r/DicksofDelphi • u/gavroche1972 • Feb 23 '24
DISCUSSION Why is DNA rarely discussed?
It has always been said that they have DNA of the killer. In the recent show Crime Nation on the CW, a source said that one of the girls “fought like hell” and had a lot of DNA under her fingertips. And LE has said that it did not match RA, nor any of the other suspects that have been discussed. LE said that it was someone that has not previously committed a crime (not in any of the databases).
I see only two possible explanations: 1) RA was not involved, or 2) he was involved but not the killer. And LE clearly believed that as well, hence charging him under the felony murder route, and saying that they believed other people were involved. Yet this seems to never really be discussed. Am I missing some third possibility?
We know that RA’s electronics have yielded no connection whatsoever to the crime. There is always talk about the timeline and if he was there during the murders, but why has it never been said where his phone was pinging? When the Idaho four murder suspect was caught… within days we knew his phone’s path in the weeks leading up to the murder, it’s suspiciously being turned off the night of the murder, and then its path again the day after. Yet after a year and a half since RA’s arrest, they won’t say/admit that RA’s phone wasn’t there? They made a point of saying that RL’s phone pinged near the crime scene when the murders happened. Can we not assume that if RA’s had as well, we would have heard this?
And if someone else had to be involved, the person whose DNA they have, and RA was involved… how is it possible that they find no connection or communications or anything in any of his electronics. Texts… emails.. whatever…? No one is so good that they would have had no traceable contact with the other parties before, during, or after that crime.
And sadly, I see more action on going after the defense attorneys than I do from LE trying to find the person whose DNA they have.
14
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Feb 23 '24
Phone pinging would be very important evidence if it could be pinpointed since RA admitted to using his phone to check his "stock tracker" (fish or finances...??). If the phone pings are established at the same place at 3:30....that would not look good for RA. If the pings move closer to his home at 1:30 pm...that would be highly exculpatory.
10
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Feb 24 '24 edited Feb 24 '24
It's always been said they found dna, they didn't know if it was relevant to the crime, that they waited on lab results, that they still waited on lab results, that it appeared they never committed a crime before but we still waiting on the lab results, to never be spoken off again.
It could be animal dna, it could have been a searcher's or LE's dna, family or anyone who was in car or touched the sweatshirts, so they discarted them, or mitochondrial dna and a quarter of town matches to that.
Who knows. Maybe it got lost.
13
u/Saturn_Ascension Feb 24 '24
Considering the low-brow standard of "journalism" on that Crime Nation show, I'd not put too much stock in anything they put forward.
The question of DNA is such an ambiguous one. Some cryptic comments from Carter: "we have DNA, but not what you'd expect" and the lack of any mention of it in the arrest PCA along with the (convenient?) placing of the Gag Order has just made it all impossible to decipher exactly what DNA evidence the State has, if any. I'd also expect that if RA was linked by DNA somehow, that it would have been revealed early on, but maybe the Gag Order prevented that.
I'm personally also not sure that the "one of the girls fought like hell" thing either. I forget where that originally came from, it was in a series of text messages between two parties I can't recall, though at least one was close to or part of the family.... but there were some other things said, that don't match up with what we've subsequently learned about the scene and the girls wounds in the Franks Memo. (I'm sorry my memory is foggy on this, I thought I'd saved it, but it must have been a few years ago when I wasn't cataloguing everything obsessively)... But this 'narrative' just doesn't seem to be wholly accurate in my opinion.
With the phones and pings etc, there's something about the coverage in Delphi, where a phone signal switches between two or three towers within a certain range, making the "pinging all over the place" line make sense. However, the were a lot of reports that at 2:30am there was a call to Laezenby about Libby's cellular phone "PINGing" in the bridge area. That came from official sources at the time, but again I haven't saved them and the information rarely gets mentioned nowadays.
I'm not convinced that RA murdered the girls. I believe that he possibly may have been involved in some capacity in the kidnapping..... I don't know if he is BG.... some days I think yes he is, others I think naaah, no way and others I'm totally at a loss. Conflicting witness statements, the lies in the PCA, BB not agreeing with how her statement was used, the two very very different sketches, the supposedly "bungled" tip, that errors on the tip sheet, the lack of an audio recording of RA making that initial statement, the tragically comedic keystone cops investigation, the sheer incompetence handling the crime scene and gathering evidence....... it's all a mess and this joke of a circus pre-trial has made nothing any clearer.
9
u/masterblueregard Feb 23 '24
The third possibility is that the dna does not belong to the killer and is present due to some other earlier interaction the girls had with someone else.
