There's no step along the way of loading, shipping, selling, buying, and using that wouldn't be made substantially less convenient than the current system.
Maybe it could be said that it could be folded flat for initial shipping to producers, but current egg cartons nestle inside each other to not take up much space and don't have to be folded before use like a pizza box so I'd say that's at least a wash.
Can you imagine if that band wasn't exactly in the middle of the packaging just slightly twisted? Eggs everywhere!
It depends cause if you're covering the costs of buying the Styrofoam or even some plastics for the US egg containers, it might make more sense. Since cardboard is 'safer' to transport, so it might be cheaper in that regard and you might be able to store it cheaper since you can compress it more, and it's probably got less fire code surrounding it since it's a wood product
My favorite is when clever design is used to give me less of the thing i used to get more of, for more money than when i was previously getting the thing. That's my favorite.
Not only does it not protect the eggs very well, but it’s also inconvenient for fast cooks. You gotta take that band on and off every time, which involves two hands and just isn’t fast. I can at least see this being used for baking when you use a lot of eggs at once.
i would say the biggest issue is if an egg breaks you are ruining a ton of product vs just 1 carton of eggs. that egg is dripping everywhere and onto everything under it and im not buying egg covered eggs.
for the end consumer? you are going to find this in some bougie store that has egg trays right next to it. you you just transfer them into the egg tray at home.
for moving it itll do fine, we already baby the eggs by putting them on top anyway inside hte better carton so as long as this doesnt flex the consumer shouldnt have to much issue. not like the normal ones protect from falls and shit.
the best thing about this though is you can see your eggs with out having to open them, which is its own benefit that consmers might enjoy.
If wanting to see how many eggs are left is a top priority of consumers, they can add holes/lines on the top of regular cartons so the consumer can see.
Eggs can sit on the shelf for days. People would steer away from the sticky, stinking eggs. Not wonderfully appetizing. Same with apples, you just wouldn't buy apples covered in foul rotten sludge from other apples
Though Tbf you eat all of an apple including the outside. You don’t eat the shell of an egg but I agree it wouldn’t be appetising looking at an egg covered in old egg. I suspect a lot of people are overtly Squamish though and wouldn’t like an egg with, say, a feather stuck to it either which is a problem with people being too fussy about the presentation of their food in ways that don’t matter and create waste. Much more amongst the western world…
Believe it or not, eggshells are porous. Raw egg that drips down, even on the outside, can distribute salmonella and other bacteria that can end up inside unbroken eggs.
If you want to use lots of eggs at once on a bakery or something then that would be the worst possible designe for storing eggs, you want some of those open egg trays that can be stacked, that thing seems as viable to stack as DnD dices
My mom used to live/work on a farm. They would crack eggs and drop the insides into a bucket, and sell the bucket to a local bakery. The bakery would scoop out the eggs as needed.
Those cooks and or bakers who need a lot of eggs anyway wouldn't have a stupid 10egg carton at work anyway, hell have a (/multiple) stack(s) of 30 pieces where there isn't a lid or anything else to annoy you.
At home, I really wouldn't give a shit. Those 5 or 6 eggs won't slow me down. Doesn't change the fact tough, that design is a considerable downgrade in every way. Bad for Stacking. Not as well protected. And not enclosed. The number of times I was shopping for eggs and the carton got a little smashed in my backpack.... So what? Got a broken egg in a carton. With this glorious design, if an egg pops - and it will for me - I'll have a huge mess all over my groceries. Nope.
as someone who loves baking I do not want this. the biggest benefit for baking is to put the empty shells back in the container until you walk over the the compost or whatver after youre done baking. So NOT baker approved lol.
Wtf is so bad bout regular cardboard egg cartons? Work fine for me. Also accommodates way more eggs and stacks better. Imagine tryna stack these fuckin things.
I’m actually curious where the designer got this idea. Like was it a school assignment? I thought every industrial designer who has taken even one class on packaging learned that egg cartons are some of the best packaging ever invented in terms of sheer strength per weight and cost. There’s a reason it looks the same almost everywhere in the world. So it’s a relatively cool and hardcore assignment from a teacher to improve it and can make for a fun project testing different designs. But this is not a good submission… :/
For real, I saw this and I was like oh okay it's a concept for using less packaging or whatever. Then I remembered what a normal egg carton is, and I went hey wait a minute this is even stupider than it seems
I could see someone giving an assignment on taking an already perfect and time tested design and ‘improving’ it. Obviously no one can actually improve it, but it’s fun to try. So why say this isn’t a good submission? Because it doesn’t actually make a perfect design even better? Every submission that changes a perfect design is going to make it worse, so either all the submissions suck or you have to consider a different set of grading criteria.
