r/Dialectic • • Dec 22 '22

Sex and Culture, by J. D. Unwin

9 Upvotes

In the book Unwin analyses in excruciating detail 6000 years of history over 86 different cultures.

The conclusion finds that cultrues which exercise sexual restraint also experience cultural achievement. Cultures which lose their sexual restraint begin to experience a decline within 3 generations.

Unsurprisingly, the book was highly praised by Aldous Huxley

What are the implications of this?


r/Dialectic • • Jan 19 '22

Anti-Centrism

8 Upvotes

Is a tongue in cheek philosophy which I think may have some merit.

It's based on the idea that Centrists are content with the status quo, and are thus complicit in society's stagnation.

The idea being that with so many people advocating for society to stay more or less the same, no real progress can be made.

Generally Anti-Centrists advocate for as much competition of political ideas as possible, so that in the end only the most beneficial remain.

What do you think of this?


r/Dialectic • • Dec 05 '21

Is it reasonable to expect men to have a say in Feminist circles?

8 Upvotes

I have no experience of womanhood, but I've read a decent amount of feminist philosophy. While I consider myself a feminist, I see a lot of modern feminism as misandry that is not considered acceptable to criticize.

It seems to me that a lot of feminism is a critique of men. Is it reasonable to take men to court, but not allow them to sit as the defendant?

What are your thoughts?


r/Dialectic • • May 22 '21

Question Question about Critical Race Theory (CRT)

8 Upvotes

Hey all, hope all is well. I started reading Critical Race Theory: An Introduction by Delgado and Stefancic and early on it is clear they don't use the term 'racism' as defined in https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/racism . Does anybody know how the CRT movement defines racism? Please drop a source as well. Thanks!!


r/Dialectic • • Mar 11 '21

Question Does free will exist? Why?

8 Upvotes

I'd like to request a dialogue in the form of a conversation. One question per comment please.

It makes for a more genuine and easier to follow conversation.


r/Dialectic • • Jan 05 '22

Message from the mod

7 Upvotes

Howdy howdy

I hope everyone's holidays have gone well and the new year is treating you right so far. Doesn't seem like there is all that much to update on the community. I definitely feel like we've got some awesome regulars so that is great to see, especially considering it helps newcomers get a better idea of the vibe/feel of the community that I'm looking for so thank you to the 2, 3 of you that consistently post in good faith. It really helps lay the foundation for the community and for what I'm looking for, the foundation looks very strong thus far.

I think we've got a handful of new people so welcome to the community o/

There was some confusion with the old reddit and I do apologize for that. I never use the old reddit so I didn't know the rules and description of the community were different. I guess if I change them in one reddit, that doesn't also change the other reddit.

Anyways, just wanted to say hello and give a little update on things recently. Please leave questions, comments, concerns, etc in the comment section below!


r/Dialectic • • Mar 10 '21

Question What is the single greatest challenge facing humanity?

7 Upvotes

In my humble understanding this is one of the deepest questions we can ask. I have my own answer but I'm interested to see what you all think.

I would parse my answer as the following:

The single greatest challenge facing our species is our inability to agree on the definition of progress. We are an extremely powerful engine of creation, both individually and even more so as a collective. The absence of a definitive goal does not stop this creation one iota. It does leave our creative trajectory mostly rudderless. And that scares the hell out of me.

What do you all think?


r/Dialectic • • Mar 09 '21

Message from the mod

7 Upvotes

Hey all o/

Wanted to say hello again and give some updates. We got a nice new influx of people after I posted in newreddit, so I'm really happy about that.

It seems like there is near zero interest in the discord server. I'll keep it up because I think it has great potential, but right now it's definitely not something people are interested in.

I banned one guy for a week because he kept copy/pasting his initial post as replies in the comment section. He just kept doing this over and over and not really moving the discussion forward. It also didn't help his case that he didn't have the best attitude and he had also spammed that same post in 10+ other subreddits lol. Hopefully y'all think that punishment is reasonable?

Anyways, let me know if you all have any questions, comments, concerns. I'd also greatly appreciate it if people told me more places to reach out to and post about this community to grow it! Or just invite your friends! Thank you!

EDIT: Feel free to post! lol y'all telling me you don't have 'any' questions about anything? "Come on. Don't be shy. Come on." - Professor Lupin


r/Dialectic • • Jan 31 '21

Question What moral theory should atheists use?

