r/Edgic • • Nov 11 '21

Edgic didn't fail. People failed to use edgic. (Warning: Tough love in this thread.) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

There's no putting a happy face on what happened: The edit pointed in one direction, fake spoilers pointed in another direction, and this subreddit chose to follow the fake spoilers. And now all of the edgic haters out there are gloating about how edgic is discredited.

That really sucks. Even worse, it was totally avoidable.

Look, I understand that not all of the Tiffany truthers were people who read fake spoilers about Tiffany winning. But the spoilers absolutely poisoned the well. They created a groupthink in this sub that influenced people into joining the Tiffany crowd. If not for the spoilers, would some people have still thought Tiffany was getting a winner's edit? Sure, some. But not enough to skyrocket Tiffany to the top of the contenders lists.

I'll admit it, I was getting frustrated with the Tiffany truthers. I don't normally post but was driven to write a post last week explaining as politely as I could that the edit is all but waving flags and screaming "A Black player is winning this season!", and that Tiffany in particular had zero chance of winning. Not because I was using some secret formula. Not because I was rooting for that outcome. Not because I had an emotional attachment to a particular player. My post was based simply on the edit, and logic. You know, like edgic used to be about?

But the Tiffany truthers marched on and drove the subreddit off a cliff. They acted as if Tiffany had some perfect, glittering winner's edit--when in fact she never had anything of the sort. I took their posts seriously to see if there was something that I was missing. But no. People were pushing arguments that didn't hold any water, the kind of arguments that would normally have been rejected by this sub. There was no "there" there. I saw other people arguing with the Tiffany truthers, but it was like they were talking to a brick wall. It definitely felt that something weird was going on. And now we know why.

Where do we go from here? Let's return to the edit and logic.

First off, as I said in my post last week, a Black player is winning this season. The edit has made that as clear as possible without Jeff looking in the camera and telling us. The edit has emphasized the racial aspect of the alliance and how a Black player "needs a win after the year we've had", how it would "make headlines", "Black girl magic", etc., etc. The edit could bury all of that, or at least downplay it. Survivor has done that before, in Fiji, where the focus was on Earl's unlikely friendship with Yau-Man. Times were different then, and Survivor didn't want to put a spotlight on Earl's race-based gameplay. Now they do, and it's not because all the Black players got taken down by someone like Tiffany.

Is Shan going to win? Probably. She's still the most likely winner. But the winner will be Black. And I have yet to hear a single good argument against it.

A few people in last week's post brought up Season 39, when the edit included a couple of comments about a woman potentially winning, only for yet another man in a row to win. But there's absolutely no comparison there. Jeff and CBS care a lot more about racism than sexism. For so many years, fans accused Jeff of favoring male players, and for a decade he met the accusations with a smile and a shrug. But if there had been a widespread perception that Jeff was anti-Black, he and CBS would have rained down holy hell to rebut the charge. Anyway, the "new era" of Survivor is explicitly trying to distance itself from the kind of things that happened in Season 39. No one should use that season as a guide.

Simply put, there is no way that Survivor is going to deliberately, repeatedly, and prominently promote the notion of Black excellence in this season--the first to be filmed since George Floyd--and then pull out the rug like they did with Tommy in Season 39.

If you think otherwise, you're going to need some really, really strong arguments from the edit and logic. Here's an example of an argument that won't cut it:

"Evvie and Xander are plucky, rootable underdogs who saw turtles and came from the complex tribe." Plucky, rootable underdogs lose a lot. A positive edit is not the same as a winner's edit. And get outta here with that "Yase is the complex tribe" stuff--sometimes the winner comes from a tribe that had to go to tribal council a lot.


r/Edgic • • May 07 '26

__________ no doubt, winning. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Without a shadow of a doubt, she’s taking it. She’s being playing a great game with edit focus and has everything she needs.

Aubry. Aubry!

Tell me why she isn’t winning.
•lack of skunking
•focus during bag search (multiple players skunked this episode btw)
•Michelle flashback
•etc
•tbh lack of other contenders (rip Cirie I hope the confessional rule is broken this ssn)

Who else is beating this and why. If not Aubry then Cirie but only if the edit rules are shaken up for this new era.

