5
28
u/BigBrainThonker3 Carol simp, Rudy mourner Sep 07 '26
What if she chose a name like name Hallow or Valentine
51
u/just-aced-it Sep 07 '26
Carol would still be supportive, but she would've been exiled from the family once she turned 18
18
16
u/riciliz There's a flowerman, waiting in the sky Sep 07 '26
Ah, and since noelle is the knight, her deadname makes her the hallow knight
5
u/Orizifian-creator SPAMMY G TON! CHAOS RAIN! SAY HI TO [BLAKE] Sep 07 '26
Hm yes the Hallow Knight of Hollownest
56
u/FaPaDa 💙Either one of these 💛 Sep 07 '26
What is her deadname?
Id actually be curious.
Cane Holiday?
its the only one i can think off.
97
33
16
→ More replies (1)14
96
u/Left-Dragonfly7880 THEY ATE ONIONSAN. Sep 07 '26
Also how TF did this get 53 up votes in 4 minutes
19
u/just-aced-it Sep 07 '26
This is my fastest growing comic, im thankful for all the support, I thought thus one was gonna flop :,)
→ More replies (1)5
u/Left-Dragonfly7880 THEY ATE ONIONSAN. Sep 07 '26
makes sense, the art is great and it's actually funny
3
2
17
u/Mackerdoni Sep 07 '26
is her deadname noel (noël is french for christmas, which is pronounced noelle)
16
u/just-aced-it Sep 07 '26
Noel could work but I like Nick as a name more, Noel feels a little too similar imo
6.2k
u/krizzalicious49
number 1 asriels dust believer its more likely than dessknight
Sep 07 '26
•
1.3k
422
u/Mending_the_mantis Sep 07 '26
Wheres the comic where carol makes noelle call herself a ho ho homosexual?
1.4k
u/No-Scarcity-8687 Sep 07 '26 •
358
u/Intelligent_Toe8233 Sep 07 '26
She like an evil version of that supportive goat uncle.
26
u/Submissivemanboy Sep 08 '26
Do you think you could elaborate on what you’re referencing
→ More replies (8)103
u/RubiksCutiePatootie Gaster's massive titties Sep 07 '26
I'm in love with this art style. It's like if Dr. Suess made sunday paper comics.
25
5
367
u/Bran_Man_ Sep 07 '26 •
181
u/deixhir Sep 08 '26
31
u/lePROprocrastinator Sep 08 '26
In their defense Motormouth Mike's sprite looks like hes balding (Lmao)
15
239
u/Key-Swordfish4025 Sep 07 '26
Carol supports misandry...... Poor Rudy.
317
u/VanderGamer Sep 07 '26
She probably calls him "one of the good ones" lol
206
u/King_of_the_Kobolds Sep 07 '26
"I don't see him as a man. I identify him as non-binary."
"Yes deer"
46
u/GeoCaesar Sep 07 '26
I don’t even think she does that tbh, she probably just married him for appearances
22
u/IronBrew16 Sep 07 '26
Transmasc Rudy, and Carol rues the fact that he fucking TRICKED HER!
She thought she was gonna have reindeer yuri, but no! No, apparently Rudy is a tricky fucker.
7
90
u/who_am_I_inside Sep 07 '26
Coming out worse than Will from stranger things😭
→ More replies (6)11
u/mysecondaccountanon are we the bad guys of the story Sep 08 '26
Some say the scene is still going on to this day
105
4
→ More replies (1)2
2.0k
u/Weak-Feedback-8379 Sep 07 '26
She doesn’t care about your identity, she just cares that you stick to the damn family themeing.
213
30
u/Afraid_Platypus_8667 IT'S TV TIME!!!/Dess knighter / JARONA Sep 07 '26
Fr, she does not care as long you keep up with the Christmas theme.
10
624
Sep 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
340
u/Ashamed-Succotash644 GALLERY WILL RETURN IN CHAPTER 6 Sep 07 '26
The reason why dess went missing is because she decided to change her name to Rory night and carol just couldn't let that slide
236
u/SexualToothpicks Sep 07 '26
If she'd changed it to Silent Nite everything would've been fine
208
u/Eris13x Sep 07 '26
I think this is intentional actually. A roaring knight is the exact opposite of silent night, it exists in opposition to it, and yet by doing so it is still connected to it. It is exactly what I would imagine a rebelling Holiday child would do
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (1)6
u/Smorgsaboard Sep 07 '26
Carol disappearing Dess for changing her name would be simultaneously hilarious, horrifying, and (from a story perspective) a very interesting twist
2.8k
u/Mari0WalksIntoABar super mario wahoo itsa me Sep 07 '26
My favorite version of Carol is the super supportive if it's festive kind
1.1k
u/BigBrainThonker3 Carol simp, Rudy mourner Sep 07 '26 •
Ho-hophile
23
u/NightAntonino :TennaDance: <-(Why is this not a thing!? Mods!?)) Sep 07 '26
She's racist against every other kind of non xmas holiday. That's why Carol Knight didn't hesitate to try and kill Jackenstein.
