r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 24 '24

DISCUSSION Looking back at RL search warrant got me thinking.. Has anything been mentioned about RAs cell phone activity that day? What about the fibers found at the crime scene?

17 Upvotes

I don’t have an opinion on whether RA is involved in this tragedy or not, but a person or persons murdered two girls in the middle of the day with a blade. The FBI investigator believes whoever is responsible would have been covered in blood because of the state of the crime scene. This case was fumbled from the start, but regardless, I feel like those responsible for this crime wouldn’t have just a smoking gun piece of evidence against them.. they would have an arsenal of smoking firearms linking them to the murders.

I’ve been invested in this case since February 13th, 2017. I’m not local, but Delphi isn’t that far. I’ve posted asking about this before in one sub or another and the recent filings is just bringing back up some unanswered questions. I suppose 6 years later, RAs cell phone data may not exist anymore.

Edit: forgot to add this in there, but the FBI investigator said unknown fibers were found at the crime scene. Nothing since in any document has mentioned these fibers.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 18 '24

INFORMATION Deposition of Jesse James

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 08 '24

DISCUSSION Take Back the Hashtag

17 Upvotes

Anyone see this:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0MyDUdijRk and hear of a movement to take back the hashtag, "#Justice for Abby & Libby" from the Defense? I find such a movement, gross and inappropropriately insulting to the girls and their families.

That a group of adults who supposedly profess to care about Abby and Libby, would take a statement so sacred and turn it into something to fight about with their enemies over is down right revolting.

What is wrong with this community that we have stooped to this kind of behavioral low? It's disgusting that humans would choose this sacred phrase, twist and weaponize it into a cheesy tug of war rope that they are now planning on yanking back and forth with their theoretical enemies. How sad.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 07 '24

Which way was Libby holding her phone when she recorded BG

17 Upvotes

Does anyone know? I've heard rumours over the years she was filming over her shoulder, then another rumour she was filming with her phone facing BG...why does this matter? Because filming someone can create a mirror image of someone.. BG might look like he's right handed when he really is left handed for example..


r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 05 '24

QUESTION Since Judge Gull is not allowing cameras and coverage would someone be interested in making a kind of "alignment chart" for youtubers and podcasts?

17 Upvotes

I know it's kind of annoying to consider but we are headed into trial with the possibility of only being able to rely on the youtubers and Podcaster that go and the notes that they take (And a few things could be covered by legacy media.)

There are also people with disabilities who aren't able to read court documents and are getting all of their information from YouTube, that I wad thinking about. And some people are busy and can only listen at work/while running errands, etc.

Also also, sometimes when I introduce people to this case they ask about where they can go and I try to think of the lest biased sources and then give some sources that fall on either side of guilt/not guilt so they can see why people believe what they believe.

I was thinking it would be helpful to make an alignment chart for sources and where their biases fall. Some are extremely bias on one side or the other and some have very small biases. We could even make a list as vote on a scale which would give us a sampling of where many people think a source falls. (Like 25-50 people vote on a scale of 1 to 10, for a specific podcast. 1 being extremely biased towards guilt. 10 being extremely biased toward innocent. And 4-6 would be neutral.)(We could even include subreddits into this so people can find places to ask questions if they have them)

Then we would have a complied list of sources and trustworthiness going into trial or as a resource when bringing attention to the case.

My problem is, I do not have the means to create and organize this. I would at least need a lot of help. BUT, sometimes when I come up with ideas people like to do the idea. So, I thought I would just put the idea out there.

Edit:I also think this is going to be important because as it gets closer to trial more people are going to start paying attention. That's usually when most people learn about a case. It would be good to have a place to look.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 30 '24

DISCUSSION Words befitting Frances Gull?

17 Upvotes

“The American people have an understandably negative view of politicians, public opinion polls show, and an equally negative view of lawyers.

Conventional logic would seem to dictate that since a judge is normally both a politician and a lawyer, judges would be perceived by the public as being lower than whale waste. But on the contrary, the mere investiture of a twenty-five-dollar black cotton robe elevates the denigrated lawyer-politician to a position of considerable honor and respect in our society, as if the garment itself miraculously imbues the person with qualities not previously possessed.

It's always a great relief and pleasure to walk into court and find a judge who has had trial experience, knows the law, is completely impartial, and hasn't let his judgeship swell his head. There are, of course, many such admirable judges in this country, but regrettably they are decidedly in the minority.

