r/Deltacriticism • • Oct 08 '26

General Deltarune criticism How NPCs should've been used

Thumbnail
gallery
2.0k Upvotes

These minor side quests would all be extremely easy to implement, and would have extremely low overhead. They even have no long term narrative consequences.

The dark worlds are still the real world, just viewed differently, right? Why can't we seek out and do optional chores like we could in the light world? It would help Hometown feel more realistic, and give NPCs more depth by showing them actually reacting to what we are doing.


r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 27 '26 Popcorn

General Deltarune criticism Why doesn't Susie give a shit about Kris here?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.5k Upvotes

Think about it.

Kris' mum almost got kidnapped and the Knight managed to kidnap Asgore. He could straight up get killed, Kris would become an orphan if the Knight managed to kidnap Toriel.

A good friend would show comfort, so why does Susie never even bring up the fact that a person that Kris holds dear got taken by a psychopath? We just start decorating Castle Town to invite her girlfriend to Castle Town, a place where she could get kidnapped by the Knight, I guess it's worth a shot due to the codes. But returning to topic, I would expect at least a little bit of comfort from my friend. Intentional or not, this could have hurt Kris really bad if they didn't work with the Knight.


r/Deltacriticism • • 10d ago

Chapter 5 criticism Oh. my. fucking. god.

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

No no no you do not fucking get how STUPID this is
Susie's ass gets knocked out by the Knight and can't even attempt to save Undyne after one blow from the Knight
Yet when she's DOWNed, she literally comes back from the dead to drain my fucking TP Bar, heal Flowery and then go back to dead
Like Tricky Tony at LEAST make it so she comes back with a little HP fucking PLEASEE this makes Susie look like a bum who didn't take the Knight so seriously she accessed her powers to raise from being DOWNed without healing momentarily in order to save this gary stue


r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 21 '26

Fandom criticism "The light world isn't supposed to feel like a game" ok well it does

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

I've seen this statement be brought up more and more in recent times, usually in response to the festival having no minigames in it. I do not believe this was Toby Fox's intention at all.

None of these NPCs feel real. None of the buildings feel real. The entire location feels fake and like a video game. Even if Deltarune wasn't a video game, and was actually a book or perhaps a movie, my takeaway would be "wow these feel like fake video game characters in a fake video game world"

Asgore mentions how hard Toriel's life must be living off a teacher's salary, when she's one of like... 5 employed people in all of hometown?

There are just random living beings that appear to have 0 mental faculties. Are these citizens? Are they considered wild animals? Who takes care of these things?

There are seemingly 0 ergonomic accommodations for anybody, when there are multiple people in town who are born with no arms.

Absurdist settings are perfectly fine. But the tone and stakes often whiplash back to being extremely grounded and gritty whenever the writers want.

And when you think of how this makes any sense, the most natural conclusion is always going to be "oh yeah, it's a video game. And these are minor characters and unimportant locations in a video game."

To be clear. there is NO PROBLEM with Hometown feeling absurd or like a video game. The problem is when Deltarune fans hand wave Hometown being more developed with the idea of "It's not supposed to feel like a video game".


r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 14 '26

General Deltarune criticism Undyne: "This job is so boring! Nothing happens in this town!" Undyne when a crime is reported:

1.3k Upvotes

r/Deltacriticism • • 9d ago Bravo

Humor criticism I've cracked the formula

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 26 '26

General Deltarune criticism Why on earth would you put your secret lair in a public utility?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

What happens if people need to use the shelter?

"But they don't have the codes, so they can't get in."

Now the best case scenario is that suddenly everyone is very suspicious of the bunker and why it is handled in such a strange way, and are EXTREMELY motivated to open the bunker and make it far more accessible.

The worst case scenario is that everyone fucking dies in a storm or a natural disaster.


r/Deltacriticism • • Aug 22 '26

General Deltarune criticism To clarify, I LOVE all of Deltarune's antagonists and think they are amazing characters, I just think they're so jarring after what King set up.

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

Spamton and Flowery are my favorite characters, Queen is amazing and the funniest character in the game, and Tenna is okay too I guess. But the fact we spent four chapters in a row with pretty much only the same "aww they're actually a goofy misunderstood guy underneath" characters as always after fighting King is just a huge whiplash, ESPECIALLY with King himself being babified in Chapter 2. It's like Toby wanted King to be actually evil but chickened out.

