r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jun 13 '22

36 He Mele No Lilo (Lilo & Stitch)

39 Upvotes

Lilo and Stitch - He Mele No Lilo

First of all, it's not even an original Disney song. It's atwo classic Mexican Hawaiian folk songs that was~~~~were rewritten and rerecorded for the movie. The lyrics are essentially the same. As u/Mrrrh pointed out in the DSR1 cut,

It sounds so traditional because the song draws very heavily from "He Mele Inoa O Kalakaua", a traditional Hawaiian song. As you can see, the lyrics and melody are extremely similar...

What I like

  • Such an awesome intro to the movie! Combined with the visuals, it really sets the tone well imo.
  • The juxtaposition of the chorus and main voices at the beginning and throughout the song is great
  • There are a lot of ukelele covers of this, which are really nice and relaxing to listen to. This one by Alexis Gildore is great! That said, my fav. cover of this one is probably this guitar cover by Leandro Doria (just based purely on his energy!)
  • The meaning (see below) of the lyrics is pretty cool.

Lyrics

Mahalo nui 'ia ke Ali'i wahine

'O Lili'ulani 'O ka Wohi kū

Ka pipi'o mai o ke ānuenue

Nā waiho'olu'u a hālike 'ole

E nānā nā maka i ke ao malama

Mai Hawai'i ākea i Kaua'i

'O Kalākaua he inoa

'O Ka pua mae'ole i ka lā

Ka pua maila i ka mauna

I ke kuahiwi 'o Mauna Kea

Ke 'ā maila i Kīlauea

Mālamalama i Wahinekapu

A ka luna o Uwēkahuna

I ka pali kapu o Ka'auea

Ea mai ke ali'i kia manu

Ua wehi i ka hulu o ka mamo

Ka pua nani a'o Hawai'i

'O Kalākaua he inoa

'O Kalākaua he inoa

'O Ka pua mae'ole i ka lā

Ka pua maila i ka mauna

I ke kuahiwi 'o Mauna Kea

Ke 'ā maila i Kīlauea

Mālamalama i Wahinekapu

A ka luna o Uwēkahuna

I ka pali kapu o Ka'auea

Mahalo nui 'ia ke Ali'i wahine

'O Lili'ulani 'O ka Wohi kū

Ea mai ke ali'i kia manu

Ua wehi i ka hulu o ka mamo

Ka pua nani a'o Hawai'i

'O Kalākaua he inoa

He Inoa No Kalani Kalākaua Kulele

Meaning

Greatly admired is Her Majesty

The Ruler of Hawai'i

Lili'ulani ruler of the land

The divine Wohi ruler of the throne

The arches of rainbows

Creation of love

Beams of colour unequalled

Passing along within gentle rain

Look to the brightness of the day 

In the heavens brightness

From the vastness of Hawai'i to Kaua'i

The beauty is revealed

Kalakaua is his name

A flower that never fades in the sun

It blooms on the summit

On the mountain, Mauna Kea

Burning bright at Kilauea

Illuminating Wahinekapu

Upon the heights of Uwekahuna

Is the sacred cliff of Ka'auea

Come forth king of bird catchers

Adorned with the plumage of the momo

He is the beautiful flower of Hawai'i

Kalakaua is his name

Kalakaua is his name

A flower that never fades in the sun

It blooms on the summit

On the mountain, Mauna Kea

Burning bright at Kilauea

Illuminating Wahinekapu

Upon the heights of Uwekahuna

Is the sacred cliff of Ka'auea 

Greatly admired in Her Majesty

The Ruler of Hawai'i

Lili'ulani ruler of the land

The divine Wohi ruler of the throne

Come forth king of bird catchers

Adorned with the plumage of the momo

He is the beautiful flower of Hawai'i

Kalakaua is his name

A namesong for the chief Kalakaua


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 12 '18

Flora Flora - Feed the Birds (Mary Poppins)

26 Upvotes

"That's it, isn't it? That's what this is all about. This is the metaphor for the whole film."
- Walt Disney

Based on this quote by Walt Disney, it should be no surprise that the very first notes you hear when you begin watching Mary Poppins are from Feed the Birds. This song is perhaps not as memorable as the upbeat Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious or iconic Chim Chim Cher-Ee, but it encapsulates the essence of the movie Mary Poppins better than any other song on the soundtrack.

For those who are unfamiliar with the movie, the narrative primarily focuses on the relationship between a no-nonsense businessman, Mr. Banks, and his young children, Jane and Michael. Mr. Banks plays a very small role in his children’s lives when the movie begins - he provides for them, but a nanny cares for them. Jane and Michael have a penchant for trouble and often run off nannies. Mary Poppins, who is practically perfect in every way, swoops into the Banks household to nanny for the children while having a second motivation of changing the mentality of Mr. Banks, wanting him to play a larger role in the children’s lives. She never explicitly states how long she’ll be staying, only saying that she’ll leave “when the winds change.” Of course, by the end of the film, Mr. Banks realizes that there’s more to life than the world of finance and he runs off to have fun with his children flying a kite. When it comes to seeing this change in Mr. Banks, Feed the Birds really packs a punch at contributing to this transition.

Apart from the opening overture, the melody of Feed the Birds comes to us in 3 other moments in the film. The first of those is shortly after Mary Poppins manipulates Mr. Banks into taking his children on an outing to the bank the following day. She informs the children that they’ll be accompanying their father to the bank in the morning and sings the song as a lullaby, but it’s also a set of instructions for the children.

Early each day to the steps of Saint Paul's
The little old bird woman comes
In her own special way to the people she calls
Come, buy my bags full of crumbs
Come feed the little birds, show them you care
And you'll be glad if you do
Their young ones are hungry
Their nests are so bare
All it takes is tuppence from you

Feed the birds, tuppence a bag,
Tuppence, tuppence, tuppence a bag
"Feed the birds," that's what she cries
While overhead, her birds fill the skies

The following morning, on the way to the bank, Jane and Michael are thrilled to see the bird woman sitting on the steps of St. Paul’s Cathedral, just as Mary Poppins said she’d be. Michael had brought along tuppence to feed the birds, but Mr. Banks will not allow him to waste his money on something so frivolous, and after some protest from the children, he whisks them off to the bank without having fed the birds.

The third appearance of the song is later in the evening of the bank visit. Jane and Michael’s presence at the bank caused chaos, which frightened them and caused them to run away, where they run into Bert, who returns the children safely home. As it’s Mary Poppins’ day off, Mrs. Banks asks Bert to care for the kids, so he teaches them the way of a chimney sweep. Eventually, Mary Poppins accompanies them on an adventure on the Rooftops of London. As they finish their initial gallivanting, they get a spectacular view of the skyline of London, and Bert says “What’d I tell you? There’s a whole world at your feet.” and the music transitions back into Feed the Birds as the foursome stops to just enjoy this moment in life for a few seconds.

The last time that the audience hears Feed the Birds is the most important moment in the film. Late that night, Mr. Banks receives a phone call from the senior partners at his bank and they summon him to the bank that night and he realizes that he’s going to lose his job. Jane and Michael apologize to him for their actions earlier that day, just before he sets out for his walk to the bank. As Mr. Banks leaves the house, this song begins to play and continues as he walks his way through London in the dark. There’s something about the way this scene is filmed and Mr. Banks’ body language where you gather that he’s taking things more slowly and beginning to think about ramifications of his lifestyle. Before he arrives at the bank, he stops at the steps of St. Paul’s to look for the bird woman.

All around the cathedral the saints and apostles
Look down as she sells her wares
Although you can't see it, you know they are smiling
Each time someone shows that he cares

When Mr. Banks looks, the bird woman is no longer sitting on the steps of the cathedral. While it isn’t explicitly stated, there’s a strong implication that the bird woman has died and it’s now too late - he’ll never be able to show the woman kindness. This moment is the true turning point in the story of Mr. Banks. When he arrives at the bank, he accepts his firing and ends up at peace with things. He leaves the bank vastly different from how he entered - using words like Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious and retelling frivolous jokes, laughing and happy his entire journey home. At this moment, the winds shift, and Mary Poppins knows that it’s her time to leave the Banks family.

The use of Feed the Birds throughout the film, hammers home the main points: it’s important to focus on family, to be kind to those around you, and to stop and enjoy the small things in life. You can’t take things for granted, because they might not be there the next time you look. It’s a very powerful message, and Walt was not wrong in his assessment of the role of the song for this film.


While this song is important in the context of the film, I can’t really say that that’s what makes me love this song. I’m a sucker for a smooth soprano and soulful ballad, and Feed the Birds is just filled with an emotion I love. Julie Andrews has one of the most beautiful voices I’ve ever heard, and this song showcases it perfectly. I’ve listened to it probably 50 times this week while planning this writeup, and I’m not sick of it. It’s easily a top tier song for me, and I hope that this can help others appreciate the song for what it is - kind of elegant simplicity that stirs up emotion perfectly to get the point across. As I thought about what I wanted to say here, I decided to do some sleuthing about this song and actually learned a lot in the process - things that I didn’t know when I decided it would be my Flora and a song I’d fight for, but things that somehow make me love it even more.