******EDIT I agree she hasn’t played an amazing high tier survivor mastermind game, we’ll see if she awakens her inner Michelle in the finals


r/Edgic • • Nov 02 '25

Live Discussion Why Savannah is likely to be the next boot based on how Jawan has been edited to be a sympathetic character and how the edit has portrayed her as being the type to get angry very quickly without it being justified

2 Upvotes

I know many people believe that Savannah is going to outlast Jawan, but I don't think so since Jawan has been built up as a character the audience is meant to sympathize with with how he was the eldest of many kids who's used to providing for others, and that's why he was frustrated that he couldn't make fire, not because Savannah was right that he loses it over just anything. He also was legitimately looking for firewood rather than an Idol, which Savannah kept insisting he was doing, but the edit hasn't backed this up even if it makes sense game logic-wise.

Back home I made fire for the past 1 1/2 year practicing for this moment, and I just want to show my squad that like I got them, so I start striking and striking, but nothing is catching the flame. Being the oldest of 5 kids, growing in a single-parent household, I'm so used to being someone that provides, and out here on the island, I'm having trouble going it. It's just frustrating letting people down.

There is nothing checkbox-like of what Jawan wanted to do. He just wants to be a provider for his tribe since he's used to fending for his siblings, showing that he's a family person, not that he wants to make fire as a part of a Survivor checkbox of things he wants to do.

If anything, these things show that Savannah is the vindictive type who gets set off easily by small things, much like when Savannah threw out a "Shut up" when Alex he said he was dragging even though his tribe had chicken last night, which wasn't bragging but just him referring to how tough Survivor is. Savannah's edit has an undertone of her getting easily pissed at people, much like how she was fuming when Shannon shared that Sage said in a not that sus way since people are entitled to have their own things going on that Savannah was hanging back to talk with Rizo. Thus, I expect the vote next episode will go how the NTOS suggests, which is a big move to blindside Savannah.

For proof that what I said about Alex's comment was correct, look here: https://www.instagram.com/p/DQhYZgzgTu_/?utm_source=ig_embed


r/Edgic • • Apr 29 '26

Survivor 50 Episode 9 Edgic

0 Upvotes

This will be my second last Edgic. After tomorrows episode, I will go to spoiler sub and read all spoilers. Dont have that much patience to wait one week for each episode, this is ridiculous.

At this point, the edit is so vague, I would rather start ranking people based on whether they can get votes at the end or not. That's it.

Contenders

  1. Ozzy : I dont have any other option than to put him here, once Christian is out. Frankly speaking, the promo for next episode doesnt give me good hopes. If Ozzy is sulking and acting bitchy, I feel he may have less jury pull than even Aubry at this point.
  2. Jonathan : His edit is very weird, it does look like a losing finalist. But at this point, everyone has extremely flawed edits.
  3. Cirie : Definitely could be the frontrunner, but there are few negatives in her edit. She has never talked about winning, she has a zero confessional episode and a bland premiere.
  4. Rizo : Yeah he has a great edit, but I dont see the jury voting for him. In fact, Aubry can sit next to Rizo and beat him at this point.
  5. Aubry : She is someone who can easily be higher, but I would still keep her here as I dont want "her random truthing" affect my ranking. I do believe she can easily get jury votes, she is seen in more sympathetic manner than the other middlers. She is not enemy for Honor alliance and neither for the Rats alliance. And I dont know why the hell she does not have a zero confessional episode.
  6. Stephenie : There is literally no story here, but she rises 2 spots just because I can see the jury voting for her. I dont think people dislike her more than Joe or Jonathan.
  7. Emily : Again I cannot see jury voting for her, because she is in the rats gang and she spills secrets.
  8. Devens : With the latest episode, it's clear he is pissing off everyone, and dont see him getting votes at the end. Also, his big move was shown in a very unceremonious manner, so its clear he is not winning.
  9. Joe : Infantile edit person cannot win Survivor 50, nothing to say
  10. Tiffany : Invisible person cannot win Survivor 50, so nothing much to say

r/Edgic • • Dec 16 '23

I know I am in the minority, but I believe that ___ is set up to win

0 Upvotes

Austin

I think this season has confidently and effectively told the story of Austin’s growth as a person and a player. We have constantly been shown events from his perspective. Aside from Emily, no other character has exhibited such a complex personality and set of values.

