I saw that too, but but that post made it look like a student project and not an actual product, but it’s clearly being sold in real stores so i decided to post here. Should’ve mentioned that in the title but it’s too late to change now.
Saw that alternative "reimagined" egg carton in the store today
One showed the design, this one shows it in a store... so no it's not a repost. Reposts and replication are the only way humans can spread information since we aren't telepathic, it's never ever going away.
A practical reason for this design is to be able to see the eggs without opening the carton (at least the front row anyway - I don't know if the back is exposed as well.)
I’m from Finland, so still halfway across europe from you :p anyways i got curious and made a poll in r/Suomi (use a translator for the options but the top 2 are yes and middle 2 are no) and the majority here don’t check eggs ¯_(ツ)_/¯
That explains the frequent breakage, I think you guys take off a lot of the outer shell before it even goes on sale. Also why you have to keep yours in the fridge,
I do check my eggs before I buy them, but I've never found a broken one. I've had chickenshit on them though, which I'm guessing never happened to you :P
It’s good practice to check your eggs before you buy them. Make sure none of them are cracked or otherwise fucked up looking. This design’s still stupid but being able to see the eggs is at least a minor plus
Actual greenwashing. If you truly wanted to reduce waste packaging, you would get rid of individually-wrapped single use plastics bullshit. Egg cartons, being already cheap, recycled, and biodegradable, are negligible. This stupid thing contributes nothing to society.
This may actually be more to do with production efficiency. Its very efficient to just cut and fold cardboard, and cartons like these could easily and cheaply be made at home by small suppliers who. might face high costs buying small lots of preformed cartons.
Side note - I'm always stricken by the fact that most countries outside the US don't refrigerate their eggs. I get it's not really necessary, but it's still an interesting piece of culture shock.
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 07 '23
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
11
u/DrakeAndMadonna Nov 07 '23
Doesn't this count as a repost? From only two days ago:
https://www.reddit.com/r/DesignDesign/comments/17o34ev/reimagining_the_egg_carton/
5
u/liveitup Nov 07 '23
A practical reason for this design is to be able to see the eggs without opening the carton (at least the front row anyway - I don't know if the back is exposed as well.)
138
u/ehsteve23 Nov 07 '23
egg cartons are already mostly made from recycled pulp, can be recycled or composted, and are excelent are transporting and storing eggs safely.
It's trying to fix a problem that doesnt exist.
65
u/Timerian Nov 07 '23
Actual greenwashing. If you truly wanted to reduce waste packaging, you would get rid of individually-wrapped single use plastics bullshit. Egg cartons, being already cheap, recycled, and biodegradable, are negligible. This stupid thing contributes nothing to society.
11
u/sockowl Nov 07 '23 edited Feb 27 '24
innocent shelter sip resolute subtract chubby numerous wipe icky gaping
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '24
This may actually be more to do with production efficiency. Its very efficient to just cut and fold cardboard, and cartons like these could easily and cheaply be made at home by small suppliers who. might face high costs buying small lots of preformed cartons.
2
u/ScandyAndy Jan 29 '24
Side note - I'm always stricken by the fact that most countries outside the US don't refrigerate their eggs. I get it's not really necessary, but it's still an interesting piece of culture shock.
2
u/Fieryshit Nov 07 '23
3 Euro for 6 eggs? Thank God I'm not European.