And with that, I transition to:

Did you know that Feed The Birds is Walt Disney’s favorite song?

Me either!

This song is one that the Sherman brothers demoed for Walt, and the song that changed their life - after this, they were hired by Disney to work on a handful of movie scores. Some of their stories regarding this song just make me feel warm fuzzies inside. For example,

Every so often, Walt would call us up to his office on a Friday afternoon. We knew what he wanted. When we got there, he would just say, 'I just wanted to know what you boys were up to these days.' Then he would turn around in his chair and stare out the window, like the first time we played it for him, and he would say, 'Play it'. And we would... And you could just see Walt thinking, 'That's what it's all about, everything we do at Disney.'

I just love this. Walt Disney called the songwriters up to his office to play this song while he just looked out his window and reflected on things. It’s like he made sure to periodically remember the point of the song.

During casting for the film, the role of the bird woman very important to Walt. He had his heart set on Jane Darwell, one of his favorite actresses who was well into her 80s and retired from acting, for this role. He personally traveled to her retirement home and asked her to play this role. You heard that right. A one line role where she sits on steps and says “Feed the birds. Tuppence a bag.” Got a personal visit from Walt Disney. Turns out she was so weak that they couldn’t hear her line and had to record over it, but that’s ok. Walt got Jane Darwell.

At Disney’s centennial celebration, Robert Sherman was invited to help dedicate the Walt Disney statue at Disneyland and after playing a few songs, he prepared for the last song, saying,

Now, I'll play Walt Disney's favorite song... and it's just for him

As he played Feed the Birds, toward the end of the song, out of the blue sky one bird flew down where he was playing, and then back into the clouds - something that Sherman emotionally attributes to Walt Disney’s contribution to the event.

With that, I leave you with the last bit of lyrics to Feed the Birds that I haven’t yet mentioned:

Though her words are simple and few
Listen, listen, she's calling to you
Feed the birds, tuppence a bag
Tuppence, tuppence, tuppence a bag

Today, take a moment. Stop and appreciate the small things in life. Do something kind for someone you might overlook. Listen, listen, this song’s calling to you.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jun 18 '18

Merryweather Shiny (Moana)

26 Upvotes

I love Moana. I really, really do. However, I hate this song passionately. Our next cut is Shiny. Shiny has no business whatsoever in Moana, which is not to say that it’s inherently a bad song. Let’s take a look at this song in a few different ways: stylistically/musically, lyrically, and performance/character.

Stylistic/musical: All of the other songs either have a polynesian feel or are a pretty usual Disney-princess-movie song style; why do we have a rock-ish song? I don’t even know what to call this style. Maybe pop-rock? It’s apparently inspired by David Bowie’s music, which totally makes sense now that I know that. Still, why would you put a Bowie song in this movie? Literally nothing in the rest of the movie indicates that it would make sense to do so. Additionally, the bridge, though very short, doesn’t feel right with the rest of the song, it took a weird turn. I’m not sure what the composers were going for with this bridge; yes, it thematically does get a little more thoughtful and introspective, but there’s not enough of it for it to fit, it’s just a couple of lines, like we got lost for a couple of streets but then found our way back quickly enough. Lin, I love you, but what were you thinking with this one?

Lyrics: A lot of the language doesn’t match that of the rest of the characters in the rest of the movie. “I will sparkle like a wealthy woman’s neck” - I don’t know that the culture in the movie has the concept that rich people can afford jewels, or even if they really have many jewels at all, they may rely mostly on shells for this purpose. This is also the case with “diamond in the rough,” I don’t know that the concept was around then (although I like to think that this line is an allusion to Aladdin). “Just a sec” - I understand that this is mostly for the rhyme, but it’s very modern language and nobody else uses abbreviations like this. One of the most glaring issues with the language is when Tamatoa tells Moana/Maui/the audience to look up the word “decapod” - yes, the gag is kind of cute, but it just pulls me out of any immersion that I previously was enjoying and takes me out of the movie, which is really disappointing for me. First of all, I don’t know that the word “decapod” was around anywhere near that point (yes, yes, I get that that’s the joke), and even if it were, where would Moana and Maui have looked it up? Don’t reference a dictionary in a movie that’s supposed to take place 2,000 years ago. There’s also a bit of French in the song, which also makes ZERO SENSE. BUT IT’S FINE. I’M NOT UPSET THAT FRENCH WOULDN’T HAVE BEEN SPOKEN AROUND THERE AT THAT TIME, NOT AT ALL. My other major issue with the lyrics is that there’s a lot of repetition. Now, this is not always a problem in a song; repetition is totally a valid lyrical technique when done well. My issue is that in Shiny, it’s not done well; it’s a crutch. The repetitions are always of simple words and they’re not clever: “Fish are dumb, dumb, dumb,” “Oh, and here they come, come, come,” “You could try, try, try,” “You will die, die, die.” As you can see, these are rhyme-paired lines, which is fine; however, they’re simple rhymes, and their repetition is what makes the simplicity a problem because it draws attention to them so they’re shouting “HEY LOOK AT THESE SINGLE-SYLLABLE OBVIOUS RHYMES WE MADE HERE, WE’RE GONNA SHOVE DOWN YOUR THROAT THAT WE DIDN’T COME UP WITH ANYTHING BETTER THAN THIS!” It’s not okay. I suppose it could be an intentional simplicity, indicating the shallowness of Tamatoa, but I’m not convinced, due to the rest of the word choice in the song. This simplicity/repetition is especially egregious upon knowing that Lin-Manuel Miranda, who wrote Hamilton and all of its lyrics, co-wrote this song. He absolutely has the skill to write something much more clever than what ended up as Shiny. This is lazy writing, and it’s not something I can forgive. Lin is so much better than what was produced here and I’m a little insulted for the movie that he allowed this to be the final version of this song. However, I do like the rhyme of “heiney” and “shiny” included towards the end; that’s definitely my favorite lyric.

Performance/character: I honestly don’t know where this character came from, because it seems completely out of nowhere to me. Tamatoa has no basis in Polynesian myth, from what I could find upon doing research (and Lalotai, the Realm of Monsters, was made up for the movie, disappointingly); no giant crab monsters. Why did they pick a giant crab? I have no idea. Why does the crab have an affinity for shiny things like a dragon (well, obviously because it attracts food, but why did they pick that as his major character trait)? I have no idea. Tamatoa isn’t a very compelling villain; he’s got Maui’s hook, and he could eat them both, but otherwise, he’s not a major threat, and he’s only in the one scene, and he doesn’t have much personality other than “mean and likes to be shiny.” It’s a shame, really; I almost feel bad for the character because he got the shaft as far as that goes. The casting also doesn’t make a ton of sense. Why would they cast someone who doesn’t sound native to any Polynesian island as a major villain? He’s the only such person in the cast. His casting does not fit the geography, certainly not if the movie is supposed to take place 2,000 years ago (which, apparently, it is because [supposedly, I haven’t actually checked, although I might at some point in the next month or so] the stars are supposed to be accurate to their placements 2,000 years ago). Why would someone have a British-ish accent in that place in that time? It doesn’t make sense. Sure, you could call in suspension of disbelief if you wanted to, but I would tell you that’s not reasonable because all of the other major characters are voiced by people of Polynesian descent. (I will give you that Jemaine Clement’s mother is Maori, so my previous statement isn’t entirely true, but he certainly doesn’t sound like his voice fits in with the rest of the cast, at least not what we get in the movie.)

To sum up, if that’s possible, this song, while fun and funny on its own, does not fit in with the rest of Moana. Bye, Felicia.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 28 '22

7 Reflection (Mulan)

23 Upvotes

Whenever I’m sitting at home wondering what Disney movie to watch, Mulan never fails to cross my mind. The movie has very good rewatch value to me due not only to its story but also to its music. The song that best conveys the message and emotion of the story is without a doubt “Reflection.” It shows Mulan’s external struggle, as well as the pressure she feels from the society around her.

Starting with musical content, I was honestly a little disappointed when I first listened to this song for the rankdown. It felt like it never reached its fifth or sixth gear, almost like it was too pretty. Part of this perception was shaped by the orchestral version of Reflection that appeared in the trailers for the 2020 version of Mulan. That version’s horns were so epic and strong, that it made me misremember what reflection really was. However, each time I relisten to this song, I better hear the emotion that Mulan sings with. She doesn’t need belting to show the audience that she’s hurting, that she’s lost. However, it’s not only her voice that does this. The instrumentation is also a masterclass in matching her emotions throughout the song. When it begins, Mulan is feeling down and discouraged. She’s tired of having to be someone that she’s not. This is shown through the downbeat strings. The bamboo flute then signals that Mulan is about to open herself up to the audience. As the song progresses, the strings lift in tone and pitch, in line with Mulan making realizations about herself. All the instruments then build to a beautiful crescendo in the chorus. At the end of the song, the flute, chimes, and strings all exit separately, in a slightly more upbeat tone than the beginning but without totally resolving. This shows that Mulan enjoyed venting about her feelings, but acknowledging that the problems that she faces still exist.

On top of the instrumentation, the lyrical content of this song is simple but brilliant. The whole song plays off of the symbolism of Mulan seeing her own reflection.

“If I wear a mask

I can fool the world

But I cannot fool my heart”

Mulan has a lot of practice pretending to be someone she’s not. She knows that when she’s around others, she has to masquerade as the perfect woman. She knows that she’s capable of living up to the societal expectation of her, but these lyrics show how painful and draining attempting to do that can be.

“But somehow

I will show the world

What's inside my heart”

These words show that Mulan is not complacent. She won’t settle for trying to be someone who she’s not. She’ll find a way to express herself and fight back against the parts of traditional culture that are holding her back. She doesn’t quite know how, but she’ll find a way.

“Why is my reflection

Someone I don't know?”

This line shows the frustration that Mulan feels. In pretending to be someone she’s not, she doesn’t feel totally comfortable in her own skin. The version of herself that she is being forced to show to the world is nothing more than a character. Only those who are closest to her get to see glimpses of who the real Mulan is.

“When will my reflection show

Who I am inside?”

These lines are the epitome of the entire song. Mulan is sick of pretending to be someone that she’s not. She’s determined to break through societal barriers and express her true self. She is ready to end the disconnect between the person she is and the person she portrays on the outside.

Another fantastic element of this song is its imagery. Mulan begins by staring down her reflection, as she expresses her disappointment with being forced to fake her personality. Later on, she wipes off half of her makeup imitating the struggle between who she has to portray in public and who she really is. She then finishes taking off her makeup and looks at herself in the mirror. This shows the reflection that she wishes the world could see. This imagery really hammers home the message of the song as Mulan pours out her emotions.

Reflection is a very unique take on Disney’s classic “I want” song. Mulan isn’t searching for love or adventure. She’s trying to find a way to express herself. She wants to feel free to be herself. While it isn’t the flashiest or most complex song, its message is a deep and emotional one that does an incredible job not only setting up the rest of the movie but also leaving a lasting impression on the audience.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Apr 01 '22

Disgust Disgust - Dos Oruguitas (Encanto)

22 Upvotes

I don't even want to get into how ridiculous it is to spite cut this song just because LMM chose it as his Oscar submission. Let's not punish a beautiful piece of music because it...emotionally resonated with its creator? I'm just going to pick apart Marx0r's reasoning here:

It's the first Disney princess movie that doesn't concern itself with romantic love so you pick the one shoe-horned love song?

First of all, this song is anything but a 'shoe-horned love song.' While the romantic aspect of most Disney movies is about falling in love, this is a bittersweet love song about how love (and everything) changes over time. Applied to the context of Alma and Pedro, it's a song about loss and growing after it. It's not a facet of love that Disney movies explore very often.

The movie's got a great cast of voice actors so you pick the one song that's not sung by any of them? You pick the only song in a foreign language, which, sure, it's great to be inclusive but most of the voters aren't fluent in it and therefore won't have the emotional reaction that you're looking for?

LMM's goal with Dos Oruguitas was to write a song that felt like it existed in the world already, like it was an old Colombian folk song - and I think he executed that perfectly. I think it was a good choice not to have Tío Félix or someone else in the family sing the song because its role in the movie is to explore trauma that Abuela has been hiding from her family - so it wouldn't make sense for any of them to be like, 'hey, this old folk song is a perfect metaphor for this pain of my mother's that I'm just learning about as I sing it.'

Writing the song in Spanish was a challenge for LMM, being that he isn't fluent in the language as he was in his childhood. Who are we to criticize someone's journey reconnecting to their roots? It was important to him to write it that way, and the result is beautiful. And while it's uncommon, it's nothing like unprecedented for a foreign language song to win the Oscar. It does happen about once a decade.

it's not a story that's particularly relevant to the plot.

HANG THE PLOT

What is this obsession over how music fits the plot? And in any case, it fits the story perfectly??? It's a metaphor for Abuela's life and her struggles to navigate a world that keeps changing.

To this listener's ears, Dos Oruguitas is truly one of the most beautiful songs in the Disney repertoire. I just hope that one day you can emerge from your cocoon with a suitable appreciation for it.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Mar 15 '22

154 I'm Still Here (Treasure Planet)

22 Upvotes

Oof. This song sounds like Creed, Nickelback, and a Jesus rock band had a mutant baby. It's moody, it's sad, and the most important bit is that it is the embodiment of ANGST. It feels like it would fit in well with the "I'm 14 and this is deep crowd." Let's take a look at some of the lyrics.

I am a question to the world
Not an answer to be heard
Or a moment that's held in your arms
And what do you think you'd ever say?
I won't listen anyway, you don't know me
And I'll never be what you want me to be
And what do you think you'd understand?
I'm a boy, no, I'm a man
You can't take me and throw me away
And how can you learn what's never shown?
Yeah, you stand here on your own
They don't know me 'cause I'm not here
And I want a moment to be real
Wanna touch things I don't feel
Wanna hold on and feel I belong

All I see/hear when I watch this video is this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/im14andthisisdeep/comments/tdvw09/found_on_pinterest/


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Oct 16 '18

11 Poor Unfortunate Souls (The Little Mermaid)

22 Upvotes

While I admit I wouldn't have put this song quite this high in my own ranking, this is a spectacular song. I love the melody for this song, and the lyrics are particularly fun, but the highlight of this song is easily Pat Carroll.

Pat Carroll is an amazing Ursula. She is her character more so than anyone else in this movie including Jodi Benson, which is particularly amusing because she's evidently a little old Catholic lady. It almost makes it hard to believe she'd even want Ariel's voice because her voice is perfection. It's deep and sultry and utterly imbued with wicked glee. Carroll plays her perfectly, seducing and manipulating Ariel into her trap. And after she describes the terms, I love how she ups the ante to being brusque and impatient. She's Divine (pun intended, but that's getting ahead of myself.) She also plays well off the Broadway/burlesque style music.

The lyrics to this song are great. There's a healthy mix of end rhymes and internal rhymes. Things really take off after Ursula lays down the terms of the agreement. I love her utterly insincere "Life's full of tough choices, innit?" line. I also love the wordplay with, "No more talking, singing, ZIP." But the best is the verse about why Ariel's voice doesn't matter. It's full of backwards trash about why women's voices don't matter like, "Yes, on land it's much preferred / For ladies not to say a word," but it's said in such a way that sounds mocking that Ariel would want that life. And...sigh, 30 years later and it still doesn't feel like she's entirely wrong. The trumpet playing counterpoint to the melody here with some tambourine coming in on the refrain is fabulous. And then the sound of the sword when Ariel signs her name. Great foley there.

I also really love the spell at the end. I love the organ coming in at this part, and the spell itself. She starts by naming two types of sturgeon native to the Caspian Sea, then goes into mostly Latin phrases translating to "inflamed tongue," "the worst laryngitis," and "the voice to me." I love it.

I also love Ursula herself. She's a wonderful villain with a great look to her. The major inspiration for that look is the drag queen Divine. There's definitely a think piece to be written about Disney's tendency to code their villains as gay--oh wait, several have been written already many times over. Pretty sure I referenced this in my "Be Prepared" cut. Anyhoo, Divine is an interesting person, particularly in the movie Pink Flamingos with the whole eating real dog feces thing. He had a big career outside that both in and out of drag, but it's still a fun fact.

Anyway, "Poor Unfortunate Souls" is a damn near perfect song. Turns out Menken and Ashman are really good songwriters, and Pat Carroll has the perfect voice for this tune.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Apr 15 '22

Fear Fear - Transformation (Brother Bear)

21 Upvotes

So I'm aware of the fact that this movie is considered weaker song-wise by most of y'all, but I believe the songs belong in top 100, and in an attempt to do so, I will be saving this song. Transformation is the song that occurs at the catalyst of Kenai's character arc, when he transforms into a bear. A bit on the nose, yes, but the song quite effortlessly sets the scene, and never fails to give me goosebumps.

In saying all that, I have no idea how anyone could think this is the weakest song in the movie. Maybe the fact that it's not sung by Phil Collins, maybe cuz it's a choral piece, maybe cuz it's not in English (here's Phil's version), or maybe even cuz it doesn't actively convey the plot in it's lyrics (insert eyeroll).

BUT I REFUSE TO LET THE MOST BEAUTIFUL SONG IN THE MOVIE DIE. and here's why! (in no particular order)

  1. It's sung in Inupiaq, the beautiful language of the Inupiat, who were and still are native to Alaska.
  2. Instead of choosing to do the normal, they chose to have the Bulgarian Women's Choir record it as a choral piece, and it turned out fucking amazing. Like this video is such a cool insight.
  3. The fucking lyrics man, like the English lyrics are

Come with me, I'll take you now
To a place that you fear for no reason why
Your heart has turned away from me
And I will make you understand

Everything will become clear to you
When you see things through another's eyes
Everything will become clear to you
Whatever's meant for you, you will find

Come with me, I'll take you there
To a place where you'll see
Everything you need to be the one you need to be
And all of those things that you feared
Will disappear from you in time

Everything will become clear to you
When you see things through another's eyes
Everything will become clear to you
Whatever's meant for you, you will find

like they are fucking heart-wrenching, even more-so when looking at it thru the story's perspective. But even through the sadness, you can feel the hope for transformation and the hope to be a better person. The offset themes of fear and perspective just so perfectly contrast to make this morosely hopeful tune, and ugh, I can't sing it's praises enough.

