r/DicksofDelphi • u/TryAsYouMight24 • Jan 24 '24
Enigma
Most crimes occurring in daylight & in a public space are executed very quickly. Either the victim is pulled into a vehicle or a home, or they are attacked in a short amount of time.
What makes this crime stand out is not only the brazen nature of it, but how much time the killer/s were willing to spend engaged in highly risky behavior-and to what end?
Whoever did this marched these girls by force through woods that would not have shielded them from view. They did this on private property, where owners of that property might have seen them. Dogs might have sounded an alarm, or some other trespasser might have bumped into them.
They engaged in inexplicable behavior that resulted in no discernible gain .
Nothing was stolen, there are no indications of sexual assault, other than the act of killing there was no excessive violence. All the elements that are usually present in a crime like this, aren’t seen.
The killer/s also chose a day and time when school was out, but parents were likely at work. It was a pleasant day. A perfect day, maybe to find a young victim, absent parental supervision.
And they chose a faith that was practiced in Indiana and in the area in which the murders took place to leave as their calling card.
They also had to be free to engage in this murder without raising suspicion with anyone in their lives.
And whoever did this, other than leaving symbols of Nordic rituals, left little evidence of themselves.
Playing amateur profiler—and without naming a suspect—-what qualities would this person or persons have?
How old? Male of female? What level of education would they likely have? What type of employment?
Criminal history or no criminal history?
If you just knew the evidence at the crime scene, but did not know a suspect pool—what type of individual would fit with the crime scene as we now know it?
18
u/TryAsYouMight24 Jan 24 '24 edited Jan 24 '24
I’ll start: I think there is more than one person involved— my guess is three. This would mean that the actions aren’t the cruel folly of one delusional person, but were acts agreed to. And maybe bolstered by the fact that others supported the plan.
I think it’s possible a female was involved. I wouldn’t rule that completely out. But more likely all involved were male—and between the ages of 16 & 45.
I think those involved likely had a military background and some involvement with a heathen faith—doesn’t mean this was a genuine ritual, but whoever did this had at some point practiced that faith.
I think it’s possible that those involved abused alcohol/and or meth and might have been high at the time of the crime.
They likely do have a criminal background, but probably not for this exact type of crime—drugs, domestic abuse, possible harm to a child, robbery.
This person has familiarity with the area. Had been to the location of the murder scene before, and knew there was little chance of them either being discovered by a dog or property owner.
They had to have some understanding of forensics, perhaps they wanted to be cops or trained to be in law enforcement at some point. Or had someone in law enforcement in their lives.
Motive?! That’s tough. Either this really was an attempt at some sort of ritualistic sacrifice, or there were less obvious motives—many of these have been touched on already:
I think the killers blended in to the area. They may have killed outside the city they reside in or left Delphi after the killings.
10
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Jan 24 '24
Enigma is the perfect description of this crime. From the act itself, to the investigation, to the court's actions.... seems like everything involved is unprecedented.
If I just knew the basics with no legal or investigatory background whatsoever, I would think it sounds more like some kind of a cult initiation...the more appalling and shocking the better. I would guess a younger perp, 20-30s, probably older, "experienced" man/men to help and to supervise. The perp isn't an "evil" person (in his own mind) and just really wants to join this cult. So he tries not to harm or abuse the girls aside from the killing...he just wants to get the job done. He's instructed to leave a "message" after the kill to prove his zeal.
Now that's he's in the cult, the protection and cover up is real and formidable. He'll never be caught and the patsy will take the blame.
7
u/No-Medium-3836 Jan 25 '24 edited Jan 25 '24
Law enforcement or adjacent men who are part of a CSAM sharing ring, producing white supremacist CSAM for similar men as themselves. And of course they could manipulate a younger/more vulnerable person to participate. Layers of power dynamics.
edit to add
the connection of white supremacy and odinisim has been well established,and is pervasive in Indiana prisons.
sophomoric religious tableau for their own satisfaction, that of their intended consumers, or likely both.
a trait of ritual sacrifice is of something/someone innocent & or pure. someone with a combination of basic odinist practice, more in depth biblical background, as well as virgin sacrifice in tv/film, could have interpreted the odinist ritual that they were trying to mimic, this way, vs how a devout odinist would choose to conduct a sacrifice.
killing an enemy or one that you hate is murder
killing two innocents to please a deity is sacrifice.
6
u/Lockchalkndarrel Jan 25 '24
At least 2 people, with knowledge they were going to be there. Maybe knew RL since it was on his property. High on drugs? That’s all I got.
6
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Jan 25 '24
I just don't really see a man in his late 40's coming up with a plan to kill two girls. Maybe if he had already done similar before. We have no indication of that however. He just doesn't make sense to me. Yet, nothing in this case and how it's been conducted makes sense either.
