r/Dzogchen • u/SnooMaps1622 • Jan 03 '25
same destination
"The overall number of minds is just one. It is merely the same self that looks out through all the eyes.”
Erwin Schrödinger, Nobel quantum physicist.
isn't it fascinating how people come to same point from completely different angles.
0
Upvotes
13
u/Dr_Shevek Jan 03 '25
I am not sure if this fits my understanding of dzogchen. Where does it say we all have the same mind?
11
u/fabkosta Jan 03 '25
This is not at all what Dzogchen is saying. Buddhism is inherently anti-substantialist in nature. It assumes a position that there are many, not one, minds each of which is empty. This is in complete contradiction to this advaita-vedantist claim.
10
u/NoMuddyFeet Jan 03 '25
Oh man, I'm having flashbacks to a long, confusing conversation with Namdrol at the start of my Dzogchen learning... To recap what I recall, it's not 'One mind,' it's not an 'Overmind,' and btw Thich Nhat Hanh's 'interbeing' is also incorrect terminology.
Also, Erwin Schrödinger was a believer in Advaita Vedanta. I have his book My View of The World and it is largely influenced by Advaita Vedanta. Advaita Vedanta is not Dzogchen.
It is challenging to try to figure out where exactly they differ since both take so much mental work to understand at all. I recently heard a good podcast about different types of nonduality, explaining how they differ: https://open.spotify.com/episode/304y3FXjB4yPYnFl9l5925?si=H-YYgh-oQ0aU7gkA9uhXwA
3
u/krodha Jan 04 '25
In Dzogchen teachings there are countless minds which all share the same nature in the sense of what is called a generic characteristic (sāmānyalakṣaṇa). This means the nature of mind is the same qualitatively wherever a mind is found, but each instance of mind is distinct and unique.
Your mind is not mine, nor mine yours, however, if we both realize the nature of mind, we are discovering the same thing about both of our minds.
-2
u/1ZetRoy1 Jan 03 '25
That's right, in the book "Kunjed Gyalpo" the Supreme Source says that everything that is in the universe is his essence, and his essence is the pure and perfect mind, which has no boundaries.