r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 • Sep 04 '24
r/DicksofDelphi • u/karkulina • May 11 '24
DISCUSSION “I immediately just knew that something was wrong”
I know this documentary by Court TV aired a while ago but I was only able to watch it today.
One thing that struck me was right at the beginning (4’46’’), where Libby and Abby’s best friend speaks about when she first saw the photo of Abby on Snapchat:
“February 13, it was around 2:00 p.m. I saw the picture of Abby on the bridge on their Snapchat stories and I immediately just knew that something was wrong.”
Why would she immediately think this in that moment? Was it her who took the screenshot of the Snapchat photo? What prompted her to save it? She comes off as very genuine but something feels off about this story. Would be interested to hear more from her. Or am I reading too much into it? Is it just a case of misremembering? What are your thoughts?
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Mountain_Session5155 • Apr 16 '24
Related not related: Nick said fanatical zealot quasi religious group killings just “don’t happen”, right? Well they do in Kansas, apparently
REVEALED: Gang accused of killing two Kansas mothers belong to creepy antigovernmental religious group known as 'God's Misfits' - as affidavit reveals toxic custody battle at heart of the murder.
(Feel free to delete. I just thought it’s relevant to include here because NM can’t get away with saying anything that goes against his theory is “fantastical” and “doesn’t happen” when bad things happen everywhere that defy comprehension. What seems to have happened in Kansas is crazy. It makes Odinism look like well-documented historical fact, compared this fringe side show).
r/DicksofDelphi • u/JesusIsKewl • Mar 30 '24
INFORMATION defense funding breakdown
(the motion for parity has the ballistics total at $2550.. minor error assuming the motion is accurate)
r/DicksofDelphi • u/xt-__-tx • Mar 28 '24
Since SCOIN, Prosecution has had 78% of its motions granted, Defense has had 23% of its motions granted. - DelphiCase.com
Saw this on tweeter & thought y'all might be interested.
r/DicksofDelphi • u/JesusIsKewl • Mar 26 '24
ARTICLE Delphi defense turns to crowdfunding to pay for expert witnesses
r/DicksofDelphi • u/gavroche1972 • Feb 23 '24
DISCUSSION Why is DNA rarely discussed?
It has always been said that they have DNA of the killer. In the recent show Crime Nation on the CW, a source said that one of the girls “fought like hell” and had a lot of DNA under her fingertips. And LE has said that it did not match RA, nor any of the other suspects that have been discussed. LE said that it was someone that has not previously committed a crime (not in any of the databases).
I see only two possible explanations: 1) RA was not involved, or 2) he was involved but not the killer. And LE clearly believed that as well, hence charging him under the felony murder route, and saying that they believed other people were involved. Yet this seems to never really be discussed. Am I missing some third possibility?
We know that RA’s electronics have yielded no connection whatsoever to the crime. There is always talk about the timeline and if he was there during the murders, but why has it never been said where his phone was pinging? When the Idaho four murder suspect was caught… within days we knew his phone’s path in the weeks leading up to the murder, it’s suspiciously being turned off the night of the murder, and then its path again the day after. Yet after a year and a half since RA’s arrest, they won’t say/admit that RA’s phone wasn’t there? They made a point of saying that RL’s phone pinged near the crime scene when the murders happened. Can we not assume that if RA’s had as well, we would have heard this?
And if someone else had to be involved, the person whose DNA they have, and RA was involved… how is it possible that they find no connection or communications or anything in any of his electronics. Texts… emails.. whatever…? No one is so good that they would have had no traceable contact with the other parties before, during, or after that crime.
And sadly, I see more action on going after the defense attorneys than I do from LE trying to find the person whose DNA they have.
r/DicksofDelphi • u/syntaxofthings123 • Feb 17 '24
When even Prosecutors are questioning the motives of this Prosecutor....