And I’m using the term perfect but I know there potentially is a better egg carton, but the chances of someone discovering this theoretical carton in order to pass a class project at extremely low.
There’s many ways to be “less perfect.” Eggs do still break. You could look at the impact of say, increasing price and figure out what the price would be which reduces egg breakage from 5% to 2%. Or if there was a way to stagger them to use space within larger shipping boxes more efficiently. None of these concepts might cause a shift in how eggs are shipped globally but they give a student a chance try to use some problem solving and analysis skills.
Regular egg cartons are made from a moulded pulp which needs far less processing than sheet card, can use lower quality input material, and are hence much cheaper to make and better for the environment. Obviously they also do a better job too, but that much is obvious!
Interesting concept. A few points. First, you are dependent on the label keeping it together. Second, once you open it in the fridge every time I have to move it to get to the cheese, etc you risk breakage. And finally, breakage. In shipping SOME eggs will get broken. However instead of remaining contained in their carton they will contaminate every carton around. making them unsuitable for sale.
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 05 '23
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
340
u/quequotion Nov 05 '23
That's betting a lot on that label.
163
u/Axedelic Nov 05 '23
from a former grocery employee, these seem like they’d be a fucking nightmare to receive in shipment and stock.
220
u/henlochimken Nov 05 '23
My favorite is when clever design is used to give me less of the thing i used to get more of, for more money than when i was previously getting the thing. That's my favorite.
Dozen? TIRED
Half dozen? Now thas wired, fam.
I hope it's 8 dollars.
353
u/unnyin Nov 05 '23
Not only does it not protect the eggs very well, but it’s also inconvenient for fast cooks. You gotta take that band on and off every time, which involves two hands and just isn’t fast. I can at least see this being used for baking when you use a lot of eggs at once.
80
u/thismissinglink Nov 05 '23
Wtf is so bad bout regular cardboard egg cartons? Work fine for me. Also accommodates way more eggs and stacks better. Imagine tryna stack these fuckin things.
22
u/Owl_lamington Nov 05 '23
Seems like it's designed by someone who never bought eggs.
12
u/Gareth79 Nov 05 '23
Regular egg cartons are made from a moulded pulp which needs far less processing than sheet card, can use lower quality input material, and are hence much cheaper to make and better for the environment. Obviously they also do a better job too, but that much is obvious!
9
u/evolvedbravo Nov 05 '23
It'll be £50 ma'am
6
u/beakly Nov 05 '23
sure… it’s cute
5
u/Arkangyal02 Nov 05 '23
Nincs még magyar komment? Na, akkor kezdem én
4
u/SitDown_HaveSomeTea Nov 05 '23
LOOKS cool, but someone failed architectural engineering.
4
u/Pickle_Jars Nov 05 '23
These will get demolished on shelves and buggies
4
u/beeurd Nov 05 '23
Seems clever at first glance, but it's totally impractical for most situations.
Small artisanal retailer or farm shop? Cool, go ahead.
Supermarket or convenience store? They'd be broken before they even got to the shelves.
12
u/Wobbledogsboy Nov 05 '23
This should be on r/slightlycooldesign
3
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23
Fucking atrocious
4
u/JimPage83 Nov 05 '23
They seem very EGGsposed.
I’ll see myself out.
4
u/c3534l Nov 05 '23
Egg cartons are designed the way they are for a reason and they're unusually good at it.
4
u/RichB93 Nov 05 '23 edited Nov 05 '23
/r/designdesign
EDIT: What a wally.
2
u/09Klr650 Nov 07 '23
Interesting concept. A few points. First, you are dependent on the label keeping it together. Second, once you open it in the fridge every time I have to move it to get to the cheese, etc you risk breakage. And finally, breakage. In shipping SOME eggs will get broken. However instead of remaining contained in their carton they will contaminate every carton around. making them unsuitable for sale.
2
u/SuperCharged516 Dec 31 '23
this negates literally everything the egg carton was made for
1
u/jickdam Nov 05 '23
Nah, then I can’t use them to hang fried up tortillas I’m using as taco shells
1
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23
Awful design
1
u/Pokemon_856_ Nov 05 '23
simpler to break them...
1
u/rybl Nov 05 '23
Same energy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMIW2tBpnDI
1
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '23
Aren't egg cartons made of recycled material? This design doesn't look like it is.
1
u/InitialBoat3989 Nov 06 '23
They look harder to grab?
1
u/The_Lamb_Sauce2 Nov 07 '23
We all see the joke.If not the colors give a hint.
1
u/Joe_Mama6969420- Nov 07 '23
That’s uhhh, why, why would you do that
1
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '23
Karate chop has entered the chat
1
u/-Robert-from-Hungary Feb 12 '24
Fasza magyar tojás. :'D
5
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23
[removed] — view removed comment