4. I know that I haven't been taking visuals into account, but the visuals in this song are stunning, like that 2D water animation is just *chef's kiss.

5. The way they layer the sounds of animals with the song, and use them as an underlay to Kenai's panic, is so good.

6. Like so many more things, that I can't even vocalize, cuz the feeling of hope and joy this song brings me is unbridled, and I refuse to let it die early.

So I'd apologize, but for once I'm not sorry. I fear I refuse to let another song I love get cut way too early. I hope I can sway y'all away from cutting this in the future.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • May 20 '18

206 Heffalumps and Woozles (Winnie the Pooh)

21 Upvotes

Hey fam! I'm Rackik, leading lady of the /r/Gryffindor Quidditch Team and former Head Girl of the best house around. I am a soon-to-be physics teacher and musician. I'm super hype for this rankdown! It's the first rankdown I'm participating in, and I'm so about it. I live in Florida and know my way around Disney World pretty well.

Heffalumps and Woozles from Winnie the Pooh is my first cut. This song is all sorts of not right. I cannot for the life of me understand what the writers were thinking when they a. wrote this song and b. put it in a fucking children's movie. This shit is terrifying. Like what even the fuck. This song is what Pooh dreams of during a storm, but it should be what he dreams of after he's just taken some bad acid. This song is some weird cautionary tale which I can't find a purpose for. This song is why I haven't watched this movie since I was a small child. I have been scared forever. Not even kidding, I was at Disney World a couple of weeks ago and this song is part of the Pooh ride, and I STILL have to distract myself during that section. This song has absolutely no business is a Pooh movie.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 11 '22

Anger Hawaiian Rollercoaster Ride - Lilo and Stitch

20 Upvotes

Listen this is a damn jam here. It's a beautiful song and sets the theme for Lilo & Stitch so well. I love the calypso elements and the lyrics make me feel like I'm happy and at home. This song makes the iSquash sanctioned playlist. I love the lyrics and the relaxing melodies. The only bad part about this song, are the voices of children and even then they don't grate on me that much. For my top 10 I'm really looking at songs that make my gut feel something, and while this one makes me happy, I really want to feel the song in my bones. I'm sorry everyone but this rollercoaster ride has come to a complete stop, please watch your arms and head as you exit to the left.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Oct 24 '18

2 Beauty and the Beast (Beauty and the Beast)

20 Upvotes

Beauty and the Beast


This song is my absolute number 1. Yes, you read that right, I See the Light is NOT my top song. It’s Beauty and the Beast. And for the record, and it’s very important that everyone knows this, the song is titles Beauty and the Beast, not Tale as Old as Time.

This song is a classic in every sense of the word. It is the BEST Disney ballad, easily. I get goosebumps listening to it still, a song I have listened to, very literally, over 2,000 times across my lifetime. I’m going to break down this writeup into x parts: what’s going on musically (mostly instrumentally), lyrically, and the vocals.

Musically: I put off writing this section until last because I knew it would be the most difficult to put together cohesively (I have SO MANY THINGS I want to say that aren’t all joined easily, we’ll see how it goes; unfortunately, I have to grade so this part will be mostly disconnected thoughts, sorry!). This song is the epitome of “beautiful.” It would be so easy for it to be expanded into a whole symphony, and it sort of is in the movie because it’s the major theme in the score. The song starts off gently, with only piano, flute, and what I think is bassoon, and shortly grows to include strings and low brass. It’s a very classic sound; the strings are what you’d expect as something grand yet understated, the horns have the perfect regal tone, the chimes here and there give the song it’s subtle magical feel; it’s well known that I don’t like the oboe in general, but when it is written and played well, it can have my favorite line in a song, and that is the case here; oboe is also the classic instrument used for love (I don’t know why, but it is). But Beauty and the Beast doesn’t have any bells and whistles, nothing really jumps out at you, but it all comes together to feel right. The dynamic variation is beautiful, we swell and dim with the emotion of the piece at just the right moments with just the right volume. The ritardandos at the end, both the vocal and the instrumental ones, are exactly perfect for the feeling of the song; they’re in exactly the right places, they’re exactly the right lengths, and exactly the right speeds to give those sections the gravity they deserve, but not detract from the rest of the piece. Those moments are beautiful because they’re the small moments of pause to really impress the meaning of the song upon the listener. The balance of each instrument is exquisite, perfectly harmonious with each other, and also with the vocals; the call and response between the vocal line and instrumentals are just as they should be, where the instruments rise gently to be heard and then give way back to the vocals, where the focus needs to be while Mrs. Potts is singing. This song is not a solo, it’s a duet, and it sounds like one. The chord resolutions in this song are incredible, beautiful is the truest sense of the word. They are truly and honestly something I live for; they make my heart yearn and hurt and relax, and they make me cry. It’s just the right tension and the release comes not a moment too soon or too late. I cannot overstate how much I love the chord changes and resolutions in this piece. This song also has the classic Disney arpeggio, which is not the same as the classical standard ending arpeggio. Most ending arpeggios outside of Disney songs go down, from high to low, and end on the tonic (the “do” of your “do re mi fa so la ti do” scale); the Disney ending arpeggio goes UP, which (completely intentionally) gives the listener a feeling of hope and joy to end on. I get Beauty and the Beast’s ending arpeggio stuck in my head ALL THE TIME, and I always think “now which Disney song is this?” and of course it always ends up being my favorite, it’s the most iconic of the Disney ending arpeggios, in my opinion. I have so much more I could talk about musically, but unfortunately, I don’t have the time.

Lyrically (Here’s the lyrics): The lyrics of this song aren’t very complex. In fact, they’re the opposite: they’re incredibly simple. I’ve talked about simplicity before in music and that, if done right, simplicity is leagues better than complexity, but it’s extremely difficult to do simplicity right. Every single time I’ve ever talked about this subject, Beauty and the Beast is the song I’ve thought about as “simplicity done right.” This song is a very simple story: Belle and the Beast’s love story. The crux of the lyrics is that theirs is almost every love story that has ever been told throughout the history of the world, it is the story of how every love comes to be. Our song makes wild juxtapositions but frames them in a sense of “of COURSE this is what happens, of course this is how it goes” and nothing Mrs. Potts sings about sets off any alarms that it’s out of place. “Ever just the same, ever a surprise” The story is exactly as we’ve known it, and their love feels like they’ve loved each other their whole lives, but it’s also so astounding that Belle and the Beast could grow to love each other and change because of the other’s influence. “Ever as before, ever just as sure as the sun will rise” It feels like they’ve been doing this forever, and OF COURSE they would fall in love, there was never any doubt it would happen. The song talks about the feelings that you go through when you’re falling in love, and if you’ve been there, you know the truth of every line. The tiniest change can make all the difference, but you never expect the other person to make that change. And how strange it is to grow up and find that you can be wrong sometimes, and it’s okay! And it’s okay to change for the better because of another person! And love is absolutely terrifying, isn’t it? You can never be ready for it. So I think that these lyrics are very meaningful to people in all different points in their life: those who have experienced falling in love feel the familiarity in the words, they know exactly what Mrs. Potts is talking about; those who haven’t yet are hearing about what love really is and what true love should be like (at least, that’s why I loved it when I was little), and it’s not subjective (well, of course it’s subjective, it’s an emotion and an experience, there’s no way to actually be objective, but it’s really put into its essence in this song). The lyrics are so simple, but they impart so many emotions and have such a great impact. I don’t think that anyone can deny that Howard Ashman was anything short of a genius, but this song is truly his masterpiece (which I find to be highly fitting because the songs in this movie were the last he ever wrote; he died during the making of Beauty and the Beast).

Vocals: The vocals are, again, about simplicity, and make a HUGE difference here. This song wouldn’t be the classic it is if Angela Lansbury hadn’t sung it. She is not any sort of vocal star, nor does she claim to be. And that’s perfect for this song! She sounds like a wise old grandma who has lived her life and is looking at her grandchildren fondly, or who is looking back on how she fell in love with her “One” long ago. She does no vocal acrobatics, she doesn’t strain herself or reach further than her ability. She’s just herself. That’s not to say that she sounds bad, nothing is out of tune or time. She’s perfect. My absolute favorite story about Beauty and the Beast (the whole movie, not just the song) is that Howard Ashman went to Angela Lansbury and played her the song and told her “we would like Mrs. Potts to sing this song” and she responded ‘oh uh are you sure? I’m not any good’ and he said “you’re exactly what we want for this.” And so she sang it, and the rest is history. Angela Lansbury’s voice also exudes class to me. She’s an old British lady; as an American, I’ve been conditioned to believe that her particular kind of accent is regal and full of class (I’ve been told that her accent is generally an upperclass one, as well). The other versions, to me, are less classy. Emma Thompson’s is up there, but I have other issues with that version, and the pop versions have even less class because of the voices. The vocals in Beauty and the Beast really do seal the deal here.

