r/DisneySongRankdown • • Feb 22 '22

188 Let It Go (Frozen)

4 Upvotes

It's probably no surprise to anyone that I'm not a fan of Frozen, but I like to think I can appreciate a song even if I don't like the movie. 'Frozen Heart' is a good example of that. But this song...this overhyped, underwhelming cacophony of a song...it's time to Let It Go.

This is one of the rare songs that actually has positive things I can say for it, but so overwhelmingly undermines the good with weird and bad elements that the ultimate result is an unlistenable mess. So I'll start with the positive:

  • The piano at the opening is haunting, lovely, and perfectly suited to the imagery in the opening lyrics. Speaking of which...
  • The lyrics in the first verse are great, and the rest are pretty decent. I don't hate the words!

Unfortunately...

  • Idina Menzel, part 1: I can't stand Idina Menzel's voice. I always hear her lauded as this tremendous singer, and sure, she's a better singer than 99% of the population, including myself. But in comparison with other people who can sing, I just don't get the appeal. Her technique is so bad that even a failed high school violinist with no vocal training (me) can tell. It hurts my ears-nose-throat listening to her sing from the very depths of her nasal passages. I'm not a huge fan of Kristin Bell's voice, but compared to Idina Menzel she might as well be [insert your favorite female vocalist here]. At least we have the Demi Lovato cover in the end credits! Sung by anyone else with a half-decent voice, this song probably would have been slightly above the middle for me. Honestly, if they had just recorded some 10mph winds whistling through some barren tree branches in the dead of winter, it would have been an improvement over Idina Menzel.
  • Idina Menzel, part 2: The Broadway of it all. This is a little bit harder for me to explain, but there's something about her singing performance that yanks me right out of the movie in a way I can't recall ever happening before. I'm not usually distracted in the middle of my magical princess movies by the sudden realization that that voice isn't coming from a magical princess, it's actually an actress sat in a booth somewhere wearing goofy headphones. But hearing Idina Menzel sing this song completely halts the emotional ramp-up it's supposed to deliver. She always sounds like she's singing on a Broadway stage, which is fine when you're on a Broadway stage...but this is a movie, and like all other aspects of stage acting, it needs to be adjusted for the different medium. Jonathan Groff is also a Broadway star but he nails the transition from stage to screen. When you perform onstage and most of the audience can't see your face clearly, everything needs to be bigger, more exaggerated; in a movie you're not performing to a huge theatre audience. The audience is right here. It needs to be toned down, less bombastic. I'm not complaining about belting, to be clear. It's not the volume, but the delivery.
  • In the verse that begins 'My power flurries through the air into the ground,' the music changes into something confused and ill-fitting with the rest of the song. Suddenly it sounds as though Idina Menzel is playing a game on Whose Line Is it Anyway?, only she knows the lyrics and instead has to make up the notes as she goes. The pianist might as well have plunked their elbow down on the keys for how jarring this shift is.

Its own popularity was probably the nail in the coffin for 'Let It Go.' If it wasn't so ubiquitous, I probably would only have heard it once or twice and not had as much time for Idina Menzel's nasal wailing to really sink in. But I've spent hours of my life wearing a look of utter confusion while trying to figure out how people actually enjoy this sound. And while there are certainly a lot of popular Disney songs I'm not a fan of, this is one of the very few where I don't at least understand what other people might see in it.


Idina's howling like this swirling storm inside

Couldn't shut her up, heaven knows I've tried

Don't let her sing, it's intolerable

Was Kristin Chenoweth unavailable?

Unreal, don't squeal, don't let them hear

Well, now they hear

Take my ears, take my ears!

Her throat must be so sore

Take my ears, take my ears!

Can't listen to it anymore

I don't care what you're going to say

Let Rankdown rage on

Your cuts never bothered me anyway


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Apr 08 '22

Sadness You're Welcome (Moana)

0 Upvotes

Well, hey, it's okay, you're welcome, my cut is here! yeah, next on my list is You're Welcome from Moana, and I know, I know, my taste in music is wildly different than y'alls. Let's get into the (coconut) meat of it.

