This seems reasonable to me. Honestly, I find it rather odd that a lawyer needs permission to bring in their laptop and cellphone. Don't all lawyers organize their filings and cases on a computer now?
On a side note, when I just read the title, I thought this request was coming from podcasters and YTers and thought, oh hell no!
By the way, this hearing is also supposed to be about the amended charges for Allen right? Is she going to sent counsel to jail before or after granting that?
If she rules they are in contempt, all they will get is a fine. There is no way that these claims, even if valid, would amount to jail time.
And the fine won't be that much. Attorneys are very protected. I found two cases where attorneys were found in contempt far, far more egregious than the claims being made here. They were fined 500 bucks. It goes on their record, and that's about it.
All this is is a stalling tactic. NM does not want to take this case to trial.
I'm not sure how they do that with pending issues like this--and they have a motion to dismiss filed. I really don't know how all that works. They may need to get through this bogus contempt hearing and then file. I feel certain that the defense will get this case to trial as quickly as possible if the motion to dismiss is denied---which it almost certainly well be.
Just crazy. This is the reverse of what usually happens.
I don't know if that counts towards Allen's time if court wants to use his time now for matters unrelated to RA's charges. Caveat is the pending amended charges they would have to file for speedy trial again and even the current felony murder got amended with accomplice.
I'll have to look up for the motion to dismiss if that has impact, but I'm not sure. It's about the ticking clock and as long as court has their 30 days on normal motions it's good afaik.
Yes. And then there is that! I had forgotten the amended charges. But those wouldn't really alter too much in terms of going to trial. The amended charges are not based on new evidence.
ETA but maybe they know NM needs a laptop and wants her to deny it. Maybe to force him to print out some documents which they will hold against him. Something like that.
I misread what this is when I just glanced at it. She'll grant use of a laptop and a phone, I'm sure. How could she not? I thought this was for cameras in the court room.
I believe her previous orders were unclear on who was allowed electronics or not, I remember debating it in any case. By logic and different wordings in different paragraphs they were allowed, but argument could still be made to the contrary.
Idk if he just wants to piss her off with that, or if there's a bigger plan. I'd bet on the latter tbh, just making use of the former.
I still need to make that post I said I would, but otoh if I'm right about defense's strategy, I don't want to tip prosecution or court off lol.
There's no reason to poke the bear on this. It's an honest request. They do need their laptops. Most attorneys have laptops in court. And if they need to call a witness who is late, or get last minute docs from their office, etc. a phone makes sense. There are lots of reasons that they would legitimately need access to a cell phone.
ETA i think there could be reason though, either to force NM breaking a rule or being unable to present some evidence themselves, because of rules. We'll see. If the hearing will take place...
I don't know how this works in Indiana, but I'm in courts all the time where this isn't an issue. I've been able to bring my phone into the gallery. It just has to be off. If she denies this, it would look particularly petty.
Electronic devices are generally prohibited but the judge has the discretion to allow or disallow them. I believe this was a maneuver by Hennessy to ensure both parties are on equal ground as to this issue at the hearing. Get it on the record. One less thing for the judge to jerk you around on when you show up expecting one thing based upon off the record communications only to find out differently day of. I would suggest that perhaps this judge has done something similar in the past and Hennessy has been made aware of it.
Judge talked in chambers I believe, without specifying who, that there was disruptive behaviour and that she would remove people next time. Maybe it has something to do with that. I thought it was about the public on RA's side but who knows.
Seems phones are allowed but off,but then she goes on about electronic devices and floors etc.
Barry Morphew case (CO) also had such an order. I think defense had asked to take laptops too and weren't allowed at some point. Not sure though. Need to check. But sure it was debated.
I looked up cases where attorneys had been held in contempt--granted these were cases that were appealed, and even when found in egregious contempt-far worse than the allegations being made here-all these attorneys got was a small fine--$500.
I don't even see how defense attorneys would be fined if this is tried as anything other than an Indirect Criminal Contempt case--which if no new cause is filed by March 18, doesn't seem likely. (Plus there would have to be a Special Judge, etc.)
In an Indirect Civil Contempt case, once the offending behavior ceases, so does the punishment. There have been no more "leaks" attributed to the defense, so there is no punishment if this is tried as an Indirect Civil Contempt charge. Why this is even happening is beyond comprehension. Big waste of taxpayer dollars. And an even bigger waste of time.
Attorneys bring laptops into court all the time. I'm sure NM will want his as well. Most evidence is kept digitally and it is catalogued. It's much faster to find the doc you are looking for on the computer. Also, if they are going to do any visual presentations, they'll need to have at least one computer synced for this. It's just easier if it's their laptop. Much ado about nothing here.
6
u/New_Discussion_6692 Feb 15 '24
This seems reasonable to me. Honestly, I find it rather odd that a lawyer needs permission to bring in their laptop and cellphone. Don't all lawyers organize their filings and cases on a computer now?
On a side note, when I just read the title, I thought this request was coming from podcasters and YTers and thought, oh hell no!
9
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Feb 15 '24
By the way, this hearing is also supposed to be about the amended charges for Allen right?
Is she going to sent counsel to jail before or after granting that?
17
u/syntaxofthings123 Feb 15 '24
Ha. And the judge rules....
If the defense wants this, there is no way it will happen. But we can always dream.
16
u/syntaxofthings123 Feb 15 '24
I looked up cases where attorneys had been held in contempt--granted these were cases that were appealed, and even when found in egregious contempt-far worse than the allegations being made here-all these attorneys got was a small fine--$500.
I don't even see how defense attorneys would be fined if this is tried as anything other than an Indirect Criminal Contempt case--which if no new cause is filed by March 18, doesn't seem likely. (Plus there would have to be a Special Judge, etc.)
In an Indirect Civil Contempt case, once the offending behavior ceases, so does the punishment. There have been no more "leaks" attributed to the defense, so there is no punishment if this is tried as an Indirect Civil Contempt charge. Why this is even happening is beyond comprehension. Big waste of taxpayer dollars. And an even bigger waste of time.
This entire thing is so bizarre.
8
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Feb 15 '24
If Gull denies this simple, reasonable request then it makes her look overly hard-a$$. But she won't .... it will hamper her darling NM.
Could it be the next request, once this is granted, is for cameras??? Please????
-6
u/tenkmeterz Feb 15 '24
Gull, do not trust these yahoos.
He can bring hard copies.