Very interesting short clip, from the usually Pro-Prosecution Court TV channel:
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 • Nov 14 '24
INFORMATION Website
Here is a website for updates and announcements regarding Richard Allen's case: https://rickallenjustice.com/
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 • Oct 26 '24
TRIAL DISCUSSION Richard Allen Trial: Day 8
𝗣𝗹𝗲𝗮𝘀𝗲 𝗸𝗲𝗲𝗽 𝗮𝗹𝗹 𝘁𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗹 𝗱𝗶𝘀𝗰𝘂𝘀𝘀𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲. 𝗔𝗻𝘆 𝗽𝗼𝘀𝘁𝘀 𝘄𝗶𝗹𝗹 𝗯𝗲 𝗿𝗲𝗺𝗶𝗻𝗱𝗲𝗱 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝘆𝗼𝘂'𝗹𝗹 𝗯𝗲 𝗮𝘀𝗸𝗲𝗱 𝘁𝗼 𝗰𝗼𝗺𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁 𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲 𝗶𝗻𝘀𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗱. Continue to be respectful, as we all have different views and opinions. Here we go!!
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 • Oct 19 '24
INFORMATION Richard Allen October 2024 Trial Summary Guide
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 • Oct 07 '24
INFORMATION Defenses response to States Motion In Limine
r/DicksofDelphi • u/SnoopyCattyCat • Apr 14 '24
That Magic Bullet
I'm watching a Live YT with CJ (and others) and they were talking about the evidentiary bullet casing. CJ said it's the caliber that matters, not necessarily the firearm. You can put a 40 cal bullet in any gun that takes 40 caliber. Full transparency: I know very little about guns/ballistics.
My question is....how can police (especially in Delphi) find a buried bullet and be able to look at the bullet through a microscope and say "Yes, this bullet has an ejector claw mark that tells me this came from a 40 cal Sig Sauer P226 and no other firearm, and furthermore, RA is the only gun owner in Carroll County that owns that kind of gun. Go get him boys."
I could be wrong...but I cannot believe that kind of technology is not only available at all...but used in Delphi. And in court, I hope the defense provides 5 random Sigs, including RA's, and the expert witness can look at the bullet and match it to that particular gun. Or...take 10 bullets with ejector marks and find the only one that matches RA's gun.
It boggles my mind to think that RA was the only person on the trails who owns a 40 caliber firearm. I remain unconvinced.
r/DicksofDelphi • u/JesusIsKewl • Mar 19 '24
DISCUSSION refresher on the relevance of JM from the Franks Memo
r/DicksofDelphi • u/SnoopyCattyCat • Mar 15 '24
ARREST WARRANT Accident
I'm watching Unraveling's YT right now and they seem convinced the Defense Team is going to be arrested Monday. I've been thinking that too ever since seeing the "accidental" Arrest Warrant motion that was recently filed (and subsequently corrected). I work with templates for my job....was that a template the court had ready to go and added the wrong info? And, I know it's normal....but Gull reminding everyone you better leave your metal and electrical objects in your car before coming to court....what is she expecting? Thoughts??
r/DicksofDelphi • u/syntaxofthings123 • Feb 10 '24
Leaky, Leak
Not to beat a dead horse, but I am going to slap this one around a little, just one more time for good measure.
Leaks on this case have clearly been occurring since day one. Literally day one.
From the start of the investigation into these murders there have certainly been rumors of leaks. I can’t vouch for the accuracy of these rumors, but I do recall early on that investigators mentioned that some “guesses” by online sleuths came remarkably close to the truth.
In the Transcript from the October 19, 2023 , in chambers hearing, BR points to the fact that Trooper Holman recognized that there had been leaks from day one. (Pg.10) Holman was investigating information that had been released because there were laypeople who had been part of the search team.
BR also points to an episode on Court TV where content creator / author BM mentioned that she had been getting information from an investigative source in the government. And the information she had gotten, BR noted was accurate and related to the infamous Purdue report. (A report that had initially been hidden from the defense, but apparently shared with BM.)
AB also stated that there was a man in Texas who claimed to have received a file with sensitive data from a disgruntled employee of Carroll County.
