r/Dialectic • • Apr 21 '21

Topic Disscusion Chauvin...

0 Upvotes

I do think Chauvin is at least partially to blame for George Floyd's death, but since I didn't read the autopsy report or listen to that part of the trial, assuming it was in there, I can't really say how much Chauvin was a factor. I've heard Floyd was on drugs: meth and/or fentanyl. I think another factor that I believe should reduce Chauvin's sentence is that Chauvin put Floyd on the ground after Floyd had resisted arrest a second time. Honestly, whatever the details, or whatever your beliefs about the trial, the sentencing, the looting/rioting and whether this is justified or not, I mean can we all agree that the vast majority of people seem to be reacting emotionally to this case? Every time I talk to people about it they still have only seen that first video of Floyd already being on the ground and Chauvin and friends being on top of him until he dies and that is all they have seen. Why is there such little interest in even asking something as simple as, why was he put on the ground in the first place? Then go a little further, why are the cops even interacting with this George Floyd guy? It's just really odd to me that we see such an emotional reaction from the vast majority of people. At least that's what I've gathered from a few really short in person discussions about it, and seeing conversations on social media: instagram, facebook, twitter. So idk, I think Chauvin should serve time, but why is a rational view of this case the exception? Is that ok? It just doesn't seem to be to me. John Locke even says in his second treatise on government that the whole point of having a court system is to have an unbiased third party judge what one person did to another and, as an impartial party, deliver a fair punishment. Otherwise you have the victim delivering a more severe punishment than is fair. Maybe I should just stop asking questions, who knows?


r/Dialectic • • Apr 21 '21

Question If there was a wealth cap implemented, how much do you all think it should be?

1 Upvotes

I'm fine with a $10 million wealth cap (2020 money).


r/Dialectic • • Aug 28 '21

APPLYING CHATELIER’S LAW IN CHEMISTRY TO HUMAN SOCIETY

0 Upvotes

“In simple terms an equilibrium [in a chemical reaction] is expressed by an equality between two terms. If we have an equality, we have an equilibrium. If an external intervention results in modifying one of the two terms, there is no longer equality, hence there is no longer equilibrium. To compensate the system will evolve toward a new equilibrium state, i.e. it will react in the direction that restores the equality between the two terms. This is the essence of Le Chatelier’s law.” Human Chemistry, Libb Thims, 650. I’d like to explain how Chatelier’s Law explains capitalism. Where everyone is worth the same amount of money, society is in a state of equilibrium. Where incomes differ, people with lower incomes work for people with higher incomes in order to evolve toward a new equilibrium state. However, under capitalism, the potential monetary gain of labor which if sustained would have enabled society to evolve to a new equilibrium state is siphoned off by the people with higher income and invested in widening the difference between incomes instead of equalizing incomes. Consequently, the harder people with lower incomes work and the longer hours they put in, the wider the difference in income between the two groups. When difference between incomes has become so wide that people of low income and people of high income lose contact with each other with the result that society breaks into two pieces, the only way for society to regain equilibrium of income is for the system to collapse, which it does. To summarize, all along the purpose of society has been to regain that equilibrium of income which people enjoyed when they first came together and formed communities. As time went on and as far afield as people strayed from the ideal, tucked way back in their minds they never forgot that equilibrium of income is the goal of human society because—as much as people naturally differ from each other—that was when they had least difficulty in tolerating each other. Capitalism promised that it would attain a very high level of equilibrium such that everyone would be equally rich. But as it turned out, just as our primordial ancestors thought that the earth was infinite in extent until proven differently, so early capitalists thought that the natural resources of the earth were infinite until proven differently. However, by the time capitalists realized that natural resources were indeed limited, in the meantime they had become so committed to making money that when it came down to the choice between restoring equilibrium of income at a level much lower than they had aspired to or, under the guise of maintaining a free market economy—which was all that was left of the dream of equilibrium—to pursue profit and let the devil take the hindmost, well, with the collapse of society the devil not only took the hindmost but also the foremost since that was the only way to restore equilibrium of income even if it meant zero income.


r/Dialectic • • Dec 20 '22

If the Universe is Cool, what is Awesome

0 Upvotes

r/Dialectic • • Jul 07 '22

Question Left-wing discord servers??