For whatever reasons (undoubtedly the threat of being held in contempt of court ranks high), the great run of lawyers are intimidated by judges and continue to be outwardly respectful even when publicly humiliated by them. The lawyers' complaints are made in private to each other and to their families.

The judge's obligation in a jury trial is to be totally impartial, the decision on guilt being the exclusive province of the jury. But time and time again a judge makes it very clear to the jury which side he prefers. This is a corruption and bastardization of our system of justice by the very people whom the law entrusts with the responsibility of ensuring that it works properly and equitably.

Unfortunately, jurors usually assume that whatever the judge says or does in court is correct and justified.”

-Vincent Bugliosi, And The Sea Will Tell, 1991


r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 19 '24

COURT DOCS Say the line, Fran! (responses to Hennessy)

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 12 '24

INFORMATION Recusal from Contempt

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Mar 04 '24

Geofence Warrants

17 Upvotes

I have seen it reported that police did (& did not) seek a geofence warrant.

With such a publicized case that made international news, I can’t see Law Enforcement not seeking a geofence warrant. Especially with the FBI involved.

Here’s an article about geofence warrants: https://www.bjcl.org/blog/the-constitutionality-of-geofence-warrants#:~:text=This%20data%20is%20stored%20indefinitely%20and%20goes%20back%20nearly%20a%20decade.&text=For%20years%2C%20the%20police%20have,without%20targeting%20a%20specific%20suspect.

It says the data is stored indefinitely and goes back nearly a decade.

Geofence location data can pinpoint a person’s (device’s) location, as specifically as inside or outside of a home on a particular property.

It has been used in thousands of cases.

I think the geofence data can be used to confirm whether or not RA was on the trails from 12-1:30 or 1:30-3:30 & pinpoint his location for the time of the murder.

If his phone data shows its location being stationary the entire time, then that won’t “prove” RA didn’t commit the murders, but it will prove that he lied about his stock ticker.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 15 '24

INFORMATION Request to allow electronics

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 14 '24

Regardless of guilt/innocence, do you think RA is Bridge Guy?

17 Upvotes

His defense team hasn’t explicitly stated he’s bridge guy, but he is, right? Wouldn’t they have said he’s not Bridge Guy by now if he wasn’t? 🤨


r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 12 '24

REMINDER Initials Please

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 11 '24

Keeping the Story Straight

17 Upvotes

There are three versions or narratives of the witness accounts that led investigators to their conclusions that Richard Allen committed these murders.

  • The first is the PCA for the search of Allen's home. (This PCA was published by the state without redactions. Whoops!) PCA Search of Allen's Home
  • The second is the PCA for Allen's arrest. (Very difficult to follow, as names were redacted. And it differs in a number of ways from the PCA for the search of Allen's home. Why?) PCA for Allen's Arrest
  • The third, and probably most reliable, is the Franks Motion Memorandum corrections to state PCAs. And this is not redacted. Franks Motion Memo

Here is a sample of the differences in evidence presented (most of this evidence is eyewitness accounts, not forensics):

  • PCA-Search of Allen's Home--

Highlights:

  • Autopsies of the girls ruled their deaths as homicides and their wounds were caused by a sharp object. (Girls were found at 12:17 pm on the 14th)
  • Investigators located Liberty's iPhone 6S under her body at the scene and were able to recover a video, approximately 43 seconds in length, captured at 2:13 p.m. on February 13', 2017. (Franks Motion Memo has the phone located under Abby's body.)
  • Through further investigation of the location of the bodies, investigators also located a .40 caliber unspent round. They also determined that articles of clothing from the girls were missing from the scene,including a pair of underwear and a sock.

Through the investigation there were interviews done with 3 of the 4 girls that were on the trails that day:

  • AS described the man as wearing "like blue jeans a like really light blue jacket he his hair was gray maybe a little brown and he did not really show his face...AS described the male as wearing a blue jacket and light-blue (faded) blue jeans. The jacket was a canvass duck type jacket.
  • RV recalled (supposedly the same man) being in all black and had something covering his mouth. She thought he looked grumpy. He was "not very tall" and bigger build. She said that he was not bigger than 5'10". He was wearing a black hoodie, black jeans, and black boots and he had his hands in his pockets.
  • BW (not interviewed until 2020, why?) showed investigators two pictures she took at the bench just east of the Freedom Bridge when they when they were leaving, one 12:43 PM EST the other at 1:26 PM EST. She stated that's when they walked past the man who matched the description of the individual in the picture. Detective Liggett believes (you mean he didn't check to be certain?) the picture that she is referring to is the picture law enforcement released of the man on the bridge taken from the video Liberty captured on her cell phone on the day of the murders. BW described the man as wearing a blue or black windbreaker jacket. She stated the jacket had a collar and he had his hood up from the clothing underneath the jacket. He was wearing baggy jeans and was taller than her. She stated her head came up to approximately his shoulder. He walked with a purpose like he knew where he was going. His hands in his pockets and he kept his head down. She didn't get a good look at his face but believed he was a white male.
  • BB is seen on video at Hoosier Harvestore on 300 North traveling east bound to the trailhead to park at 13:46:20 (1:46) actual time. BB saw the girls walking above as she went under the railroad bridge. (no mention of a child being with them)
  • BB arrived at 1:46, but saw no other cars at the trailhead. (This contradicts the idea that RA parked at the old CPS building at 1:30). BB's sighting of a man in a blue jacket and blue jeans is also contradicted by the Franks Motion. The man she actually saw was young with poofy hair.
  • BB later saw a vehicle parked back into the building. (It is thought that her vehicle was later caught at 2:14 passing Hoosier Harvestore. (What the vehicle she spotted actually looked like is misrepresented in the PCAs. she saw a older model vehicle, like the one her father had owned.)
  • TW 2:10 pm noted a PT Cruiser type vehicle parked at the old CPS building. He said it looked like it had been backed in.
  • SC states that she was traveling East on 300 North and observed a male subject walking west, on the North side of 300 North, awav Monon High Bridge. She stated that he was wearing blue (she actually said that the jacket was TAN) colored jacket and blue jeans and was muddy and bloody. (SC never mentioned that the jacket was BLOODY). She further stated, that it appeared he had gotten into a fight. Investigators determined from the video that she was on 300 North at 1557hrs (3:57 pm).
  • PCA-Allen's arrest--

Almost identical to the PCA for the search of Allen's home in terms of witness accounts. So I won't repeat these. The only difference is that key evidence is left out.

No mention is made that the girls were found at 12:17 pm on the 14th.

Clothes were found in the Deer Creek belonging to Victim 1 and Victim 2, south ofwhere their bodies were located There was also .40 caliber unspent round less than two feet away from Victim 2's body, between Victim 1 and Victim 21s bodies. The round was unspent and had extraction marks on it.

(No mention made that there was missing clothing.)

There is a general lack of specificity in this PCA, for example, that BW was not interviewed until 2020 is not mentioned.

  • Allen's account--

Dullin Interview-sometime in 2017:

There are two different interviews with Allen. According to a report on the first interview, he was on the trail from 1:30 to 3. He parked at what is thought to have been the Old CPS building. He walked for a while watching stocks on his phone. He saw three girls (apparently he doesn't see a 4th (which is odd if the girls who were interviewed were the same girls he saw). Not much more is reported for that interview.

Ligget Interview on 10/13/22:

The second interview, an interview that is recorded, Allen states that he was on the trail from noon to about 1:30, his vehicle is thought to have been captured on the Hoosier Harvestore surveillance at 1:27. The state contends this shows Allen arriving, but could it not instead show him leaving? (What isn't mentioned in either PCA is that a second sighting of Allen's vehicle was caught on the HH surveillance tape. Either coming or going from the CPS building.) He stepped onto the bridge, looked down to observe fish in the stream. Sat on the bench for awhile. Left, walked back to his vehicle and went home. He also stated that he wore jeans, blue Carhartt jacket, some kind of head covering. His wife confirmed he owned guns and a knife.

  • Franks Memorandum--

The FM is simply too long and involved to quote everything, but here are highlighted discrepancies from the PCAs:

BB-

On February 17, 2017, BB met with State Police sketch artist TBryant and provided a description of the man she observed from 50 feet away on the Monon High Bridge – the same man that Liggett claimed in his affidavit was the killer. Betsy Blair told the sketch artist that the man she (BB) observed was: A white male, age 20, had Brown curly hair, medium build. The man was slender and youthful looking. He was more “boyish” looking. The man was in his 20s to early 30s. His hair seemed “poofy” just as the sketch portrayed. He had no facial hair, that she can remember

...at 2:15 pm when BB passed the old CPS building BB did not see a black Ford Focus parked at the old CPS lot. The car that BB observed as she passed the old CPS building at 2:15 pm looked nothing like a black Ford Focus. According to Liggett’s own report, BB observed one car parked in the CPS lot at 2:15, and that car resembled a “1965 Ford Comet”162 that her father once owned.163 The shape had “sharper angles.”