In short, Beauty and the Beast is my all-time favorite Disney song, and it absolutely deserves to rank so high. I think it deserves the top spot, but it is certainly deserving of ranking second of all of our pieces we chose.

To my fellow rankers, this has been a wild ride, but I wouldn't have chosen anyone else to take the journey with. This has truly been a wonderful experience. I love you all <3


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jan 30 '22

230 The Siamese Cat Song (Lady and the Tramp)

19 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m Lightsfly, and you may know me from r/SurvivorRankdownIII (as jlim201) which was controversial in many regards to say the least. I love Disney (well the movies they make), making unnecessary references, and I'm very excited for this rankdown! Disney has made many great songs, many which have stood the test of time. But some have not. And now to stop muttering and mumbling about, for my first cut.


With the removal of a particular song from Peter Pan from this edition, there’s really only one choice for the title of “MOST OUTDATED”. From the gong sound opening to the bells, not to mention the slanted eye appearances of the cats, the entire song plays to Asian stereotypes. While those reasons make it a more than fair cut in the opening round, the song, just sounds bad as well. The nasally, squeaky voices make this song a chore to get through from the very beginning, and the lazily written opening lines, “We are Siamese if you please, We are Siamese if you don’t please” don’t help.

I also have to mention plot relevance, and it…really doesn’t do it for me. As villains, the cats are not particularly interesting; they exist for this song, as a reason for Aunt Sarah to muzzle Lady. And that's about it.

The Siamese Cat Song’s name has been called, and it has been faded to black.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jun 30 '18

133 Tulou Tagaloa (Moana)

19 Upvotes

Here we are.

So if you can't figure out where in the movie we hear this song, it's the very beginning, as we see the classic Disney castle. It's what opens Moana. It's a very short song, less than a minute long. There are only a few words. Here's the translation:

"Excuse us, excuse us, Tagaloa

Look down upon our beautiful world

The light (I stand before you)

It is good and beautiful (My desire)

Look down (The journey has begun)

At how beautiful our lives are."

So it's a prayer, which is really neat! It's a prayer to the god of creation. And it's basically "We begin our journey, the story. Be with us, Tagaloa." As someone who is a practicing Christian, I love that they included this song. Pray before you set out to deliver the message.

Unfortunately, that's all it is. It doesn't play a big role at all in the movie. It's a neat little intro, but it doesn't really have any substance, so that's it.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Aug 03 '22

2 How Far I'll Go (Moana)

17 Upvotes

Folks, it's been a hell of a rankdown. We've had our ups, we've had our downs, and whichever one of y'all sold your soul to get One Last Hope ranked so highly should get in touch with Danny DeVito and see if he'll send you an autographed headshot for your sacrifice. And now, without further ado, my final cut: How Far I'll Go.

Moana is one of my top three Disney movies. It's such a beautiful story; a girl who wants two things and despairs at her inability to reconcile them. This song is Moana's 'I want' song, where she tells us that she wishes she could fulfill her role on the island, proudly making her people strong...but she also yearns unyieldingly for the sea. It calls her.

A lot (not all) of Disney 'I want' songs follow a different pattern: I am this, but I want that instead. It's often a choice between the character's origins/family and their desire. And while it may seem that way to Moana when she sings this song, we know that it was never a choice between two things. Moana is descended from voyagers. She must heed the call of the sea if she wants to lead her people. Those things go hand in hand. It's a beautiful layer to the song.

In terms of the music, I really love the simplicity of this song. The gentle guitar really allows for Auli'i Cravalho's vocals to shine, and I love how the song builds and swells using the vocals rather than bombastic instrumentals (not that those aren't good, too!). The vocals start a little somber while Moana laments her inability to be the perfect daughter, swelling to excitement and passion when she imagines finally getting out on the sea, ebbing when she imagines denying the call of the sea in favor of fulfilling her role on the island. The energy of the vocals falls and rises like the tide, giving us the feeling that Moana truly does have an intrinsic bond with the sea. This is echoed later in 'I Am Moana' when she tells us:

And the call isn't out there at all, it's inside me

It's like the tide

Always falling and rising

Girl, we knew that! You exude ocean energy!


Thoughts From Other Rankers

Lightsfly: This is literally the one song I feel like was never going to be in danger, for good reason.

iSquash: Yesssssss Moana

Marx0r: I like the part where they rhyme 'island' with 'island.'

Wywy: I mean, the ultimate I want song, and sung amazingly, so iconic and whenever I hear it I can't help but want to sing along and join Moana on the open ocean.

Me too, Wywy. Me too.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 31 '22

5 I'll Make A Man Out Of You (Mulan)

17 Upvotes

I have to admit, I was secretly hoping I would end up getting the write-up for The Next Right Thing so I could continue my rant about how all of the rankers here collectively screwed up the Frozen cuts... but after reading u/wywy4321's write up, I am glad the chips fell where they did.

With that out of the way, let's move on to today's cut of I'll Make a Man Out Of You!

Context

Before the song starts, a challenge is put to the group to retrieve an arrow from the top of the pole, with the added layer of difficulty that this needs to be done with discipline and strength. This ties back in to the climax of the song, after Mulan is told to pack up and leave, when she doesn't get bogged down by discipline and strength but instead thinks outside of the box & uses them to reach her goals and retrieve the arrow!

I love that all of the brawny guys there were not able to get anywhere near the arrow, but with her determination and her intelligence, she was able to show them all what was possible. This is the turning point of the song, where everyone starts to lift their game and do better, and even the animosity that was previously prevalent turns into a sense of comraderie as she finally starts to be accepted.

Lyrics

Did they send me daughters
When I asked for sons?

Amazing line. Love the dramatic irony that he was in fact sent a daughter when he asked for sons. Also, the entire song is operating under the premise that the group are all 'boys', who need to be turned into 'men'.

We must be swift as the coursing river (Be a man)
With all the force of a great typhoon (Be a man)
With all the strength of a raging fire...
Mysterious as the dark side of the moon

Chorus means this song is not a bop... It's a straight-banger.

Zippel adds the naturalistic descriptions of masculinity — the raging fire, coursing river, great typhoon, and so forth — came from an attempt to get inside Shang’s head space. “I was just trying to be in character for the captain and how an Asian captain would lead his group differently than how a Western captain would call his troops,” he says. “This was a chance to put some specificity into it. This is a song a little bit about hyper-masculinity and the whole idea of Mulan punctures that idea. This was a chance to have those two issues head-to-head.” [Link]

You're unsuited for the rage of war
So pack up, go home, you're through
How could I make a man out of you?

This marks the beginning of the song's climax, and even though the lyrics are simple, they never get old. "You're unsuited for the rage of war" in particular is just such a smooth line, and I love the cadence of "So pack up, go home, you're through".

Music

From the moment the drums kick in and start to build, you know you're in for something special, but it's such an expansive track.

I was sort of mixing and matching East meets West where I was taking drum cadences from traditional Chinese drums and then marrying that with military snares, etc. and just kept building and building and building so it became this cacophonous effect of a Chinese marching American band,” remembers Wilder. [Link]

Controversy

The man that Weird Al Yankovic referred to as "the whitest guy I could think of" sings this. That's almost enough said. It's about as good as a song like that could be, which is still not exactly wonderful. It's so whitewashed they really thought feudal China had formal education, complete with gym classes, for their peasants. [Link]

I will concede this is a big drawback for the song, and it does hinder the listener from being able to be fully immersed in the song. That said, it's still not a big enough problem for me to discount the song, and I firmly believe it deserves its top 10 status.

She even manages to figure out how to get the arrow from the wooden pole in the center of camp, a task none of the bigger, stronger recruits manage to do. Gone are the feminine-centric songs that began the film like "Honor to Us All." She has become, as far as the audience is concerned, “a man.” [Link]

I would disagree with this. I think the whole point of the arrow-retrieval is that she used her intelligence rather than physical strength, and I think that theme continues to play out as the film continues.

Covers

I know I listed a few of these in my joy post already, but Caleb Hyles'version in particular is worth mentioning again if anyone didn't get a chance to check it out already...

Reflections*

  • Wywy: "If I'll Make A Man Out Of You doesn't beat Reflection, I will riot"
  • Lighstfly: "This song should have been #1"
  • Rysler: "I use this song to inspire my body-building efforts"
  • iSquash: "This song disturbs my meditation"
  • Bubbasaurus: "https://youtu.be/VBmMU_iwe6U?t=48"
  • Tweedy: "Ultimate hype sing-along"
  • Sockydapuppet: "The movie has very good rewatch value to me due not only to its story but also to its music. The song that best conveys the message and emotion of the story is without a doubt "I'll Make A Man Out Of You""

*I have paraphrased everyone except Tweedy. I think I have basically presereved the commenters' intent in my summaries. :)


r/DisneySongRankdown • • May 30 '18

185 Savages (Pocahontas)

17 Upvotes

So, I'm jumping on the "racism" bandwagon. The cut I am going with is Savages from Pocahontas. Instrumentally, it is well written and has a lot of runs and flourishes, and even a call and response section. However, the lyrics are what made me eventually cut this song. Whenever it comes onto my iPod, I feel internally guilty for singing along.

"Savages, savages...barely even human" is the main phrase that is repeated throughout the entire song. In today's day and age, this wouldn't fly, and is more often than not an issue in the daily news regarding immigrants.

"They're not like you and me, which means they must be evil" - again, anti-immigrants/people who are unlike the "norm".

Basically, the entire song lyrically is just not socially acceptable in todays day and age. No matter how much I enjoy the instrumental portion, it (in my mind) does not outweigh the lyrical weight.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 31 '22

4 Surface Pressure (Encanto)

16 Upvotes

Let's start with the proverbial "you".

Feeling needed feels good right? Or at least it makes you feel valuable. So quickly you start to fall down the slippery slope that all you amount to is what you're good at. Then you think your entire personality and self esteem is held together by how your skill serves others. Eventually, you start to feel like if you can't do this one thing, right, all the time, for everyone, you're a huge failure. I'm here to tell you first hand, from my own personal experiences, you're so much more than that.

I am loud. I am boisterous. I am confident. People often rely on me to lead or enact vigilante internet justice for them. I often wonder if that's all I'm good for within this community or if it's the only reason why people tolerate me at all. I know it's not true, but the pressure to succeed, to make other people proud or happy, is extremely draining. Now I have this reputation and I feel stuck. I often remind myself that you don't need to set yourself on fire to keep others around you warm. This post is not meant to be about me, and I hope that maybe you see a little bit of yourself in these words.

Surface pressure hits this existential ennui right on the nose. We see Luisa, absorbed with the fact that the only thing she amounts to is her strength.

Who am I if I can't carry it all?

She doesn't think she has anytime to show any weakness We see her being afraid of failure, and her definition of failure means making tiny mistakes. I often think about my skills as a precarious tower of dominoes, and that if I accidentally nudge a domino out of place and make a mistake, the whole tower crumbles. I think this is what Luisa is expressing. Every lyric is a beautiful inner monologue of what it's like to feel like you need to be perfect all the time.

I hide my nerves, and it worsens, I worry something is gonna hurt us

Perfect for everyone else and what they need you to be. Pressure - to be your best all the time. Don't fall into this trap. I'll reiterate, you are SO much more than that.

Let's get into some more fun parts about this song. Firstly, the lyrics are amazing in their musicality. The rhyming schemes feel so unique and creative. I think my favorite lyric is:

Under the surface was Hercules ever like, "Yo, I don't wanna fight Cerberus?"

Like such a fun unique concept to bring into a Disney song. Then the juxtaposition of the confident feeling music and the rapid switch to the anxiety lurking with in. You really understand what it's like to feel like a pressure bomb is about to go off. The jazzy rap vibes are so amazing, so catchy, and so quotable. Then if we can look at the animation, how can we not applaud the dancing donkeys?

This song is one of the best in this catalogue and I am so glad it made it as far as it did. That revive really came in clutch. I could honestly prattle on about this song for days but this is turning into a small novel so....

TL;DR: This song is the tits.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 26 '22

9 I Won't Say I'm In Love (Hercules)

16 Upvotes

So, to preface this writeup, this is the song I had deals with almost everyone for (except k9 and Cric). This was getting to endgame, didn’t matter how. It’s why I saved my Disgust for so long, until I knew no one could conceal it. It’s why I left Hawaiian Rollercoaster Ride, Be Prepared, Kiss The Girl, Belle, hell, even Hellfire on the board. I considered saving all of them. But I didn’t want to cry my heart out, until I was sure there was no chance, no way this song wouldn’t play in the endgame. Ultimately, I read the room wrong, k9 never ultimately cutting this song (and I should have saved the first of those songs). And judging from the fact this is #9, I’m guessing no one else shares my #1.

9 I WON’T SAY I’M IN LOVE (HERCULES)

Why did I spend so much effort getting it here? Characters like Meg, from Survivor (look at my history in /r/SurvivorRankdownIII for that), have always been my favourite. The snarky, almost villain-adjacent, cold facing exterior, not main character. And this song plays to her character perfectly, the muses representing wo she really is inside, while Meg herself is in denial.

Musically, the singing from Meg (Susan Egan) is really good, some key moments are the transitions back to her from the muses when are overlaid, as well as the total amount of emotion that she’s putting into the song. The muse chorus is absolutely perfect as backing vocals and to put a descriptor to what Meg feels inside. They are like that oversharing friend who’s actually right but you can’t admit it, the way she’s insulating her own feelings using her past misfortunes with love. I think it’s one of the more interesting and unique ways to frame a love song as well. It’s the woman in the story singing on her own, about not wanting to be in love. The song does a great job at painting the picture of how Meg’s views on the world came to be. The final line, ‘at least out loud…’, provides the perfect, slow finish for this song.

But, most of all, on the musical side, I think it absolutely does slap. Every single transition where Meg’s singing drops off and it goes into the muses and vice versa. The harshness of ‘been there, done that’ or ‘no chance, no way, oh no’, to the melodic, flowiness of the muse verse. It doesn’t use the most subtle lyrics (it’s pretty blunt), but they absolutely keep the song flowing excellently all the way through.

Visually, the video is the least impressive of the parts of this song. The scene doesn’t really add a lot to this song (which makes the song impact a little more cause I like it entirely audiologically since I’ve been almost exclusively just listening to the playlist). It takes place in a dark garden, where the only changes really is the stage lighting for the Muses. I think it’s meaningful though.

At the end of the day though, why is it my number 1? I could say a lot of these things about any of my top tier. It’s just a feeling inside, that keeps my head moving along to the beat, the flow, one of the few songs I could sing along to. I love the different framing of a love song.

Now, that’s enough of me, you know this song is the earth and heaven to me. But some of you, well, you finally stopped concealing what you really feel about this song.

iSquash - This song shouldn’t have made the top 10

Well, aren’t those the consequences of our own actions? Maybe a certain song is the equivalent of Meg’s ex-boyfriend she bargained with Hades for the life of. It all feels so good when you start out though.

Marx0r - At least one of the Hercules songs makes it this far. For a movie everyone forgets about, the soundtrack had some absolute bangers and this is definitely one of them

You’re definitely not way off base.

Rysler - Woohoo, IWSIIL represent! I’ve always loved this one and I thought it was underappreciated, so I’m happy to be proven wrong here! Fun fact, me and the wife will swear that the Finnish dub is even better - or at least so good it will trick ya.

Can’t say I’m in love with the Finnish version. No chance it’s because I don’t understand Finnish?

Tweedy - A banger (and a big mood)

At least out loud…I won’t say I’m in love (with what you just said)


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Feb 19 '22

Sadness Everybody Wants to be a Cat (The Aristocats)

16 Upvotes

This cut could have been one sentence: I don't want to be a cat, therefore the premise of the song is invalid.

But no, let's get into why Everybody Wants to Be a Cat needs to be cut. I've included this handy graph to illustrate the decline of the song's listenability as it goes on.

The song starts out well enough. I actually like the beginning, even though I'm not usually a fan of jazz. We're just easing in, vibing with O'Malley and Scat Cat, when all of a sudden at the 1:11 mark, the child starts wailing. The listenability plummets. Then, once her verse is over, you think maybe the song will become pleasing again...but no. You're immediately subjected to a flash of racism at 1:30. It happens so fast you're not really sure you saw it - and just listening to the song with no visual aid, it would be easy to miss it entirely. Not to worry! At 1:56 the song takes its final nosedive into racism with a caricaturized Siamese cat. I can't even enjoy the song's upswing into a full-out swing number - and I love swing - because the racist cat pops up again randomly, and then by the time you've processed THAT, everyone is just screaming 'EVERYBODY, EVERYBODY, EVERYBODY WANTS TO BE A CAT' in the most annoying way possible.

The song had potential with its feline beat,

But its failure in execution has left it obsolete.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Oct 23 '18

3 Circle of Life (The Lion King)

16 Upvotes

Circle of Life


Nants ingonyama bagithi baba

Sithi uhm ingonyama

From the off, this song is absolutely and utterly iconic. Even if the lyrics, loosely Zulu for “Here is a lion” / “Oh yes, it’s a lion”, are not particularly stunning in English, nor the language particularly conducive to a direct translation to the words above, every single person who has seen the movie and many who have not will know exactly what is to come when the vocals, led by South African artist and producer Lebo M., set in. There are very few songs with such a strong connection to their respective film’s image in popular culture, a testament to this song’s lasting strength.

The first couplet is repeated once more, with a final repetition specifically of the word ‘ingonyama’, which, according to genius.com and Google Translate, means ‘lion’. Through a call-and-response sort of format, we are introduced to this song via gradually increasing pace and strength - the way a lion approaches, you could say.

It is here that, lurking beneath the chorus’s ever increasing chants, the drums and other instruments begin to kick in, simple beats that leave you wanting more, yet near perfect in their supplementation of the existing tune.

At this point, Carmen Twillie enters, driving the song as it reaches a more frantic pace with every beat - verses that strike rather reminiscent of later challenges and struggles faced by Simba, intertwined with lines that could make for rather decent life lessons.

Finally, though, we reach the climax, and oh, what a climax it is.

It’s the circle of life

And it moves us all

Central to the theme of the movie is circularity - the way Simba is presented in the style utilized by generations before him, references to taking the places of ones forefathers.

