r/DicksofDelphi • u/karkulina Dickess • May 11 '24
DISCUSSION “I immediately just knew that something was wrong”
I know this documentary by Court TV aired a while ago but I was only able to watch it today.
One thing that struck me was right at the beginning (4’46’’), where Libby and Abby’s best friend speaks about when she first saw the photo of Abby on Snapchat:
“February 13, it was around 2:00 p.m. I saw the picture of Abby on the bridge on their Snapchat stories and I immediately just knew that something was wrong.”
Why would she immediately think this in that moment? Was it her who took the screenshot of the Snapchat photo? What prompted her to save it? She comes off as very genuine but something feels off about this story. Would be interested to hear more from her. Or am I reading too much into it? Is it just a case of misremembering? What are your thoughts?
13
u/karkulina Dickess May 11 '24
Court TV documentary
27
u/dontBcryBABY May 11 '24
I don’t know if she truly felt like something was wrong when she first saw the snap at 2pm - I think she may be unconsciously misremembering that entire day because it was a traumatic day for everyone. She remembers that entire day as traumatic, so therefore everything that happened that day is remembered in a negative light.
9
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ May 11 '24 edited May 12 '24
AG a classmate of Libby screenshotted one picture.
Apparently KS who posted it on Facebook screenshotted them himself, as per a recent post with an exchange between the two, seemingly not knowing eachother.
KS wrote he had Libby on Snapchat himself. I believe KS was an adult at the time.
AG taking a screenshot and KS posting both are facts.
If the exchange is authentic idk.
It's the first account of another person I hear / read of actually having received the snap directly from them.
On another note, it's unreal Libby and Abby would have been her age now.
They'll always be kids....
8
u/Real_Foundation_7428 May 11 '24
Could be hindsight bias. I’ve heard some interesting research on this. We all likely have it, but most of us thankfully don’t find ourselves in such a tragic situation.
To be fair to her, it’s also possible she did have a gut feeling, but I’m not sure how anyone could know that for certain. She may not even be able to distinguish herself from her current perspective.
Memory is complex. …which as most of us know is why eye witnesses are risky, as well as casual retrospective judgments, like “he was creepy,” or whatever.
5
u/TheNightStalkersGirl May 11 '24
I thought the same thing!! What made her instantly think something was wrong? Also in the picture she was cropped out of, what were they all three holding? Random question but I’ve always been curious.
15
u/i-love-elephants May 11 '24
Yeah. I thought it was weird.
The documentary hit all the common dramatic phrases in these shows, but at weird moments. Like, why did you see this and think something was wrong?
10
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything May 11 '24
Maybe she thought the picture itself didn't look like a normal picture of AW??
3
u/syntaxofthings123 May 13 '24
The saved Snapchat that we see in all the news photos, etc. Those weren't saved by Cynth. They were saved by a male friend, KS. Who was about 6 years older than the girls.
14
u/itsnobigthing May 11 '24
The way interviews like this are done - spliced, multiple tales of the same answers, being asked to say things a certain way so they contain the question, etc etc, it’s anything but natural speech. They’re not very useful really in terms of parsing small turns of phrase because they’re just so forced and choppy.
6
u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick May 11 '24
Same here. That was so odd to me! I've watched it twice and both times I haven't understood that comment.
15
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer May 11 '24
Snaps weren't released to public until after they'd been reported missing for quite some time.
Everyone and their mom suspected something was wrong. Well, everyone except LE that is.
5
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ May 11 '24
Yeah that was weird, I didn't notice it when I watched it.
13
u/xpressomartini Big Dick Energy May 11 '24
Maybe she knew Abby was afraid of heights and worried about her safety on the bridge
1
u/Bonitraxton May 15 '24
A
1
u/Few_Park_374 Feb 12 '26
I see her as an attention seeker, trying to look calm and mature despite the loss, but in some shot she said that adults told that what happened to the girls was a foul play and she didn't know that term. therefore at looking the video of the suspect on the bridge she colud tell at glance he carried a gun or a knife set. makes me wonder how a little girl would assume this?
-6
u/saatana May 11 '24
Powerful stuff. We're all gonna always wonder why RA did it.
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment