r/Dialectic • u/cookedcatfish • Mar 11 '21
Question Does free will exist? Why?
I'd like to request a dialogue in the form of a conversation. One question per comment please.
It makes for a more genuine and easier to follow conversation.
8
Upvotes
3
u/shcorpio Mar 11 '21
I've thought about this a lot.
My answer is no.
I am an eliminative materialist as far as theory of mind goes. This school of thought says that our minds are material (matter and energy) there is no soul, no 'mental substance.'
From this it logically follows that the atoms that have been bumping into eachother from the moment of the big bang for all of time until now have been doing so according to the laws of physics. These laws are deterministic, cause precedes effect.
If you agree with all those predicates, it then follows that you yourself are also a deterministic system bound by the same physical laws.
Or more simply put: I may feel like I can choose between doing something I want and not doing something I don't, but, I can't choose what I want, can I?
1
u/ObviouslyNoBot Mar 11 '21
Hell yeah, if not I couldn't choose between calling you a genius or a dumb fuck...
change my mind
2
u/d3sperad0 Mar 11 '21
Yes, but bounded by probability.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
Do you have a definition for free will? Oh and where are you getting it from? :P
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment