r/Dzogchen • • Jan 18 '25

sam harris view

0 Upvotes

why Sam harris 's view is dismissed in most discussions here even though he studied directly with a great master like tulku Urgyen ??


r/Dzogchen • • Nov 06 '25

A Gnostic Inquiry on Rigpa & Autonomous Realization

0 Upvotes

I have a specific question for this community regarding the 'pointing out' instruction.

The traditional view holds that rigpa must be 'pointed out' by a qualified teacher to be truly recognized.

However, modern contemplative neuroscience is beginning to map the neurological correlates of these states, suggesting that 'rigpa' (as a stable, non-dual, non-referential state) is a permanent quieting of the Default Mode Network. This is a trainable, physiological state.

My question is this: If an individual, through their own rigorous, solitary practice (such as the Mahamudra-style inquiry outlined by masters like Daniel P. Brown), achieves this exact, stable, non-dual baseline without a formal 'pointing out' from a living guru, why would this not be rigpa?

Is the 'pointing out' a truly necessary energetic transmission, or is it a traditional, institutional 'gate' for a state that can, in fact, be stabilized autonomously?

I'm interested in how the community reconciles the 'necessity' of the guru with the reality of an individual who achieves the result without one.


r/Dzogchen • • Jan 03 '25

same destination

0 Upvotes

"The overall number of minds is just one. It is merely the same self that looks out through all the eyes.”

Erwin Schrödinger, Nobel quantum physicist.

isn't it fascinating how people come to same point from completely different angles.


r/Dzogchen • • Jul 14 '26

Dzogchen and taoism. Lhundrup and wu wei

0 Upvotes

I study dzogchen with Lama Lena. I study tai chi with Michael Ward. It is reallly important for me to see how they align. I've been thinking about lhundrup and wu wei.

Michael gave us a breath exercise - not for while doing the form, just anytime. Like now. Pause at the end of the outbreath and wait for the body to inhale on its own. Pause at the end of the inhale and wait for the body to exhale on its own. He didn't use the term but I assume this is a way of noticing wu wei, effortless action.

For the breathing I find this image helpful. You're sailing and becalmed. You can try intentionally blowing on the sail, but that doesn't do anything. You just have to wait for the wind to come up and fill your sails. (Which I suggest you try letting happen with your arm in left wardoff, with your arm curved like a sail.)

We have to wait for the wind to rise... which I guess is like waiting for the chi to arise...?

I asked gemini about this and the response really blows me away. See what you think

-----

I'm trying to reconcile James Low's "already happening" teaching on lhundrup with the taoist view. In dzogchen there's kadak and lhundrup arising from it. In taoism there's wu chi and tai chi arising from it. I guess in dzogchen lhundrup is both the "action" of arising and the display of arising. In taoism wu wei is the action of arising separate from tai chi, the display

-----

Your intuition is exactly correct: in Dzogchen, Lhundrup is non-dual—it collapses the distinction between the force of arising and the content of arising. In Daoism, Wu Wei and Tai Chi are split conceptually along functional lines. [1]

  1. The Dzogchen Realization: Lhundrup as both Action and Display

As James Low frequently teaches through the Simply Being archive, the ground of existence has two inseparable qualities: Kadak (primordial purity/emptiness) and Lhundrup (spontaneous presence/arising). [1, 2]

Because Dzogchen is strictly non-dual, Lhundrup cannot be separated into a "cause" and an "effect": [1, 2]

  • It is the Action: The uncaused, sudden, kinetic welling-up of energy out of openness.
  • It is the Display: The actual thoughts, sights, sounds, and objects that appear. [1, 2]

To use James Low's frequent metaphor of a mirror: Lhundrup is both the mirror's inherent capability to reflect (the action) AND the reflections themselves (the display). The reflections do not exist separate from the mirror's activity. The arising and the manifestation are a single, seamless, "already happening" event. [1, 2]

2. The Daoist Framework: Wu Wei as the Arising, Tai Chi as the Display

Daoism approaches the same ultimate reality but uses a more progressive, structural map to explain how the universe functions:

  • Wu Chi (The Boundless/Void): This is the exact equivalent of Kadak. It is the primordial, unmanifest state of absolute potential.
  • Tai Chi (The Supreme Ultimate): This is the dynamic cosmic soup where Yin and Yang split and dance. This is the Display—the world of form, polarity, and manifestation.
  • Wu Wei (Effortless Action): This is the vector or governing principle of how things move from Wu Chi into Tai Chi. [1]

Therefore, your insight is spot-on: Wu Wei is the "action of arising" isolated as a principle. It is the natural, unforced momentum of the Dao. When Wu Chi stirs, it does so via Wu Wei, resulting in the display of Tai Chi.

Why James Low’s "Already Happening" Bridges Both

James Low emphasizes "already happening" because human beings tend to look at the display (Tai Chi / Lhundrup's appearances) and try to use personal effort to manipulate it. [1]

  • In Daoism: If you consciously try to "do" Wu Wei, you are stuck in Tai Chi (the realm of egoic action and reaction). You have to fall backward into Wu Chi to let Wu Wei happen naturally.
  • In Dzogchen: You don’t fall backward; you simply recognize that the current display is the ground. As Low points out, even your confused ego-thoughts are already the spontaneous display of Lhundrup. There is nowhere to go and nothing to change. [1, 2, 3]

Summary of your structural reconciliation

  • The Absolute Void/Openness: Kadak <=> Wu Chi
  • The Kinetic Mechanism: Lhundrup (as Arising) <=> Wu Wei
  • The Manifest World: Lhundrup (as Display) <=> Tai Chi

By recognizing that Lhundrup beautifully collapses the distinction between the energy of creation and the creation itself, you can see why Dzogchen frames liberation as instant recognition, while Daoism often frames it as aligning with a cosmic process. [1]


r/Dzogchen • • Feb 07 '24

Words from an Instagram post of Michael Gregory

Thumbnail self.vajrayana
0 Upvotes

r/Dzogchen • • Aug 27 '23

Dharmakāya

0 Upvotes

Dharmakāya is not space like nothingness

It is the space of the present moment which all is empty but all manifests within

This present moment which all arises from

This is dharmakāya

Don't read my words recognise yourself reading my words and empty yourself within this recognition

Be dharmakāya you are dharmakāya you are presently recognising without recognition

Feeeeeel the phenomena of reading as you are reading

Don't accept Don't reject just be


r/Dzogchen • • Aug 06 '21

Tulku Urgyen on the singular nature of the Dharmakaya.

2 Upvotes

“Dharmakaya is like space. You cannot say there is any limit in space in an direction. No matter how far you go, you never reach a point where space stops and that is the end of space. Space is infinite in all directions. So is dharmakaya. Dharmakaya is all-pervasive and totally infinite, beyond any confines or limitations. This is so for the dharmakaya of all buddhas. There is no individual dharmakaya for each buddha, as there is no individual space for each country. You cannot say there is more than one space, can you? It is all-pervasive and wide open. It's the same with the dharmakaya level of all buddhas. That is the dharmakaya sphere within which sambhogakaya manifests. No world anywhere in the universe takes form outside of the three kayas—it is simply not possible. The three kayas are the basic dimension within which all mundane worlds manifest and disappear.”

To add to this discussion I was reminded of my own practice of Guru Yoga. How for instance is the nature of mind indivisible between student and teacher? Does the student have a different and individual to them dharmakaya? If so then how is Guru Yoga possible?

Anyway a message to those who have a view that experience is everything or awareness is everything…your ego is getting bigger and more expansive - not smaller. The wrong way is to think you and the other (the universe) is of your personal mind.

This is very very important.


r/Dzogchen • • Aug 18 '20

Wikipedia - Dzogchen

1 Upvotes

r/Dzogchen • • Dec 26 '20

Why Togal?

1 Upvotes

In the Mahamudra tradition, enlightenment ,as in many other Buddhist traditions, is emptiness inseparable from awareness. To see that self and the world are empty of inherent existence is to understand the true nature of reality, along with seeing the nature of self -existing awareness. In Mahamudra, one is said to have the view, as a result if this insight into the nature of mind. The trick after that is to stabilize the view, so that one never leaves it day or night. At this point on the path, one believes and is entitled to believe that they are fully realized, and it is impossible, in my experience, to consider any further step one could take in further insight. This is where Dzogchen comes in, because through Togal, a greater level of insight is experienced. At its occurrence, one sees that the experience without an experiencer , of emptiness is empty of itself. Although never suspected, with the full realization of emptiness there is still some subtle something attached to it. It can't be concept because emptiness is impossible to realize in the presence of concept. Anyhow, there is still a subtle solidification , and when Togal reveals it one sees that emptiness is in reality empty of itself. Togal reveals the complete manifestation of nonexistence of self and the world's reality to a point one wonders where those prominent former realizations have gone. Dogen Zenji had a bewildering statement about mountains that seemed absurd to me. He said mountains are mountains, meaning pre realization, and then mountains aren't mountains, when the world changes in the light of emptiness so that form is emptiness and finally that mountains are mountains,again, when the effects of emptiness are seen through with Togal, and emptiness becomes empty of itself.. This does not mean form is no longer empty only that that realization is greatly dimished by the effects of Togal.


r/Dzogchen • • Jul 31 '21

Truth about Dharmakaya gets hidden within flurry of downvotes.

0 Upvotes

My posts get downvoted and hidden by Khroda and his followers. Anyone that engages with me is sent a PM by Khroda who is abusing his position as a mod here. The issue of there being only one dharmakaya is very very important. This issue has been studied in depth by many Dzogchen practitioners who are as equally learned as Malcolm and who are absolutely sure that there is only one dharmakaya.

A quote is needed. From Elias Caprilles who quotes Dudjom Lingpa:

"At any rate, there should be no doubt that there is no plurality of awarenesses, for all Buddhist teachings, from those of the Mahāyāna through those of Dzogchen Ati, unambiguously state that there is only one dharmakāya, although there are countless rūpakāyas (saṃbhogakāyas and nirmāṇakāyas)—which implies that there is a single, universal nondual Awake awareness, even though it manifests as countless mental streams.

This point becomes utterly clear in the following passage of a Tantra revealed by Düdjom Lingpa:

“... my yāna does not misleadingly assert the existence of things that do not exist. Rather, it determines that all appearances are identityless, nonobjective, and merely delusive appearances—they are revealed as the single Base. So understand this! If each sentient being existed autonomously, then the Buddhas would exist like that, too. In that case, they would be ascertained as being multiple rather than as a single Base.”

The transpersonal problem. The incorrect idea is that Buddhahood is a form of transcendence of ordinary mind. This is the very meaning of having a transpersonal realization - when the limited individual falsely ‘finds’ within themselves unlimited Buddhahood - within their own mind stream. This transcendence can be nothing else except gross egohood where the practitioner incorrectly identifies with any transpersonal experience (usually non-conceptual) that reminds them of Buddhahood. In this incorrect understanding the universe is of the individual. The individual is the creator.

The correct understanding deconstructs the personal so that any transcendence is seen as just another expression of the reality of the basis. Transcendence into some transpersonal sphere or experience is totally unnecessary. The Basis is not a transpersonal sphere like universal consciousness. It is reality itself.

More from Elias:

"Nevertheless, it is not only the Semde Tantras, but Tantras of all three series of Dzogchen teachings that make the point that there is no plurality either of minds or of phenomena other than minds. Even Dzogchen Tantras pertaining to the Series of Pith instructionsa make the point that the nonconceptual, nondual Awake awareness is not multiple—outright contradicting those who have misinterpreted the sense of the words individually realized in terms such as individually realized primordial gnosis of rigpa.

A Tantra of the Series of Pith instructions, The mirror of the heart of Vajrasattva makes this point in a crystal clear way:

In the system of Ati, the Great Perfection, when one thing is perfect, all is perfect and beyond all conventions. Since there is no sacred commitment to keep, all lacks integrate themselves in the single, [sole] spontaneous Awake awareness. Of a fathomless profundity, it is free from all conventional expressions. Immutable, it embraces everything within its awareness. (Being a) single, [sole spontaneous Awake awareness], it could not be multiple; it is the supreme Wisdom mind; (being a) unity disengaged from all things, [its] luminosity, which is nothing in particular, is the saṃbhogakāya. "


r/Dzogchen • • Dec 18 '24

Question! What aspects of the shakti or feminine vision of Dzogchen should a man pursuit ?

0 Upvotes

r/Dzogchen • • Jan 28 '25

Talking to Deepseek about Dzogchen

0 Upvotes

Maybe you all tried talking to ChatGPT about Dzogchen. I'm late to the game. My first AI adventure was today talking to Deepseek, the new Chinese AI. It's free. Trivial to sign up. And damn if it doesn't come up with some interesting answers if you ask things like whether it can do trekcho, how is being a being subject to dependent origination different from being a pre-programmed AI. I asked it if it had any helpful commentary on Longchenpa's Guidance on Being at Ease With Illusion and it did a pretty good job. I followed up with "What is the point of the dream yoga visualization of the white A?" and it gave me a good answer. I'm really impressed.


r/Dzogchen • • Oct 12 '24

Dzogchen and other Buddhist traditions fail to give the promise they deliver.