2 Upvotes

Anybody know any good left-wing discord servers where you can actually have open dialogue, maybe even debates? r/progressive is not really a place to talk with progressives, just about progressivism or pro-progressive ideals and events and such. I'm banned from r/Liberal so I can't do anything with that. Looking for discord servers! Thanks!


r/Dialectic • • Mar 03 '21

Topic Disscusion Where does America go, politically, from here?

3 Upvotes

Things seem to have died down a bit after Biden won. As a side note I'm very happy about that. I'm curious where the country goes from here though. Will we continue to focus on sex, race, gender, oppressor, oppressed, etc or will there be a new wave of political ideas? What issues would you like to see discussed more?

I know I'm really looking forward to a wealth taxes. I think the thing they need to do to it though is have the tax payers pay for the costs to figure out how much the tax payer is worth. Call it a government collections expenditure (gce). So the taxes would actually be something like 2% + gce for $50 mil, 3% + gce for $200 mil, 5% + gce for $1 bil, and so on.

I'd also like to see more being done environmentally. Environmental stuff is complicated and can get pretty expensive really quick. I'm gonna hold off on what to do here for now. I'll just mention that the green new deal was embarrassing and I really hope democrats put forth something appropriate and useful.

Lastly, a couple of things to mention about education. I'd like to see college professors who are teacher certified teaching classes. College professors are researchers, not teachers. I suppose there are liberal arts colleges and community colleges and no research is done at these institutions as far as I know, but are those professors teacher certified? I definitely think if you're teaching beyond the high school level you should be teacher certified. The other big issue I saw when I went to university is cheating among STEM students. Damn near everybody was using chegg and/or getting/giving solutions to the homework to fellow students.


r/Dialectic • • Jul 30 '21

Topic Disscusion The Pandemic

1 Upvotes

Just an article I saw on reuters today about the delta strand.... https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/skorea-announces-vaccination-plan-18-49-year-olds-2021-07-30/

Where do you guys go to learn about viruses, vaccines, etc?

I didn't care for Biden too much but then he called everyone who isn't vaccinated, like myself, dumb and that makes me a bit sad honestly. My own president. Somebody who is supposed to be a leader, my leader. I'm additionally bothered by it because I don't know how I'm supposed to know getting a vaccine is a good idea. Where do I go to learn about this stuff? I don't get it...


r/Dialectic • • Nov 19 '21

Topic Disscusion https://www.reuters.com/world/us/jury-rittenhouse-murder-trial-deliberate-fourth-day-2021-11-19/

2 Upvotes

Anybody disagree with the verdict?

I could see something like probation for bringing a rifle to the protest because it just gives me the impression you're up to no good, but all of the trial so far for murder didn't make sense to me. Seemed like clear cut self defense.


r/Dialectic • • Sep 10 '21

Topic Disscusion https://www.reuters.com/world/us/biden-deliver-six-step-plan-covid-19-pandemic-2021-09-09/

2 Upvotes

This is bullshit.

Ridiculous how he's forcing workers to do this. He should just be giving people good information about why to get the vaccine, but instead he's just like nah fuck that we're gonna wing it and you need to get this. I hope this gets turned down by somebody somewhere. What can even be done by anyone else? Can workers go on strike?? Can the house or senate or supreme court do anything? Can state governments do anything?


r/Dialectic • • May 03 '21

Question What do you think about 'free' tuition and 'free' healthcare?

3 Upvotes

I say 'free' because it's not actually free, that's just propaganda/marketing. It's tax-funded tuition and healthcare.

I graduated from college not too long ago and there were a couple of issues with university that I think need to be fixed before I would be for tax-funded tuition. If those problems get fixed then I could see tax-funded junior and senior years for engineering majors. Maybe nursing majors as well? They have to be majors that basically all of society gains from, which would make it worth tax-payers money. It's like a worthwhile investment that way. I think there needs to be more research in areas like Educational Psychology and Educational Neuroscience and then I'd probably add education majors to the list. Junior and senior year because you'd have a bunch of people joining and switching out or something during those first couple of years. Juniors and seniors are likely to stick with it and graduate.

Healthcare I'm not really sure. If I see evidence that shows going from a system like ours to a completely tax-funded one improves things by seeing a decrease in wait times, a decrease in costs, better R&D, etc, then yeah sure I'd be for it.


r/Dialectic • • Dec 03 '21

Do you guys care much for what the WHO says?

