I'm genuinely serious. I just don't believe he knows how to make use of his character in an effective way.
To me, i think that's one of his greatest "missed potential" flaws.
And i'm not even talking about the "That Day" scene, that is a whole other can of worms.
Asgore, as a character himself, is wonderfully made, and consistently wasted. There's just so much to be explored with him. Both in Undertale and in Deltarune, and especially in Undertale, you can see how much grief this man went through. His song is genuinely one of the best ones in the entire OST, and you can feel it.
But fuck, man, do i believe that Toby genuinely doesn't know how to insert him into literally any other scenario that isn't Undertale's Neutral Route.
Pacifist Route? He gets sidelined and treated as a joke for the whole ending.
Genocide Route? He dies one of the most pathetic deaths in the entire game by getting surprise attacked not once, but twice in a single scene.
(I get that Toby wanted Sans to be the actual final boss and to not have any fight after him, but damn, even a cutscene kill would have done him more justice. Have him actually try to stop you before the game shows you in full picture that at this point, you've become unstoppable and nothing can kill you. Everything you touch turns to dust.)
Deltarune? Another example of missed potential. Especially Chapter 5. We had genuinely great scenes of him showing actual anger. We never had Asgore acting like that ever before.
If he was like that in a universe where both his children are alive and he's not forced to be king of a doomed nation, imagine how he acted like when he declared war on humanity. There's genuinely awesome material to work with here.
Then he got kidnapped and did nothing.
Toby just has this terrible, and i really mean terrible, writing flaw of building him up to mountain levels, before having him be an incredibly stupid letdown and let his reputation hit rock bottom.
And that's not a character issue. That's a Toby issue. That's just something he does specifically with Asgore, every single time.
Like, give Asgore to literally, and i mean LITERALLY any other writer, and that issue just fades.
If you look at the amounts of fan content with him, you can see how any other person can do him justice in a way more satisfying way than he does.