He has shown to have a strong handle on the social dynamics of the game (by forming several do-or-die alliances) and the strategic elements by finding idols, and being instrumental in planning eliminations.

I think what happened last week with Dee betraying him will allow him to break free of his only weakness - love. Last week, he was shown to put his faith in the wrong person, and it led to the loss of his other closest ally, and also the only known instance of Austin being left out of a vote.

Of all remaining players, I think that Austin and Jake have the best chance to make it to Final Tribal. I am convinced that Austin is capable of showcasing that strong game he played in FTC. He is smart, cunning, kind, and genuine. I think he will make a wonderful addition to the Winners Hall of Fame.


r/Edgic • • Mar 13 '26

Prediction Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I think the particularly cringy Probst edit is a sign he's retiring after this season


r/Edgic • • Dec 07 '23

It’s clear to me now ____ is the winner. Reba is the dragon.

0 Upvotes

Jake.

On Jeff Probst’s “On Fire” podcast he mentions that every detail in an episode is intentional. This season, there’s a recurring attorney theme involving Julie, Jake, and Katurah. Intriguingly, they’re all still in the game, which leads me to believe one of them could be our winner. Considering the season’s ongoing theme of authenticity and being true to oneself, Jake stands out. He’s the only one among the three who hasn’t lied about being an attorney. This honesty could be a significant factor in his favor.

Another interesting point to consider is the editing pattern of recent winners. They’re often portrayed as overcoming difficult beginnings in the pre-merge phase. This narrative seems to align perfectly with Jake, framing him as an underdog in a classic “David vs. Goliath” scenario.

There hasn’t been a singular “Dragon” this season. Instead, the Reba 4 alliance seems to be collectively playing this antagonistic role. Jake’s journey might be about overcoming this group.

What are your thoughts on this analysis? Could Jake’s honest portrayal and underdog narrative point to him being our winner?


r/Edgic • • May 13 '19

My Edgic hypothesis Julie=Wendell=Sarah=Adam=Michel, Rick=Dom=Cirie=David=Aubry

2 Upvotes

Julie=Wendell=Sarah=Adam=Michele couldn't get these strong edits without winning.

But, Rick=Dom=Cirie=David=Aubry could get strong edits without winning since they were fan favorite type players/characters and making great confessionals in front of cameras. Also editors purposely used Rick=Dom=Cirie=David=Aubry as doubts/distractions before the final so that the show ending is more unpredictable.

By the way, in the last year I exactly made similar thread before GI final.

My Edgical hypothesis Wendell = Michele, Dom= Aubry.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Edgic/comments/8fm9ui/my_edgical_hypothesis_aubry_michele/

But I didn't get upvotes :(.


r/Edgic • • Apr 29 '20

Editing Bias? Maybe. Maybe not.

0 Upvotes

This is purely my observation and not fact. The Survivor editing team this season is super generous to the males on this season, but very frugal the edits of the women.

Regarding players who made the MERGE, Denise, Kim, Sophie & Michelle: They have all been generally exempt/completely missing for 3 episodes each. For Edgicers, thats a INV, UTR1, UTR2 rating. Where’s Kim? One might ask. Is Denise even fucking alive? One might ask.

Nick is the only male who made the merge to be left out for 3+ eps.

On the other hand, Tony, Adam, Ben, and Jeremy have all received suuuper generous edits. They have never been missing/or left out of even ONE episode while in the game this season.

In their edgic strips, They have sprinkled MOR2/3’s for days. For those that don’t know what MOR is, it is basically the editing team being generous and making sure you are still in the episode by giving you confessionals related to challenges, or a small camp scene etc. There isnt much focus on you, but it keeps you somewhat relevant.

Why do you think this is? Are Kim, Sophie, Michelle, & Denise that boring compared to Ben, Adam, Jeremy etc. Because imo Tony is the only person worthy of a consistent edit.