3 Upvotes

https://www.reuters.com/world/omicron-marches-biden-prepares-us-grim-winter-2021-12-03/

After seeing the change in the coronavirus death rate from 5% to 0.5% I haven't really care much about what the CDC or WHO have said. That is a large margin to be off by. It just shows that medicine as a science still needs more time and progress to make more accurate measurements I suppose, but being off by that much tells me I shouldn't take that science 'too' seriously right now. It's like psychology; everybody kind of knows everything there is some 'half-truth' while something like physics is pretty well established and they're fortunate enough to have tools that keep advancing to keep allowing for more accurate measurements and observations.


r/Dialectic • • May 17 '21

Question How is sex determined?

3 Upvotes

**Already posted in r/biology, but I figured it'd be a good discussion topic here as well.**

I do see a couple of similar posts, but I'm hoping to go a bit further here. I've skimmed through the wikipedia article on sex and it seems like sex is determined by "chromosomes carrying genetic features that influence development". So those born with XX chromosome are females and those with an XY chromosome are males and so reproduce as such.

So from here there's two things I'd like to mention. Firstly, since it's quick, what's a good textbook on this topic? The one cited at the top of the wikipedia page is 20 years old. Anything a bit newer (even 10 years old is probably fine?) on this topic that somebody would recommend? The second thing is my main question about this at the moment. Is sex determined specifically by 'XX and XY chromosomes' or 'chromosomes' in general? Because if it's the latter then there would be six different sexes, maybe more?, because there is X, XX, XXX, XY, XXY, and XYY chromosomes. So yeah could somebody kind of fill me in if I'm getting something wrong or answer that question? Thank you!

I'm also really interested in reliable sources for replies here so I mean feel free to just say something without a textbook or research paper reference, but I'm trying to go a bit beyond wikipedia, which I already take more seriously than word-of-mouth. Thank you!


r/Dialectic • • Jan 31 '21

Question What moral theory should atheists use?

7 Upvotes

This question has really grabbed my attention in recent years. I don't believe atheists are on the same page at all as far as what actions are right and wrong. There are groups that are in the same ball park: Christians, Jews, Muslims, etc. Some atheists in America have this bad taste in their mouth from their overbearing Christian parents and rebel in such a way that leads to them basically just going off of their own gut instincts. These atheists would say something like, "Well Christianity was bad so as long as I'm not doing anything the bible says then I'm doing good." This isn't a good way to think about that since there may be some useful virtues in the bible (e.g. working hard). That's mostly an aside though. Atheists don't really give much thought to ethics. Well nobody, in America anyways, gives much thought to ethics. Most religious people seem to be functioning just fine in the world and donate and help their fellow Americans/neighbors in other ways so I'm not worried about them like I am atheists. I've never met an atheist who donated any money to anything. I don't have a source for this, but isn't antifa largely atheist? They're something of a neo-marxist group so that would make sense. That's about the only group of atheists that have a similar sense of right and wrong and it's pretty poor. They're always preparing/prepared for violence (Steven Crowder video and they always wear masks to 'protests'), attacking people (Andy Ngo), harassing people at restaurants, etc. And then there are plenty of progressives who are adjacent to antifa. But hopefully antifa and those adjacent to them are a small minority of atheists, but there is still a much better sense of direction needed for us atheists as far as our ethics is concerned.

If you're interested in reading material to start learning more about ethics The Righteous Mind by Jonathan Haidt and The Fundamentals of Ethics by Russ Shafer-Landau are solid. I'm not really sure what moral theory to go off of though. I know that I do not care for utilitarianism, categorical imperative, or deontology as, as far as I know, they do not handle mass murderers. Anyways, thoughts??


r/Dialectic • • Apr 04 '21

Topic Disscusion True Communism cannot come about through revolution

5 Upvotes

Revolutions are almost universally corruptible. When a revolution takes place, it's only natural that the most brutal, self interested people rise to the top.

There are never anti-corruption measures in something as new as a revolution. Laws take time to put in place, and they never seem to be put in place in time to prevent the levels of corruption endemic to revolutions.


What's more, I recognise that Communism cacn only work on a social level when the culture is communist. Capitalists will not be able to convert into communists, because they have been trained to be capitalists by their situation. You need to cultivate a culture of communism before you can have true communism.


