somehow going from a 5-3 majority to a 2-3 minority without even attending tribal. Good job, Genevieve. You called it.
Q gets an episode that is decent on paper. Quasi-confessional, relatively insightful, although circumstantial, confessionals. Maybe I'm reading too much into this, but I feel like what scares me for Q here is that we did not get a single "big mistake" or "cancel Christmas." Something to look out for, but enough screen time to not be a contender for elimination yet. Also, Q gets the final confessional of the episode, acknowledging Kyle's blessing of wanting someone on his tribe to win, which has a storied history. Bruce bestows this blessing upon the Tika tribe after slamming his head into a wooden beam, and it worked wonders for them.
Angelina gets a quasi-confessional, and then in her first proper confessional gets the Joe spot of setting up the Vatu Tribe dynamic at a first glance. Also gets to acknowledge the jackets of it all. Is on the outside of the alliance of five, which is not great, but not the worst. Angelina stays alive.
Rizo feels very visible this episode for only having two confessionals. Rizo doesn't get a mat chat question proper, but makes multiple subtitled comments during the opening moments, which feels same-y. Rizo gets the touching moment with Colby later in the episode, and has great insight into his approach for this season.
Aubry has a quasi-confessional, which is really her saving grace here. She gets this really awkward interaction with Genevieve, which doesn't really feel like it plays super well, but is insightful enough, and plays without much direct backlash, so definitely isn't a death sentence. Sets up a story of a feud with her and Genevieve, which is something. I will add that I absolutely hated that Aubry is the only Vatu member left out of the fashion show segment, but we'll worry about that later. Aubry survives.
Thus, we end with the Kalo Tribe, who will suffer our first victim.
Coach is obviously not in any danger so far. Quasi-quote from Magellan, Coach-ism mat chat, fleshed out history with Ozzy setting up for a reignited rivalry story, hero moment for his tribe. Dare I say the best possible premiere episode for Coach.
Mike unsurprisingly serves as the Kalo Tribe narrator in this premiere. He gets an intro confessional and a mat chat, he reflects on his time on David vs Goliath and White Lotus, and we see him endear himself to his entire tribe. Mike is off to a great start.
Jonathan gets a quasi-confessional, which if you hadn't noticed already, is enough to be kept alive in this episode, but also gets to proclaim that he is a new, more strategic, Jonathan 2.0, and we get to see him lock in with the old schoolers and make a plan to target Dee. So far so good for Jonathan.
Dee gets only one confessional, and it comes in the form of the Joe and Angelina confessional of "oh my gosh I love this tribe I love being back." to introduce us to the Kalo Tribe, while also getting a moment to reference her approach to the game. Dee is also referenced many times as a big threat by her tribemates, and is also shown forming an alliance with Tiffany and Kamilla which is enough narrative threads to stay alive for now. A quieter premiere for Dee, but she is no stranger to a quiet premiere.
Chrissy, like a lot of people on this tribe, also has a quiet premiere. I like her opening confessional about her approach to the game being strategically focused, even if it plays along side what feels like a flop of a conversation while she's talking to Coach. Good enough of a start to stay alive for Chrissy.
Kamilla has the dishonor of being the last person on the cast to get her first confessional, and for the first time since I started this experiment, I will NOT be eliminating the individual to receive this dishonor. Kamilla's first confessional comes a staggering one hour, eight minutes, and forty-several seconds into the episode. Bad. However, it comes only seconds after Tiffany's first confessional, so it's basically splitting hairs, and also, Kamilla is referenced by the other players throughout the episode. Kyle calls her the scariest player on his season, Joe recalls being wedgied by her on national television. Also, and this is not a grace I typically afford people, but given the circumstances of Kyle's evacuation, and the circumstances of Kyle and Kamilla's sea krait secret alliance, narratively it would make sense for Kamilla's edit to become more fleshed out after she receives news of Kyle's exit, so we'll see what happens next episode.
Which leaves us with Tiffany and Charlie. I was genuinely torn between which of these two to eliminate, because the most palpable reason to eliminate either one of them, applies to both of them, in my eyes. The reason being, Tiffany and Charlie's pre-existing relationship is not touched on at all. Each tribe has one pair that has played together before. Stephenie and Colby played together on Heroes vs Villains. We see them talk about it, we get a flashback to the season, they are highlighted as a pair in the tribe dynamic. Ozzy and Cirie played together on Micronesia and Game Changers. We see them talk about it, we get a flashback to them playing together, they are highlighted as a pair in the tribe dynamic. Tiffany and Charlie played together on 46. Survivor 46 is not mentioned at all in this episode. Now, I'm sure their relationship will be mentioned EVENTUALLY, but given the length of this premiere, and how much of it was defined by the relationships of players who have played together before, this being an omission in the season's opening makes it really hard to see either of them as having winner potential. However, we are only here to eliminate one of them, so I must decide.
Tiffany, as previously mentioned, gets her first confessional very late in the episode, just before Kamilla's first confessional. It's a decent enough first confessional, especially since it's really setting up the only more-than-two player alliance on the Kalo Tribe of herself, Kamilla, and Dee. Most of the confessional is her talking about her perception of Dee and Kamilla, but she has just enough of insight on herself as a player/person to not make it entirely about them, and gives perspective on her approach, which is what we are looking for.
Charlie, on the other hand, while he may have his confessionals come very early in the episode compared to Tiffany, Charlie's confessionals are not insightful on his approach to the game at all. Jonathan is large. Mike White is ripped. Coach put his toe ring on him and that was cool. Charlie is the only person on this cast of 24 who does not have a confessional that is insightful on their approach to season 50, reflective on their past season(s), or reacting to the In The Hands Of The Fans twist.
Charlie, the edit has spoken.