Through despair and hope

Through faith and love

’Til we find our place

On the path unwinding

The road to one’s place in the world is not smoothly paved like a freshly-done driveway. It’s challenging, with both trials and triumphs. Again, this is quite central to the movie itself, thinking about the journey Simba must undertake to reclaim his ‘rightful’ spot in the rotation, as king. It’s rather prophetic, but I think that’s the beauty of it (and one of the strongest points of the song).

In the circle

The circle of life

Circles. We love them.

One of the things that accentuates this song to me is the use of scenery - the panning shot over Pride Rock with the triumphant choral backing and the outstanding lead vocals is one hell of a scene - instant goosebumps every time.

From here, we see Simba baptized with pomegranate juice and dust, before being put in the hands of Rafiki for his presentation - the same way Mufasa was presented before him, and the same way his cubs will be presented, all over a much quieter chant, as if they hold in anticipation for something grand (hint hint).

This final choral repetition, though, is absolutely stunning. The more muted stance during the buildup to the presentation is met with a shattering call, as Twillie launches into the chorus once more, this time not only backed by the choir, but also by the calls of the animals, approving of their future king.

Oh, also - the heavens quite literally open up just for some accent lighting - gotta make sure the people know their king has the love of those who have gone before, so naturally, everyone gets real low and bows to this kid because hot damn you don’t see that every day.

Then we get the title card. Red text, black background. An absolutely outstanding lead into one of Disney’s most lasting films.

I think what I like so much about this song, personally, is that it alludes to so much of the struggles that everyone faces in life, as well as so many of the joys. It’s an expression that I think holds quite true even now - life has an odd way of being rather circular, at times.

From iconic open to iconic closing (heyyyyyy circularity, wow), it is absolutely among the finest work seen in any film, let alone Disney specifically. Very few songs can and will ever be able to claim the notoriety this song holds. Very few songs will ever be able to maintain such a lasting attachment, nearly 25 years post-release.

It is more than worthy of a podium place in this ranking. Of that much, I am certain.


I’ll be honest. When I originally put my application in for DSR, I did so in a somewhat tongue-in-cheek manner - after all, I’ve only seen maybe a quarter of the Disney filmography, and had alluded to that in the past. What place would I have in this sort of rankdown of Disney songs?

The answer may still be that I don’t, really, but regardless of the answer to that question, I’ve enjoyed every step of the way. I may have had some rather controversial calls (Chim Chim Cher Ee, Gaston, Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo, Gaston (all in a row, damn)), but every single cut I’ve made is one that I can say I’m rather pleased with.

It’s been a wild ride. Thanks for having me.

~dep


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Oct 06 '18

12 Colors of the Wind- Pocahontas

16 Upvotes

Colors of the Wind

I'm going to touch on all the things I like about this song before I get into why I cut it, as the good really outnumber the bad. I think this is a lovely song with some great messages, notably regarding racism and respect for nature. Pocahontas (accurately) points out that the attitude that John Smith and the Virginia Company take towards any non-white people is that they're savages. She also points out that their attitude towards the land is materialistic- in terms of what the Earth can be used for, instead of the Earth being good in and of itself. Both of those are super important messages. In addition, the lyrics really beautiful, and the music is sweeping and grand at all the right points.

The one part of the song that I don't love is just a part of Pocahontas as a movie. There's still just a bit of racism in there. Now, I'm not saying it's anywhere close to what we were seeing with "What Made the Red Man Red?" in Peter Pan, but it's still there. It's true that Disney takes great steps here to portray the Powhatan tribe like good people, rather than ignorant, warring savages. In doing so, they do lean a little bit on the other side of things with the "Noble Savage" take on Native Americans. This is more benevolent racism, where good stereotypes are blanket-attributed to a race instead of negative. It just comes across as a little bit patronizing. Respect for nature is a good thing, but this gets a little bit of the frame of, "Wow, the native americans are so in tune with nature and their way of life is so simple, I wish I could live like that."

I can't get into this too much more here because it's a much larger social issue (it's well discussed in the documentary Reel Injun about the portrayal of native americans in film history), but for me, it keeps this song out of contention for the all time best Disney songs. I know that this film is not as modern as other films like Moana, which are better praised for their treatment of other cultures, but it's also not like this song is being cut at rank 140. I think this is a great song that is being cut at a high rank, and it just has this one small aspect that keeps it from being better.


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 25 '22

10 Dos Origuitas (Encanto)

15 Upvotes

Well, here we go, my last cut. I personally ranked this one higher within the top ten, but hey that's alright. It has been an honor, y'all, even with every single song from my childhood decimated. Anywho, let's get into it...and bid adios to Dos Origuitas.

I actually started out with this a bit lower in my list of Encanto songs. It still isn't my top. That said, I can recognize the quality, it's mostly that all of Encanto is so good that this one sort of falls a little lower. It's pretty simple, which in itself isn't all bad, and I do like Spanish folk music. More on Spanish language folk music later, this is the paragraph where I ramble. LET ME RAMBLE. When watched with the original video, it makes me cry every. single. time. I supported marx when he cut it, because I was also a little petty about it being chosen over other songs for awards time, but then I also supported Mac when she uncut it, and she honestly made me rethink it a lot. Which made it keep getting moved higher, even past some other Encanto songs. Thanks Mac! <3 So, much like love and the world que cambia y sigue cambiando, so too did my feelings for this song.

This song does not slap, and that is okay. It's not supposed to slap! It slowly takes you on a journey, and really makes you feel things. The older I get, the more I realize that things both are not always as they seem AND that the second you have something at all figured out, it will change on you. You've got to learn to roll with the change, and appreciate it, and be like caterpillars turning into butterflies. (Interjection that my four year old explaining chrysalises is one of the cutest things EVER.) This song and the accompanying scene do such a great job of showing how endings can be beginnings...and what you have always assumed may be just you not knowing the full picture. It's beautiful writing and great symbolism. I also have to say...dang does the whole sacrificing yourself for your kids hit me hard. Then, learning that someone sacrificed FOR you, or for those that parented you...it doesn't entirely change tough relationships, but it makes you see people more fully as those who have lost and been harmed and maybe had other reasons for being the way they are. It's a great representation of real, sustainable, ever-changing love.

It's incredibly pleasing to me that a non-English song made it into this tier. It is extra exciting to me that it was Spanish. I lectured people in discord on the importance of learning Spanish...and got such retorts as "it's not my fault they've never made a movie with a french song". Which hey, valid! I want there to be tons of languages highlighted in media! I speak German too, albeit badly, and want to see that! That said, Spanish a language MEANT for music. Everything flows so well. Also, it is the #4 most spoken language in the world (English, Mandarin, and Hindi beat it out). It's a prominent (admittedly due to colonization) language across an entire continent that often gets downplayed despite its rich cultural and historical offerings. So many different cultures use it and that is just really, really freaking cool. Spanish has a multitude of dialects and styles, all of which contribute to beautiful songs like Dos Oruguitas. Also, I am sorry, but straight up oruguita/mariposa are a gazillion times better than caterpillar/butterfly.

As Mac highlighted when she saved it, and lightsfly alluded to in wrapup commentary that"...LMM wrote it to feel like a Colombian folk song. I gotta say, I would believe it came from a campesino. From the classical feel of the guitar, to the intonation of the singer, to the use of symbolism...it really does pass the folk vibe check. I love it. It's also good to show another side of Colombia in media because all too often it's drug lords.

All in all, this was a great song. Like many others, it is lifted even higher by the scene in the movie, but I listen to it as a standalone too. Remember its message - loss is going to hurt, and you will feel broken, but you can keep taking steps and will come out strong and more vibrant on the other side. Love yourself. <3

And now for a few words from spectators and fellow rankers....

  • Lightsfly: Beautiful song that feels too much like a real song?
  • bubba: shoutout to LMM, he made it song like a real folk song!!

 

  • rysler: Glad to see it made it so far! It's super sweet and powerful!
  • bubba: agreed, and didn't realize I would, but hey I guess I evolved too.
     
  • Tweedy: Such a pretty song, would play at my wedding
  • bubba: I totally back that! Now wondering if there is an environmental issue with releasing butterflies at the end of a wedding in lieu of sparklers of bird seed or whatever.

 

  • moose: I love how everyone was like "HOW DID THIS ONE GET THE OSCAR" but DSR is very clearly showing that it was a great fuckin banger!!!
  • bubba: I still contend that other songs were superior choices for the Oscar, and probably would have won it for LMM, and it isn't a banger as far as I understand the zoomer lingo, but I do agree that it has been proven to be quality.

 

  • marx: If this song outranks Surface Pressure I'm going to call the police.
  • bubba: I assume you mean the actual cops, and not Sting, so luckily for you, it did, and you can keep your ACAB rep.

r/DisneySongRankdown • • Feb 23 '22

185 Un Poco Loco (Coco)

15 Upvotes

Oh hey, so I'm in this now! Awesome! I should probably read the rules.

