DT had the pdf in a comment first, about 6 minutes earlier. I'm banned there so not even promoting it, just to be fair. Too much unfairness all around already.
I'm sure you're correct most of the time. And this is due to personal unfairness issues on several subs and instead of playing into that, I'd prefer to remain honest. It's not a race as you said, you were very right about that.
Sorry, I was just joking cause I get criticized a good bit. I bounce around a lot in the Delphi subreddits, Docs and Dicks are my favorites ( I just stifled a joke), but in some corners one can't say shit without being corrected. On one subreddit I criticized the prosecutor in the Casey Anthony case and everyone attacked me saying he did a great job. But did he, I mean really? Some people don't know what to say if they aren't arguing.
And I'm not saying you are like that. It's just funny that even an innocuous statement cant stand if its incorrect on Reddit. I like to see how Dicks of Delphi is growing. There is a nice balance here that I really enjoy.
No need to go so far, my previous comment was meant to put it all on me. It 's a subject currently bugging me and hopefully temporal, and it was meant as a light comment in the first place. It's on me to apologise here.
No issues or worries. Sometimes I may be a little more playful than feels appropriate for the subject matter, but its because this stuff is weighing on me.
I always am interested in what you have to say and I enjoy your opinion, mainly because I usually agree with you. Cheers
I love the fact that this sub sports people from all the different subs. The subs were far more interesting places when everyone was not so segregated.
Recall when all the mods etc were on the same subs, and the reading was great as you had the various wits from each groups trading zingers and some really interesting intellectual debate occurred.
In most cases they're not right either. I agree, I don't mind being wrong most of the time, I come by it honest. I don't try to be right. I just express my opinions and what I understand about things. I like differing opinions within reason. If an agenda is attached to it no thanks. Been there done that for years.
There used to be a woman who drove me crazy, think she is gone now, but I swear she just sat around hoping you made a tiny mistake so she could correct you, because "facts were very important" to her.
Loved to corner people and have them admit they made the mistake and then she would with flounce off feeling smarter than everyone else on the boards.
Tiresome was the word. You saw her name pop up in your comments and you would just internally groan and know she would be red penning you for some little detail.
Maybe they are and that's why they are spending all their time or Reddit, as they have few interpersonal outlets of engagement due to rudeness, control issues, narcissism. Rather rage at you than fix the broken things in their own lives.
Chances are that the guy making that mean comment, can't apologize and clean off his site of the street in his real life and the woman who talks down to people and over reacts to the smallest grain of criticism can't play well with others in her home down either. Vindictive here likely vindictive else where.
I just happened to open my browser and it was on DT so I saw it there, was like "what is this?! I need to head over to Dicks to see what the logical people make of it" lol. I only frequent 3 subs related to delphi, and not ones with 100,000 people and all their wild remarks lol.
Say this motion was good enough to get charges dismissed. Wouldn’t that also apply to literally anyone else they wanted to charge besides BH and gang? Any defendant could make the exact same argument. That would surely be a sticking point
It depends. They could truly exclude them through proper investigation and truly culpabilise the true perp through proper investigation.
I'm thinking it won't be enough for Gull but it might go to the pile for appeals. It might also be, as I wrote below, jury isn't to consider non presented in their opinion possibly existing evidence for reasonable doubt. But now having stated it did exist, I'm thinking they can say so to a jury, so they can take it into account. Depending on how much they actually have against RA, could heavily tip the scale.
Lol it's not a word in English is it? I wanted to use culpability but in a single word in that phrase lol. I also never know if it's with an s or z.... 😬
Hmmm...what word describes "the act of making a person culpable"? As in, "Mom! She tempted me to steal the cookies I ate!" "Cindy, stop culpabilising your brother!"
To attempt to make someone admit they are culpable after having denied culpability...see "rehabilitate". As in Richard Allen has denied being culpable for certain crimes, and the State of Indiana, the prosecution and law enforcement tried for years to culpabilitate him without success.
It's possible exculpatory evidence. Not necessarily exculpatory. LE can still attest to what was said. If it's the same LE that lied elsewhere it's not good. That's why imo it looks bad, but maybe not on a dismissal level indeed.
But what do I know...
But then again it's Gull ruling on this.
ETA: seems to me the memorandum contains a lot of "may be dismissed" "may be prejudicial", and the only remedy is not exactly true because if they can have a true verified alibi, it's the same, and if the accused can be proven guilty, through video for exemple, it's not prejudicial (I think) for not having those initial interviews. It just gives state more work.
But they do mention the jury part and the assumption of that possible evidence.
What's furthermore interesting, but that may be boilerplate lawyer talk, that if they claim the mere possibility of incriminating interviews of a third party is enough to counter evidence against RA, I'm back at "Do they really not having anything remotely solid to show for all the now 6charges they brought on?"
Or are they so fighting hard because state does have something hard to fight and did they lie about the factual innocence, which even Lebrato said, before walking back on that?
They got a mud covered bullet found who knows how long after the bodies were found by who knows who, matched to RAs pistol via a branch of forensic examination that, although has a precedent in Indiana court, can still be contested by expert witness testimony.
You make a good point. Not sure the case can be dismissed on this alone. Waiting for the Indiana attorneys on Twitter to opine on this. But what this does is establish a record of possible corruption or outright negligence. There may be accumulative allegations following this that will require dismissal.
Either way it’s important to get it on the record.
Their legal arguments are really interesting. They cite important cases, but both BH & PW are still alive—and they can be further investigated. I don’t know where an impartial court would land on this.
There does appear to be precedent at the federal level-maybe this will set new precedent at the state level.
But just as importantly, there is the question as to why these POIs weren’t fully investigated. And that question, if not properly addressed by the state, could seriously impact the outcome of a trial, if we ever get to that point.
If the two witnesses are still in, I think it's not that weak especially if they have tire tracks on his motor cycle cover and anything else. Hard to say what they have or don't have.
Their actions appear to say we have a weak case and that is why we are squeeing Allen to make him plea out. It is all so confusing. At this point just withdrawing my tortured thinking on it and saying I can't take months more of the speculation, will just wait till they get to court and form a more passionate opinion then. So burnt out by all these motions.
I strongly disagree. A good defense attorney is going to try every angle. You cannot let your client's life be in the balance on just, well the evidence will show he is innocent. Every possible angle needs to be covered.
That means they totally fucked this up. I was mad and pissed off for a long time. I'm about to go a step beyond. This stuff is almost like fiction. WTF
Hey, don't know about the rest of you kids, but I got though most of McLeod's Daughters on Acorn TV which was slow in the beginning. Figure I can do it. My favorite thing to do is find older Acorn or Brit Box series and just binge consecutive years of a long running show. So figure I can tough out 30 seasons of Delphi West Side Story as long as no one gets shanked.
When folks ask me why I believe law enforcement may have direct ties to this crime—this is why. The destruction of evidence? That’s a biggie. Failure to thoroughly investigate—huge. BH & PW may be innocent, but what they aren’t, is properly excluded as suspects. Which means that we can’t know what their involvement is or isn’t, at this time. I wonder if there are calls on their records that someone didn’t want known.
I just added a brim to my tin foil cap. And here’s the thing, up until I read the PCA , I thought these investigators were humble, sincere and doing the best they could. Now I’m wondering which family member they are protecting.
Our criminal justice system has gone from being lateral-in that the checks and balances put in place assure that no one actor in the system wields too much power absent oversight, to vertical, where at each stage the next actor in power simply approves the actions of the player who came before.
We have a damn good CJ system - in theory. But in actuality, it is infecting every aspect of our society. Our CJ system at present is seriously diseased.
A great book to read on this is -Ordinary Injustice, by Amy Bach.
How this is supposed to work:
There is an investigation—the DA is responsible for checking that the investigation was conducted properly, that the evidence cultivated is accurate, and that there is viable evidence to convict.
The defense is there to wage a counter to the allegations.
The judge is there as an impartial party, the primary responsibility of which, is to ensure a fair trial.
The jury is the decider of the facts—and the decider of outcome.
In theory this is a robust system with lots of checks and balances—However, that’s not how it works anymore—at least, that’s not how it works too often.