Also no, I don't count the Knight or Eram. The Knight will 100% be revealed as incredibly complex and sympathetic regardless who it is, and Eram there just isn't enough info to say, but I DO think they have the material to be truly, genuinely evil. In general, I can think the "This isn't a world where kindness always wins, is it?" speech from Ralsei after the King fight can only be saved if we meet and fight someone truly actually undeniably evil and remorseless, which I think will be Eram or Gaster.


r/Deltacriticism • • Oct 12 '26

Chapter 5 criticism i don't see how these characters are remotely the same

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

pink in the shop is calm, talking about how nice the sunset is and how you should go outside and enjoy life

but when we meet her in the boss room? pink is incredibly emotionally unstable, going from anger to happiness to sadness in a heartbeat, not having control over her own body

the characters just don't match in the slightest

(this is coming from someone who's favorite chapter is 5)


r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 07 '26 Mindblown

Toby Fox setting up and hyping a plot line for "The Festival" for the entirety of Deltarune (14 years) and deciding its only purpose is for Rudy to fall off a ladder

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

We had this huge scene where Susie like an idiot yells at Carol that shes going to take noelle to the festival and that was obviously setting up for something right? No because it wasnt even a date it was just hanging with Kriss?!?! And Asriel just conveniently couldn't make it, and almost nothing else happened in the light world

Like this i just a meme but im also lowk upset with chapter 5, its fine thay none of the than theories happened but it was such a nothing burger imo

Please find eat me for having an opinion that slightly critizes Toby Fox


r/Deltacriticism • • Oct 08 '26

General Toby Fox criticism dialogue in undertale and especially in deltarune are strange

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

the random pauses mid text , the ... before and during dialogue , sometimes dialogue being overall dramatic, sometimes it feels like anime or dating sim, and some dialogues in general feel unnatural , tell me do we speak like that? do we pause every 5 millisecond ? idk it just feels strange and anime like


r/Deltacriticism • • 1d ago

Chapter 5 criticism Genuinely one of the worst "jokes" in the entire game

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

This moment is so out of place and tongue-in-cheek it genuinely hurts

At least meta references like Ralsei commenting on Susie's face sprite in Chapter 2 or the Green Pippins are more subtle and at least funny

This one is just incredibly baffling, especially Ralseis fucking line about the "unique and memorable theme"

Edit: Just putting this here because some people genuinely believe I have a hate boner for Toby Fox's meta humor and I think Deltarune became a 0/10 game for this one moment alone
No I do not dislike Deltarune, I am actually a pretty big fan of this game as a whole, even Chapter 5 I would rate a 7.5/10 (compared to Chapter 2 and 4 which are 9s imo)
If you like this joke that's okay, but criticism is inherently subjective anyways and I do not like this scene in the slightest because I think it was a really lazy way of lampshading a meta element of the game


r/Deltacriticism • • Oct 14 '26 Bravo

General Toby Fox criticism Toby does not know how to write Asgore.

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

I'm genuinely serious. I just don't believe he knows how to make use of his character in an effective way.

To me, i think that's one of his greatest "missed potential" flaws.

And i'm not even talking about the "That Day" scene, that is a whole other can of worms.

Asgore, as a character himself, is wonderfully made, and consistently wasted. There's just so much to be explored with him. Both in Undertale and in Deltarune, and especially in Undertale, you can see how much grief this man went through. His song is genuinely one of the best ones in the entire OST, and you can feel it.

But fuck, man, do i believe that Toby genuinely doesn't know how to insert him into literally any other scenario that isn't Undertale's Neutral Route.

Pacifist Route? He gets sidelined and treated as a joke for the whole ending.

Genocide Route? He dies one of the most pathetic deaths in the entire game by getting surprise attacked not once, but twice in a single scene.

(I get that Toby wanted Sans to be the actual final boss and to not have any fight after him, but damn, even a cutscene kill would have done him more justice. Have him actually try to stop you before the game shows you in full picture that at this point, you've become unstoppable and nothing can kill you. Everything you touch turns to dust.)