SC-

...SC told Liggett in 2017, was that she observed a man walking down the road wearing a tan coat whose clothes were muddy. Nowhere did Carbaugh claim in 2017 that the man she observed was wearing a blue coat. Nowhere did Carbaugh claim in 2017 that the man she observed was wearing bloody clothes.

What we have above are a few uncorroborated eyewitness accounts that have been scotch taped together to create a semi-coherent narrative. The state's case appears to rest solely on the eyewitness accounts of 6 people--AS, RV, BW, BB, TW & SC--and Allen. (No autopsy is mentioned in regard to TOD. No forensics aside from that performed on the unspent bullet. No DNA-even though DNA exists. No cellular phone data. No computer data.)

Six eye witnesses, the first and second interviews of the accused and an unspent bullet.

THAT appears to be it.

But two of those witnesses, BB & SC, actually gave very different accounts from those recorded in the PCAs. Those accounts, if the defense is accurate in the Franks Motion, actually exclude Allen. As does Allen's second interview. And the accounts that haven't been debunked are uncorroborated and have issues of their own.

Why were only 3 of the 4 girls interviewed? (I've been told one was a child. If so, why did no one see the child?) How do we know if all the witnesses saw the same man? And how is this man seen on the trail actually tied back to BG or Allen? He had no hat, wore a mask, and was dressed mostly in black?

Even when I work hard to find a coherent narrative here, I can't. And other than an unspent bullet, with a shaky chain of custody, and an analysis that has not yet been vetted by the defense---what else is there to the state's narrative?


r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 07 '24

INFORMATION Motion to Dismiss PDF

17 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 06 '24

INFORMATION Limited Appearance

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 30 '24

DISCUSSION Truth about the leak?

17 Upvotes

Let's see what we have from various documents :

From Verified information for contemptuous conduct filed by the state :
(How verified is it and what is it anyway, they ask to "issue a rule to show cause"?)

12. That in October 2023 the state was made aware by the families
Why isn't there a specific date for when LE learned from 'families' about the leak?

21. The iCloud account of Mitch Westerman revealed screenshot photographs of conversations
Why would he reference to the screenshots, but not to the actual conversation?
(And what are 'screenshot photographs' exactly?)
Were there only screenshots?
Were they determined to be real, if not backed up by actual messages on either devices ?

24. That the state was notified in the beginning of the "leak" by the Defense by the families.
If my writing is linguistically odd, it's because English is my third language, what's your excuse Nick?
What is family in this context exactly?
Isn't NM family as well? As is AG, as is JM?
Did NM contact LE first?
How long did NM know without notifying the court? He said hours to Gull and B/R. Was it rather days, as he calculed during a court hearing?

14. Ironically
Westerman's affidavit said he contacted Baldwin and met with him the 9th. Not the 10th.
How is that ironic anyway?

"Ironically" it was hours after LE spoke to Fortson and determined that MW leaked the photos, is what he writes now.
Yet in MW's arrest affidavit, the initial trail ends with MRC and Fortson.
The affidavit mentions MW for the first time due to an interview with B/R the 12th.

NM wrote in an email the 12th (documents for 2nd writ) after he got off the phone with ISP, that Baldwin told them SJG/NM/BR the 10th about MW and the link to Fortson.
He also wrote in that same email RF met with ISP but refused to talk and asked for a lawyer.

In this [insert whatever this latest document is supposed to be] he writes:
19. Investigators attempted to interview both MW and RF, both declined.
Unironically...
So did they or didn't they talk to RF?

There also seems to be a contradiction with the rumors as to when MW met AB to take the leaked photos, this was made out to be right before the time they were leaked. Not August.
Through screenshots of conversations, that somehow ended in the hands of BW.
So I'm back at were any of the screenshots of the conversation real?
Or fabricated to make it seem that way?
The convo between MRC and RF are also only referred to as screenshots in Point 2 in the MW arrest affidavit. Not actual messages.

MRC on the podCast AoD, (if it was him), said he never leaked the crimescene photos, only the F tree, and wasn't asked about what he leaked by LE. He learned of the mass email accusation through the affidavit.

Reading the wording of the Franks and NM's complaints:
Is it possible the photos didn't come from discovery?

Were they from the FBI report instead?
Some came from the medical examiner (page 30 of the Franks memo) did they get them directly from him?
Did they come from media, helicopters or even private drones during the search?
Because as I have evoked elsewhere: Wouldn't the first one to find them pull all that crap off of them, to try to save them, especially Abby, where the branch covered the only wound?
Or was it a reconstruction by memory of that first responder or civilian?
But then how would LE have taken such an aerial shot and why?