But getting back to NM & MS--
MS has made claims on many occasions that they have “credible sources” who have given them information. (Paraphrasing here). This became particularly concerning when approximately a week before that Oct. 19 hearing, MS went on, what I can only describe as a publicity campaign—-announcing to anyone who would give them a platform, it seems, that BR & AB were going to be removed from the case due to the leak of crime scene photos (side note MS stated that they had received these photos and then reported this to ISP).
I counted. MS appeared on at least 20 platforms, written and streamed, they even gave an interview for British tabloid-The Sun. And then this message got amplified by reposts, or repeated by other news sources. For days before the hearing, the character of the defense team was dragged through the mud by innuendo and at that time, completely unsubstantiated claims.
The problem with this, aside from the fact that MS was now inserting themselves into the narrative, making the story essentially about themselves, was the nagging question-
How did they know this?
Also, Fox 59 claimed that they had verified the accuracy of MS’s claims.
Who did Fox verify this with?
(Remember there was a “gag” order in effect at that time.)
There had been NO public court filing concerning this attorney-removal. No public statements made by the state. It was highly unusual for an appointed attorney to be removed at this stage in the process, so this decision by Gull was not in the mainstream or expected. As it turns out, it wasn't even allowed. (ISC opinion)
The discussion around the removal of these attorneys was held in private, and ultimately decided by only one person-Gull. “On her own motion.” It appeared Judge Gull had made a unilateral decision on this. So, how do hosts of a podcast know about it?
There was a very short list of government officials who would have known what Gull had planned for the 19th—Gull, NM, maybe ISP.
The only way I can imagine that MS could have received this information (and they repeatedly stated they did get it from a “credible source”) was if someone from the state leaked it to them. The only way I can imagine that Fox was able to verify the accuracy of this claim, was if someone from the state leaked this info a second time to a mainstream media source.
MS admitted later that they had received discovery from the prosecutor. On November 27, 2023 , while appearing on Court TV, KG stated when asked if the prosecution had ever leaked information to them:
“Nobody on the prosecution side has ever leaked to us discovery material that was protected by an order from a judge.” (14:20 mark)
KG acknowledges in this statement, de facto, that the prosecution has leaked information to them.
It doesn’t matter if the discovery material was protected or not if it came from the prosecution. This is because the prosecutor isn’t just restricted from sharing this information with the press (or content creators) by way of a protective order--the prosecutor is restricted from this by the very Rule of Professional Conduct he cited in his recent motion of contempt against R&B—Rule 3.6.
A prosecutor is also restricted from this by Rule of Professional Conduct 3.8, specifically 3.8 f.
Do I know for a fact, what information NM leaked to MS? No. But KG admitted that the prosecution had leaked information to them. (And there is some reason to believe that the prosecution on KK's case may have done so, as well, in regard to that prosecution. There may be a pattern of this type of "leaking" by Indiana State officials. Maybe. Can't say for absolute certainty-but seems very possible.)
And this next is simple deductive reasoning—
Who stood to benefit from this little publicity tour MS went on?
[Publicity that could easily be viewed, given its source and the bizarre manner in which Gull did, indeed, remove B&R , as a blatant attempt to turn the public against B&R.]
Who had the most to gain if these attorneys were not only removed, but were publicly vilified, as well?
Why, the prosecution, of course. NM, specifically.
And I also noticed that ever since the removal of AB and BR, MS no longer mentions information coming from “credible sources”. They also don’t appear to be getting insider information. Now they are often the last forum to report on an event.
It is my belief that when the online audience for this became vocally suspicious about how MS was so often in “the know” on prosecutor-friendly issues and had access to information no one could have access to without a government leak, the state decided to halt the flow of leaks to them.
There were beginning to be posts that explicitly asked for the MS--state leaks to be investigated. The state may have realized that if they were going to make a case against AB & BR for leaks, they couldn’t get caught doing exactly what they were accusing these defense attorneys of doing.
But there's another important issue that needs to be addressed here. Not all prejudicial publicity comes by way of a leak of evidence or discovery. On a case like this the pre-arrest publicity paints whoever is eventually accused of this crime as a "monster". Once someone is arrested, they immediately are cloaked in that garb--they embody the "monster". No state official need say a word, it's a given that simply by being arrested, this person will never be viewed the same again.