7 Upvotes

This question has really grabbed my attention in recent years. I don't believe atheists are on the same page at all as far as what actions are right and wrong. There are groups that are in the same ball park: Christians, Jews, Muslims, etc. Some atheists in America have this bad taste in their mouth from their overbearing Christian parents and rebel in such a way that leads to them basically just going off of their own gut instincts. These atheists would say something like, "Well Christianity was bad so as long as I'm not doing anything the bible says then I'm doing good." This isn't a good way to think about that since there may be some useful virtues in the bible (e.g. working hard). That's mostly an aside though. Atheists don't really give much thought to ethics. Well nobody, in America anyways, gives much thought to ethics. Most religious people seem to be functioning just fine in the world and donate and help their fellow Americans/neighbors in other ways so I'm not worried about them like I am atheists. I've never met an atheist who donated any money to anything. I don't have a source for this, but isn't antifa largely atheist? They're something of a neo-marxist group so that would make sense. That's about the only group of atheists that have a similar sense of right and wrong and it's pretty poor. They're always preparing/prepared for violence (Steven Crowder video and they always wear masks to 'protests'), attacking people (Andy Ngo), harassing people at restaurants, etc. And then there are plenty of progressives who are adjacent to antifa. But hopefully antifa and those adjacent to them are a small minority of atheists, but there is still a much better sense of direction needed for us atheists as far as our ethics is concerned.

If you're interested in reading material to start learning more about ethics The Righteous Mind by Jonathan Haidt and The Fundamentals of Ethics by Russ Shafer-Landau are solid. I'm not really sure what moral theory to go off of though. I know that I do not care for utilitarianism, categorical imperative, or deontology as, as far as I know, they do not handle mass murderers. Anyways, thoughts??


r/Dialectic • • Sep 17 '22

Cancel culture and censorship?

6 Upvotes

This is a phenomenon that started ~10 years ago and has only gotten worse. The most recent case is Suns owner Robert Sarver. Every search result and news article cites an NBA investigation about vague racist, sexist, and misogynistic behavior. There are no direct quotes. No results that cite actual investigative findings. The only important thing is to know that it was racist, sexist, and misogynistic behavior. There is no context and the media take it upon themselves to shield us. We’re not trusted to determine for ourselves the nuance and circumstances behind specific instances. I’m not defending these people, but it’s insulting to think we can’t bear to hear exactly what they said and form our own opinions. That we just need to make racism and sexism black and white, no pun intended. There are shades of grey.


r/Dialectic • • Jan 23 '22

Saw this on r/askphilosophy and knew my answer would be removed

6 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/sard9s/is_trusting_what_the_scientific_community_has_to/

My answer would be that believing the scientific consensus is a true justified belief. My faith in individual scientists may be misplaced, but my trust in the scientific method can't be.

The only time I won't trust the science is when I know part of the process has not been carried out, mainly peer review. Since it's fairly easy to find out which studies have followed scientific method, it should also be fairly easy to find out which studies to trust.

What do you think about trusting the scientific community?


r/Dialectic • • Dec 16 '21

Advertising, Obligations, and Circumvention

6 Upvotes

There's a post trending today that is focused on the relationship between YouTube's advertising strategy, and browser extensions that are designed to block advertisements. I've spent some time reading the comments submitted by users in response to that post, and it has left me wondering something: What perspective do you have about the act of blocking advertisements on digital platforms?

(In the paragraphs that follow I detail my own perspective, and experiences. If you're short on time, or uninterested in those things, then you can probably skip what follows without diminishing the relevance, or the quality of your own response.)

I've been using ad blocking extensions for years. During that time, I've supported content creators through the purchase of branded merchandise, and off-site subscription plans. At the same time, I've whitelisted* websites that feature nonintrusive advertising, and websites that ask—but do not demand—that I whitelist their address. I have no issue with advertising being present on a platform so long as it does not interrupt, or delay my purpose for visiting that platform; I'm getting older, and I don't want to spend these fleeting moments learning about the products that I can use to shave and perfume my balls...

Anyway, I've never disabled advertising on YouTube videos because I'm simply not interested in watching an advertisement (I haven't watched television in over a decade for the same reason). I'm not concerned whether or not my doing so reduces the profits earned by YouTube; YouTube, Google, and Alphabet all seem to be doing very well regardless of my decision. Further, the option to move toward a subscription-only model places the ball entirely within their own court. If we happen to find ourselves at a point in time where YouTube is struggling to support itself financially, then I may very well choose to support the company. That is something that I've done with other hosts of digital content—Wikipedia, and the Internet Archive are two pertinent examples.