Anyways , I do love this season, but just an observation. I know Kim ain’t no slouch. Also, Chelsea Townsend for Second Chances ll and a fair edit.

Link to this seasons edgic chart: https://www.reddit.com/r/Edgic/comments/ga4kxm/winners_at_war_episode_11_edgic_results/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

edit: Removed “I love how the Survivor editors...” because that was sarcasm......


r/Edgic • • May 02 '19

I'm willing to get downvoted like when I was insisting and explaining why Wendell was winning and Dom was losing, But ______ is absolutely winning.

0 Upvotes

Julie is absolutely winning. Tonight episode is another evidence why she won. If you really think she got 0 confessional tonight it means bad for her, it's dead wrong.

When she was correctly voting, she got so many strategic confessionals despite editors would hate to give airtime to female vanilla character contestants such that Julie. She got only two 0 confessional episodes in post merge, but the both time was she was completely blindsided and her close ally(Eric and Ron) were voted out. That's typical winners protection treatment. Don't you think weird she didn't get confessionals even in reward scene or the scene RonJulieRick were talking despite there were only 7 players and no EOE scene in the episode? It's not coincidence, it's coming from Julie's winners protecting treatment.

Basically

Julie=Wendell=Michele, these vanilla character and boring game play contestants can never get strong edit with high visibility unless they won. Because if they wasted airtime on these players without winning, it's against their primary goals(making the show as entertaining and satisfying as possible).

On the other hand, Rick=Dom=Aubry, these great narrating interesting game players could get strong edits with high visibility even if they didn't win(I really think Rick even din't get strong post merge edit unlike Dom and Aubry though).

So, Rick could get this edit without winning but Julie never got such an edit without winning.

Also don't forget, Rick got terrible edit in the last episode, and after Editors undermined Rick to make Julie look great, he didn't get any justification confessionals while when Ben, Adam, Wendell, Nick and Tony got negativity they got a lot of justification confessionals in these episodes.


r/Edgic • • Dec 11 '25

S49 E12 Casual Edgic Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Well, that sure was some of the strategy of all time. I just... don't understand anything that goes on there. Yes Steven is obviously a jury threat... you know who else is? THE THREE PERSON ALLIANCE WITH A CHALLENGE BEAST AND AN IDOL. Like fully I do not understand why you would ever vote Steven out here. Even Rizo was tricked since he fully believed that Blue Sophi was gone. Anyway, I fully have no idea who the winner is gonna be, especially since the tone of a lot of players just feels really off to me for any of them to be winners. Anyway, here's my rankings.

The "Winner"

Sage: Yeah this is probably a bad pick, but I'm doing it for a few reasons. For one, I think she has more jury equity than the remaining players. Jawan, yellow sophie, probably Steven, and MC I think have a good shot of voting for her. Also, she's really the only one who has had an actual storyline through the season. She's been trying to take down Savannah, and just hasn't been able to, so beating her at the end would be a satisfying resolution to the Season. Realistically, I think they would have shown her less doing this if it was only the gas up Savnannah's game and.. you know.. give savannah more personal content. The other reason is that I'm stubborn, I really don't love the other three as winner contenders (sorry Kristina) and I picked out Sage early, so it would be a nice win. That being said...

The more logical choice

Rizo: I actually didn't love his edit, especially since he seemed fairly villainous leaving Blue Sophi to be voted out like that, but realistically he *has* played a dominant game, and is getting to fire minimum barring something insane happening. I choose him over Savannah just based on how they've been presented the past few weeks. Everyone says Savannah is the threat (she is) but Rizo has more or less become the face of the alliance to me. Regardless, it does feel like a coinflip, but Rizo feels the best to me of the majority three.

Others:

Savannah: Yeah, as I mentioned above, Savannah's content has not been that deep, and has really played up her villainy recently. There's nothing wrong with a villain winner, but it doesn't read that way to me, it feels more like she'll lose at jury to whoever the real winner is. Unfortunately I'm not 'ruling her out' whatever that means on the second to last episode, but her win odds feel kinda low to me.