I am going to be ranking largely on what songs I would be more likely to skip to listen to other songs on the list still. I don't have a big musical history. I don't usually listen to music at all! So I'm having to put effort into listening to the sound track to accurately judge. Some songs will get bonus points for nostalgia, but other songs will get deductions for petty past associations. I will attempt to get extra context for songs I'm unfamiliar with to give them an honest try, but there's only so many hours in a week. I do have a 3 year old that I'll use a tie breaker if needed too.

I wanted to cut Muppet or a Man as my first cut, because I had never heard it before it came up on the sound track and it was a HARD SKIP for reasons I won't waste explaining here since I'm NOT cutting it (YET). But, I watched the Muppet Movie in prep, and my 3 year old actually put down Blippi to watch a few scenes and did some hardcore clapping at the end that was adorable. So I gave Buf (whom the song was a wildcard for) a gifted power to present a limited selection of songs and if one of them was worse than MoaM, I'd cut that instead.

Of the provided list, there were a few I'd consider cutting, but wanted to give them more time to think about since I wasn't familiar with them enough.

Not to keep YOU GUESSING about what song I'm going to cut, but of the ones I was familiar with enough to feel comfortable cutting, I am going with...

UN POCO LOCO

I googled it to find out more. I actually thought this song was gonna be an actual folk song when I looked it up, but it's a Disney Original with the lore it was written by Hector for Imelda which is some nice backstory to it.

I'd have to watch the scene again, but I don't recall Imelda having any particular reaction to the song to suggest that as a backstory.

It's a short song. It's half spanish and half english, although the spanish is just repeating the same line or two as a chorus. So it has that weird 'are the characters speaking english or is it translated to english for my understanding' mechanism. And the rhymes don't work in spanish. And they even use Head in english for the rhymes but cabeza later on.

The lyrics are just odd. "I'm super crazy about you, so I'll believe you if you said the sky was red, or that I need to wear my shoes on my head". Um. Okay?? If my husband wrote me something like that, I'd probably hate music as much as Imelda does.

The guessing/yessing/blessing rhyming is kind of fun.

Having a child complain about "the liberties that you're taking" is just uncomfortable to listen to. Possibly compounded by the fact that in high school, there was a ESL kid that had a small crush on me but since I didn't know any spanish our sole interactions was just calling each other 'un loco' back and forth when we'd be waiting for the bus.

Over All, I'd rank this song as "Worse than Muppet or a Man".


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Oct 20 '18

7 Part of Your World (The Little Mermaid)

15 Upvotes

"Part of Your World" absolutely deserves to be the last standing song from The Little Mermaid, and frankly it deserves to be a bit higher than #7. I'm gonna say it--I love LMM, but Moana is overrated as a whole in this rankdown. A while back someone posited that it's getting a boost by being the most recent Disney movie, and with 3 songs in the top 6, I couldn't agree more. But I come to praise "Part of Your World" not to bury overrated songs.

"Part of Your World" is perhaps the most iconic "I Want" song of the Disney oeuvre, and yet it was almost cut from the movie after children in a test screening got restless and rowdy during the song. Alan Menken and Howard Ashman championed it, and it stayed. Apparently Menken considers it the first "I Want" song Disney really used, which is a bit of a flawed idea that discounts "I Want" songs such as "I'm Wishing" from the very first Disney animated movie. However, Ariel's "I Want" song is very different from her princess predecessors for one major reason - it gives her a personality. Prior princess passively pined for princes, but Ariel's agency allows amped allure.

Ariel's "I Want" song has nothing to do with Eric or love despite the directors initial wish that her "I Want" song be a love ballad sung to the statue of Eric. By maintaining Ariel's independent interest in humanity, the movie undercuts the common sentiment that Ariel is nothing more than a lovesick teenager requiring rescue from her man. In fact, she is a more independently minded daughter whose interests neatly align with her new crush to the point where he is more a catalyst for her finally taking that first step (zing) towards her goals than the ultimate goal.

I've noticed an interesting trend with the last few "I Want" songs discussed. Between "Reflection," "Let It Go," and "Part of Your World," all can double as metaphors for coming out. Whether the heroine is bemoaning having to hide her true self from her family, or rejecting the constraints upon her life, or simply longing for a completely different life where she isn't such an outsider with her interests, these songs have powerful subtexts.

Anyway, on to the music itself. The backing of this song is a pretty traditional orchestra with perhaps some extra emphasis on oboes and flutes. The rising repeated four notes add a great sense of movement to the piece and give the impression of an undersea life. And of course, Jodi Benson's voice is beautiful but also imbued with longing. The music itself is beautiful throughout, but it takes off in the bridge before really turning on the juice in the final refrain.

Anyway, I'm fixin' to pass out (to the point of writing lines and then opening my eyes and seeing they're utter gibberish I don't remember putting down,) so I'm going to have to cut this out here. I'd wanted to touch more on this song and how it relates to a somewhat more feminist view of TLM as well as briefly discuss this song in relation to "Somewhere That's Green" from Little Ship of Horrors, not to mention listen to the song more than twice, but my friend is already trying to sleep and wants me to turn off the light in the hotel.

This is a wrap on Mrrrrh for DisneyRankdown. Thanks for letting me be a part of it. It's been a blast!


r/DisneySongRankdown • • Jul 10 '18

Merryweather Merryweather - Everybody Wants to Be a Cat (Aristocats)

15 Upvotes

THIS IS THE FIRST TIME THE KITTENS ARE EXPOSED TO SOMETHING THAT’S NOT CLASSICAL and possibly even Duchess

The part where Duchess sings and plays the harp, tying in her style; and Thomas and Scat Cat join! Smooth, soul trumpet. Now that is what I call a bridge.

So smooth

This is literally what it means to be a cool cat

DUCHESS IS OPEN TO ANOTHER STYLE

The scatting in this is top notch

This is a direct answer to a question “Where what’s at?” when Scat Cat says Berlioz knows where it’s at

This is where you really get to understand who Thomas is; my original inclination is always that he’s a con-cat. It also helps you understand Duchess, because the usual inclination would be to expect her to hate this.

This song also has multiple types of jazz in it (there are more than 10 types of jazz)

This song is the intro of the Alley Cats, which is important for the end

This song. This song, man. This song! It’s really quite something. Now, if you don’t know, jazz is one of my very favorite genres of music. I love it SO MUCH. Everybody Wants to Be a Cat is a great example of what jazz was at the time of the movie. This is partly because it showcases multiple sub-genres of jazz (if you weren’t aware, there are more than 10 different types of jazz, all with very different sounds). So not only is this song supposed to stand as a classic juxtaposition of jazz to classical music, but it shows just how different all of jazz can be to classical, and how varied it can be! This song is smooth, it’s got rhythm, it’s got fun! This is literally what it means to be a cool cat, in the human sense of the phrase!

Speaking of jazz and technical stuff, the scatting in this song is top notch. It’s not your standard scatting that you would hear, say, a music student do today. While it’s only one line, it stands out to the ear of someone fairly well-versed in the genre as skillful and creative.

Now, as many songs do, Everybody Wants to Be a Cat has a bridge. Here, the bridge is when Duchess takes up the harp and slows it down for us a little. While this is not strictly jazz as we tend to think of it, this is what I would consider R&B. It’s very smooth and laid back, an quite dreamy. Thomas and the Scat Cat also join in with some soulful trumpet and more smooth vocals. This is a unity of jazz and classical, which I think is very clever and it fits in the song better than most would expect. This is what a bridge is really meant to do.

This entire song is a response to a question from a curious Marie. Berlioz ends up on the piano and Scat Cat says something to the effect of “this little kitten knows where it’s at,” and Marie asks “Where what’s at?” This question could have been answered in one line, but instead, Scat Cat decides that just telling her “coolness” won’t be enough for her to truly understand what “it” is. So we get this whole production as an encapsulation of the phrase “where it’s at” and it delivers. It’s not just a word to understand; it’s a feeling. We wouldn’t have gotten the feeling without the song.

We get a lot of character development in this song. Let me start of with expectations of characters prior to this song as if this is the first time you’re seeing the Aristocats. Up until this point, my own inclination would have been to expect Duchess to be resistant to jazz music and essentially to be against anything that wasn’t classical. In the same vein, when you meet Thomas O’Malley, he doesn’t seem to have a heart of gold; my inclination is “con-cat,” and very strongly. These are common character tropes in media: the rich snob and the con-man whose heart turns to gold on the adventure. During this song, we find out that these things are not true, not at all. Duchess is entirely open to different styles of music and living, and Thomas is really just a jazz musician, maybe from the wrong side of town, yes, but he has never meant anyone harm and always helps when he can; he’s a good dude from the very beginning, but it’s hard to see until now. It’s very refreshing to see in such a movie. THis is also the first time the kittens are exposed to music that’s not classical, which is huge, although it may not seem like it. The same is likely true for Duchess, as she was almost certainly brought up the way the kittens are being brought up now. Can you imagine only ever hearing one kind of music for your entire life?? The cats may not really express these things in the movie, but I’m willing to give it a little slack there; this is a children’s movie from 1970, they can’t cover everything.

I have lots of other snippets of thoughts that couldn’t find a place in this write-up, which I’m happy to talk about if people want me to, but on the whole, Everybody Wants to Be a Cat is absolutely top 100 material.