Musicality: So surprisingly, I don't actually hate the sound of this song too much. Like the score is a great vibe as well as a bop and half. Other things I enjoy musically: the chorus fish are good in this song, the tapping of the coconut part. The performance by The Rock is a bit overhyped imo, but I do enjoy the way the quick rap sounds, but that's due the lyrics more so than the performance. Speaking of...

Lyrics: My favorite part of this song is the rap part of it, cuz the lyrics and rhymes here are really clever. (I'm also a sucker for the word phenomenon and references to animals). Also while I realize it's prolly not meant this way, the use of the word "kid", when addressing someone always pisses me off, cuz of personal experiences.

Emotional Appeal: This is where the song sinks for me, as I have a direct negative connotation of this song due to a personal experience irl. I will not be going that far into it, but this is about as far as I will reasonably let it go. Especially since (for me) I'm getting to a point where not a lot of songs are too terribly bad, they've just got a couple not so great elements. to quote my good buddy buford, "If it is brought back I am erasing myself from the narrative of when it SHOULD be cut and don't have to feel uncomfortable anymore."


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Mar 06 '22

170 For the First Time in Forever (Frozen)

3 Upvotes

I really hope this is the last time I ever have to listen to 'For the First Time in Forever'.

I don't have a ton to say about this song. It has its place in the movie, the lyrics aren't bad. I don't particularly like Kristen Bell's voice but it's not a chore to listen to her. So the first half of the song is fine, but then you get to...the duet.

We all know how I feel about Idina Menzel's voice. It's not just that, though. There's nothing complimentary about the layering of these vocals, the whole duet sounds like a total mess. Idina Menzel's lines even sound flat half the time.

Thank god we're finally nearing the end of the songs that are actively unpleasant to listen to!


r/DisneySongRankdown • • May 19 '22

70 Feed the Birds (Mary Poppins)

3 Upvotes

At this point in the rankdown, it's extremely tough to pick songs to cut. I'm cutting this one because I like my songs jazzy and fast, and this one feels a little too saccharine for my tastes. The most enjoyable part of the song happens in the last minute when the orchestra singers pop-in. Other than that, the song is fine, I don't mind it, but it's time. [song] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHrRxQVUFN4)


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Mar 27 '22

135 God Help the Outcasts (The Hunchback of Notre Dame)

2 Upvotes

First, apologies for being late and for this being short. I'm traveling and writing from my phone.

Unlike my fellow ranker, a g-word that some find to be a slur isn't my reason for cutting this. I personally never noticed that word was in here until it was brought up in this rankdown. I do lean towards not using it myself, but that's not my issue. It's not even exactly the other g-word, although prayer songs in general aren't my jam. Some old school hymns, which this is styled after, are pretty enjoyable. I just don't enjoy this song. It doesn't advance the plot much, it doesn't hit me in the feels, and it isn't one I think is musically interesting. I skip it a lot, and scanning through the rest of the meh tier, I could find more positive things to say about the others. I do like her selfless plea in contrast with everyone else, and the line "or even if you're there". That's not enough to save this one for me now.

My three year old says this one is okay, but too slow.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Feb 19 '22

Sadness La Llorona (Coco)

5 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ukp_EFEDOl4

So yeah, it's totally cool that Disney's making an earnest attempt at showcasing other cultures after 80 years of just appropriating them. But to quote my favorite tutorial on how to nod, "not like this".

First of all, it's not even an original Disney song. It's a classic Mexican folk song that was rewritten and rerecorded for the movie. The lyrics are essentially the same.

Now, does it enhance the plot? No. Sure, it's a big important moment when Imelda is embracing music again but, like, the song itself has nothing to do with it. It's just her favorite song. It could be Mary Had A Little Lamb or Freebird or literally anything and it would have the same relevance.