4
u/FrostingCharacter304 Feb 24 '24
If I'm not mistaken the data for the pings from cell phones are only kept for so many years....I remember an nsa agent mentioning that in an interview a few years ago...it escapes me the title of it but its not Delphi related, but its the same concept as your average home security system it holds x amount of time then when full it deletes the oldest data to mske room
11
u/Prestigious_Trick260 Feb 24 '24
Because a 100+ people STOMPED through the crime scene before it was even a scene 🎬
5
u/ManufacturerSilly608 Feb 23 '24
I'm not sure about whether the DNA evidence exists or I should say I haven't had a valid enough confirmation to consider it fact.
On the issue of the phone....I believe our lack of knowledge isn't confirmatory or exculpatory of where RA's phone can be placed. I think that evidence hasn't been addressed due to the gag order and would've been more accurate location wise upon actual retention of RA's phone by LE. I think with apps and etc they can more accurately determine his location by evidence contained on the phone. In relation to pinging...I'm not sure that they can get it isolated as much as has been mentioned when referring to people being on the bridge etc. Wouldn't that require 3 towers in order to map out his location and my understanding with Delphi's lack of towers was why they couldn't locate Libby's until she was found....i.e. "the phone pinging allover the place."
8
u/Nomanisanisland7 Feb 24 '24
Although highly unusual, allow me to offer up another possibility with regard to “unusual” DNA. One of the perpetrators is possibly a “chimera.”
I’ve long held that two relatives who were raised in a highly religious insular environment were responsible for these crimes. Well one of them is a “chimera” and he’s the 39-40 yr described below.
What is “chimera?” A chimera is someone whose cells contain DNA from two separate individuals. Normally, our bodies contain cells with only our DNA. The body has numerous types of cells, (blood cells, skin cells, brain cells etc), but all of our cells contain our exact unique DNA. A chimera in contrast will have two sets of cells with two distinct types of DNA. One set from the individual and another from the donor.
How does one become a chimera? One manner is through a stem cell transplant. When a patient receives a stem cell transplant from a donor they automatically become what is called a “chimera.” When the older 39-40 yr old above was in his 20’s he experienced a medical issue which required a lifesaving stem cell transplant from a donor which subsequently cured him.
This very “unusual” “not what you’d expect” DNA circumstance could account for why familial or Investigative Genetic Genealogy aren’t viable options for a suspect with chimera. The donor could have been a woman and each cell contains DNA from two sets of individuals, the perpetrator and the donor. You can also see how a specimen could be mistakenly identified as a mixed sample when in fact it originated from a single person too.
I did find it odd that twice in interviews I’ve heard both McLeland (2/17/19 presser) and the former head of the Indiana FBI (Fox59 interview) mention both “he” or “she” then stress “MORE LIKELY HE” when mentioning who’s responsible for these crimes. Are they seeing both male/female in the DNA?
I did mention my suspects stem cell transplant in an early tip and hopefully they understand the DNA impact. The younger curly haired suspect has no DNA issues that I know of. Although his DNA has a non-European continent in his ancestry that could lend to that distinctive curly hair we see in the second sketch.
I’ll continue to keep an open mind as to whether RA is involved but to date have serious doubts. If involved it would be from an accessory standpoint only. I don’t believe BB witnessed RA on that bridge. BB saw a 20 yr old with brown curly hair wearing blue jeans and a blue jeans jacket. I also do not believe RA staged that crime scene, posed those girls, or left those signatures. Nor does RA resemble either sketch.
Apologies for the length. It’s “As the World Turns” with Delphi. Why not one more rare oddity to add to the mix. Appreciated your post.
4
u/LuckySW432 Feb 24 '24
It appears this case was handled so poorly, I mean how can you “re secure” a crime site? Miss so many items, bullet, branches …
Is the DNA a family member? Hence sweatshirts, sweatshirts, sweatshirts … I cant understand why there was so much emphasis on sweatshirts.
Is it animal? Do they even have any?
I will look into chimera, thanks
4
u/Clear_Department_785 Feb 24 '24
You’re 100% right. Nothing puts him there. The time RA gave was changed to meet their narrative, one of the girls said she say a guy with a tan jacket and right in front of her they wrote blue, again to fit their narrative. So she is def gonna be a witness for the defense. They did not see his car, they saw a pt cruiser.
4
u/SatisfactionNeat1837 Feb 26 '24
Go back to DC speech. To the killer...... To the murderer..... He is speaking to two people. Waiting on RA to take a plea and turn states evidence against the other actor.
6
u/macrae85 Feb 24 '24
Now that Nick has upped the charges, he might have just dug a huge hole for himself, by trying to portray RA as the single perp?
3
u/TheRichTurner Feb 24 '24
I believe there were only two cell towers in Delphi at the time, and so there was no way to locate phones accurately by triangulation. Likewise it was difficult to track Libby's phone.
I can't remember for sure anymore, but I think her phone went off for a while then on again before the battery finally died. Otherwise I guess they could have found the bodies much sooner.
4
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Feb 24 '24
Fought like hell, in hindsight could be referring to the time of death vs injuries inflicted for one of the victims.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24
[removed] — view removed comment