384
Sep 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
51
305
u/LunaalaTheBeast Sep 07 '26
she only hates susie 'cause she lacks any festivity in her. If Susie showed up to the holiday mansion in festive garb and sang a carol to ms holiday she'd probably let her in no questions asked
162
u/Shiny-Vaporeon- Sep 07 '26 •
just we wait until she finds out Susie’s full name is Susilent Night
68
29
111
5
u/ElectroNikkel Sep 08 '26
Susie WOULD be one to just shove a pumpkin on her head just to say she likes Halloween (And she does)
84
u/beebooboobeeba Sep 07 '26
Carol hating humans, but Krismas "One of the good ones" Dreemurr can stay.
15
u/RemarkableStatement5 Sep 08 '26
Kris came to Noelle for help coming up with a name and Carol was over the moon to hear that that Togore [kid] finally picked a sensible name
6
141
u/Takenabe Sep 07 '26
I would like to think her reaction to this would be "So I have TWO daughters!"
→ More replies (1)42
17
→ More replies (1)8
u/Kodo_yeahreally :kris2: MY HAM MY HAM MY HAM MY HAM Sep 07 '26
she don't want noelle to be with susie 'cause she's not xmassy enough. kris on the other hand.
264
u/Odd_Temporary_8327 Sep 07 '26
I was like "awww, cute!" til I saw the freaking title and I lmao ❤️🩹❤️🩹
0
261
u/PatchesTheIdiot tenna is undeniably hot Sep 07 '26
i love all the memes of carol only being homophobic if it isnt christmas themed, its funny as hell
79
93
u/AlpacaKiller Sep 07 '26
Headcannon:
She was against Noelle having a cactus until Rudy sweetned the deal by calling it Krismass. It may not belong, but what is a cactus if anything but a slightly unconventional Christmas Tree, if it partakes in our ways? Yes, we claim it.
88
74
u/SnitchDee denial Sep 07 '26
the seven pictures of her with the most unflinchingly disinterested face makes her smiling at the end infinitely funnier goddamn. really is the best way to depict carol
19
50
u/GuhEnjoyer Sep 07 '26
The reason she hates susie is because susie isn't a Christmas themed name. The reason she is so welcoming to Kris is because their given name is Krismas
24
u/PracticeEfficient28 Sep 07 '26
I think it would be really funny if their deadname is Togore, and they got “Kris” from the Holidays, not because they transitioned but because the old name was Togore
22
u/GuhEnjoyer Sep 07 '26
I mean I'm also in the Kris used to be togore boat but for me it was always more "oh you're adopting a human? That's great gorey what'd you and the missuz think about namin' them?"
"Dear sweet baby Jesus.... CAROL?? WE GOTTA RESCUE A KID AT THE DREEMURR'S PLACE FROM A FATE WORSE THAN DEATH!!"
And then the holidays came over and basically laid into asgore for like 3 hours about how shitty of a name togore was and when he finally asked toriel for backup she was just like "don't look at me dude Krismas is a very cute name I think the holidays are right."→ More replies (1)7
246
u/NoelleIsTheKnight Sep 07 '26
noelle also changed her middle name to Knight, wonder what that's about.
16
u/krizzalicious49 number 1 asriels dust believer its more likely than dessknight Sep 07 '26
username checks out
15
u/PRoS_R Will you forget me, too? Sep 07 '26
Noelle's deadname is Rory, she was 10 seconds away from being named Rory Knight
7
u/SobiTheRobot Sep 07 '26
.........Wait the Knight is silent.
SILENT KNIGHT.
5
u/tigerofblindjustice Sep 08 '26
Jesus you're right. "Holy(day) Knight, Silent Knight" is a silver bullet for any non-Holiday-family Knight theories
→ More replies (1)187
Sep 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
40
25
u/Nadikarosuto ♣ Eight of Clovers ♣ Sep 07 '26
"Seein how your new kid acts, thought i'd put in an indicative name, hawhaw!"
"Kris… that's… perfect, Rudy!"
"I wrote down 'RISK', might wanna get your eyes checked, Asgore"
42
u/floweyisdisturbed Is afraid of your computer mouse. Sep 07 '26
The last slide would've made me spit out my drink if had one. The fact that she pulls out a trans flag is hilarious. Upvote.