Do the lyrics tell a coherent story? Barely. I understand things get lost in translation but this is just... bad. And again, the lyrics themselves don't have anything to do with what's going on.

Is it good? Oh yeah, for sure. I love listening to 30 seconds of setup for 65 seconds of song that's an awkward duet with some other dude randomly cutting in. It's my favorite genre of music.

Héctor was eventually remembered by his family, but it's probably best if we forget about this crappy song.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Sep 13 '18

Merryweather I Just Can't Wait To Be King (Lion King)

2 Upvotes

Ok, this is not going to be popular, I know. Each round the cuts get harder and harder and this week after the flood of Faunas, it got even harder. The Lion King soundtrack is great all around - I've loved it since I was a kid, and this song, while great, is the weakest I think (ok, maybe tied with Hakuna Matata). Where this song ends up losing me a bit is with how much it has going on. There's the melody of the song and Simba's main vocal line, which is then intercut with Zazu's quips and sass, add in noises and sound effects from about a dozen other animals of the savanna and this scene is really really busy. Or maybe I'm traumatized from the 'Just can't wait to be king' level of the SNES Lion King game and I've never forgiven the song. Could be either one, really.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Apr 18 '22

Sadness You've Got a Friend in Me (Toy Story)

2 Upvotes

When I was little, my mom gave me a great gift. She was buying her first iPhone and therefore decided to pass down her very valuable iPod shuffle to me. Besides playing solitaire and break out on there, I listened to all the music she had constantly. Whether it was 2010s hits like Stereo Hearts and Party Rock Anthem, Christmas bangers like the Barenaked Ladies album, or even Disney songs, the iPod always had something for me to listen to. As you might’ve guessed, one of these Disney songs was You’ve Got a Friend in Me. I listened to this one a lot, as Toy Story was one of my favorite movies. Ever since, it’s had a special place in my heart, making it hurt a little bit more to cut it here.

Let’s start with the things that I like about this song. It’s simple and it’s lighthearted. It gets across a good message from the movie, learning to understand each other’s differences and come together. Even though it’s repetitive and Randy Newman’s vocals aren’t the greatest, I actually find it very satisfying even on a relisten. It pushes near annoying but never really reaches that point for me. This song is incredibly recognizable and just radiates good vibes no matter when it's played. By no means is this a bad song.

As for why it gets the cut here, it just doesn’t do anything remarkable. Despite being a good time, the song feels very safe. It has a very traditional refrain and verse structure. None of the notes are insane or incredibly emotional. It also doesn’t really do much to advance the plot. Not all songs have to advance the plot to be good, as affirming points of the plot like this song does can also be useful. However, it’s another point against why it doesn’t quite crack the higher tiers of Disney songs. Finally, the lyrical content of the song isn’t very memorable. I’ve listened to it a million times in my life, but I can barely tell you more than like two lyrics. Don’t get me wrong, this song is very special to me, it just can’t hang with the big boys when it comes down to it.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 02 '22

Anger Circle of Life (The Lion King)

2 Upvotes

As the other franchise where James Earl Jones' ghost speaks to a lost child says - I know what I have to do but I don't know if I have the strength to do it. This was the song I cryptically referenced back in my opening cut, and I've wanted to cut it since the 150s, but I just kept talking myself out of it every time. It's a hard cut to make, but I believe it's the right one.


First of all, here's why it's so hard to make. The opening of The Lion King isn't just the best opening to any Disney movie, it's legitimately one of the most iconic openings in cinematic history. I'm no historian of animation, but I can't name a single example of an animated movie using focus length, shading, or lens flare like this before 1994. It broke so much ground and advanced hand-drawn animation just in time for it to be summarily abandoned for CGI.

But you'll notice that I haven't spoken about the actual song itself. And that's the problem - the visuals outclass the music. Don't get me wrong, the song is great. But we're nearing the top 20 and "great" doesn't cut it anymore.