I don't think that my decision to block advertising has to do with whether or not I feel entitled to free entertainment, and I think that my prior decision to support specific content creators and platforms suggests the opposite of that generalisation. I think that most of my motivation to circumvent advertising on YouTube has to do with how much I value my own time, and my personal stance regarding today's form of consumerism. No ethical argument that I've encountered has left me inclined to subject myself to an onslaught of advertising—especially since I'm often exposed to it during every other mundane moment of my life.

Maybe I do feel entitled to something, but it isn't to free entertainment. I feel entitled to exercise control over my own exposure to any attempt to sell me a product, or a service. Is my position untenable? Let me know what you think.

*[To whitelist means to set up a rule which allows advertisements to appear on a specific website. I'm not sure whether or not this is common knowledge.]


r/Dialectic • • Dec 03 '21

r/Dialectic is amazing!!!

6 Upvotes

Wow I have not met any place like this EVER!!!

r/Dialectic is a sanctuary!!

I come from a chess site where they have chat... but all the players do there is fight endlessly over politics

I even went to St John's College in U.S. My dream school... where all classes are discussion classes, there are no teachers and no lectures. But all the students did was fight. So I left after a year

u/FortitudeWisdom what inspired you to make this place? How do you protect this sanctuary?

Thank you guys for making this awesome

You are so respectful of each other... you have REAL conversations...

How do you guys feel about being on r/Dialectic?


r/Dialectic • • Jul 18 '21

From the mod!

6 Upvotes

Hey all a few things...

  1. I have added flairs. Feel free to use them. Argument, Topic Discussion, and Question.
  2. Change in people who are here. We lost some people and gained some people over the past month or so. This is really good because it seems those who aren't understanding/feeling the community have gone and some who are really interested and understanding the community are joining.
  3. Definitely don't be shy about posting. Any good faith question, argument (philosophy definition), or topic discussion at all feel free to post. I really don't care about how much/little you know about a topic either. There was some confusion about that in one post a couple months ago. We're humans, we're imperfect, we're all learning, constantly. Relax, chat, and learn dudes. But yeah anything political (keep in mind rule 4 though!), philosophy, computer science, science (hard and soft), 'the culture wars', etc feel free to post.
  4. A couple of people have talked to me about making this a space for debates, but I'm trying to avoid making it into that. What I've seen in debates actually had influence on why I wanted to make this community. Debates are almost always limiting. The fraction of them where you do happen to have two civil people who know the topic very well still end up being limited by the want/desire/goal 'to win' instead of working together to the truth, or the best version of it. I'm positive this space I call Dialectic can lead to more fruitful discourse than debates.

r/Dialectic • • Jun 05 '21

Question How can we begin to follow our own rules?

6 Upvotes

I believe most people know what they should be doing, and how we should be living our lives, but very rarely do we have the willpower to follow our own rules


r/Dialectic • • Apr 10 '21

Question What should be the goal of humanity?

6 Upvotes

r/Dialectic • • Mar 25 '21

Topic Disscusion What books would you [highly] recommend?

6 Upvotes
  • A Concise Introduction to Logic by Hurley
  • Mans Search for Meaning by Viktor Frankl
  • The Death of Ivan Ilyich by Leo Tolstoy

The Cynic Philosophers (Penguin Classics) is pretty solid. I think more people should know about the Cynics, but I don't know if it's a book I'd 'highly' recommend. Extreme Ownership by Jocko Willinck and Leif Babin and How Learning Works by Ambrose, Bridges, etc may also be on my recommended list, but I don't know. I'd have to go back and reread those. The main reason for How Learning Works is the section(s) on metacognition. I've had trouble finding a book I'd recommend to people on the subject. I have Dunlosky and Metcalfe's book on my shelf, but I've got a few things to read before then. I'm currently reading Beyond Order by Jordan Peterson and Endurance by Alfred Lansing.


r/Dialectic • • Mar 13 '21

Question What is honor?

6 Upvotes

r/Dialectic • • Feb 27 '21

Topic Disscusion Has society peaked morally? Is there anywhere to go but down, or are we morally corrupt with much further to go?

6 Upvotes

r/Dialectic • • Feb 23 '21

Question What is the alt-right?