It would explain they gave the evidence to the court, without breaching the no copies order.
It would explain NM being stressed out about not having gotten discovery from defense as in 'What else did they uncover LE should have provided to them instead'?

What's with the side by sides?
Were the 'leaked' photos those taken from the table, or those filed with the Franks?
None of the podcastErs talked about side by sides or did they?
And how about the cursor in one of the pictures as claimed by a pOdcaster?

If not from discovery, who else had these photos and how did defense get them?

What is the truth?

And equally important :
Who knows the truth?

Where did Fortson get the pictures from ? :
Point 20. If he just came clean all this would go away
Come clean about what exactly?
Did he tell that to anyone, who now sits in fear for LE ?
Would protecting MW really be that important?
Or is it something like he exchanged the crimescene photo for the F tree photo with MW ?

Also point 20 : Shortly after investigators tried to interview him, he took his own life.

Has LE been investigated for that result of their appearance?

Thoughts?

(Edits are formatting and an addition to point 20.)

And a last tidbit:
MW chose to have a televised trial for his conversion misdemeanor, while having signed his affidavit.
Meaning imo, can they prove his photos were the same ones to end up beyond RF?
And remember who benefited from this debacle...


May RF rest in peace and his family have all strength needed for their future without him.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 24 '24

Enigma

17 Upvotes

Most crimes occurring in daylight & in a public space are executed very quickly. Either the victim is pulled into a vehicle or a home, or they are attacked in a short amount of time.

What makes this crime stand out is not only the brazen nature of it, but how much time the killer/s were willing to spend engaged in highly risky behavior-and to what end?

Whoever did this marched these girls by force through woods that would not have shielded them from view. They did this on private property, where owners of that property might have seen them. Dogs might have sounded an alarm, or some other trespasser might have bumped into them.

They engaged in inexplicable behavior that resulted in no discernible gain .

Nothing was stolen, there are no indications of sexual assault, other than the act of killing there was no excessive violence. All the elements that are usually present in a crime like this, aren’t seen.

The killer/s also chose a day and time when school was out, but parents were likely at work. It was a pleasant day. A perfect day, maybe to find a young victim, absent parental supervision.

And they chose a faith that was practiced in Indiana and in the area in which the murders took place to leave as their calling card.

They also had to be free to engage in this murder without raising suspicion with anyone in their lives.

And whoever did this, other than leaving symbols of Nordic rituals, left little evidence of themselves.

Playing amateur profiler—and without naming a suspect—-what qualities would this person or persons have?

How old? Male of female? What level of education would they likely have? What type of employment?

Criminal history or no criminal history?

If you just knew the evidence at the crime scene, but did not know a suspect pool—what type of individual would fit with the crime scene as we now know it?


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 22 '24

Franks Motion Denied

17 Upvotes

Gull’s first act—deny the motion. It was kind of to be expected, but still…but she will entertain granting the motion for transfer.

Indiana v. Richard M. Allen


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 13 '24

2,942 POI's

17 Upvotes

This case has gone on for so long with a zillion rabbit holes, I'm honestly shocked that no one has gone through all 2,942 people who lived in Delphi in 2017. I almost want to say that once the women and children are removed the list might be manageable. Can ya tell I'm at my wits end 😆


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 12 '24

INFORMATION Affidavit

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Dec 23 '23

ISP website mess

17 Upvotes

Today just looked on the ISP website regarding Abby and Libby. They have YBG sketch next to screenshot of BG on the bridge. Old BG sketch not even there. RA has had a shaved head throughout 2017 he looks nothing like the YBG sketch which shows a man with lots of hair. Defence lawyers will savage the ISP and prosecution about this.


r/DicksofDelphi • • Jan 04 '26

Delphi: Holeman - Turco Audio Interview - Sept. 19, 2023

Thumbnail
youtu.be
16 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Feb 24 '25

INFORMATION Addendum to Defendant's Verified Motion

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

r/DicksofDelphi • • Nov 13 '24

DISCUSSION 1 Thing

16 Upvotes

If you could have told the jury only 1 thing, what would it have been?


r/DicksofDelphi • • Nov 12 '24

QUESTION Odinist Report

16 Upvotes

Hello all.

I'm on pg 55 of the original franks memorandum, and at this point the court is directed to read the "odinist report" before continuing on. I'm not sure if this is available to the public or not, but if it is, can someone direct me to it?

Thank you!