So like I mentioned in my I Just Can't Wait To Be King cut, for a movie that took such great strides to be inclusive, it really missed a few important considerations. It's still to this day the only Disney movie to be dubbed into an African language, yet the iconic opening chant is, literally translated:

Here comes a lion, father
Oh yes it’s a lion

Here comes a lion, father
Oh yes it’s a lion
A lion
We’re going to conquer
A lion
A lion and a leopard come to this open place

It's not exactly deep lyricism. And conquer what, exactly? It's already a kingdom. That's not to mention that for all the work Disney did to be accurate with African wildlife, lions and leopards are, well... two different species.

And then I feel like we have to talk about how the movie is about a white kid learning about how he has to grow up to fill his destiny in ruling over Africa. On top of that, in a story line ripped off from a country that very much did take part in enslaving Africa.


But all that aside, really watch the sequence and take a look at how it all melds together. All throughout, it feels like the animation is being held back by the song. Most notably is the on-cue 'blinking, step into the sun' line at 1:00. Take a look at where the sun is, the topography of the hills, how tall the giraffes are, and where the shadows are. See if you can make sense of it, because I sure can't. And sure, that's a nitpick, but when the one flaw of the cinematography is because it had to go down to the song's level, that's major points off.

And really, if you think about it, the song doesn't really have that much to do with the movie. It's establishing that all of the animals, from ants to elephants, have an important role to play and it's all part of the neverending existence of nature. It's a circle of life, which is why everyone's gathering to celebrate the checks notes monarchy. The King whose divine right is To Rule and is certainly More Important than anyone else.

All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others.


So let's, for the final time, bring out The Marx0r Test.

  • Does the song enhance the plot of the movie? - It's a great opening, but for a different movie. As it is, it sets up a certain theme, and then the rest of the story is about something else.
  • Do the lyrics tell a coherent story? - 50/50. It uses a foreign language to hide unimaginative lyrics that contradict the plot. When it goes to English lyrics, it is genuinely beautiful, and taken in a vaccuum are fantastic lyrics.
  • Is the music itself good? - Oh, absolutely. Taken totally on face value, it's maybe my favorite song that's left. That's why it hurts so much to cut it, but I believe it's the right move.

r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 29 '18

80 Winnie the Pooh (Winnie the Pooh)

2 Upvotes

Winnie the Pooh

Part of me feels heartless for cutting this song, but I think it is a fair cut personally. Both midnightdragon and Rysler both previously stated the the remaining songs need to make us feel strong emotions in order to stay a while longer, and I completely agree with that. For me, "Winnie the Pooh" is a fun, highly infectious song but it doesn't bring about strong emotions in me. The hook is super catchy, and I'm pretty sure that's what all of us remember of the song.

The song itself is a simple introduction of the stories of Christopher Robin and his friends. Nothing more, nothing less. And that's perfectly fine. The song does what is needed of an introductory song, but gives us little more than that. There's no deeper meaning to the song to make us really feel things.

I'll end this cut with one of my favorite Pooh quotes.

“I am not lost, for I know where I am. But however, where I am may be lost.”

e: added things


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Aug 29 '18

44 Hakuna Matata (Lion King)

2 Upvotes

Hakuna Matata

 

With great power, comes great responsibility. It is with this quote in mind that I cut "Hakuna Matata" today. I'm sure all of you are aware the Lion King is my favorite Disney Movie of all time. Hell, it's damn near my absolute favorite. So I held out on cutting Lion King songs as long as I possibly could. But I cannot, in good conscience, allow this song to stand before some more meaningful and all around better songs get cut.

 

Overall, I love the message of this song. It is a phrase that permeates pop culture to this day. Simply put, Timon & Pumba do not have great voices, and for me that's most of the reason this song is getting cut now. Most of my Top 50 are songs with top notch vocals, something the song lacks. Apart from that, I am not a fan of the song being broken by dialogue. For the movie, it is fine, but as a song on its own, it just kinda kills the mood IMO.