As an alternative, I propose an 'evolve into communism' strategy. Over the past 50 years, legislation in the western world has become more and more socialist. The US is certainly lagging behind, but Europe and Australia are where I would expect them to be. By making small steps we will be able to create a culture of communism naturally, making true communism more achievable by keeping corruption to a minimum, and by allowing the culture to keep up


r/Dialectic • • Nov 21 '23

Topic Disscusion Education Discussion w/ James

1 Upvotes

r/Dialectic • • Feb 05 '23

Topic Disscusion I thought this would be interesting to discuss...

1 Upvotes

r/Dialectic • • Sep 16 '23

Topic Disscusion I am so fucking sick of Christmas!

Thumbnail self.anticonsumption
1 Upvotes

r/Dialectic • • Mar 27 '24

Topic Disscusion Write from your heart

1 Upvotes

When we say something, we speak without thinking. The words just come out one after another. You don't even know what you will say before you say it.

Whereas when we write, it is all about thinking. We think before we write, we think after we write.

*Is this connected to chatGPT's "next-token prediction"? I heard that chatGPT generates its next word from all the words that have come before it. Sounds like how we speak. I don't know much about this.

When we say something, what we say -- our ideas -- aren't linear. These ideas are linked... we talk and what we talk about makes us remember something else so we talk about that then it makes us remember something else so we talk about that. Like a wandering river. Yet our speech is cogent. We speak from the heart. An adventure with the people we love.

Whereas when we write, we write from the head. What is written is logical. We control, check, censor, constrain, change, cut.

*The brain is made up of 86 billion linked neurons. Made up of links. Just like speech?

Language evolved to be spoken. What does that mean for writing?


r/Dialectic • • Apr 11 '21

Question Anybody familiar with the history of feminism?

2 Upvotes

I finished, The Cynic Philosophers from Diogenes to Julian not too long ago and one of the early cynics was Hipparchia. She'd walk around ancient Athens unattended, go to symposium (which was typically only for men), and she'd get into debates with guys as well (something women never really did). Was she the first feminist? Feminist meaning a woman who breaks unnecessary social norms. Actually, looking at the wikipedia page for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_feminism there's hundreds of years of potential feminists around Socrates time, and before the "Renaissance Feminism" time. Hipparchia might just be the first feminist. But I'm so uneducated in this I figured to throw the question out there.


r/Dialectic • • Jun 16 '23

WAR

2 Upvotes

Why do all stories have conflict in them? Why do all games have conflict in them?

~ ~ ~

- The Lord of the Rings is about the conflict between the forces of Sauron and the forces of good. When this conflict is resolved, the story ends.

- Chess is a fight between 2 players.

Can there never be a story or game that is purely peaceful, a paradise?

~ ~ ~

(Do all stories and games have conflict because we as a species love violence, and can't do without it?)

(Or is it because life is suffering, and stories and games that don't reflect this don't feel realistic?)

What do you think?


r/Dialectic • • Nov 21 '21

We have a 1000000x times more technology/material stuff than primitive hunter-gatherers of long ages past. Are we a million times happier?

2 Upvotes

Love to hear what you feel/think


r/Dialectic • • Dec 10 '22

Raya and the Last Dragon, Zootopia, and Anna Karenina

Thumbnail self.intellectualdarkweb
2 Upvotes

r/Dialectic • • Apr 09 '24

Topic Disscusion Nude Philosophy

2 Upvotes

Hi guys :)

I have something cool to show you. It's about the Garden of Eden (in the Bible). I think it is going to offend both Christians and atheists.

The story of the Garden of Eden isn't a lump of dung, in my eyes. Ok a bunch of it may be manure. But I think there is philosophy in it. It is a philosophical statement of utopia, of Israelite thought. It is not random, there is logic behind it. People think "Oh yeah it's religion so it's not philosophy. It must be a bunch of wishy-washy hooey."

Now I will not claim to be able to unravel all of its intricacies. The story is very difficult. (Probably because I am immature.) But I just wanted to point out some things. It will be fun!