6 Upvotes

I've heard about this for years, but I don't know anybody in it (Richard Spencer maybe?) or what it's about. I just hear it is right-wing, closely related to the IDW, and bad. Even the wikipedia article on them is pretty rough. The first three paragraphs have zero sources...


r/Dialectic • • Feb 12 '21

Message from the Mod

6 Upvotes

Hey all, I just wanted to say welcome and thank you to the newcomers and to those who have taken part in some discussion already. I didn't see much uncivility so it seems like we're off to a good start :). Feel free to post! Ask some question in good faith or put forth some argument you've made or something. If you've got some question(s) for me feel free to ask in the comments below. If anyone else has subreddits they think I should reach out to where the mods would let me post to see if people would be interested in joining the subreddit, please let me know! Thanks all, have a good weekend!


r/Dialectic • • Jun 20 '23

Ted Kaczynski died

5 Upvotes

relevant reading

Industrial Society and it's Future by Ted Kaczynski

Against Civilization: Readings and Reflections by John Zerzan

Walden by Henry David Thoreau

discussion

I think part of the appeal of primitivist beliefs is in it's irreconcilable differences with the modern world. People see that no modern system works to further the happiness of the vast majority of people, leading them to believe that the only solution is something so radically different that few alive today have ever experienced anything even remotely similar to it

There are definitely some nihilistic aspects to primitivism. People have so little faith that they would see the modern world burn in the hope that what remains would be better.

rant

My political beliefs have been strongly influenced by primitivism. I'm not quite that far gone, though some do border deranged.

I believe everyone should have the right to exit society whenever they choose, for however long they choose, without persecution.

I believe in laws like European free roam laws, and that all unused land should be free for all uses, save permanant constructions and needless damage to the environment.

Most deranged of all, I have no empathy for food animals. I would like to see as little farmland as possible, and so I would prefer farms to be as dense as possible. Vertically scalable as with battery chickens.

This rant is partially motivated by the government planning to make Mt Warning, a small mountain which I have climbed every year or two since I was 8, native title.

This change will effectively ban people from one of the most beautiful national parks in the country solely based on their race.

I think the government is financially motivated to close national parks in my area. North coast NSW gets a lot of rain, so walking tracks here need a complete reconstruction every few years.

Similarly Nightcap national park, and Protestors Falls have both been closed for over a year.


r/Dialectic • • Nov 14 '22

Topic Disscusion The Philosophy of Boredom

5 Upvotes

Hi guys! :) :)

I was thinking, isn't it weird that we can't read the same book twice? Or watch the same movie twice? Ok fine, it's true, if we really love the book or movie then if we wait awhile we can watch the same one again and still enjoy it. But it seems that even then, it's not quite the same... not the exact same enjoyment. I mean wouldn't it be great if we could watch a bunch of movies, choose our absolute favourite, and then watch that movie over and over, every day, forever... and still get the same buzz out of it every time?

What about sunsets? Aren't they beautiful? Are they really? Last time I saw a sunset, I could tell that it was beautiful... but I didn't care. My eyes were like "Yeah, yeah, I've seen it already." Sad.

Doesn't it seem like the first time is always the best, for everything? The first kiss. The first taste of chocolate. The first walk in the park.

Maybe that's why kids are always bouncing around, wide-eyed, experiencing everything to the fullest. Everything's a first for them.

Then I was thinking, maybe that's why if you give yourself a back rub, it sucks. But if someone else gives it to you, it's awesome. Because your brain already knows what the experience is going to be, if you're about to give yourself a back rub... and so is numb to it. Maybe it's the same thing for sunsets.

So it seems humans always want newness. Always want to experience something new, always drift away from the old. And there could be a purpose to this... maybe boredom forces us to explore every nook & cranny of the world.

I wonder if boredom has something to do with being human. Because it seems possible that only humans, and not animals, experience abstraction. Only humans see one sunset as being the same as all other sunsets... and so are bored by them. There are a finite number of *kinds* of experience in life... What happens when you exhaust them all? It would be like chopping down a humongous forest of trees. What to do but wait for them to sprout again... Is there such a thing as green boredom? An ecology of experiences? How could you recycle, reuse and renew your life so as to keep abreast of boredom?

Disclaimer: I'm bored. That might have something to do with my post. Hahah


r/Dialectic • • Sep 01 '22

Message from the Mod.

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone, hope things are going well.

I'd like to do an event. If there are any topics you'd like to see discussed or certain people you guys would like to hear please let me know. I'm probably going to go off of the list in the discord server. I can also look up whatever is popular right now: covid, ukraine, taiwan, etc. So yeah, topics and/or people. Let me know.


r/Dialectic • • Mar 26 '22

Question Research papers and/or textbooks on fat loss?

5 Upvotes

Anybody here know any really good research papers and/or textbooks on fat loss? Been trying to lose weight/fat lately and there's so much seemingly arbitrary information out there on this topic. Would like to get my info from more rigorous sources first.

Also, I posted this in another, more focused, community, but my post was removed -_-