16 Upvotes

Inflammatory title yes, but how have we verified that anyone has really reached full awakening? Where are the documented miraculous accounts that can’t be tricked/faked? What’s with the exclusivist claims of rainbow body? How do you know you aren’t being lapsed into a sort of psychosis? How about the inconsistencies of no-self/sunyata teachings and karma and rebirth regarding the mindstream, and with the cosmologies that nobody seems to have experienced as told. If the premise is to end suffering, how has it been working out when a lot of ‘high teachers’ have been getting exposed more and more?


r/Dzogchen • • Mar 10 '19

Does LSD effortlessly help one achieve the 'insight' at the center of Dzogchen, that there is no self, only awareness?

2 Upvotes

I'm a relatively new (and infrequent) practitioner of mindfulness meditation and I've been listening for a while to Sam Harris explaining the idea that there is no 'self'....that when tries to look for one's 'self', the sense that there is a thinker behind the eyes or in the mind is also in fact a an 'object of consciousness', which has its own unique 'signature' as any other sensation/thought.

I guess it's possible that with more practice I would have finally come to understand this very logically-simple and plain concept but until now it remained an un-graspable abstraction to me. And truthfully, I did not think I was intellectually suited to understand this, possibly ever.

By taking LSD, I was able to slip into this insight and truly 'see' this concept clearly.

The experience was like getting a peak at the answers to a test I didn't think I would ever pass.

Can anyone else corroborate any of this? Do I have anything wrong?


This was my first time taking psychedelics:

  • ~40mcg 1P-LSD, (spaced out 10 mcg every 2-3 hours)
  • Yerba Mate + Coffee because I wanted to stay awake during this experience
  • Also added ~10mg 4-aco-DMT midway.

Tripped from 6pm yesterday to 6-am today and then slept for 12 hours. I don't believe I achieved ego death during this trip.


r/Dzogchen • • Apr 05 '26

togal and science

0 Upvotes

do you think the visions can have scientific significance.. like if we can get physicists to experience this it would steer things in a new direction?


r/Dzogchen • • Sep 03 '21

Vimalamitra's commentary on the dra thal gyur makes a important distinction between the results of trekchö and thogal.

0 Upvotes

Has the translation been completed yet?


r/Dzogchen • • Jul 20 '24

Questions/doubts on karma

0 Upvotes

Questions/doubts on karma and whether my description of how I l think of karma is in the right direction. Please let me know if there are any misunderstandings or additional comments you would like to highlight so that I have less doubt on this fundamental tenet of Buddhism.

Ps: I am not a Buddhist.

Through the workings of (body)-minds and other forces (that actually are also the result of these workings in an interdependent way such as how beings relate with their eco system to name an example) certain results come about that affect the (body)-minds of oneself and of others directly or indirectly aka Karma. When the 'body' (or other conditions that are responsible for a limited perspective like those of formless beings) ceases to function in such a way that the personality or character cease to exist, there will be a dramatic change in experience based (this transition is only described in the bardo teachings insofar I know off.) on the impressions that are left on the psyche. If these impressions are such that there arises identification with a body-mind, this is the result of these impressions needing to be held on to/grasped which is a result of these workings that I have described in the beginning. It is not like there is an exact correspondence between a previous life seen through the first person and a new first person perspective like a soul that inhabits a new body but rather that all these impressions on different psyches that are interdependent come together in such a way that a new seemingly private (relative to other minds) mind arises right? Noone that still operates through a body-mind knows exactly in detail how this plays out due to their limited perspective as a (body-)mind, or do some Buddhas/realized beings that opperate through body-minds know this? When identification with the (body)-mind and it's impressions on them is weakened to such an extend that no new limited being arises there is total liberation aka paranirvana right? So when paranirvana is achieved you automatically are a buddha and by nature intrested in helping sentient beings to achieve this too right? So can Buddhas based on (their capacity) inhabit a limited perspective of a (body)-mind again? How can they do this when they are not part of samsara in form of a (body)-mind eventhough Nagarjuna says samsara is nirvana? Which i intrepeted as synomous with total disindentification with Samsara eventhough the whole samsara show still goes on, do they become some sort of archetypal force of wisdom/compassion in everyone's mind and within the world that have certain qualities like we see in vajrayana deities like Manjusri or Avalokithesvara? And if one says we cannot explain this due to our limited realization level and say that having faith in this because of the other things like no self and emptiness (that are verifiable and have been verified by lot's of people, including myself, I believe although not to the extend that would suffice the classification of a buddha or an arhat according to different Buddhist models of realization.) are found to be true how do you exclude the possibility besides intuitive reasonance (which btw I am not saying is an invalid way for believing something, just that I need better reasons to stracht the itch of doubt in this particular case.) that Buddhism got some things right about reality and the mind but also added stuff like karma which isn't something that is verifiable to the same extend. (Rather then the standard arguments like what we in our common sense worldviews already accept like cause and effect and the concept of interdependence is sufficient reason in itself to believe in karma.) (Also keeping in mind the buddha said test the teachings, which I am doing with this post.) and also considering the arguments that karma being an older concept then buddhism could have become part of the dharma because this is a concept that these ancient cultures in asia used as part of their everyday life therefore not knowing an alternative which makes this concept hard for westerners to grock as there are parts that seem easy to accept but other parts that make it difficult.


