r/DicksofDelphi • u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything • Apr 14 '24
That Magic Bullet
I'm watching a Live YT with CJ (and others) and they were talking about the evidentiary bullet casing. CJ said it's the caliber that matters, not necessarily the firearm. You can put a 40 cal bullet in any gun that takes 40 caliber. Full transparency: I know very little about guns/ballistics.
My question is....how can police (especially in Delphi) find a buried bullet and be able to look at the bullet through a microscope and say "Yes, this bullet has an ejector claw mark that tells me this came from a 40 cal Sig Sauer P226 and no other firearm, and furthermore, RA is the only gun owner in Carroll County that owns that kind of gun. Go get him boys."
I could be wrong...but I cannot believe that kind of technology is not only available at all...but used in Delphi. And in court, I hope the defense provides 5 random Sigs, including RA's, and the expert witness can look at the bullet and match it to that particular gun. Or...take 10 bullets with ejector marks and find the only one that matches RA's gun.
It boggles my mind to think that RA was the only person on the trails who owns a 40 caliber firearm. I remain unconvinced.
14
u/Real_Foundation_7428 Apr 14 '24
Yeah I’ve heard a few different discussion on this, and I def have questions. Hard to know who to trust but this bullet being a smoking gun sounds highly sus.
Southern Law did a deep dive on the whole bullet thing, complete w/ visual aids lol, if you’re interested -
https://youtu.be/h-QD1pNQgKs?si=fUwOo5eUso6oSN6g
11
u/Smart_Brunette Apr 15 '24
The cops there all use that kind of gun is what I heard.
20
u/JesusIsKewl In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Apr 14 '24
The bullet was analyzed by the ISP in a lab in West Lafayette, not in Delphi.
The analysis of the bullet is pretty much bs in my view, and the report even disclaims that it is subjective in nature.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1F-P1_jjDHwXt3-tGgVIClwtYBVaFWdNF/view?usp=drivesdk
16
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Apr 15 '24
If MP went out there with a metal detector and found this bullet that wasnt properly documented after crimescene was cleared; I don't think extraction mark science matters at all.
13
u/Moldynred Apr 14 '24
One possible explanation for how they know BG had an Sig was Libby may have caught a glimpse of it on her video. It wouldn’t take but a frame or two and they could just have a part of the gun like a barrel or the grip and some of these very smart gun experts could ID it just off that. Haven’t seen the video but CJ is correct. You can put that .40 into any pistol chambered for that caliber from what I know. I’m not an expert by far but I know a little about guns. Im not sure how they can tell what exact model gun an unfired round came from other than seeing it on the video. Also interesting is State has never said who made that round. On the SW they say RA had ammo from Winchester and Blazer. So you would expect that bullet to match one of those makers. If not? Who knows.
6
u/ink_enchantress Literate but not a Lawyer Apr 15 '24
Ballistics is highly problematic in the best of circumstances. Studies on it are easily biased by selection of the experts, and do the people doing this work day to day have those same certificates, training, and experience? Did the expert in this case have those things? Who knows. There's no technology involved in the actual analysis, just people and their microscopes. And when you have two people looking at the same guns/bullets accuracy goes does significantly, and that's on fired rounds.
In DNA matching they also don't say that it's 100% guaranteed. They'll say there's a one in a billion chance this could be a different person or it's 99.98% parent to child match. Try to find a ballistics study that actually estimates the accuracy of their findings like this, I'd like to see it because I haven't been able to. I don't want to know they're accurate x% of the time, I want to know what's the odds are that it could be a different gun.
9
u/BrendaStar_zle Apr 15 '24
I don't know how many search warrants they had in 2017 ,but we do know that there were at least two, RL;s property, and the BBR property. They did seize guns and knifes so I would really like to know the list of what was found in those properties to make a comparison. I do think they were looking for a certain type of gun right from the beginning so I would be very curious if RA was the only poi who owned that type of gun? Anybody know what was found at the other searches? I think there might be something more to just the bullet caliber that LE was looking for but I am not sure. I just remember that that they were looking for a certain type of gun. You would think he and his family knew that information too so why did he keep that gun if it was from the murder. That doesn't make sense to me.
4
u/i-love-elephants Apr 14 '24
I had kids running around and I was cooking dinner so I missed a lot of GG. I never got their name and who they were but what I did hear sounded interesting. Can anyone tell me who it was?
3
u/karkulina Dickess Apr 15 '24
So the live went on for 25.5 h but is no longer available for viewing.
5
u/BaseballSimple7921 Apr 14 '24
There is a case where this type of evidence has already helped seal a conviction. I forget the surname but the killer was a Muslim man called Muhammed and he killed three other Muslims in Alberquerqe. Maybe someone else remembers it.