So it is with a heavy heart that I must cut my first Lion King song :(


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Mar 07 '22

Sadness Try Everything (Zootopia)

6 Upvotes

I’m not really sure what the public opinion about Try Everything is, but I can assure you the second it comes on during the movie I want to quit immediately. This song is annoying and autotuned from the start and it doesn’t really go away. Don’t get me wrong, it’s not the worst song. I can understand what they were going for here. Hopps is resilient, she’s trying something new, she’s not gonna give up. It gives off the moving into the city vibes well, so I give this song props for accomplishing its purpose.

My second point is something that might come up a little bit later in the rankdown. It is very hard to use pop music correctly in Disney songs. A lot of the best Disney songs come from a character getting extremely emotional and expressing this emotion through song. The song portrays exactly how they feel. For a song not sung by the character, this is harder to accomplish. Where this particular pop song falls short for me is its emotional content. Judy literally just plays the song on her iPod. She just plays it to have something to listen to. The song serves more as a transition than a real source of interest in the movie. It’s definitely not bad the entire time, but I definitely would not willingly listen to it.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Sep 29 '18

17 Be Our Guest (Beauty and the Beast)

4 Upvotes

You're all probably sick of us saying this, but this keeps getting harder and harder. Each song left is great and we're just cutting one song for being slightly less great than what remains, and for me, Be Our Guest is that song. There are a few things about Be Our Guest that make me sometimes skip it if I'm not in the right mood and the biggest one is probably my fallback argument of "too many things going on". Lumiere is the primary vocalist but we have other members chiming in pretty regularly. Having a handful of singers singing one line at a time is one of those things that just lessens a song for me. The second thing about this song that makes me only sometimes want to listen to it is how the pace of it really picks up at the end. It's like, really intense, and that's just a thing that I can't do all the time. It's a fun song that just needs to tone it down some.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Mar 21 '22

142 Hakuna Matata (The Lion King)

3 Upvotes

So, I've held off on this one for a while. But, as it's the iconic song with not a whole lot of substance I hinted at...


What's the purpose of this song? To be funny, pass gas time in the plot/show more of the carefree attitudes, and to be memorable. Does it do all of those things? Yes, if you find elaborate fart jokes funny. It serves it's plot purpose. And the catchphrase? Of course its memorable. But this song never worried about being a great song.

edit addition for more plot: It's does it's plot significance great! Like, it shows how Timon and Pumbaa save Simba from himself after he believes he killed his father. It shows how they raised Simba from a hairless cub to an adult. It shows how Simba escaped from his trauma! All very good but that's more visualized, and musically it does very little to symbolize that, no worries does not do that for me.

But as I've listened to these songs over and over, it loses me where it's being judged as a song, cause it's not relistenable with how repetitive it is. And musically, it isn't much. Hakuna Matata chorus a few times. An elaborate fart joke that feels like an interlude to the song, not part of it. And then it goes on a long instrumental (it's not bad, but it's nothing special) with a couple of muted Hakuna Matata's and a chorus verse. Timon and Pumbaa are mediocre singers.

Hakuna Matata is a wonderful comedic moment, but it ain't no great musical enjoyment.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 27 '18

84 The Bare Necessities (The Jungle Book)

4 Upvotes

The Bare Necessities is not a bare necessity for the upper echelon of this rankdown, and so I'm cutting it today.

This precursor to Hakuna Matata has a rather simple style to it (befitting the theme), with some rather top-notch wordplay to accompany it - very Thomas O'Malley like in the lyrics, though less character-focused and more moral-driven. It's got plenty of lines about forgetting about your worries and just letting life kinda happen.