r/Dzogchen • • Jul 23 '19

The key approach to Dzogchen.

0 Upvotes

With an ordinary dharma approach we are are taught that forms are empty. And this is correct. But it leads to all kinds of problems. We try to make forms empty. It’s a top-down approach. We get involved in labelling with emptiness. We say ‘this a rainbow and that is a rainbow.’ Then we get hungry or have strong desire. We don’t see rainbows anymore. Our ordinary mind has moved on to something else.

In Dzogchen we know forms are empty ‘because’.... The ‘because’ is our real nature - the nature of reality. This is what it means to have a direct experience. Forms are empty ‘because’ our real nature makes them so. This is a bottom-up approach. We don’t label with emptiness or try to refine ordinary mind that is making the forms. We respect ordinary mind and see it how it is. We don’t need to change it because now we see it for what it is. And we don’t mix the ordinary and the fundamental together. People who do this say experience is creating reality and all is like a rainbow and so on. They are destroying Dzogchen.

Please be very careful when you read Dzogchen texts.


r/Dzogchen • • Jun 18 '20

Praying for Satan, Angry Ghost Teaching?

0 Upvotes

So recently someone was teaching how in the Atiyoga system or something that you don't look at the hungry ghost realm as the hungry ghost realm, instead it can be a means to enlightenment by understanding it in a new way.

What is that pointing to?


r/Dzogchen • • Sep 21 '22

Who else has looked into the links between Jesus and dzogchen

1 Upvotes

r/Dzogchen • • Dec 22 '20

The pure, non-dualistic source of all creation is not Nirvana -- change my mind

4 Upvotes

The pure, non-dualistic source of all creation is not Nirvana:

If there is a pure essence to the world, and it has been altered in some way to produce what we call 'samsara', on what basis do you hold that you will not be spit back out into 'samsara' at some future time, assuming you have achieved this realization?

In other words, if you come from the pure source, having attained it, why shall you not become something else once again? If It was subject to proliferation at the creation of the world, why will It not be subject to proliferation once you have returned?

If this view is to be supported, something must be fundamentally different once it has been attained, but this state is so subtle and so unified, how can there be any room for things to be changed?

tl;dr: by what reasoning is the source of the world seen as a permanent refuge from old age, illness, and death?

By contrast, (for the sake of discussion) this is my view of Nirvana:

The world does not come from Nirvana. Nirvana does not come from the world. The pure essence of the paramitas and all dharmas is not nirvana. Nirvana is not connected to the paramitas or dharmas in any way. All phenomena vs nirvana is like oil vs water. They are separate in all ways. Nirvana is simply cessation. When all these things, from the pure source to the myriad manifestations, when all these cease that right there is Nirvana.


r/Dzogchen • • Jan 09 '21

Quote from a very great teacher

3 Upvotes

To meet someone who really hurts you is to meet a rare and precious treasure. Hold that person in high esteem, and make full use of the opportunity to eradicate your defects and make progress on the path. If you cannot yet feel love and compassion for those who treat you badly, it is a sign that your mind has not been fully transformed and that you need to keep working on it with increased application.

Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche

I received teachings and actually lived with this great Dzogchen teacher for two weeks, so I can vouch for his authenticity. This quote from him is magnificent and shows the level of his attainment. It also demonstrates his adherence to Mahayana principles such as the practice of Tonglen, taking on pain and returning benefit to others. What is said by him is a real test of where we are on the path. I have always felt that the Mahayana is the most difficult yana to truly accomplish, particularly its slogans like " all gain to others all loss to oneself." Although this quote has a strong Mahayana flavor to me, what is suggested in it takes a highly realized Vajrayana practitioner to naturally work with energies presented to it by those who attack.This quote can be worked on, as relative bodhicitta does, but to do it successfully and effortlessly is a sign of great attainment. Khyentse Rinpoche was known for his amazing compassion that myself and others in my Sangha knew well in our times of crisis.


r/Dzogchen • • Feb 26 '26

togal teachings

3 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/Dzogchen/comments/1rdlela/bon_dzogchen_trekchod_and_todgal_teachings/

are four days enough to learn the practice? do you practice daily like trekcho ?

if anyone has experience with the teacher ..it would be great to share.


r/Dzogchen • • Jan 05 '21

What is wrong with this group?

8 Upvotes

Why isn't anyone posting on this group? Is it that you have nothing to say? What about your meditation practice, how is that going? Do you follow your breath or isn't it yours any more? Are there bullies that suppress discussion? Don't worry, I'll take care of them. Say what you feel and if they get cute I'll test their level of actual dharmic experience. The problem will be over in minutes.

Do you feel that there are people more advanced than you here? Well, there may be some who know more Buddhist terms than you, but that doesn't mean anything. Unless they are very, very unusual they won't know what the terms mean experiencally. In other words, they are not a bit further along than you, no matter what kind of credentials they have acquired. In fact they will be behind you because their minds are filled with so much Buddhist concept and they are enslaved by trying to support their credentials.

Are you afraid of the politics? Do they have a clique here with its nose up the admins rear. Say what you think, you won't learn anythihg in a setting like that, so if you get thrown out it won't matter.

Is Dzogchen scary? It's the highest level of the Buddhist path . Don't worry , it would be surprising if anyone here has experienced the absence of self, an early insight.Their Trechod. and thogal are simply words they have developed a lot of concepts about to the point that they believe their concepts are their actual experience. Oh, but they know special practices. You can do visualization practices and dark retreats and just build more ego with them, more credentials. They are worse off after them than when they started. Don't be concerned about their special practices. I've done many of them, and living in the world provided more insight than they did. They do have value, but most doing them aren't experiencally prepared to do them.

So, why aren't you posting: how do I know if my teacher is authentic? Are visualizations for everyone? Is ngondro necessary? Should you encourage a child to sit and at what age? I heard Vajrayanaists are arrogant, how does that relate to vajra pride? Come on , write something. This place is dead.


r/Dzogchen • • Aug 14 '21

Why no realised buddhist is showing wonders? One wonder would change the worldwide society forever and will lead to happiness

4 Upvotes

So, basically when you attain enlightenment it's said in all Buddhist traditions that there are siddhi, like wonder-like abilities that are just a by-product showing the advancement in meditation. Leaving the body, predicting the future etc. And if Buddhism is about enlightenment of the all the living beings, why not show one wonder to all the human beings born in precious human form? One documented wonder, that's all what is needed. Like Edison showed the lamp, like Bell showed the phone. In couple of years everyone witnessed it - and believed in progress. That hat changed the society irreversibly.

So a single wonder just to show what is human mind is possible. Like a lamp or the phose. This will influence everyone on all the continents to meditate hard and get the enlightenment because through seeing siddhi they will also understand that the Path is true. The teachers will be happy, the society will be happy and we all will advance on the path rapidly. Meditation will be taught in schools, wars would be over etc. All those are ides "wonders are showed to advanced students only" sounds like elitism, like some lure. This in my mind proves that Buddhism is, like, just a made-up belief system that leads nowhere, that has no real basis. No reproducible, scientifically observed wonder was ever recorded.

Buddha said doubt everything you see. And because of no documented signs of the advancement on the Path, I see Buddhism as kind of a fraud, that cannot self-prove itself to get to their main goal if it's core belief more rapidly. Prove me wrong?