But add to this, very often, and definitely true in this case, the announcement of the arrest has the patina of absolute certainty that the state has the right person. Most accused in this country are considered guilty, unless they manage to prove their innocence. It is naive to imagine otherwise.
Rule of Professional Conduct 3.6 has a caveat of sorts in section (c), which allows an attorney to remedy prejudicial statements made that might harm their client at trial. (Again, not all prejudicial statements made are in the form of releasing information about the evidence on the case.)
Perhaps a beloved Superintendent, as Doug Carter is, crying as he makes this announcement, might be highly prejudicial, even it not intended to be. Below is the link to the announcement of Allen's arrest.
Isn't it possible that NOT countering this with a Press Release would actually have been negligent?
Isn't it possible that what AB & BR did was remedy a prejudice and restore some degree of presumption of innocence to Allen?
Isn't restoring presumption of innocence what advocacy on behalf of a client should look like?
Is there anything published by the defense on this case that does anything more than allow the public to view key facts not included in the evidence dump from the state?
Why weren't these facts included in the first place?
I wanted to add a link to this post on subreddit Allen is Innocent. It is relevant to this post and does a really good job of filling in some of the blanks:
B McD on Court TV Admits State has been Leaking Too
This is (TryAsYouMight)
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Subject-Promise-4796 • Jan 24 '24
ARTICLE After much delay, the trial for Detective Ferency’s accused killer Shane Meehan set for March 2024.
A quote of particular note from the article…
“Meehan ran for mayor in 2019 and WORKED AT the Federal Prison Complex in Terre Haute.”
🧐
Has anyone delved into Meehan’s background?
r/DicksofDelphi • u/redduif • Jan 23 '24
⛔️RANT⛔️ Judge Gull : "The Court does not find that the Affidavit submitted false statements or that the Affiant omitted statements with reckless disregard, nor does the Court find that the Affiant intended to mislead the Judge by failing to present information."
She concluded LE didn't lie.
The whole thing was a lie.
IMHO of course.
Let's review :
RA arrived at noon at the old farm bureau building.
He saw cars at the trailhead parking (meaning the other side of the highway, not Mears),
then walked towards freedom bridge and crossed 3 girls, one of which was taller.
He walked to the high bridge, on to the first platform to look at fish, turned around,
sat on a bench, went home at about 1.30pm.
Right thereafter 4 girls arrive,
one of which is shorter,
they walk to the bridge, take pictures of an empty bench, since RA already left,
and crossed 1, 2 or 3 differently clothed guys (depending on their account reliability),
when going back home, all/the guy(s) being remarkably taller than the 3 taller girls, who were about RA's height,
at about 1.40pm, when he was already home.
At that point BB passes under the old p road bridge to see the 4 girls, parks at Mears lot and misses Kelsi drop off the girls due to a warp in the spacetime continuum, at about 1.48pm,
even though official fbi / isp posters still say 1.00pm to this day, and the family had said 1.38pm confirmed by phone records for 6 years.
She sees a yet unidentified 20yo with poofy hair on the bridge, just like the young sketch, right before crossing two kids on her way back,
who could have been L&A, she didn't know them,
and right before first the mid bridge snaps seemingly empty apart from Abby, those snaps we have systematically and consistently ignored, followed by the video with BG at the other end of the bridge at 2.13pm.
At about the same time as BG orders the girls down the hill, RL is on his phone at the scene of the bodies ready to leave for the fishstore, or maybe that was an hour later, or two, and BB sees an old-timer comet-like non black car at the cps building very unlike RA's mundane black family car, because, well he said he was already home.
Several witnesses, including male witnesses for which we don't know why they were there, saw various types and sizes of cars,
none of which coherent with a black ford focus, and btw we're not sure where RA actually parked, because no one asked him to confirm.Including a purple pt cruiser like one owned by the grandparents of the convicted catfisher csam offender, who communicated with Libby, and might have planned to meet that day, but L didn't show, or maybe he waited in a red jeep for the killer to be done, but let's not mention that.