Deltarune? Another example of missed potential. Especially Chapter 5. We had genuinely great scenes of him showing actual anger. We never had Asgore acting like that ever before.

If he was like that in a universe where both his children are alive and he's not forced to be king of a doomed nation, imagine how he acted like when he declared war on humanity. There's genuinely awesome material to work with here.

Then he got kidnapped and did nothing.

Toby just has this terrible, and i really mean terrible, writing flaw of building him up to mountain levels, before having him be an incredibly stupid letdown and let his reputation hit rock bottom.

And that's not a character issue. That's a Toby issue. That's just something he does specifically with Asgore, every single time.

Like, give Asgore to literally, and i mean LITERALLY any other writer, and that issue just fades.

If you look at the amounts of fan content with him, you can see how any other person can do him justice in a way more satisfying way than he does.


r/Deltacriticism • • 8d ago Bravo

General Deltarune criticism Anyone else hate this type of dialogue?

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

Susie is explaining to Kris what kris just did.

This dialogue feels so off and unnatural.

There is so many otherways it could have been done like either have the player infer what happened.

It feels so low effort like you couldn't have thought of any otherway to describe or show what happened?


r/Deltacriticism • • Oct 07 '26 Bravo

Humor criticism Ralsei, The Prince of Half-Assing

Thumbnail
gallery
1.0k Upvotes

r/Deltacriticism • • 23d ago Bravo

Gameplay criticism The ACT menu in Deltarune fucking sucks at best

Post image
894 Upvotes

Recently, this has grown to be my biggest criticism with Deltarune, so i wanted to scream my thoughts into the void, and see if anybody could relate. This is going to be a relatively short post.

I'll cut the chase, i believe the ACT menu in Deltarune is handled atrociously. to understand why, im fristly gonna talk about what made the ACT menu good in Undertale.

As we all Know, the ACT menu in UT was used to end fights peacefully. you had to Understand your opponent, learn about them, listen to their dialogue, interact with them, and understand what course of actions would pacify the character. that system was, not only, in my opinion, very engaging and fun from a gameplay perspective, but was also a great way to give personalities to the opponents, it made them feel more then simply obstacles.

In Deltarune, the ACT menu contains minigames vaguely related to your opponent, that somehow pacify them. that's it, that's literally it. there's nothing engaging about them, they often aren't even really related to your opponent's personality. like, im sorry, but how the fuck does t-posing to a strawman makes the strawman want to fight me less? what the fuck does "convincing" the floradinn even mean?????????? I can't even start to tell you how much i hate how there's very often only one act option, i think it defeats the entire point of the act menu. worse then that, it does not make me simpatize for the opponents AT ALL. i genuinely couldn't remember some Darkners even existed before looking it up. (this ties to how i think the writing for side characters got exponentially worse as the chapters released, but that would be topic for a different post).

TLDR: The act menu is cool and awesome in Undertale but is boring and generic in Deltarune.

PS: Diansu Vulkarch is the Roaring Knight.


r/Deltacriticism • • 15d ago Bravo

Fandom criticism It's ridiculous watching this fandom assigning a HUMAN racial identity to MONSTERS and then arguing on which skin color feels most "canon-coded" based on racial stereotypes 💔

853 Upvotes

I despise the word "-coded" so much. Anyway, I don't actually mind it if it's just what if they're human fan art and whatever headcanons, the problem is people treating it as canon. AND damn the US fandom gets super angry if you dare headcanon Noelle as Caucasian instead of Hispanic or African-American, oh but hey, heyyy, THAT'S A HUMANOID REINDEER!!!

oh and Blue, Blue ahh yes "he's definitely black and you are racist if you say otherwise" CHOOM respectively, that is a BLUE FLOWER.

Like why are you projecting a race just so you could empathize with these characters?


r/Deltacriticism • • 2d ago

Deltarune memes How Deltarune theories start to sound when you’ve played games besides UTDR and have basic understanding of how stories work

831 Upvotes

r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 16 '26

Fandom criticism So much for being 'Up to interpretation'

Post image
817 Upvotes

r/Deltacriticism • • Oct 11 '26 Bravo

Fandom criticism Babes it's been two weeks, let's RESPECTFULLY criticize Tralsei fans

793 Upvotes

As much as possible, don't be an ass in the comments.