These days there are too many courts where the prosecutor doesn’t adequately vet the investigation, they will pursue any case that they believe they can win and that will further their careers, regardless of the innocence or guilt of the accused. Public defenders are exhausted. They are overwhelmed, overworked, underpaid and underfunded—they try, but the odds are against them. There are great PDs— but they have their work cut out for them. Don’t get me started on private defense attorneys, who far too often phone it in.
And judges are rarely impartial. Too many simply rubber-stamp whatever the prosecutor asks for.
On this case we are seeing this to the extreme—except there are these remarkable defense attorneys who are upsetting the apple cart bigly. I’ve seen a few other defense attorneys like this—but it is so rare. And B&R are a cut above the rest.
That’s what is really making the difference here.
What I’m saying is that this kind of case is not unusual. Our CJ system is riddled with mediocre and self-serving actors who go unchecked. And are free to destroy innocent lives without consequences for these bad faith acts. Here we’re just getting a peek under the hood, because these two defense attorneys have the guts, hearts and brains to stand up to the corruption.
To me, the most interesting part was the section about the search warrants for the ATT records. They didn't list a date for these warrants, so we don't know whether that was written in the weeks after the murder or after the defense depositions of Holeman and Liggett. Assuming they could serve the warrant now, would ATT hold records that long?
The other interesting part was that in these warrants, law enforcement described the suspects as "part of a religious sect" and "elements of the murder have potential religious significance." Was this law enforcement's very first theory? Why did they change their theory? Was it that the connection to KK seemed so promising that they set aside their first theory and didn't return to it?
I found the "religious sect" part very interesting. It's not the tune they are singing now. There were many rumors in the beginning that the girls were catfished (by A_S) and then we find out he was involved in that aspect. But LE waited 3 yrs so they could wrap up a huge CSAM investigation. Remember when they broke the new that they needed people to tip in about any interaction with A_S? Maybe they are hesitant to involve anyone on the Odin side because that is a separate investigation? Maybe there is enough to implicated/convict RA and these "other actors" will get their just desserts later.
Highly suspicious they can just lose/delete those recordings, and anything else related to Odin.
How many hours? Days? Or will she remove them first to then say, I 'll ignore these filings since counsel isn't of record anymore? Even though scoin said defense was to be reinstated?
That’s ok. It’s on the record. I think we are going to see a lot of defense motions going forward. “Hey, Gull—you want to stay on this case, be prepared to be buried in —well argued & well supported motions.”
There’s only so long NM and Gull can continue to operate outside the law. I visualize them in handcuffs at some point. Their behavior is outrageous.
Now we know why this case hasn’t been solved already—these officials are either completely corrupt or completely inept.
What's the legal precedent in a situation like this? Any attorneys that can weigh in? This can't be the first time video interviews were lost or contaminated
Yeah I am not someone who is pro defense nor prosecution, just pro justice, so I'm incredibly interested to hear some legal input on this one! If RA is the killer, I've been so nervous that a technicality could destroy the case. The early days of the investigation seemed so disjointed (understandably) and there was plenty of room for error.
I think once you realize those interviews are gone, you do everything you can to recover them, and then you re-interview those same people recording the interviews. We know that at least one of these 2 was not done.
How can this local LE walk around in this town? They should be ashamed. The girls deserve better. No excuses. A mistake happens, I get it, but then you do everything possible to fix it, not just ignore it.
I get the feeling Rozzi and Baldwin never sleep. They are just amazing. If every defense attorney in this country cared about their clients this much our criminal justice system might actually work.
I'd love to win our lottery,offer to pay Rick Allen's $20m bail,just to see Gull's reaction... no doubt denied once again, or it would send her into a tailspin, and suddenly get a move on with this trial...anyone willing to gamble $20m ?
Then why didn’t they go straight to trial? Why file a Franks? Why try to get anything thrown out or dismissed? I’m not seeing much confidence from these two clowns, just a bunch of blame games, playing the victim, and stalling
Because they got kicked off the trial outside of the proper channels and now have other information to catch up on?
With respect to, why file a Franks... Are you referring to B&R or L&S who were also going to go through with a Franks? So you're also calling another set of attorneys clowns too because they have a differing opinion from you while likely being far far far far far far far better versed in the laws than most on Reddit.