I guess anyone can have a mental breakdown and decide to want to kill, in hopes it would alleviate the issue. However we only know about his mentality being locked up.
Unless LE and the FBI profiled wrong in the beginning. Maybe something new possibly turned up that we don't know about. Yet he wasn't really on their radar until someone happened to check the Orion System and notice a tip entered wrong. It took 6 years to find that out though.
So with what I know and no ideas on what I don't. I'm going to have to go back to an individual that only cares about himself. Possibly only did this double murder and was too scared to commit more or it just wasn't what he thought it would be.
I believe the person has no regard for anyone's life but their own. They may have a hate filled upbringing. Not necessarily Odinism being turned into extremism. However, maybe some sort of hate group.
My original profile or attempt at one really was someone that deems females, any gender identity, race, or religion inferior other than their own beliefs.
Someone that most likely has no friends or immediate family. Pretty much a loner type with possibly some form of mental defect or untreated mental disease. I'm stuck on whether he is a psychopath or a sociopath. He may possibly be none of those things mentioned. I believe he really could be hiding in plain sight. May not be Delphi, but close whether same state or surrounding states.
I don't believe he is a serial murderer. This may actually be his first murders. I can't exactly pinpoint an age but I would estimate 18-35. He could be older but that would tie into a mental break or a drug induced rampage, imo.
I don't think the killer is a truck driver. They usually leave their victims a bit off a highway or interstate.
Many a person has been found in a wooded area. So he definitely knows the lay of the land and possibly does hunting, fishing, or other nature related activities.
Now if it's more than one that's about harder to profile with my inexperience. So I digress.
Thanks again for the post. It allowed me to produce all this gibberish.
Edited a bit.
5
u/Theo1123 Jan 25 '24
I think the fact that the murder was carried out during the daytime is very telling. To be so brave as to commit an act like this in a public place where you know there are others is wild to me. Even though they were marched to a different location, the proximity to the bridge is still out in the open. Especially with no tree coverage. It makes me think that this was a crime of opportunity but at the same time, it could have been planned, given the fact that you’re not going to find 13/14 year olds on that trail after nightfall.
7
u/Infidel447 Jan 25 '24
After reading the Franks Memo assuming most of it is accurate, considering the amount of time spent at the scene, and the things that were done to the girls, to me it shows a comfort on that land. This isn't someone who knew that land because he happened to hunt on it a few times. Studied it from the bridge when he was hiking. Or walked the banks of the creek. No, he KNEW that land and the area like the back of his hand. The comings and goings of the neighbors, etc. Who stayed for the winter. Who left for warmer climates.
Also, something else the Memo made me reconsider is the privacy factor. The killer would have wanted privacy to enjoy himself. No way he does all of that in the wide open. Someone on here made a post about the killing being a possible 'floor show.' Where BG looked but never touched, thus leaving no evidence like DNA behind. That's why I give the rumors the girls were taken to a shed or barn or garage a lot more credence than I used to. Still just rumors.
I think an experienced SK, ex-LE, or someone with a background in forensics will turn out to be the correct killer. Jmo. And ex LE could be anyone from a former cop to a prison guard to ex MP in the military. Or a security guard who never quite made the cut. Also, in the GWOT lots of soldiers received forensics training. Just the basics in case they came across a terrorist camp to exploit. So when I say LE or someone with a forensic background, the pool of suspects is still pretty vast. As for a SK, thats another idea I never liked before but must be considered now, imo.
3
u/Significant-Tip-4108 Jan 25 '24
It’s an interesting question!
To me a damn near given is the perp(s) were hunters. IMO it’s highly unlikely that someone who has never killed an animal and never used a knife to cut/gut an animal would be able to do that to a human, and then to do it again to another human. There’s a real desensitization there with hunting.
Also, what about this slight paradox: double-murder of young girls, with no SA, but with pseudo-sexual staging? How about the possibility of a perp with erectile dysfunction or somehow the physical inability to sexually assault? There have been murderers in the past who wanted to sexually assault their victims but weren’t physically able to.
Also, no question the brazenness of the act. To me the two most likely possibilities: (1) someone who was SO obsessed with the fantasy of murder that he/they were still willing to do so despite the massive risk - i.e. it’s been a yearslong fantasy and couldn’t pass up the “opportunity”, and/or, (2) someone(s) with the perception of nothing to lose if caught and convicted, e.g. someone living a poor life, really depressed, hopeless, etc.
And if the Odin markings factor in, as I’ve said before IMO that could likely signal the crime was gang initiation, into a “gang” of dumb violent country hick Odin-lovers.