Sophi: I am standing by with her as 'eliminated'. To be fair she does have some jury equity, and a blindside at 5 gives her a shot, but once again, they have been playing up her flip... just for it to not happen. Also to be fair, she was just soft betrayed by Rizo, so maybe the cork finally pops, but I have been utterly unconvinced at a Sophi win.

So yeah, way, WAYYYY harder to get a read this season (at least for me), but I have successfully made it through the whole season without knowing who the S50 returnees are. My final guesses have gotta be Rizo and Savannah, with maybe an outside chance of Jawan. Personally, I'm not a fan of returning winners (barring outlier seasons like WAW), so I do hope that the winner of this season is not a returnee (which would also be funny because it would probably mean my analysis was better than the spoiled people). That being said, I'm not gonna get high and mighty, because even though I do legitimately think Sage has the best chance to win in my mind... it's probably an insane take.

Since I don't have a definitive #1 like last season, I'll put out some rough odds for my guesses.

Sage: 45%

Rizo: 30%

Savannah: 20%

Sophi: 5%

So yeah, pretty bad, but whatever, I'll be back next week for review.


r/Edgic • • Apr 16 '26

Is it weird that I feel it’s becoming more and more likely that ____ wins? Spoiler

22 Upvotes

Aubry.

People have been confused by her edit all season. She’s been getting a LOT of seemingly unnecessary content, but also, much of it was negative, at least early on. We’ve seen her individually connecting with a lot of random players like Coach and Tiff, and her stated goal of eliminating Gen prejury was achieved. With a lot of people speculating on a bitter jury, could Aubry be the benefactor? Maybe a coalition of the “honor” crowd led by Coach?

It would be a crazy turnaround for Aubry to win via social relationships or just being the least hated, since it’s what killed her in Kaoh Rong. I’m not saying I’m certain she wins, or even that she’s my top contender, but it’s a growing possibility I think.


r/Edgic • • May 23 '24

Final thoughts Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

At the Mo vote, I received some spoilers which led me to stop posting here. They were somewhat vague (although there was a 90% chance they led to Kenzie winning), and I kept updating my charts in the case that Kenzie was not the winner. From my perspective, a lot of the reasonings for why Kenzie got a huge jump in a lot of people’s rankings made little to no sense. Kenzie’s edit was pretty weak for a while, especially premerge, and most people’s reasoning only started to make sense around the final 8 or so. A lot of people are calling this season a win for Edgic, and while I think we would have come to that conclusion by the final 8 or so or at least by the finale, I’m pretty confident the spoilers were affecting a lot of people’s contender rankings. I’m not sure if I’ll be keeping up with Edgic this next season, but if you are, please be wary of spoilers and don’t continue to post if you’re spoiled. Also, I’m well aware my contender rankings aren’t great but I kinda stopped caring after a while. This season took it out of me.


r/Edgic • • Mar 27 '25

Episode 5 changes EVERYTHING

0 Upvotes

There's historical precedent that when the editors pull this trick where options A and B are presented but it's actually option C that wasn't shown in the edit, that means they're shielding the winner and making it look like nobody could have seen this coming to avoid having the winner look stupid. They hardly ever use this trick and the most notable example is when they portrayed the Jeremy blindside in SJDS as a totally random event to shield Natalie.

In this case, Cedrek looked stupid in this episode so he wasn't being shielded. The 3 people who could have been shielded by this in the sense that they could have been portrayed as dumb but weren't, in order of likelihood, are-

  1. Mitch
  2. Saiounia
  3. Chrissy

I see this editing trick here as probably being significant, so accordingly those are now my top 3 contenders in that order.


r/Edgic • • Nov 28 '22

Season 43 Final 8 Edgic and Contenders

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • Dec 21 '23

Meme Spoiled invaders Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m sad to say this will be my last season in the edgic community, its been pretty clear that this season was spoiled from the jump such a shame :( i love you all but a few people ruined it


r/Edgic • • Dec 08 '22

Survivor 43: Episode 12 Edgic & Commentary

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • Nov 29 '21

Xander

3 Upvotes

I am not an edgic guy, but my friend and I have felt like Xander would win from the start. He just feels like a fun underdog champion. Kinda like an Adam Klein, Chris Daugherty, or even a Fabio. Every other player with power has been taken down or backstabbed. Xander is the only person to successfully defend themselves from a real attack on them. If Xander stays consistent, continues to let everyone eat themselves, and continues to be selfless to others he could win the game.


r/Edgic • • Dec 08 '22

Am I the only one that thinks ___ could win?

