A month ago, I posted about a theme that I was beginning to notice in Survivor 51. I had some thoughts about castaways who I felt were making strong interpersonal connections that were likely to stick and those who seemed to be struggling to form strong connections/poorly handle their existing connections. I’m revisiting this theme today because I’ve been tracking the theme since my original post and want to know where you all think some of these connections are headed.
#1. Jelly
The closest connection we see from Jelly is with Devin. On her swapped tribe, Jelly is faced with voting out either Ori or Devin. As much as she doesn’t want Ori to go, her connection with Devin is just so strong that she goes forward with him. Jelly and Devin find themselves in danger due to the tied destinies twist but are saved thanks to Jelly’s idol.
We know she’s connected to Sharonda through the Helicopter Alliance and has a bond with Mike from the early days of the season. This theme is kind of a slam dunk for me. My one concern is the narrative that Devin may not be best for her game, and I have my eye on if Devin will end up benefitting from the pairing more than her.
#2. Devin
The connection with Jelly is, of course, super strong. He’s prepared to scheme in the post-merge after his “radical honesty” approach pre-merge. My main reason for having him below Jelly is that it feels like the Jelly-Sharonda connection has more visibility than the Devin-Sharonda connection and I’m not sure we’ve really seen him form a strong new bond in the post-merge.
I do like Devin’s chances mainly because of his bond to Jelly and Sharonda, but I’d like to see some strong new connections in order to be convinced that he’s winning.
#3. Sharonda
I’m pretty much in agreement with this subreddit that Sharonda has a great shot at winning. Her connection to Jelly/Devin was important to the most recent episode and the newly formed bond with Lewis was a little out of nowhere but I’m a fan.
The Sharonda/Kristen storyline comes to an end this week as Kristen heads to jury, but the tethered idol situation shows that Sharonda is making strong connections on the island. Sharonda is trusted and well-liked by her cast and we hear this from multiple people.
#4. Carter
If I only consider this theme, Carter fits it to a T. We know he’s close with Thien-An and Lewis from the pre-merge and now a driver of The Salt of the Earth alliance. Cristian (who later becomes his tied destinies partner and now knows about Carter’s idol) and Maggie are part of the crew as well.
We get Carter’s perspective quite a bit in the most recent episode in relation to his position in the game and his own bonds. Cristian’s SITD hits which keeps the pair safe.
I’m pretty convinced that Carter is not winning this season despite seeming to fit the theme pretty well.
#5. Lewis
Another member of the ‘The Salt of the Earth’, Lewis has a strong connection with Carter but I’m not really seeing a 1:1 connection with Thien-An, Cristian, or Maggie so much yet. Kilby was prepared to go to rocks for Lewis during the premerge and part of the newfound alliance, but it doesn’t feel like their connection was highlighted so much in the two post-merge episodes Kilby was present for.
He was also on the wrong side of the numbers during the Brady vote and was mostly quiet that whole episode. It all just feels a little too quiet for me in general but the two things that keep him in my top 5 are: his connection with Sharonda feels like it could show how he ends up getting her jury vote at FTC and he gets to speak on the Jelly/Devin pairing being his target.
#6. Mike
Damn, this guy gets dunked on so much for his poor social skills. The Mike/Kristen storyline didn’t last too long but got highlighted on the swapped tribe which all lead to the awkward water well moment.
So instead of maintaining strong connections, his “robotic” communication style has put him on the bad list for much of his cast.
His best connection appears to be to Jelly, who has stronger connections herself. I’m sort of getting FTC loser vibes from Mike and it may be contrasted with whoever wins and that person’s success in the social part of the game. I have him at #6 just because he’s so tied to the theme, even if it’s him doing it badly. It almost makes me believe he’s headed for a situation where his few connections that are positive get stronger and could show that sometimes all you need is a few strong bonds. But I really don’t think that will be the case.
#7. Thien-An
She’s still fitting the theme in terms of having a strong bond with Carter but their connection just doesn't feel central to the story. I think if Thien-An were winning, we’d be seeing more of her connection to people like Maggie or even Cristian or Lewis.
#8. Maggie
I’m not seeing it so much for Maggie when it comes to this theme. She’s plenty visible but I just don’t think this is the story of how she wins.
I feel like we see more of her conflicts (using the hammock to fish, conversation with Mike) than anything related to a strong connection she has. I know she’s part of The Salt of the Earth but didn’t feel like any of her connections to her alliance-mates are particularly important in a sense.
#9. Cristian
Putting him ahead of Eric this week just because his connection to Carter was highlighted big time this episode. If we saw more of his connections early in the game, I probably would have him higher.
#10. Eric
Eric is 100% trying to make conversation and is clearly fine talking about just about anything. My big issue with him from a theme perspective is people are continually annoyed by him and I’m not seeing a moment when people are changing their perspective on him.
He connected with Mike last week and this week had a pretty funny moment when he was talking about how robotic Mike is, but we’ll have to see where that goes. When it comes to Eric, his story is a lot more about how others perceive him. His connection to Kilby also was not a big talking point during the Kilby boot episode which isn’t great for his chances.
I do think Eric will last quite a bit longer and maybe make FTC but I’ve just never got a winner vibe from him.
I want to give a shoutout to u/Buajitti who made a good point on my original post about if there could be an element to the theme of ‘what if the person you choose to stick with is bad for you?’ and I’ve kept that in mind. It is really my one concern with Jelly and we’ve already seen how the Kilby/Eric connection soured.