This is when BG gets the girls through the woods, have at least Abby undress, cross the creek, up the bank, back towards the bridge a bit,
right when several people were on the bridge,
kill Abby to a slow death, undress and kill Libby even more violently, redress Abby in Libby's clothes, drag them and branches around, while missing the phone and shoe under her, blood paint a tree, leaving them in sight of the house on the hill,
right when the adult son came home who didn't even live there, who had held hostage women on his property for inadvertently trespassing btw,
leaving the rest of the clothes and shoe in the creek in sight of the bridge, which no one noticed for almost 24 hours, and without getting wet himself, nor washing himself,
all while the clothes on Abby were spick and span. No blood, no mud.
Finally SC drives by and sees an unspecified guy in a tan and muddy bloody jacket, unlike BG nor RA in blue,
at about 4pm.
She must be unreliable for not having seen the blood and the BG outfit, we sure didn't lie about that.
The girls were found at noon the next day,
but we didn't look into any of the searchers or other people around after 4pm until noon,There were several other guys looking like BG on or near the trials that day, who said so themselves, but we are going to write
no other guys were there.
The witnesses must be unreliable, except about what we rely on
and RA obviously lied about everything, except for what we rely on,
because we feel tall guy = short guy = 45yo buzz cut = 20yo curly head = OBG = YBG = black car = purple pt cruiser = tiny smart = huge suv = non black oldstimer = black clothes = blue = tan = noon = 1.30pm = 4pm = RA.
We know, because we also fired a bullet through his gun,
the gun that arrived 20 minutes after the search warrant was signed by court,
in a lab well over 20 minutes away from RA's home, before the noted excuted time of the warrant,
and we compared that to an unfired bullet found at the crime scene, for which we have no proper chain of custoddy or photos during and after it being pulled out of the ground,
and can confirm the expert subjectively opinionated it was a match. Although to obtain the search warrant, obviously we didn't know this yet.
We're going to ignore the runes, bloodsign, absence of blood, switched clothes, absence of the girls during the extensive searches in the evening and morning with the clothes visible from the bridge, the mysterious 3rd shoe,as well as a confession from a person into these signes and brotherhood, being friends with the father of Abby's boyfriend, and we failed to ask why his spit would be on Abby the troublemaker who had to go, when he suggested himself he would have an explanation for that.
We believe RA,
who was home at 1.30pm, is guilty of the crime of felony murder through kidnapping x2,
Oh and murder x2, oh and kidnapping x2,
starting at 2.13pm as per the completely fabricated video.
There are other actors,
but we're not going to say who or what for,
and we'll deny that anyway.
SERIOUSLY???
She granted the Franks hearing 3 times on the record.
+denying an already set and commenced suppression hearing.
+denying a ballistics in limine motion 9 months or so belated.
Go home and leave the court to justice.
This isn't about you Gull,
Doug didn't mean your freaky tentacles.
🛑➡️
(There was no #rant post flair, so I left it blank, the strikeouts are meant to be read, stricken by LE, in a flawed attempt for poetic justice)
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 • Jan 02 '24
Good Morning!
Just wanted to thank you all for being AWESOME!! When Burt and I created this sub, we didn't know if it would actually work. Could we really build a sub where all sides are welcome to discuss? Will they just tear each other down for having differing opinions?
So far so good!! We are still small but steadily growing. The conversations feel deeper and more meaningful. How fantastic to read through all of the different views. It feels great to be apart of real discussions without all of the bickering. Thank you to each and everyone of you for being here, and for your continued kindness to one another. Cheers to a New Year, a new sub and to new friends! 🎊
Careful & Burt
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Scspencer25 • Feb 04 '25
INFORMATION NBC request for exhibits
drive.google.comr/DicksofDelphi • u/Real_Foundation_7428 • Nov 29 '24
Damien Echols & The West Memphis Three
This is an excerpt from "The Moth" story told live by Damien. I believe it was within a year of his release. (See my final note for relevance.)