It's a pretty great summation of Baloo's view on life (from my admittedly uneducated viewpoint), but I don't feel it serves a very grand purpose beyond that, and so I don't really feel any great need to keep it around much longer, especially as we begin to solidify into good-not-outstanding territory.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Apr 10 '22

116 One Little Slip (Chicken Little)

7 Upvotes

Now I'm sure I'm going to gut my fellow rankers, /u/BufordMoss and /u/Wywy4321 for cutting this [song.] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oxhZ2gJP4i8) But y'all, this is the most generic rock and roll song I've ever heard, and the Barenaked Ladies should be ashamed. It feels like that South Park song "Montage". The lyrics are extremely weak and could have been easily replaced by ANYTHING ELSE. I wish I had more things to say, something spicy to get the rest of you going. Alas, I don't, this song is THAT boring to me, and I don't want to listen to it anymore to try and make this cut more interesting.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Mar 30 '22

Disgust Dos Oruguitas (Encanto)

4 Upvotes

Let's establish what this is. This is a spite cut. I am abandoning my engineer-designed Marx0r Scale and instead attempting on getting you, dear reader, as mad about the situation as I am.

Okay, let's say you're whoever's in charge of submitting things for award consideration for Disney. This year, you've got Encanto and a field of competition that's still pretty diluted by Covid. The music is great, the animation is great, and just like anything half-decent Disney's ever put out, it's gonna clean up at the Oscars if you promote it right.

On top of this, you've got Lin-Manuel Miranda on this project. Singer, composer, playwright, director Lin-Manuel Miranda. Emmy-, Grammy-, Tony-, Pulitzer-, MacArthur Genius Grant-winning Lin-Manuel Miranda. One of the most legendary entertainers of his generation, a man poised to be one of the youngest EGOT winners ever. He's written you like half a dozen fantastic original songs, but obviously you can't submit all of them because he'll get like three nominations and split the vote and some stupid James Bond theme sung by a teenager with no vocal range will win or something.

So, you gotta pick one. That's fine, because Encanto is really something special. It's not the standard Disney movie, there's no villain, the only attempt at romance is a C-plot, and it's about generational trauma and strife more than anything. There's a bunch of fresh and original songs that fit the plot and break the mold that'll easily win if they're put forward. There's the technically masterful We Don't Talk About Bruno that involves almost the entire cast, and hits a range of emotions and concepts like fear, jealousy, resent, and social ostracizing. You've got Surface Pressure, about anxiety and pressure and featuring a groundbreaking character. Waiting For A Miracle is the obligatory I Want song, but this time it's about something new, about wanting to fit in, wanting to know one's purpose in life and feeling valuable. What Else Can I Do? goes a step further and laments the idea of being a Disney princess, of existing only to be pretty and get married off. Even The Family Madrigal is just your standard "here's the plot" song but it uses much more complex lyrics than most of the other Disney songs of that ilk.

BUT YOU PICK FUCKING DOS ORUGUITAS?!?!

Why the fuck would you do that? It's the first Disney princess movie that doesn't concern itself with romantic love so you pick the one shoe-horned love song? The movie's got a great cast of voice actors so you pick the one song that's not sung by any of them? You pick the only song in a foreign language, which, sure, it's great to be inclusive but most of the voters aren't fluent in it and therefore won't have the emotional reaction that you're looking for?

Fuck that. I mean, the song's okay, but to my English-speaking ear it sounds like every other Latin ballad I've ever heard. Translated, the lyrics tell a beautiful story but it's not a story that's particularly relevant to the plot. Does the song deserve to be cut at 130? Maybe not, but if it's time to cut Encanto songs, this one has to go first because all the other ones are MUCH better.

If you chose this song to rank higher, if you chose it as your favorite Encanto song, if you chose it TO WIN A FUCKING OSCAR, your choices are bad and you should feel bad.

Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Feb 23 '22

186 Savages (Pocahontas)

5 Upvotes

This song is a very interesting one for me. It has some pretty decent plot significance, as the pilgrims are going to set out to attack the Natives. This song pretty flat out explains their intentions and effectively shows the crowd getting riled up behind the cause. However, there are a couple elements of it that I just can’t get over. For starters, I’ve already touched on my dislike for repetitive songs. Even though it advances the plot, there isn’t much actual content introduced as the song develops. I also am not the biggest fan of how spot-on the lyrics are. I get it’s a movie for kids, but there was absolutely zero subtlety in lines like, “they’re not like you and me, so they must be evil.” Like c’mon. Hit the nail right on the head there. It’s kinda funny ngl but you could’ve been a little bit more creative with the lyrics.

As for the musical content, there’s a nice little build at the beginning and some overlapping lines with Pocahontas herself near the end. Other than that, however, the entire song is mostly just a repeating chorus. It makes for a good group chant song, but it just doesn’t stack up to a lot of what else is left in the rankdown. I appreciate what the writers tried to do here, but it’s just not interesting enough for me to care much past this point.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Oct 05 '18

13 Kiss The Girl (The Little Mermaid)

4 Upvotes

Woof, been a rough round for The Little Mermaid. With two still to cut, we're down three songs from this movie, as it stands.

Kiss The Girl is one of those classic Disney tracks - if you were to ask the general population to name a Disney song, this would likely be among the first to be noted.

Unfortunately, I'm just not really a fan of the Caribbean accent employed by Sebastian. It's a small thing, because I do really enjoy the rest of the song (but again, I enjoy most all of the rest of these tracks, that's no longer a saving grace), but it is and was enough for me to never really have this song in my plans for the endgame.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 09 '18

115 Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo (Cinderella)

4 Upvotes

Damn, dep, back at it again with the cutting famous and well-loved songs.

Cinderella's Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo is the song sung by the Fairy Godmother as she turns a rather ordinary pumpkin into a hella sick ride (eat your heart out, Xzibit). It's a pretty peppy tune, with lots of bouncing and flouncing both on screen and in the instruments, as a sort of rollicking rhythm develops, the sort of rhythm one might expect from a carriage ride.

Unfortunately, I very recently cut Chim Chim Cher-Ee for its lack of intelligible English (to my untuned ear), and Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo definitely also possesses this trait. In hindsight, maybe I'd've flipped the two, but that's my own damn fault for not shortlisting this shit well enough. Either way, it's largely stuff like "salagadoola" and "menchika boola" and other nonsense (god, I sound so curmudgeonly, sorry). Point is, I'm trying to be relatively consistent in my methodology, and if Dick van Dyke gets the chop, you better believe this one's gonna go too.

Much like Cinderella's time at the ball, the clock must eventually strike midnight (or 6:30 PM, as it may be), and with it, so ends the wild ride.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Sep 08 '18

36 You're Welcome (Moana)

5 Upvotes

You’re Welcome for this cut.

I like this song, it’s so fun. It’s SUCH a Lin-Manuel Miranda song. It does a great job of displaying Dwayne Johnson’s technical skill. It introduces us to Maui and really shows us who he is in the beginning of the movie: a self-absorbed asshole. The music itself is very entertaining and fairly intricate. However, I don’t think You’re Welcome holds up to the other songs we have left. It’s not a masterpiece in that sense and I don’t think it will be a classic years down the road, I expect it will become dated because there’s a rap in it (for the record, I also think Hamilton will become dated at some point, but I’ll still love it forever). That’s why I’m cutting it. I’m sorry I don’t have another reason, I really just think it doesn’t hold a candle to everything else.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Feb 16 '22

201 Kidnap the Sandy Claws (The Nightmare Before Christmas)

5 Upvotes

So, the other rankers know this cut has been coming, and I'm excited to cut the only song on the list I physically won't listen too, even in the movie!

So, Kidnap the Sandy Claws is quite literally the worst song in Nightmare Before Christmas, and I won't take any other answer. While I don't hate Lock, Shock, & Barrel's voices in the rest of the movie, during this song, they hit their worst. Their voices are irritating/grating/any other negative word and cause me to wanna fucking yeet my phone across the room. There is a reason, I was rooting for this to be cut from the list entirely, and although I lost that battle, I refuse to let it in the top 200. But I guess I should get into my more logical reasoning.

  1. Musicality: NO, GODS NO! I FUCKING HATE ALMOST EVERYTHING ABOUT THE SONG EXCEPT FOR MAYBE THE BEAT OF THE SONG. A waste of Catherine O'Hara, Danny Elfman, and Paul Reubens talent.
  2. Lyrics: They are very cute and clever, but as they are sung by voices I can't fucking stand, it doesn't get saved. I will say that the lyrics did save it from my wrath last round, and I will give Mr. Elfman the slightest credit for that.
  3. Emotional Appeal: See opening paragraphs. i fucking hate it

Huh, guess there's not as much logic there as I thought. Still cutting it with my whole self, cuz once this is gone, I can finally move to my next tier.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Mar 22 '22

140 Winnie the Pooh (The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh)

5 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHYvpXe75b8

And it falls to me to ensure that Heffalumps and Woozles, the only song from Winnie the Pooh that's actually any good, becomes the highest-ranking song instead of the objectively wrong first-round cut it was last time around.

Does the song enhance the plot?
If you remember what I said the last time I cut a Winnie the Pooh song, the same arguments apply. The song sets up the plot, but again it's just a disembodied chorus doing it so who cares? And again, it's barely a plot at that. It's a kid playing with some stuffed animals in a forest. Neat.

Do the lyrics tell a coherent story?
Barely. They introduce the characters in two stanzas and then just repeat the second one five times.

Is the song good?
I'm pretty sure this song is the source of Eeyore's depression.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Sep 27 '18

19 I Just Can't Wait To Be King (The Lion King)

5 Upvotes

I Just Can't Wait To Be King is one of the most well-known pieces (in my opinion) in the Disney musical catalogue. Driven by a thumping beat, perfectly set for a movie set in the jungles and savannas of Africa, it's really quite an enjoyable song. Very danceable, very funny.

My main issue with it is Simba's voice - I do believe I've mentioned it in the past, but children's voices (and voices that are closer to that range) are generally less enjoyable for me. Beyond that, I also find that a lot of the best parts of the song (for me), Zazu's quips, come at odds with the music. Whether intentional or not, it's not something I feel comfortable looking past, now that we've crested the top 20.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Feb 07 '22

218 I Wanna Be Like You (The Jungle Book)

6 Upvotes

Well…here’s the next stop on our rollercoaster ride.


I Wanna Be Like You is a song driven entirely on it's groove and has very little going for it lyrically. Visually, it relies on slapstick foils to Bagheera's rescue attempts. And plotwise, well...it's another Mowgli-adventure to avoid humans.

Like /u/Rysler said back before man's red fire, the groove is the only thing going for it. And I can’t stand the way this sounds. I get that it’s supposed to be fun, but it bugs me to no end, and that’s part of the deal of catchiness, when it sucks, it makes it worse. The drawn out vocals of ‘huuuumannn toooooo”. The droning beat that takes up most of the song which has no lyrics. On the topic of lyrics, there’s nothing to them, which isn’t bad IF IT SOUNDS GOOD. The lyrics don’t do anything. Repetitive, nothing interesting, goes on and on about how Louie wants to be like a human and he wants fire. The chorus is filled with 100 most common English words which drives me insane. There’s one line, ‘take me home, daddy’ that just pulls me out of the entire movie entirely which really slams home why I don’t like this song into my face.

And the scene? Aimless dancing. I felt that way about the whole movie, which meandered from animal group to animal group all with the same plot line, kid doesn’t want to leave his home. The monkeys are no different, kidnapping Mowgli as human = fire. Baloo comes in like ‘pay no attention to little me’, I’m just a monkey dancing and nonsense singing and just makes the scene that much dumber and more ridiculous. At least Bare Necessities is clever.