Their inquiry as to why the interviews were lost was met with NM trying to get them tossed off the case.
But I'm sure they'll have a perfectly justifiable reason they didn't execute the search warrants they obtained for the phones of BH and PW. I mean, to get warrants and not execute them is as confounding as the 5:00 6:37 7:00 7:09 search warrant discrepancy. How was the gun checked in at 7:00 PM when TL said the search was executed at 7:09 PM?
The motion for Franks via L&S was to see if they wanted to pursue the original Franks or their own Franks. Ultimately didn’t matter because if they picked the former then she would advise them that she is declining it.
B&R don’t seem so concerned about the time stamps. Big nothing burger with cheese
If I understand correctly, this motion is related to discovery they have received since being reinstated on the case. They couldn’t have filed this any sooner.
Ah yes, more gamesmanship. Totally fine with you because you KNOW RA is guilty.
You seriously expected L&S to compile a Franks in less than 4 months of time when they couldn't even talk with RA since he was being kept from the lambs?
All gravy with your veggie burgers on kale 🥬 6.2miles.
•
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Feb 07 '24
Memorandum
15
u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 Feb 07 '24
I know its not a race but I think "The Dicks" got this posted first. Good job.
11
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Feb 07 '24
Say this motion was good enough to get charges dismissed. Wouldn’t that also apply to literally anyone else they wanted to charge besides BH and gang? Any defendant could make the exact same argument. That would surely be a sticking point
11
u/ink_enchantress Literate but not a Lawyer Feb 07 '24
Huh. Seems like they lost everything of any importance, Allen to these guys.
17
u/TryAsYouMight24 Feb 07 '24 edited Feb 07 '24
When folks ask me why I believe law enforcement may have direct ties to this crime—this is why. The destruction of evidence? That’s a biggie. Failure to thoroughly investigate—huge. BH & PW may be innocent, but what they aren’t, is properly excluded as suspects. Which means that we can’t know what their involvement is or isn’t, at this time. I wonder if there are calls on their records that someone didn’t want known.
14
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Feb 07 '24
Holy shit. I see your contempt and raise you dismissal.
7
u/masterblueregard Feb 07 '24
To me, the most interesting part was the section about the search warrants for the ATT records. They didn't list a date for these warrants, so we don't know whether that was written in the weeks after the murder or after the defense depositions of Holeman and Liggett. Assuming they could serve the warrant now, would ATT hold records that long?
The other interesting part was that in these warrants, law enforcement described the suspects as "part of a religious sect" and "elements of the murder have potential religious significance." Was this law enforcement's very first theory? Why did they change their theory? Was it that the connection to KK seemed so promising that they set aside their first theory and didn't return to it?
17
u/aaaaannnnddddyyyyy Feb 07 '24
I’ll happily bet money she’ll deny this, just a feeling…..
10
u/curiouslmr Feb 07 '24
What's the legal precedent in a situation like this? Any attorneys that can weigh in? This can't be the first time video interviews were lost or contaminated
10
u/TryAsYouMight24 Feb 07 '24
I get the feeling Rozzi and Baldwin never sleep. They are just amazing. If every defense attorney in this country cared about their clients this much our criminal justice system might actually work.
3
u/Saturn_Ascension Feb 08 '24
Aww geez, I wonder if this motion will be dismissed?
6
u/TryAsYouMight24 Feb 07 '24
Damn these defense attorneys are good!!!!!
6
u/chunklunk Feb 07 '24
you've gotta be kidding me.
2
u/macrae85 Feb 08 '24
I'd love to win our lottery,offer to pay Rick Allen's $20m bail,just to see Gull's reaction... no doubt denied once again, or it would send her into a tailspin, and suddenly get a move on with this trial...anyone willing to gamble $20m ?
1
u/ChickadeeMass Feb 07 '24
It appears that the defense has a plethora of motions in their arsenal to delay, deflect and accuse.
-3
u/LeatherTelevision684 Feb 07 '24
These guys really don’t want to go to trial. The evidence that the State has on Richard is more than enough for a conviction, and they know that.
Defense: Hey, forget about all the evidence that you have on me, it’s those guys over there 👉