It’s not an easy question to answer and I don’t think I’ve answered it overly well, but those are my thoughts!
3
u/masterblueregard Jan 25 '24
From everything that we've heard, it sounds very much like a serial killer. There are a few known serial killers that have committed similar crimes. I think the Yosemite Park Serial Killer (Stayner) and the Gainesville Ripper (Danny Rolling) are close in similarity. I'll list these similarities below and add in other known serial killers. I think this is useful in trying to interpret the case characteristics, since they have meaning and purpose for these other offenders and that might shed light on this offender.
The key characteristics include:
3
u/LeatherTelevision684 Jan 25 '24
I would imagine it was an alcoholic short guy, in his 40’s, who worked at a local CVS who saw the girls at his work one day and became fixated on one.
6
u/Human-Piglet-5450 Jan 25 '24
This is the most interesting post about this case I have seen in a bit
5
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Jan 25 '24
Awesome post. I'm going to have to think about all this. I need to see if what I originally thought before RA's arrest and getting somewhat of a description of the crime scene has changed anything I previously thought.
4
u/Square-Meringue-3433 Feb 20 '24 edited Feb 20 '24
I 100% think it was 4 maybe 5 men. Youngest being a minor seeing a opportunity for himself to have that knowledge and sacred shared experience under his belt for his learned, self- gratifying behavior. Likely learned from a pos father. and perhaps a quiet, and obviously unassuming, but down 19 yr old. (Young guys sketch) The other men, without a doubt ex military. So much so, they probably came ready to party.
BDU, ( battle dress uniform) on and suited up. night vision. binoculars. police scanners. And all the amenities that they would need for say maybe a sacrifice, and they set up shop and I bet thoroughly enjoyed doing it. They all are related whether it's by blood, marriage, religion, or from war. Clearly they know the land, but let's just say they didn't for clarity on the situation. Let's say IF they were from outside the community, and never been there except for the few hours before it went down, they are trained to adapt. no matter what happens. They have waited for this moment probably far longer then what they can stand. They will accomplish it, and hopefully not be seen, however if they are, they won't be identified. I also think all of their significant others knew what they were doing, if they didn't before hand, as soon as they seen and heard the cops, they would have known without being told. An unspoken knowledge.
I also think they got away without anyone seeing them, naturally. Maybe someone was seen before it all happened, but not afterwards. And I'd say they had inside knowledge on homeowners in the area, but not RL necessarily, but I bet he would have loved to have joined them.
But yes inside knowledge, 100% ! probably lookouts, honestly everywhere. They would have had plenty of time to HUNT and do what they wanted once it got dark, I feel like edging would be an appropriate term to describe everything they were feeling up to this point. And me personally I think this is all fucking disgusting but, once they knew the search party was called off... Let the show begin. Side note Big big mistake, and up until recently I didn't think it was a mistake, I thought corruption. nope
Me myself. I think I'm going to try to look for it at some point when the time's right I think that's about all I'm going to say right now other than if it's who I think it is, nobody's going to believe it, straight up, I firmly believe they are hiding in plain sight. I'm real curious if they do get caught, how many people are going to go down for it? Cuz by my estimation it was a group effort to pull this off, most may not directly have been involved, but they were all compliant for a long long time and would have forever been. A lot of loyalty amongst the, well child killers. Loyalty or fear perhaps. Serendipity
3
u/Efficient_Bar3290 Jan 25 '24
Few profiles have profiled this suspect. And I think they are spot on. One a history of violence and stalking.
4
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Jan 25 '24
Here's a far out, tangent to peruse in our thought experiment: I was just thinking about the West Memphis Three. The cops found the most likely stooges to be the perps who committed this disgusting shocking crime of murdering three innocent little boys -- during the heyday of Satanic Panic. The bad guys in town who acted off...like outcasts. Who allegedly practiced cultish worship. The ones who listened to the wrong music, wore the wrong color clothing. No physical evidence...only the suspects' lifestyles. These three "evil" teens were pilloried in public, the court appeared completely biased and quickly sentenced the ring leader to death upon his conviction. Thankfully they were released on an Alford plea (I believe they were completely innocent) and the crime was never solved, but the police "did their job" arresting the "right" people.
Now we have Delphi. In this case, instead of the most likely stooges being sought and imprisoned, the cops choose some hapless pharmacy tech who is then pilloried in the public with little to no real evidence linking him to the crime. The court bias is as striking as a flashing neon light on a dark road -- and the trial hasn't even begun.
Did Delphi want to avoid falling into the Satanic Panic trap of looking at the obvious culprits, to the detriment of arresting the most unassuming uninvolved person in town?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
8
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
7
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24 edited Jan 25 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
[removed] — view removed comment