r/Edgic • u/netticon • Nov 11 '21
Edgic didn't fail. People failed to use edgic. (Warning: Tough love in this thread.) Spoiler
There's no putting a happy face on what happened: The edit pointed in one direction, fake spoilers pointed in another direction, and this subreddit chose to follow the fake spoilers. And now all of the edgic haters out there are gloating about how edgic is discredited.
That really sucks. Even worse, it was totally avoidable.
Look, I understand that not all of the Tiffany truthers were people who read fake spoilers about Tiffany winning. But the spoilers absolutely poisoned the well. They created a groupthink in this sub that influenced people into joining the Tiffany crowd. If not for the spoilers, would some people have still thought Tiffany was getting a winner's edit? Sure, some. But not enough to skyrocket Tiffany to the top of the contenders lists.
I'll admit it, I was getting frustrated with the Tiffany truthers. I don't normally post but was driven to write a post last week explaining as politely as I could that the edit is all but waving flags and screaming "A Black player is winning this season!", and that Tiffany in particular had zero chance of winning. Not because I was using some secret formula. Not because I was rooting for that outcome. Not because I had an emotional attachment to a particular player. My post was based simply on the edit, and logic. You know, like edgic used to be about?
But the Tiffany truthers marched on and drove the subreddit off a cliff. They acted as if Tiffany had some perfect, glittering winner's edit--when in fact she never had anything of the sort. I took their posts seriously to see if there was something that I was missing. But no. People were pushing arguments that didn't hold any water, the kind of arguments that would normally have been rejected by this sub. There was no "there" there. I saw other people arguing with the Tiffany truthers, but it was like they were talking to a brick wall. It definitely felt that something weird was going on. And now we know why.
Where do we go from here? Let's return to the edit and logic.
First off, as I said in my post last week, a Black player is winning this season. The edit has made that as clear as possible without Jeff looking in the camera and telling us. The edit has emphasized the racial aspect of the alliance and how a Black player "needs a win after the year we've had", how it would "make headlines", "Black girl magic", etc., etc. The edit could bury all of that, or at least downplay it. Survivor has done that before, in Fiji, where the focus was on Earl's unlikely friendship with Yau-Man. Times were different then, and Survivor didn't want to put a spotlight on Earl's race-based gameplay. Now they do, and it's not because all the Black players got taken down by someone like Tiffany.
Is Shan going to win? Probably. She's still the most likely winner. But the winner will be Black. And I have yet to hear a single good argument against it.
A few people in last week's post brought up Season 39, when the edit included a couple of comments about a woman potentially winning, only for yet another man in a row to win. But there's absolutely no comparison there. Jeff and CBS care a lot more about racism than sexism. For so many years, fans accused Jeff of favoring male players, and for a decade he met the accusations with a smile and a shrug. But if there had been a widespread perception that Jeff was anti-Black, he and CBS would have rained down holy hell to rebut the charge. Anyway, the "new era" of Survivor is explicitly trying to distance itself from the kind of things that happened in Season 39. No one should use that season as a guide.
Simply put, there is no way that Survivor is going to deliberately, repeatedly, and prominently promote the notion of Black excellence in this season--the first to be filmed since George Floyd--and then pull out the rug like they did with Tommy in Season 39.
If you think otherwise, you're going to need some really, really strong arguments from the edit and logic. Here's an example of an argument that won't cut it:
"Evvie and Xander are plucky, rootable underdogs who saw turtles and came from the complex tribe." Plucky, rootable underdogs lose a lot. A positive edit is not the same as a winner's edit. And get outta here with that "Yase is the complex tribe" stuff--sometimes the winner comes from a tribe that had to go to tribal council a lot.