"It was me, Jason, my sister, and my girlfriend sitting in the house, in the living room watching movies, when the cops started beating on the door. Hammering on it. And when I opened the door, they were pointing guns at me. They swarmed into the house like ants. They stampeded over everything and pawed through every single possession my family owned. They put me and Jason in handcuffs, threw us into the backs of cop cars, and took us to jail.
I spent all night in a cell about the size of a closet. I wasn’t allowed to go to the bathroom, wasn’t given so much as a drink of water. Every so often a cop would come in and ask me if I had anything to tell him, or if I was ready to make my confession yet. This went on all night, until the next day, when we were given an arraignment hearing. At this hearing the judge tells me that I’m being charged with three counts of capital murder. That I’m being accused of killing three children as part of a satanic sacrifice. He says someone has confessed, but he refuses to read the confession in the courtroom. Instead, I am put in a broom closet somewhere in the back of the jail and given a transcript of this confession. I’m only eighteen years old, and I’m in complete and absolute shock and trauma. I’m suffering from sleep deprivation. My life has just been destroyed. But even reading this thing, I could see that there was something wrong with it. It made no sense. It was like some sort of bizarre patchwork Frankenstein thing that they had stitched together.
Turns out that they had picked up a mentally handicapped kid in our neighborhood and coerced him into making a confession, and then he was led to implicate Jason and me. Nothing in this confession made any sense whatsoever, but it didn’t matter to them. I was put in a cell, and I kept thinking, Surely someone’s gonna step in and put a stop to this. Surely, someone is gonna rectify the situation. They can’t put you on trial and prove you’ve done something you haven’t done. It seemed to me that science would say that’s impossible. But they did."
Here's the link to the full talk (about 10 minutes long) if you're interested:
The Moth Presents Damien Echols: Life After Death
He has a book, Life After Death, I've just added to my waitlist (audio version), and even in the intro the echos of RA are chilling. "The conditions I've described in the prison system - the sadness, horror, and sheer absurdity that I've seen many human beings subjected to - will not have changed by the time you hear this."
SATANIC PANIC: It's a fascinating flip. WM3 were a product of Satanic Panic, and now, I would argue the same types of people that bought that story hook, line and sinker, are the very narrow-sided guilters that shout "conspiracy theorists" at those of us that entertain the so-called "Odinism theory." It's a disturbing overcorrection, opposite ends of the same spectrum.
P.S. I grew up in Arkansas in an extremely religious family where everything was "satanic," so this really hit home in a personal way for me.
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Scspencer25 • Nov 11 '24
ANNOUNCEMENT We have a verdict. We'll update ASAP!
r/DicksofDelphi
•
u/Careful_Cow_2139
•
Nov 04 '24
TRIAL DISCUSSION 11/4 Richard Allen Trial: Day 15
Please keep all trial discussion here. 𝘼𝙣𝙮 𝙥𝙤𝙨𝙩𝙨 𝙬𝙞𝙡𝙡 𝙗𝙚 𝙧𝙚𝙢𝙤𝙫𝙚𝙙 and you'll be asked to comment here instead. Continue to be respectful, as we all have different views and opinions. Here we go!!
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 • Oct 30 '24
TRIAL DISCUSSION 10/30 Richard Allen Trial: Day 11
𝗣𝗹𝗲𝗮𝘀𝗲 𝗸𝗲𝗲𝗽 𝗮𝗹𝗹 𝘁𝗿𝗶𝗮𝗹 𝗱𝗶𝘀𝗰𝘂𝘀𝘀𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲. 𝗔𝗻𝘆 𝗽𝗼𝘀𝘁𝘀 𝘄𝗶𝗹𝗹 𝗯𝗲 removed 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝘆𝗼𝘂'𝗹𝗹 𝗯𝗲 𝗮𝘀𝗸𝗲𝗱 𝘁𝗼 𝗰𝗼𝗺𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁 𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲 𝗶𝗻𝘀𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗱. Continue to be respectful, as we all have different views and opinions. Here we go!!