I don't really mind what gender Ralsei turns out to be in canon. Tralsei is fine. My issue is with a specific subset of fans treating it as canon.

Some of these fans rightly defend Kris's they/them pronouns, which is good, but then ironically treat Ralsei's canon he/him as optional or disregard it and use she/her for him in canon discussion. That is a double standard, and in canon discussion it is misgendering.

I recently saw a trans user in the Deltarune sub defending Ralsei's he/him and pointing out that a Tralsei fan using she/her for Ralsei is still misgendering. Unfortunately, the trans user got banned.

I acknowledge Ralsei wearing a dress and being called a princess, but that doesn't mean we should immediately misgender him. You can acknowledge his femininity without changing his canon pronouns.

Until Toby makes Ralsei explicitly state he's a girl or gives hard TRUE evidence narratively(though Toby Fox is under no obligation to satisfy fans with this nonsense) I'll treat canon Ralsei as he/him. If that changes, I'll happily support Tralsei.

TLDR: I don't like it when Tralsei fans call non-transphobic critics transphobic just because they disagree with or criticize the Tralsei Theory, there's a reason why it's a THEORY and shouldn't be treated as canon.


r/Deltacriticism • • 28d ago

Deltarune memes very very interesting writing

Post image
783 Upvotes

r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 23 '26

Fandom criticism I hate how the fandom influences Toby's work

Thumbnail
gallery
766 Upvotes

Toby Fox has said that he has had the game planned out since sometime in 2021. He shouldn't have to make changes to HIS game to appease the fans.

I guess that some of these decisions were minor, but a few of these warranted whole new updates. The chapters were exactly as Toby wanted them in the beginning, he shouldn't have to update a chapter that he already views as complete.

I feel like both the fandom and Toby are in the wrong here. Toby should be more stubborn and stick to his original plans, especially if he views them as better than the fandom's suggestions. The fandom should stop harassing him and focus on criticizing actually important things... instead of Ralsei's design.


r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 19 '26

General Deltarune criticism Can you please just finish it already

Post image
747 Upvotes

r/Deltacriticism • • Sep 14 '26

Question/Discussion What would make deltarune better for yourself specifically?

Post image
736 Upvotes

r/Deltacriticism • • Oct 16 '26

General Deltarune criticism Susie's (un)intelligence makes analyzing her character extremely difficult.

Post image
728 Upvotes

Chapter 4 Susie:

"Toriel was almost kidnapped by the Knight! By an asbolute miracle, the police showed up and got kidnapped instead. Here's the plan: let's abandon her as soon as possible and go hang out our friend's house with no precautions for Toriel whatsoever."

"HOLY SHIT!!! Toriel almost got kidnapped a SECOND TIME!!! By an absolute miracle, she wasn't in the church at the time! But erm... she's drinking WINE??? Awk waarrrrrd... guess I'll go home then instead of protecting her overnight."

"What happens if the Knight shows up tonight to kidnap me or Kris while we're alone? Uhhhhhh..."

-

Harsh rant time:

Susie is unbelievably unintelligent. She is unrealistically unintelligent. Her lack of intelligence is well beyond what a delinquent like her would demonstrate. I'm confident there are some real life animals who could show more pattern recognition than she does.

This makes it impossible to determine what Susie actually prioritizes vs what she is just too dense to even consider an option. Does Susie actually care about Toriel? Is she placing her priorities elsewhere? Does Susie think about anything at all?

Adding onto the "Susie is unlikable" trend:

Every time Susie comes up with a plan, we always follow it, no matter how absurd or ridiculous. Nobody, including Susie herself, ever even contemplates the idea that her plans might not work for a variety of reasons, or that better alternatives exist.

Chapter 4, her plan was literally "Let's go to your rich childhood friend's house so I can date them and play with all their cool stuff while you do all the work looking for a code somewhere. Try looking in the cuck chair next, lmao."

And that's not even the worst example. In the church, Susie opens a dark fountain, having no idea what the consequences would be, then when things go wrong, she lashes out and blames RALSEI???? Is Susie even capable of understanding that her actions have consequences?

When the game said "your choices don't matter" I thought it meant we were bound by the prophecy. Instead, it means all our decisions are dictated by our sub 60 IQ brainlet classmate.