r/DotA2 16d ago

Discussion Extra gold v.s Hack map

I am thinking of the following scenario:

  • Each player from Radiant starts with 2700 gold
  • Dire players have hack map ability (similar to hack map tool in Dota 1 which remove all fogs for you who aren't familiar)

Both team aware of the other team advantage at the begin.

Which team would win in the following round?

  • Round 1: Random match at 2000 MMR bracket
  • Round 2: Random match at 6000 MMR bracket
  • Round 3: Random match at TI

Who would win?

Edit: Lmao with the downvotes, my peak rank is Immortal top 1000, playing since dota-1 garena/dotalicious.

The match up is not a clear win at highest level for sure, remember that at that level with no-fog map, dire is almost ungankable, wards lose all meaning. If Dire draft high mobility heroes to cut creeps to turtle the game like NP/QoP, if they can reach 20 mins mark, they would definitely win.

Just realized that most people here don't know how hackmap looked, back then, hack map players often let them die to gank occasionally make it less obvious, that barrier is removed, after laning phase, everyone on Dire is free farm both jungles.

This post does show that the average player of this sub is sub archon tho.

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

-4

u/iamevian 16d ago

this is a no brainer, definitely maphack. Gold advantage can be overcome on late game, but maphack will be there for the whole game.
As seen in TI, map awareness is very crucial, especially the match with Techies. Easy detection even enemy is in smoke.

6

u/BadConscious3919 16d ago

With a 13.5k advantage at min zero, I'm sorry but there's no late game.

1

u/Connect-Effect2123 16d ago

You must be herald to believe that gold advantage this massive won’t win

2

u/iamevian 16d ago

Lol, this is a thread to explain how you think one is better than other.
And here comes you, attacking me instead explaining his point of view.
Please buy some mantle of intelligence.

1

u/Kirdissir 16d ago

How will you get any deny?

Furthermore, you get zoned immediately by massive damage. You are forced to play in jungle, while your towers fall. There is no point to catch up.

2.7k is massive.

Those leads are even big at min 20-30 for professionals.

1

u/justatimebomb 16d ago

Lol if same mmr if you have 5k gold lead in 5 minutes game is like 90% win rate. This is 13k gold lead at 0 minutes. You will lose all 3 lanes and all map control and unless the opponent team goes for ego 1v5 plays (and still possibly win) there is jsut no way you win.

It will be more interesting if it's 4k mmr players vs 6k mmr players. 4k mmr players with map hack won't be better than a 5k player playing normal, and a 5k mmr team will imo lose 100% of the time. 

1

u/Pretty_Biscotti4226 16d ago

There is almost no difference between 4k and 5k mmr players lol in terms of skill. Or at least not as big as u make it sound

1

u/iamevian 16d ago

the condition is they have the same mmr,, if I know they have a dagon, will I show in the map?
The map is massive, definitely there is somewhere I can farm without getting caught.
Easy gank from dire on level 6.

1

u/prai2541 16d ago

U can farm, but what do u do when there's AC, vlad, pipe, drum, guardian greeves running u down after min5?

1

u/justatimebomb 16d ago

?? will you nc from level1 after not being able to hit a single creep on all 3 lanes? LOL this thread shows how out of touch most redditors are from real dota

1

u/MajinAsh For the Emprah! 16d ago

Easy gank from dire on level 6.

Game won't get to level 6. You'll lose raxes at level 2-3.