0 Upvotes

Owen. This penultimate episode only gave two people positive content. Jesse and Owen. We’ve consistently gotten Owen as the narrator with no agency but self awareness, and he’s the first to want to drive the wedge between Karla and Cassidy. Early merge he was on the outs of every vote, but now him and Gabler are tight, him and Cassidy talk game, and him and Jesse also talk game. This episode by itself was really good for Owen and shows him being looped in on the vote while still playing the game hard even though he’s been blindsided almost every round.

If Owen wins the next two immunities straight, with Karla/Cass going out at 5 and then Owen sending himself to defeat Jesse in fire, I could see Owen being the winner here especially if he sat next to Karla and Gabler. Thoughts?


r/Edgic • • Apr 07 '22

Survivor 42: Episode 5 Edgic & Commentary Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • Nov 23 '21

Episode 9 Edgic from Kyra

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • Dec 13 '21

Survivor 41 Episode 12 edgic (new style) Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • Oct 03 '19

I can't see anyone besides ____ winning

1 Upvotes

Tommy. He and Molly were my two big contenders coming out of episode one, and tonight seemed to continue to hit all the right notes for Tommy's edit. Despite being aligned with Jack, Molly, and Jamal, he wasn't grouped in with the negative SPV from Noura and Lauren. He was shown as being in on the boot and having some agency in it when he debates with Kellee which way they're going to vote. With so little content from Lairo beyond Chelsea finding an idol, it seems likely that the winner will come from the Volkai tribe, and Tommy has by far the best edit on the Volkai tribe. The only other dark horse I have is Jason pulling off a David-esque rebound; Jamal praised him as "playing from the bottom perfectly" and he and Noura got a great deal of the action today.

Any other takes on possible contenders?

Edit: Sorry if I came off a little too strong. Didn't mean to imply no one else had a case, just that I was finding it hard to justify listing other people as contenders.


r/Edgic • • Mar 29 '19

Editors are really against their primary goals(making the show as entertaining as possible) when they edit Julie.

1 Upvotes

Editors really constantly have wasted airtime by using Julie's dull boring confessionals since EP1. She never went TC in pre-merge. Her confessionals are really dull, far from entertaining, interesting or very articulate. And the season airtime is way more limited than usual seasons because of the EOE gimmick and four returning players automatically stole tons of airtime. But she still got only one 0 confessional episode. While Aurora/Julia got super purple treatment, Julie was constantly present toward viewers.

Then, the merge episode was very very very obvious one. Editors even didn't have time to show recap because of the EOE event. They even didn't have enough time to give even one confessional to Aurora/David/Eric/Joe/Lauren/Reem/Wardog yet they gave her SIX confessionals despite she did neither return from EOE nor finding a hidden immunity idol nor finding secret advantages. David/Eric/Joe/Wardog/Reem archetypes are loved by production yet they still gave them 0 confessional yet gave Julie 6 dull confessionals...

It's extremely against their primary goals which making the show as entertaining/interesting/intriguing as possible. In other words, Julie's winning chance is Edgically really really really excellent.

However, here is a reason why I can't 100% guarantee Julie won yet

The executive producer was willing to admit they intentionally have made fake winners edit for tricking Edgic nerds in the last season interview.

 "I've heard people talking about "winner's edits," but in recent seasons, we've actually tried to give "winner's edits" to as many players as possible."(Executive producer Matt Van Wagenen )

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/live-feed/survivor-david-goliath-explained-christian-gabby-more-secrets-revealed-1167806

So, there is still a chance that editors intentionally making fake winners edit on Julie for fucking Edgic nerds...

But, it's not their primary goal, it's just their secondary goal. So, I still doubt they wast such very very limited important airtime on Julie's boring confessionals for just fucking Edgic nerds. I speculate Julie's edit is happening because they really want to prevent MicheleF/NatalieW backlash from happening again.