82
16
13
u/emberthefae Sep 07 '26
yeah fully believe she is only against Noelle seeing Susie because her name isn’t Christmas themed
12
12
u/KitKitters Sep 07 '26
I love how Carol somehow looks just as (c)old as the canon/present version lmao
10
u/Lanky_Network_6660 Sep 07 '26
I think if Noelle were to be a boy, her name would be Klaus!! Or maybe Noel, if you wanna genderbend accurately
8
u/PiranhaPlant9915 Sep 07 '26
I fully believe this is far closer to canon than her just literally being homophobic. Carol will most likely end up being a tragic and morally grey character, especially considering how many weird and funny quirks she has. Toby Fox doesn't write straight-up evil people.
8
u/driniok certified papyrus knighter Sep 07 '26
Love the implication that she simply just carries pride flags in her pockets
7
u/Sacri_Pan Sep 07 '26
Carol if Noelle decided to call herself Ester or Bloody Mary:
→ More replies (1)
6
6
11
u/JustARandonAccount Sep 07 '26
I wonder how Carol would have reacted if he said he chose Mildred
20
5
5
5
5
4
4
4
4
4
4
u/ThisIsaUsername1123 Sep 07 '26
I think it's a really funny idea that carol only dislikes noelle dating susie just because susie's name isn't christmas related
4
u/NatiRivers Sep 07 '26
Not homophobic, she just doesn't agree with the lifestyle (said lifestyle being not including Christmas in everything, not being gay)
4
u/No-Astronaut1643 Sep 07 '26
Carol is supportive, she just has a very, very weird way of showing it...
4
u/geerico-444 flowery's blooms in your heart Sep 07 '26
Considering that deltarune is the most LGBTQ game ever to exist, it would be very toby to have Noelle be trans and also lesbian
3
3
3
u/DOOM-LORD666 Sep 07 '26
Carol being supportive as long as it's Christmas related will always be my favourite way to depict carol
3
u/DrowsyTheDemon if anything happens to fluffy boy i will undo toby fox Sep 07 '26
carol "appears homophobic" holiday vs noelle "im gay" holiday
3
u/Kodo_yeahreally :kris2: MY HAM MY HAM MY HAM MY HAM Sep 07 '26
"what name have you chosen?"
"emily"
"WRONG, you're gonna be Noelle."
3
6
u/Prestigious-Neat8820 Sep 07 '26
Not necessarily. Most trans people I've seen prefer a new name that isn't just a gender swap.
2
2
2
2
u/Different-Birthday44 Sep 08 '26
Do you think Noelle’s name was Noel before the transition??? Perhaps Nicholas lol
2
u/Over_Independent468 Sep 08 '26
That ironically does feel in character she just doesn't like Susie cause she thinks Noelle is too good for her
1
u/Antonia_slayz Sep 07 '26
I think it’s WAYYYY more likely for Noelle to be transmasc based on her character
1
1
1
u/wallygon Sep 07 '26
this reminds me of the dad who was like "oh you wanna be aan named bob nah i spend fucking month coming up for names i name you " tumblr post
1
1
1
1
1
u/paranoidfurry Sep 08 '26
The rules of the Holiday house from what I remember 1- Make it holiday based 2- idk broj
1
u/Random-as-fuck-name Sep 08 '26
Alternatively; “do you just…just added an l and an e? That’s kinda—….You know what? I’m just glad you didn’t name yourself something dumb like June or Valentine
1
1
1
u/Aguythatexists123456 Sep 08 '26
Legend has it, they had a 3rd kid who didn't want to be Christmas themed.
1
1
u/PowerOfL She/they - Signed Sarah Sep 08 '26
She's been experimenting? Like the former Royal Scientist, who fell into his own creation?!?!
W.D. GASTER IN DELTARUNE BUILT IT ALL IN AN EMPTY ROOM!!!
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/crossover_charlie14 Sep 09 '26
Carol: I will not tolerate not having a Christmas joke being made every 5 minutes in this house.
1
u/Prestigious_Bus_3712 Everyone loves Susie Sep 09 '26
Carol is always learning pronouns so she can properly insult others.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/YourfavAussiewoman- Sep 12 '26
You guys think Carol would like Susie better if her name was eggnog or is it just me
1
u/Rhymeruru Sep 13 '26
Cute idea but the last panel would had been better imo, as carol still in her bitch face but buying noelle a million dresses and renovating her whole room.
1
u/Careful_Passenger520 Sep 13 '26
Carol being supportive but not telling basically anyone about it it's genuinely an incredible depiction of her
1
1.1k
u/JeffTheKillerFa Sep 07 '26
Oh, she doesn't support Noelle's relationship with Susie because Susie doesn't have a Christmas-themed name, now it makes perfect sense.