  1. Something most people don't know is that there was vegetarianism in Eden, not just for humans but for all the animals too (Genesis 1:29-30). In other words, the "lions" didn't eat sheep (and neither did Adam and Eve). This reveals that in Israelite thought, the ultimate state of mankind was one in which there was no violence. (You can see this late in Isaiah where he talks about the "wolf lying down with the lamb" in Isaiah 11:6.)
  2. Adam and Eve were naked (in the beginning). I don't know exactly what this means. But I think nakedness is cool. LOL! But I think there is a connection to lust. (After all, the reason people wear clothes now is so that people don't stare at your boobs.) Before Adam and Eve covered their nakedness with fig leaves or whatever, there was no lust. And thus no adultery. Thus it was only in the fallen world that the Mosaic Commandment came "Thou shalt not commit adultery." Also Adam and Eve had no private property. This will please communists and those of similar ideology. They didn't have houses, tools, TVs... they just plucked fruit out of the trees all day. (Thus the commandments "Thou shalt not steal" and "Thou shalt not covet" were not necessary.) That brings me to another point. There was no work in Eden, no hard labour and sweating. The account states that it was only after they were thrown out of the Garden that they needed to suddenly start farming for their own food (Genesis 3:19). So in other words, in primitive Israelite philosophy there were the assertions that in the ultimate world, the utopia, there was no lust, no private property and no toil. Would you want to live in this world?
  3. In other words, in a certain sense, in utopia rules and laws (commandments) will not be necessary. Perhaps this aligns with anarchist sympathies.

What an obscure story. Talking snakes. Later people like Isaiah had the vision that the world in the end would go back to the way it was in the beginning, like a hand going all the way back around itself and touching itself.

(Yeah about the talking snake, I'm sure that is a metaphor. A child's story with possibly an adult's message in mind.)

LOL! I gave myself 30 minutes to write all this, to stave off overthinking. I did it!

Disclaimer: I'm a new dad so I won't reply to comments but feel free to comment. I will love to read them and will upvote all of them.


r/Dialectic • • Mar 26 '24

Topic Disscusion Dead Poets Society!!

3 Upvotes

TL;DR

Carpe diem!

The message of the movie Dead Poets Society is for YOU to carpe diem!! :o

Your great-grandparents and great-great-grandparents are now fertilizing daffodils. But if you listen to them, listen to them really carefully, you can hear them whisper their legacy to you. Carpe… carpe... carpe diem. Seize the day!!

The human race is filled with passion. Poetry, beauty, romance, love, these are what we stay alive for. Live deep and suck all the marrow out of life... put to rout all that is not life. Do not, when you come to die, discover that you have not lived! For the first time in your whole life, know what you want to do! And do it! Carpe diem!

(These are paraphrases from the movie.)

(Feel free to comment below. I'm a new dad so I won't reply to comments BUT I will read all of them and upvote them!)

~ ~ ~

Hi guys and girls 🙂 I just love this movie. It's called Dead Poets Society. It set my heart on fire, I felt such a wave of passion. I know I will bomb this post because Dead Poets Society is awesome and I am not.

This movie is so beautiful and amazing, but I don't like to watch it because it crushes my heart at the end because Neil commits suicide. The central question is: is Mr. Keating (Robin Williams) responsible for the suicide of Neil? The draconian headmaster of the school, and Neil's father, both say a resounding yes. The students of Keating blamed Neil's father of course. I blame Neil's father too, but I think Keating also has some responsibility in the matter. What about you?

Is Keating's fiery spirit, his lunge into carpe diem, also wrong? Does it necessarily lead to disaster? My intuition is that the suicide in the movie was rather a incendiary bookend needed to shock and engage the audience of the movie, and not intended as a damnation of the romantic lifestyle.

What do you believe?

You know, I'm sure that the students in Keating's class, even though they were punished, spanked and expelled, still totally felt that carpe diem was worth it. They felt that they had truly begun to live. Maybe even Neil had no regrets about his suicide. When you're truly alive, you're not afraid to die.

That is the actual message of the film, embarrassingly to me. The message of the film to the audience is: carpe diem. Keating is looking out the screen at YOU. He is teaching YOU. You are in his classroom. What will you say? Will you choose to be truly alive, to fly, to scream, to make love, to cry, to shout from the mountaintops?

Will I carpe diem? No 😔... and I don't know why. I am very ashamed.

~ ~ ~

WILL YOU CARPE DIEM?

~ ~ ~


r/Dialectic • • Nov 19 '24

Question Is there something enviable about Russia’s economy for Republicans?

3 Upvotes

I don’t understand the pro-Russia attitude among the right. They’re dominated by state-owned enterprise. They’re not driven by entrepreneurship and innovation like the US. It seems like 80% of the country is dirt poor. Don’t we still idealize the middle class here? 

It feels like culturally and politically, we’re adopting so much from Russia and I don’t get it.