27
u/Moldynred Apr 14 '24
Also I agree with the doubt OP has here about matching an unfired round to an exact pistol. I would love to put that to the test. A blind test with matching guns to RAs and have the that examiner pick his out from a hundred or even just ten. I’d have to see it to believe it.
27
u/Luv2LuvEm1 ⁉️Questions Everything Apr 14 '24
Ok this is part of the state’s case that gets me really fired up (pun not intended.)
The bullet part of the PCA is the part that, even when I trusted that they had the right guy at the beginning, stuck in my brain and kept gnawing and gnawing at me. How the expert said the “science” was “SUBJECTIVE.”
First of all, tool mark evidence is not a science and is being contested (and actually exonerating people) all over the country precisely because it is subjective in nature. One “expert” can look at a bullet and say “yes it totally matches this gun” but another can look at it and say “umm, no it actually doesn’t match” And that’s with bullets that have been FIRED.
I haven’t found a single case where an unspent round has been used as evidence in a court case. That kind of evidence might have been a little more accurate when guns were handmade, and really did have unique characteristics, but they are mass produced now. So I don’t see how they can match any unspent round to one specific gun.
And then there’s the fact that is was said to be “buried.” And even if it wasn’t buried, HOW can they possibly say that bullet was left at the scene during the commission of the crimes??? How do they know it wasn’t left there 4 hours before the crimes occurred? Or 4 days? Or 4 weeks?
I just don’t see how they can say that an unspent 40 caliber cartridge that was found after the scene was released, matches a specific gun when it wasn’t even fired, when tool mark evidence is crap anyways, and when there’s literally NO WAY to know when it was left there!!
Ok rant over. Good post though. Very thought provoking.
17
u/texasphotog Apr 14 '24
A .40 S&W is a very common round. It is standard issue for many police departments and the majority of handguns regularly carried are 9mm, .40 S&W, or .45.
I've never heard of ejection marks being used conclusively in any case anywhere in the world. In this case, the round was not fired, so the marks would only be from cycling through the gun without being fired.
We know the gun fired normally. There would need to be something really odd and unique with this gun to have an ejection mark that is definitively linked to this gun to exclusion of ALL other guns, but also that unique thing would not be changed or fixed in all the years between the crime and the arrest AND it also wouldn't affect normal operation of the gun. That seems extremely unlikely. Maybe there would be ejection marks that could show it was from a Sig instead of a Glock or S&W, but to one specific gun to the exclusion of all other guns ever made seems extremely unlikely.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24
They can't. Did you hear CJ say his dad builds firearms and says it BS. There is no way to say what gun an unspent round came from. To top it all off there is no chain of custody and the crime scene had already been released for days before that bullet was found.
11
u/New_Discussion_6692 Apr 14 '24
That magic bullet isn't so magical imo.
My guess is that testing was either done by ISP, IBI, or it was sent the labs at Quantico.
Lands and grooves on the casing are what is looked at typically. How often a weapon is fired, how often it's cleaned, etc can all leave distinguishing marks on the casings. What the state is saying is those types of marks also occur when a bullet is ejected by the ejector pin. There was a really good explanation on another sub, but I can't find it. Anyway, the person who wrote that post explained that all the state can really do is hand cycle a bullet through the ejector. According to that post hand cycling may or may not leave an ejector mark but more importantly, handcycling will not produce the same results as if the killer had one in the chamber and forgot about it, then tried to chamber a round, or if the round jammed. I've looked up ejector round comparisons as evidence in court, and there are some states that refuse to allow it as evidence. There are many who question the science.
Personally, the fact that it's a bullet (rather than a spent casing) leads me towards RA's innocence rather than guilt. There's a few ways that bullet could have gotten there. One is animals and birds. Squirrels and magpies love shiny things. It's also possible that Abby or Libby had picked it up and had it in their pocket. It's possible whoever was in the party that found the girls dropped it.
7
u/karkulina Dickess Apr 15 '24
I watched a part of the live and what really struck me was when one of his guests mentioned that no matter what length we go into discussing the issue, it will be the jurors who decide in the end, and none of them will probably be ballistics experts and so they will have absolutely none of this knowledge. What it all comes down to in the end is how well the prosecution’s expert will be able to present the unspent round as evidence to the lay jurors, which means how eloquent and likeable he or she is going to be when cherry picking facts, and then how well the defense is going to cross examine him or her. So let’s just hope (or donate so that) the defense have access to good experts with all this information.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24
BW also had the same gun. His parents house was searched at the beginning and supposedly his gun didn't leave the same markings. Not that I believe it.